Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP doesn't help with baby costs?

387 replies

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 15:25

Hi

I've been with my DP for 8 years. He has a 13 year old DD from a previous relationship and we have one DS together and he is 2. He wasn't planned not sure if it's relevant.

We live together, his DD is with us 5 nights in every 14. He has been split up from DSD mum since she was 2 and rightly has always paid maintenance.

My AIBU is we now have a child together. The house we live in is DP name. He has a much better paying job than me, over 100k and I earn 30k.

I pay half of all bills and for food shopping but DP won't let me pay towards mortgage.

I pay for DS childcare so I can work, I have not a lot left over. Things are very tight.

DP pays maintenance above CMS level to DSD, and DSD also attends private school at a cost of 2.5k a month roughly which DP pays for. DSD mum had a similar job to me and earns similar from what I understand.

I think it's great that he does this for his DD and that he's in a position to, when we first met I thought it was so much more attractive then a man trying to dodge paying for the child.

But I can't help but feel our DS isn't being treated the same as DSD. It now feels like he's trying to dodge paying anything for OUR child. DP doesn't give me even a penny towards any activities, clothing, nursery etc for DS.

He says that he puts a roof over our head and that's enough, and that it's fair?

I've asked about if in his head he's planning to do the same with private school in future for our DS but he's quite vague.

AIBU to feel like my DS is being treated unfairly?

OP posts:
wibblewobblequack · 24/11/2023 08:06

That's really helpful @Grimchmas, thank you.

I'm still taking all your responses in. I'm very grateful for all the advice I just don't know what to do.

I can't save, I have nowhere to go at the moment if I was to leave.

Do I keep working on my masters and try and financially get myself into a better position hopefully through a better paying job?

I know he absolutely won't marry me, he's never been interested in marriage.

Like I've said quite a few times any time I try and speak about it he turns it around on me, that I don't trust him, that I'm ungrateful.

When I've tried to talk to him about the discrepancies between his contribution towards DSD and our DS he makes out like I am begrudging DSD and her education, which I'm absolutely not. I just want him to help with our DS.

I've also mentioned before the fact that I'm doing drop offs/pick ups for DSD costs me a lot in fuel which I can't afford, and he acts appalled that I'd even ask for fuel money because we are a family and I'm very petty to ask.

OP posts:
CrabbiesGingerBeer · 24/11/2023 08:00

With the estate, be aware that your son can only make an application for ‘reasonable provision’ if he’s left out of the will if he is being financially maintained by his father.

Basically, once he turns 18 (or possibly slightly older in the unlikely event his father helps with university fees), he isn’t entitled to a penny (unless by ‘North’ you mean Scotland - the rules are different there).

Also, with university fees, his father’s income will be taken into account for the maintenance loan even if he refuses to pay.

I know this sounds premature but you need to be aware that this could be looming on the horizon.

Grimchmas · 24/11/2023 07:40

Do you really think half of his estate would be left to a child who he can't bear to be left alone with? One who he doesn't see as his financial responsibility right now? One who he is happy for you to go into debt to look after instead of pay for, right now?

Peel back the scales from your eyes, please, even though it's going to be painful.

Start thinking about the things that you don't want to think about.

The what if scenarios.

Your own retirement.

Why are you thinking about what other people would think if you left him, ahead of what YOUR needs are, and what works for YOU?

He isn't even meeting his son's needs. His son needs much more then a roof over his head, and that roof can be met much more cheaply than is being chosen to be at present. Is it nice? Sure I'll bet it is a nice house to live in. It's a gilded cage. Still doesn't meet yours or your DS's need for financial security, for food, water, heating, activities, hair cuts, health stuff, clothing, toys, craft stuff and childcare, does it. The gilded cage doesn't meet DS's need for a father who will look after his own son, not even for an hour. It's very clearly not going to put DS through private school. It didn't prevent you from using up your life savings on your maternity leave, in fact it caused it by being an expensive house to run that you had to pay half towards. It didn't pay your pension contributions and living expenses while you were on maternity like all decent dads do, did it.

The house is a gilded cage, your partner's asset and his weapon to beat you with. He uses it as his top trump card and to prevent you two from having a serious and honest sit down review of household finances. He has made unilateral financial decisions that have been at your medium and long term expense and to his capital gain for your entire relationship. He has gone from the generous boyfriend who will buy a round of drinks to the selfish father who has no qualms about his life partner having to use her capital that should have been invested in property, to survive while looking after his newborn son. He has been happy to let you get into debt with day to day living expenses including that of his son's and even some of his daughter's, rather than prevent that by providing even a small regular stipend towards the cost of his son. During this cost of living crisis he has paid well into his own mortgage and pension, goodness knows what his savings are like, and is paying £whatever for his daughter, including but I imagine not limited to private school fees. Meanwhile he gives you "BuT i PuT a RoOf OvEr YoUr HeAdS yOu UnGrAtEfUl WeNcH" then silent treatment if you ask for more than the occasional grocery shop.

Yes, you have allowed yourself to be financially and emotionally abused. You have been unpaid nanny and housekeeper to enable this walker to live a life of his choosing - in fact you aren't even unpaid, you have been paying for the privilege of providing home cooked food, a shopping, cooking, cleaning and child RAISING service, through paying half of the house bills, providing your own car and fuel to ferry his DD around, and providing everything from clothes and food to entertainment and education costs to his son! He's got it fucking made with you as his nanny/housekeeper, he even presumably gets sex out of it and what does it cost him for all of this? Literally fuck all, an occasional shopping trolley of food, and the occasional inconvenience of his not unpaid-but-actively-paying nanny/housekeeper/chef/handmaiden trying to have awkward conversations with him about money, which he shuts down quickly with anger then silent treatment.

He's got it absolutely MADE while you're absolutely FUCKED. Why aren't you LIVID??

You can't change the past. But you can change the future.

It starts with peeling back the scales from your eyes and seeing your situation for what it really is.

For me it then continues with you informing him that with immediate effect you're not paying towards the gas/water/electricity/council tax/household maintenance of his house or even any minor costs associated with his daughter like fuel to pick her up. You're informing him not negotiating with him since every time you try to talk about money with him he gets angry and gives you the silent treatment, but if he'd like to calmly sit down and have an open and fully transparent and honest conversation with you about equitable finances as a supposed loving and respectful couple who have a child together, you'd be open to that.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 24/11/2023 07:29

My guess is DSD’s Mum was ‘a bit funny with you’ when you had your DS because your partner had been telling her your relationship wasn’t serious.

He basically arranged for you to pay him for acting as a nanny to his daughter. No doubt he intended to have ‘it’s not working’ conversation when she was old enough not to need childcare.

The unplanned pregnancy screwed that up but he’s managed not to let it have any sort of financial impact on him (since he’d be paying the mortgage whether you lived there or not).

wibblewobblequack · 24/11/2023 07:28

So when we discussed buying a new house and putting mine on the market, the original plan was that we'd be buying together and I'd be putting my equity in.

At some point he convinced me that it was better for me not to go on the mortgage, and that he could just put me on the deeds to the same result.

He almost acted like he was doing me a favour and taking care of me. As in he suggested "well if we do it this way it means you can get a new car" (mine was a total old banger that was having constant issues at the time).

I see how utterly stupid I've been.

OP posts:
Boomboom22 · 24/11/2023 07:28

This is definitely financial abuse. What does he say when you point out you are now in a much worse position than when you met? He has essentially stolen your ability to be a home owner. Bills should be split proportionally.
Although not married you may well have a decent claim on the house considering this. See a solicitor to find out. And don't accept him thinking he's making you secure, he's no in any way. Tell him he is trapping you and putting you in debt. He's a thief.

billy1966 · 24/11/2023 07:19

magicofthefae · 23/11/2023 22:02

OP, you are mistaken in thinking the man isn't awake of costs involved. He knows everything!!! He is actively taking you for a mug, financially abusing you.

Even if you stay with him, which I hope you don't, squirrel money away for your future safety.

Don't do the food shop. Buy sandwiches for you and your son. Get him to go out and buy food if he wants food in the fridge. If he says why's the fridge empty. Say after paying nursery fees and my CC debt I've got no money left, I'm skipping meals.

Make an excuse up about work, eg boss has you lined up for promotion so is giving you extra responsibility, therefore you doing step child's pick up and drop off is not possible. He will have to find childcare for her.

Don't pay half the bills. Just say you're paying all the nursery fees you CC debt etc. You don't have the money.

Don't clean or maintain the house, eg don't wash his clothes etc. Just keep your and your child's stuff clean. Treat him as a flat mate. Treat the house as a hotel. If he says why haven't you cleaned say, I'm too busy working. You'll have to hire a cleaner or do it yourself.

Get an extra job on the weekends. Say you're working on increasing your income as you suggested to me. Get him to look after the child he has with you.

Use every saved penny as your exit fund.

When he kicks up a fuss about it, use the deflection tactics, guilt trips, and gaslighting that he uses on you. For eg...You're so lucky I do all the childcare, pay for nursery, etc. Shout. Change the subject. Silent treatment.

He's very shrewd, you need to be shrewd too, and leave immediately if you can, claim CM. If not, don't spend a penny more, as detailed above, save money, then leave.

Your child deserves a happy mother and a stable and loving home, even if that is a small 2 bed flat somewhere. A massive house can't compensate for him witnessing the abuse of his mother, which he will pick up on, when he's older.

Excellent post.

Please contact Women's aid.

He lived off you, made promises about the house, and now hasn't.

He has and is financially abusing you.

He has you in debt and you are controlled by your debt.

He is limiting your movements by keeping you in debt.

I absolutely believe this has a coercive ring to it.

I think you need to talk seriously to Women's aid.

Why should you have been put into debt, him having lived off you, you now have no home and are in debt and controlled by him?

I think you should be looking for a settlement and should be looking at making a complaint to the police about coercive control.

You need advice. As @magicofthefae has wisely written, he knows EXACTLY what he is doing.

You are being 100% used and abused.

None of this is accidental.

You need to see can you get some money from him to get set up elsewhere.

He used you, lived rent free, had you sell you house with promises, get yourself into debt with mat leave and now controls you.

I think you need good legal advice.
Will he want a police complaint made against him?

Coercive control is an ugly accusation.

Start with Women's aid.

Keep posting.

wibblewobblequack · 24/11/2023 07:18

@mathanxiety he wasn't homeless, he had a home (a flat).

For the pp that said I was attracted to his "assets", when we met I had the bigger home of the two of us. That's why he moved in with me.

We (I thought) were happy at the time and the natural next step in the relationship is to live together? It made more sense for him to move to mine than for me to move into his little flat?

In terms of not contributing, he said it was to the benefit of both as he'd be able to save lots and we'd be able to buy a dream home (together).

OP posts:
wibblewobblequack · 24/11/2023 07:15

AFAIK the school is over 10k a term, and 3 terms a year.

I know DP pays the fees, DSD mum isn't in a position to. I know she contributes towards some uniform and normal bits for school. DP also pays CM but from what I gather it's above CMS amount.

They were never married, split up when DSD was 2. I don't think it was a bad break up.
I'm not sure if they owned a house together as I've never really asked, I just know that DSD mum lives in her own house now with a mortgage.

I get on with DSD mum fine, she can be a little funny sometimes, for example when we had DS.

DP tells me they split up as DSD mum wasn't happy with how much he worked.

OP posts:
arethereanyleftatall · 24/11/2023 07:15

Remember - he doesn't want you to move out.

Because if you do, he'll have to pay £1.2k child maintenance plus all instead of half the bills. You're worth, what £2k+ a month, to him. He'll have to do his own cooking, shopping and cleaning.

Whereas for you, if you move out, you'll gain £1.2k child maintenance which should cover rent/mortgage plus child benefit, possibly uc. And you'll be rid of this colossal prick.

The ONLY thing he does for you is pays the mortgage. And that is covered by the CM you'll get.

So if he says he'll kick you out - firstly, he won't, and secondly, that's fine, you're working towards that anyway.

Love what @MargotBamborough wrote above, if you can keep calm and parrot that, perfect.

brentwoods · 24/11/2023 02:45

He saw you coming. He used you to further his own financial success and isn’t even supporting his own child. Get some self respect.

RantyAnty · 24/11/2023 02:17

Was it his idea for you to sell your house?

mathanxiety · 24/11/2023 01:37

@wibblewobblequack

Why was he homeless/ why did he have to move in with you?

Did his ex get a portion of the proceeds of the home they lived in?

What issue caused the breakup with the mother of his daughter?

mathanxiety · 24/11/2023 01:35

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 21:50

@Scarydinosaurs this is maybe where I struggle. I don't think he spends a HUGE amount of himself.

He does have a very nice car, but he's not hugely into fancy clothes or anything like that. He has decent stuff but he takes care of, he's not off spending huge amounts all the time on stuff like that.

He does go out for drinks or to watch the football but it's not weekly, maybe a few times a month.

I think a huge amount of his money goes on the school fees, child maintenance, house, car, pension possibly? I'm not 100% but it definitely doesn't appear that he's spending it all on himself as such.

The house and pension are all for him. All the mortgage payments and the pension contributions are for him and him alone. He is spending a huge amount on himself.

He's buying assets that are increasing in value. Those are big ticket items that you will never benefit from. You will never get a penny of the treasure he is stockpiling for himself.

MrsKeats · 24/11/2023 01:10

I want to know what school in the north costs 30k a year. That's insane to me.
I'm guessing your son won't have the same education.
Also why is he paying for this and maintenance?

TanquerayTickles · 23/11/2023 23:03

I mean, honestly, I think you'd probable be better off financially single, given maintenance, etc.

However, I would bring up the disparity again with him, point out the fact he pays nothing towards his child, that there's no equity in contributions given both your incomes. If he still plays the 'I pay the mortgage' line, I would bring it up in front of joint friends, assuming you have some, explaining the division in finances and make out you're querying how everyone else splits things.

*He will hate it , but rightly or wrongly, sometimes these men need shaming, and what he is doing is shameful, so there's no need to protect him.

*This is assuming there's no physical abuse or threat to you or your child, which you haven't mentioned there is so am going with that.

Moonshine5 · 23/11/2023 22:49

OP you sound like a decent person but you also sound like a lodger. When your child is grown what if you break up ? Where is your pension your security?

SunRainStorm · 23/11/2023 22:43

This is incredibly unfair to you.

Honestly I'd leave and claim CMS.

You'd probably be better off.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 23/11/2023 22:39

Blimey op you are so vulnerable, your dp has got this all worked out.

You would be so much better off as a single parent and I say that as a single parent! He is not your partner, he doesn't love you or your son and he has no respect for you.

Please start working out how to leave.

Badgrief · 23/11/2023 22:38

If he says he's providing you with a home ask why you have to pay half the bills and all the food costs when he didn't do the same while living under your roof. Deliberately or not (and I don't believe he doesn't know what he's doing) he is accruing wealth - equity in the house, savings, pension etc - while you are getting further into debt.

If you split up or he falls under a bus tomorrow, you are homeless and in debt. Without you around, at worst he would be looking for a nanny and increasing the cleaner's hours. He has security and you have none, pointing that out doesn't mean you don't trust him.

I wonder how old his daughter was when he split with her mother and when he started to pay towards her maintenance?

BlueEyedPeanut · 23/11/2023 22:37

Claim CB if you aren't already. It's better than nothing. He can pay that back in his taxes.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 23/11/2023 22:30

Puzzledandpissedoff · 23/11/2023 21:22

... you can start by deducting half the cost of nursery from your share of the bills and backdating this to when your child first started nursery

OP already addressed this, Margot, apparently she feels this would be a trigger for him to chuck her out, which as I just said he could do at any time anyway

That's awful that she thinks he'd do that - you really must make a plan to leave him if he thinks that little of you. I would still stop
Paying though and say you haven't got enough as you put nursery on credit card. IF he kicks you out you would be homeless and probably a high priority for social housing!

Dixiechickonhols · 23/11/2023 22:24

A very possible scenario is he made a will leaving everything to his older child before you had ds and not got around to adding ds.
So she inherits the lot.
You would then need to look into making an inheritance act claim for your son which would be costly and time consuming.
Why haven’t you asked him? If answer is you are scared to that really says it all doesn’t it about your relationship.

mugofstew · 23/11/2023 22:23

MargotBamborough · 23/11/2023 22:15

I think this is what I would do. I would sit him down and say the following.

"I've been thinking, I would like to get married. We live together, we have a child together, it's the sensible thing to do. Shall we book the registry office for next year?"

If he says no, you say, "OK. Well if you don't want to commit to me I think I need to leave and strike out on my own. Being in this relationship is holding me back. I'm in a sort of no man's land where we don't have shared finances but I also don't have any financial independence because I'm subsidising your lifestyle in a way I can't afford."

When he gets all indignant and says you're not subsidising his lifestyle, it's the other way around, you say, "Yes, I am. You lived with me for free when I still owned a house, and then I sold that house and used the equity to fund my own maternity leave when you should have been supporting me during that time because I was having your baby. And now I've gone back to work and I'm paying 100% of the cost of nursery for our child when this should be a joint cost. And on top of that I'm paying 50% of the bills to live in your very expensive house when you earn five times what I earn. If I didn't live here you would have to pay 100% of those bills yourself and you would also have to pay me child support."

If he says you can't afford to move out, you say, "Actually, I can't afford to stay. Literally, I can't afford to live month to month when you are putting all your money towards a house that is in your sole name, leaving me to pay all the irrecoverable costs for our child as well as half your bills. You're building a secure financial future for yourself and I'm getting into debt. And of course I have no hope of building up any equity in my own property or saving for my own retirement for as long as this situation continues. If we were married it wouldn't be as much of an issue, but we're not married and you've just said you don't want to get married, which means I need some financial independence for myself. If I move out and rent somewhere then what with the child maintenance payments from you and the child benefit I'll be eligible to claim, I'll be able to get back into the black. So. Have a think about it. I want to be married in the next 6 months or I will start making plans to move out."

I think this is sensible. If you aren't in a position to save money secretly you are going to have to have this kind of conversation.

Azerothi · 23/11/2023 22:20

It doesn't matter if he has made a will or not. The boyfriend would lie to the OP about who benefitted, he doesn't sound a very honest or decent man who provides for both his children. He is under no obligation to show the OP, his girlfriend, the will.

I do wonder though why you don't want to marry him or is it you he doesn't want to marry?

A bit late now I know but I live in hope women won't keep treating themselves and their children as second class citizens to their current boyfriends. Like the OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread