Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP doesn't help with baby costs?

387 replies

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 15:25

Hi

I've been with my DP for 8 years. He has a 13 year old DD from a previous relationship and we have one DS together and he is 2. He wasn't planned not sure if it's relevant.

We live together, his DD is with us 5 nights in every 14. He has been split up from DSD mum since she was 2 and rightly has always paid maintenance.

My AIBU is we now have a child together. The house we live in is DP name. He has a much better paying job than me, over 100k and I earn 30k.

I pay half of all bills and for food shopping but DP won't let me pay towards mortgage.

I pay for DS childcare so I can work, I have not a lot left over. Things are very tight.

DP pays maintenance above CMS level to DSD, and DSD also attends private school at a cost of 2.5k a month roughly which DP pays for. DSD mum had a similar job to me and earns similar from what I understand.

I think it's great that he does this for his DD and that he's in a position to, when we first met I thought it was so much more attractive then a man trying to dodge paying for the child.

But I can't help but feel our DS isn't being treated the same as DSD. It now feels like he's trying to dodge paying anything for OUR child. DP doesn't give me even a penny towards any activities, clothing, nursery etc for DS.

He says that he puts a roof over our head and that's enough, and that it's fair?

I've asked about if in his head he's planning to do the same with private school in future for our DS but he's quite vague.

AIBU to feel like my DS is being treated unfairly?

OP posts:
PostItInABook · 24/11/2023 09:56

Jesus Christ OP. Get your head out of the sand! This bloke is an absolute gaslighting arsehole and treating you like utter shit. Start getting angry and advocate for yourself.

Grimchmas · 24/11/2023 09:52

I can't save, I have nowhere to go at the moment if I was to leave.Do I keep working on my masters and try and financially get myself into a better position hopefully through a better paying job?

how realistically likely is it that masters will get you a better paid job, and how quickly? A lot of that depends on industry and experience.

But to the fact that you can't save - this is why you need to reduce your outgoings, and why I suggested stopping paying utilities, Council tax and whatever other things you are paying towards the house etc. Why you need to just stop taking his daughter places unless he provides fuel.

Like I've said quite a few times any time I try and speak about it he turns it around on me, that I don't trust him, that I'm ungrateful.

there's a concept i like to recommend, that i call "getting comfortable with being uncomfortable and allowing others to feel uncomfortable".

ALLOW awkward silences; don't go rushing to fill them. Stay calmly persistent on topic. If he gives you the silent treatment cease doing anything at all that makes his life comfortable until he talks you to in a respectful manner like an equal. Stop washing his clothes, stop cooking for him, stop transporting his DD, stop trying to fix the silent treatment and get on with yours and your son's lives. He can either grow up and have an adult conversation or he can continue to sulk like a toddler: either way, show that you're just going to be getting on with your life.

So he calls you ungrateful amd says you don't trust him. Don't allow him trying make you feel shame to derail the point of the conversation. "I understand that you think that I'm ungrateful, but the fact of the matter is that we need to come to a different financial arrangement because this one is leaving me in debt every month with no savings and no assets."

"regardless of whether you think I'm ungrateful or not, allowing your son and your partner to live in your house isn't covering the financial costs associated with your children."

"regardless of you paying your mortgage, there are other expenses to keeping our son and your daughter that I am unable - and shouldn't have to - cover by myself."

Ignore his attempts to emotionally blackmail you into dropping it and behaving like the good little stepford girlfriend that he wants you to be.

I think the most effective and efficient way to do this is to stop paying towards the bills and stop taking his DD to things unless he provides PROPER petrol money or his vehicle with his fuel. Buy only the food that you and your DS need, on a daily basis if you have to. (This is another example of getting more comfortable with being uncomfortable). No matter how much he tries to tell you how unreasonable, petty, selfish you are being or whatever else he can throw at you, keep your cool on the outside and tell him that any time he wants to sit down and have a calm and loving discussion about how to look after both of your best financial interests together, you'd be happy to review arrangements. Until then, you must act in your own best interests, just like he does every time he shuts you down for trying to talk about money.

PrinnyPree · 24/11/2023 09:50

OP you're like a frog that's been slowly boiled to death, his financial abuse has been creeping and his gaslighting has made you question what is fair. But now you have zero assets, are in debt and are 100% reliant on him to keep a roof over your head as he continues to drain your resources by forcing you to pay MORE than half of bills on a fifth of his wage. Ignore him saying the mortgage is a bill, he's just paying off the debt so he can outright own his asset, it's not a bill and you are not benefitting unless you are on the deeds.

If he promised you he'd put you on the deeds if you sold your home I would seriously be speaking to a solicitor about this and see if you can claw back some of your lost assets?

Harden your heart to him, his actions are abuse pure and simple, he's taken away your independence and has you in a cage of servitude. Get your ducks in a row OP. Xx

Also in the meantime stop paying any bills apart from childcare and stuff for your baby, if he complains say you can't bloody afford it and you're going into debt. If he brings up you not trusting him again, turn it round and say surely if you trusted me my name would be on the house deeds by now like you promised!?

Concannon88 · 24/11/2023 09:46

Apart from you are already a single parent. His "higher outgoings" are going into a nice little nest egg tho arent they, his house! But yours are going on your sons childcare, so you can work to provide for your son, that you'll never see anything back from other than cards on mothers day.

billy1966 · 24/11/2023 09:41

Would his job be affected by a charge/conviction for financial abuse, coercive control?

Would he be happy it being made public his abuse of you, his coercion of you?

You have more power than you realise, you just have to be prepared to reach out for support.

Seek out advice quietly to see where you stand.

You could well be eligible for refuge and housing.

Let people help you.
Tell them you are finishing your education.

soscarlet · 24/11/2023 09:39

What do you get out of this relationship, @wibblewobblequack? Anything other than the nice house you get to tiptoe around?

Please understand you will do your son far more harm staying in this abusive and dysfunctional home than you would by removing him and yourself from the nice house.

Chipsahoyagain · 24/11/2023 09:38

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 15:41

He won't pool finances.

We've lived together for 6 years.

Before we lived here we lived together in my house which was owned by me.

He didn't pay any bills or contribute other than the odd food shop but my mortgage and bills were small as it was a starter home so I didn't mind so much.

He also said he was saving so we could buy a house together and that I would benefit from his savings.

When I sold my house I bought a new car (£10k) with the equity and paid off some debts. The rest of the equality I had to use to help get through my maternity leave as he didn't help with a penny towards that and I still had to pay half the bills and for food.

Stupid, I know. I wish I hadn't spent the equity.

You have been very, very stupid. Really you have . Can you not see how you have made yourself so vulnerable. Honestly I despair. Why are you allowing him to not pay for his child, let alone have done nothing to protect yourself legally.

Goldbar · 24/11/2023 09:31

I am sure there will be people who can give much better advice than me, but if he earns over £156,000 per year, you may be able to apply to the courts for "top-up" maintenance, which I believe gives the courts more discretion in ordering maintenance or even a lump sum payment in some circumstances.

I would seriously advise getting some decent legal advice as a first step. It may cost you, but I don't think you can afford not to. They may suggest negotiating some sort of settlement in lieu of coercive control proceedings/a court application.

Goldbar · 24/11/2023 09:24

Your partner is a deeply selfish man.

Abergale · 24/11/2023 09:23

You poor thing op. Honestly in your position I would calculate what all the bills are split down the middle INCLUDING nursery and stop paying some of the other bills to even it out. You have credit card debt, you literally can’t afford to be paying more than half the bills on the house he has chosen and if you lived alone your house would be smaller and bills cheaper.

I would then say to tell him you want to go on the deeds now. If he refuses you ask for rent for the time he lived rent free with you.

I think your relationship is all but over anyway, it sounds like he just wanted a housekeeper.

Bornonsunday · 24/11/2023 09:20

If he refuses to wear condoms then having a baby was his decision. He can't put that on you and make out that all the costs of childcare should be born by you.

Cosyblankets · 24/11/2023 09:13

It's really hard to think of being alone again at my age and starting again.

You're alone now though.
You really are.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 24/11/2023 09:08

With the additional information (no sex, not sharing a room or even a floor), you aren’t his partner, you are live in staff that he’s conned into paying for the privilege.

If you stay, your son will be significantly financially disadvantaged over you leaving. That’s not ‘having the best life’, that’s you enabling your partner’s abuse of you and your son - and yes, that’s exactly what is happening here.

If you leave, he has to pay for his son. If you don’t, he doesn’t and clearly won’t.

MargotBamborough · 24/11/2023 08:58

wibblewobblequack · 24/11/2023 08:06

That's really helpful @Grimchmas, thank you.

I'm still taking all your responses in. I'm very grateful for all the advice I just don't know what to do.

I can't save, I have nowhere to go at the moment if I was to leave.

Do I keep working on my masters and try and financially get myself into a better position hopefully through a better paying job?

I know he absolutely won't marry me, he's never been interested in marriage.

Like I've said quite a few times any time I try and speak about it he turns it around on me, that I don't trust him, that I'm ungrateful.

When I've tried to talk to him about the discrepancies between his contribution towards DSD and our DS he makes out like I am begrudging DSD and her education, which I'm absolutely not. I just want him to help with our DS.

I've also mentioned before the fact that I'm doing drop offs/pick ups for DSD costs me a lot in fuel which I can't afford, and he acts appalled that I'd even ask for fuel money because we are a family and I'm very petty to ask.

You're not a family.

If you were a family he would have supported you during your maternity leave, you would both be paying childcare for your shared child proportionate to your respective incomes, and you would co-own the property that you live in.

Time to say no more lifts for his daughter and no more family food shops out of your limited income.

If he wants to be a family then all family costs should be shared proportionate to your incomes. He can't pick and choose when you are a family and when you are not.

MargotBamborough · 24/11/2023 08:55

wibblewobblequack · 24/11/2023 08:44

I've suggested bills be proportionate before but he says he has higher outgoings than me due to "putting the roof over our heads" and DSD education.

Rubbish.

He would have those outgoings whether you and your child were in his life or not.

The reason he has higher outgoings than you is because he is paying 30 grand a year in school fees for a child who actually has fuck all to do with you and is not your problem, and because he is building up equity in a house you do not own.

billy1966 · 24/11/2023 08:53

You have to call Womens aid for advice.

He has you penniless and in debt and is keeping you that way as nanny for his first child while contributing nothing to the child he had with you.

He has deliberately gotten you stuck and he wants you to stay that way.

He shuts you down any chance he gets.

Get your hands on any paperwork, photograph it on your phone and email it to yourself.

Bank accounts, pension, morgage, anything.

He deliberately put you in debt and has deliberately told you one thing about the house, has you pay as much as he can unofficially.

This is financially abusing you and coercive control.

I think you need to read up on Coercive control and talk to Womens aid.
Ask should you approach the police for help, quietly.

Do everything quietly.
Ask about legal aid because he has you in debt.

wibblewobblequack · 24/11/2023 08:51

It's really hard to think of being alone again at my age and starting again.

I was never sure I wanted even one child, then DS happened and I love him to bits but being a single parent was never how I planned life.

I definitely don't want any more children. I've got some gynae issues and I've got to have surgery, I've asked to be sterilised alongside this which has been agreed to I'm just waiting for a date.

Those saying about sex, we hardly have any anyway. DS and I have mostly slept in a separate bedroom to DP since he was born. DS had (and still has to a degree) a lot of trouble sleeping.

DP said from the get go that he needs his sleep for work. DS and I ended up sleeping downstairs for the first year of his life as DP said he could hear him too much upstairs, even in a separate room.

DP also refuses to wear condoms, which I've asked him to do until I am sterilised.

I want DS to have the best life and I wonder if I should just put up to keep this roof over his head.

OP posts:
wibblewobblequack · 24/11/2023 08:44

I've suggested bills be proportionate before but he says he has higher outgoings than me due to "putting the roof over our heads" and DSD education.

OP posts:
jeaux90 · 24/11/2023 08:44

@MargotBamborough has given you a really good script to go at this.

Also remember your leverage in this negotiation is how much you do for his child. If you move out he has to do it ...he should be doing it anyway.

And if he doesn't budge I'd say you can't afford to stay and I wouldn't. You've already cornered yourself. You need to find a way to get back out on your own.

XjustagirlX · 24/11/2023 08:25

Ideally you would sit down and explain

  • bills should be on proportionate to income
  • you should be on the deeds
  • he needs to pay proportionate to childcare

he doesn’t want you on the house because if you split up it is his house
he doesn’t want to marry you because if you divorce he could lose his house
he won’t pay for childcare as he believes your child is your hobby and has sexist views
these are all facts and he doesn’t see a long term future with you.

i understand it’s difficult to leave. As a first step I would explain to him that for security and retirement reasons you want to buy yourself a small flat to rent out. So he needs to pay 50% of the childcare. If he refuses then say you will need to save costs elsewhere.

  • I would then only buy cheap frozen microwave meals for his tea
  • every tea will be beans on toast or a microwave meal
  • say you are not using your car anymore. Get the bus to pick up your son or walk. He will have to sort out getting his daughter unless it costs you nothing.
  • do not have sex with him
  • shame him in front of friends and family. Casually mention you are looking to buy a flat as it isn’t your house.
Concannon88 · 24/11/2023 08:22

He says you dont trust him? Tell him its him who doesnt trust you!

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 24/11/2023 08:20

Ohtobetwentytwo · 24/11/2023 08:12

He isnt putting a roof over your head, he is keeping your mitts firmly away from his personal investment.

You would be financially better off alone.

So much this.

Bills for a huge house are going to be far more than bills for a small flat (obviously). A massive part of the reason you are getting into debt is because you are subsidising his lifestyle with incredibly limited benefit to yourself.

You might be living in a nicer house at the moment but with your salary, the CM and the UC you would be entitled to, you could afford something decent and still have significant spending money.

Lavenderosa · 24/11/2023 08:15

You could start by contacting Women's Aid because you are being financially abused. They will help you build a plan for your future. You need support to take the actions required to improve your situation. Please seek some professional advice and start putting yourself and your son first.

Ohtobetwentytwo · 24/11/2023 08:12

He isnt putting a roof over your head, he is keeping your mitts firmly away from his personal investment.

You would be financially better off alone.

wibblewobblequack · 24/11/2023 08:06

We are in England, not Scotland.

OP posts: