Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP doesn't help with baby costs?

387 replies

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 15:25

Hi

I've been with my DP for 8 years. He has a 13 year old DD from a previous relationship and we have one DS together and he is 2. He wasn't planned not sure if it's relevant.

We live together, his DD is with us 5 nights in every 14. He has been split up from DSD mum since she was 2 and rightly has always paid maintenance.

My AIBU is we now have a child together. The house we live in is DP name. He has a much better paying job than me, over 100k and I earn 30k.

I pay half of all bills and for food shopping but DP won't let me pay towards mortgage.

I pay for DS childcare so I can work, I have not a lot left over. Things are very tight.

DP pays maintenance above CMS level to DSD, and DSD also attends private school at a cost of 2.5k a month roughly which DP pays for. DSD mum had a similar job to me and earns similar from what I understand.

I think it's great that he does this for his DD and that he's in a position to, when we first met I thought it was so much more attractive then a man trying to dodge paying for the child.

But I can't help but feel our DS isn't being treated the same as DSD. It now feels like he's trying to dodge paying anything for OUR child. DP doesn't give me even a penny towards any activities, clothing, nursery etc for DS.

He says that he puts a roof over our head and that's enough, and that it's fair?

I've asked about if in his head he's planning to do the same with private school in future for our DS but he's quite vague.

AIBU to feel like my DS is being treated unfairly?

OP posts:
davidcameronsshed · 24/11/2023 12:42

Check if the amount you'd be entitled to via CMS is indeed around £1200, also work our UC, child benefit and other entitlements to cost up your potential income, plus your salary. Then look online to see if there are any nice flats within budget near your chosen primary school and start imagining a life where you and your son can have real security and a living calm peaceful SAFE home without the responsibilities of his daughter or his food shop etc.

You deserve to be happy and so does your child.

I also think you would benefit from some counselling to work out why your self worth is so low that you've enabled this guy and allowed him to treat you and your son this way.

What is your industry and what are the prospects of accessing help through your Masters University or employer? Otherwise Google "low-cost therapy" in your local area.

Also you should contact Women's Aid, and Citizens Advice to find out more about your options. And finally plenty of solicitors do free consultations- look some up and see if you can find one to attend during the working day.

Start making plans and stepping up as tiger mum. Your son needs you to do this, and you owe it to him and to yourself.

arethereanyleftatall · 24/11/2023 12:17

@MrsKeats & @Dixiechickonhols

To throw something else in to the mix. Maybe far fetched but...This is all a plan from him and his ex. A weird one, but nowt so queer as folk. Saw op coming. Use her to make sure their kid could stay in private school. Rinse her whilst paying off 3 properties between them. Send money to 'ex' to keep it away from op. Get her to do childcare. Once no longer needed, dump. Run off in to the sunset together.

The stingyness to op vs generosity to ex, got me thinking this. Then the 'ex was furious when I got accidentally pregnant' but cemented this thought. Plus the lack of care towards their son.

Sorry op, but this is already so bad.

Even if you can't allow yourself to think he's bad yet. Keep this thread. Keep coming back to it. He is bad.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 24/11/2023 12:13

I can see what your DP gets from this relationship but what about you?
With a child, you should be a team
Expenses should be shared and with your income disparity, costs should not be halved leaving you struggling and him quids in
You're being too accommodating to your detriment
If he threw you out one day, you would be homeless
Please think very carefully and protect your own interests because he never will

davidcameronsshed · 24/11/2023 12:07

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 21:50

@Scarydinosaurs this is maybe where I struggle. I don't think he spends a HUGE amount of himself.

He does have a very nice car, but he's not hugely into fancy clothes or anything like that. He has decent stuff but he takes care of, he's not off spending huge amounts all the time on stuff like that.

He does go out for drinks or to watch the football but it's not weekly, maybe a few times a month.

I think a huge amount of his money goes on the school fees, child maintenance, house, car, pension possibly? I'm not 100% but it definitely doesn't appear that he's spending it all on himself as such.

No op. He has TWO properties which thanks to YOU he's managed to pay down the mortgages on, protecting HIMSELF and giving HIMSELF security and a pension. And NOTHING for you!!!!

Sorry about the capitalisation but your thread is making me extremely and unusually cross. You are constantly rationalising his abuse and defending his choices. Your self worth is at zero. At this rate I'm sorry to say but your son will grow up in a toxic home witnessing abuse of his mum by a father who "huffs" at the prospect of caring for him. Just what exactly do you think that's going to do to your little boy? Distort his feelings of self worth and his views of healthy relationships. He'll either end up needing years of therapy to overcome the dynamics in his home or he'll watch and learn to become the abuser himself. But at least he will have lived in a nice house!!

MrsKeats · 24/11/2023 11:39

Exactly dixie
Can't find any day school in the north charging 30k a year.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/11/2023 11:38

At some point he convinced me that it was better for me not to go on the mortgage, and that he could just put me on the deeds to the same result

Hang on, @wibblewobblequack, so are you saying that although you're not on the mortgage you're actually on the deeds?

Because if so that would make a heck of a difference to your position - and if not, why would you choose to move into that "dream house" without being on either?

MargotBamborough · 24/11/2023 11:23

Dixiechickonhols · 24/11/2023 10:27

A post that sticks with me from relationships is a woman aged 60. Been with partner years and they split.
Unmarried, his house, his pension.
She was living in a small flat, working all hours to survive.
Meanwhile the sons were preferring to live with dad when back from Uni as he had space and mod cons they were used to. He could buy them nice gifts. They and their girlfriends were going on nice foreign holidays with dad and new gf, expensive meals out, house deposits and cars. Mum felt awful. She was watching another woman benefit from the pension and house she’d enabled him to fund.

This is so important.

@wibblewobblequack This is your ghost of Christmas future if you stay with this man.

But it's not too late to change things. You're not yet 40. You still have time to move out, rent a property you can actually afford to live in with your child and boost your income by claiming child benefit and child maintenance. In time you will be able to clear your debts and start building up savings again. You'll be able to buy your own place eventually and save for your own retirement. When you're not doing school drop offs and pick ups for his daughter you'll have more time to spend on your son, your masters, your career.

If you stay with this man you won't be able to do any of these things. You'll be scrimping and saving to enable him to build his nest egg at your expense.

This can't be said too many times.

If he refuses to pay towards to cost of raising the child that you share when you are living under his roof, you need to live under your own roof and then the CMS will force him to pay towards the cost of raising his child.

If you don't move out you will be trapped in a relationship with this horrible man until such time as he decides he wants to move on. And then you will be homeless and penniless.

This is no life, OP. Not for you, not for your son.

Spell it out to him.

"We're not a family. If we were a family my name would be on the deeds of the house that I enabled you to buy and all our shared costs including the mortgage, bills and childcare for OUR child would be paid for out of a joint account that we would both have full access to. If we were a family you and I would have equal spending money. If we were a family you wouldn't be deliberately keeping our finances separate so that if you one day decide you don't want to be with me any more you will be able to throw me out onto the street, keeping your assets for yourself and leaving me with nothing but the debt I have incurred giving birth to and paying for our child all by myself. Now either you put me on the deeds of this house, open a joint bank account with me and ideally marry me, or I am done."

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/11/2023 11:11

And this is why you should never trust anyone else to "take care" of your financial future. Educate yourself, research options, get independent advice, have frank discussions about contributions in relationships and what is fair.

Munchyseeds2 · 24/11/2023 11:09

Heatwavenotify · 23/11/2023 16:27

Oh sweetheart what a mess you have got yourself in. Agree with everyone on here. This isn’t a relationship, you’re staff.
Work out a way to leave, get what benefits you are entitled to and claim CMS.
Things will only get harder as you get older. You don’t want to find yourself homeless in another 10 years when he’s bored and he doesn’t need you to do his childcare.

Pretty much exactly what I was going to say.
You will end up with nothing.
You really would be better off leaving this non relationship

Dixiechickonhols · 24/11/2023 10:53

MrsKeats · 24/11/2023 10:47

Still no answer on why he's paying 2.5k a month school fees AND maintenance.

That really makes no sense given his financial attitude.
Could he be married Op or have something in his past he’s anxious to pay her hush money to hide.
The amount he says he’s paying in fees seem very high for a day school up north eg Stonyhurst full boarding is that price.
You don’t appear to know much about him despite length of time together.

MrsKeats · 24/11/2023 10:47

Still no answer on why he's paying 2.5k a month school fees AND maintenance.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/11/2023 10:42

Also it's a £500k house not a fucking luxury palace.

He nedds to stop going on like Lord Bountiful because he permits the mother of his child and his son to live in his £500k house.

The massive fucking bellend.

Laurdo · 24/11/2023 10:39

wibblewobblequack · 24/11/2023 08:51

It's really hard to think of being alone again at my age and starting again.

I was never sure I wanted even one child, then DS happened and I love him to bits but being a single parent was never how I planned life.

I definitely don't want any more children. I've got some gynae issues and I've got to have surgery, I've asked to be sterilised alongside this which has been agreed to I'm just waiting for a date.

Those saying about sex, we hardly have any anyway. DS and I have mostly slept in a separate bedroom to DP since he was born. DS had (and still has to a degree) a lot of trouble sleeping.

DP said from the get go that he needs his sleep for work. DS and I ended up sleeping downstairs for the first year of his life as DP said he could hear him too much upstairs, even in a separate room.

DP also refuses to wear condoms, which I've asked him to do until I am sterilised.

I want DS to have the best life and I wonder if I should just put up to keep this roof over his head.

You're a single parent anyway. Do do all the childcare for DS and on top of that you have a stepkids to run about after Would you not rather be a single parent in a house that's yours, that you know no one can toss you out off? Yes it must be lovely to live in a big 500k house but kids don't care about that kind of thing. I think it's far better that you had a smaller house, that you knew was your own rather, than live in someone else's house with no security.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/11/2023 10:33

What the actual fuck have I just read?

How on earth did you buy his "better for you not to be on the mortgage" bollocks? You earn £30k, not as much as him but not nothing, your income being taken in to consideration would help with your joint borrowing power.

Even if you don't earn much or indeed anything, you could still be on the mortgage. You are clearly not a stupid person, you are doing a Masters, so why did you not research your noptions?

So here is how it could have been done more fairly. Mr Monkey and I are not married. When we bought our flat he was a very low earning contractor but had a very big cash deposit from selling his flat. I had at the time, a much higher income.

So we got a joint mortgage with him assessed as zero income. We are both on the mortgage and deeds. We have a deed of trust drawn up to reflect the fact that in the early years he has more money tied up in the property than me and that should be accounted ahead of any 50/50 share i n any equity gains for if we split. I pay the mortgage, so over time we will replace that DoT to reflect a more equal contribution. The mortgage and deposit are both roughly half purchase price of the property - Mr Monkey put in some more money to account for the interest I would be paying.

MargotBamborough · 24/11/2023 10:33

Abergale · 24/11/2023 09:23

You poor thing op. Honestly in your position I would calculate what all the bills are split down the middle INCLUDING nursery and stop paying some of the other bills to even it out. You have credit card debt, you literally can’t afford to be paying more than half the bills on the house he has chosen and if you lived alone your house would be smaller and bills cheaper.

I would then say to tell him you want to go on the deeds now. If he refuses you ask for rent for the time he lived rent free with you.

I think your relationship is all but over anyway, it sounds like he just wanted a housekeeper.

Even splitting down the middle is unfair if he earns five times what she does.

Dixiechickonhols · 24/11/2023 10:27

A post that sticks with me from relationships is a woman aged 60. Been with partner years and they split.
Unmarried, his house, his pension.
She was living in a small flat, working all hours to survive.
Meanwhile the sons were preferring to live with dad when back from Uni as he had space and mod cons they were used to. He could buy them nice gifts. They and their girlfriends were going on nice foreign holidays with dad and new gf, expensive meals out, house deposits and cars. Mum felt awful. She was watching another woman benefit from the pension and house she’d enabled him to fund.

Grimchmas · 24/11/2023 10:24

And by the way, be prepared for him to try to call you out that you're saving money to leave him. Turn that right back around on him and tell him that keeping you living in poverty in his fucking gilded cage mansion is an acceptable way to keep you in a relationship with him?

Haydenn · 24/11/2023 10:24

He doesn’t want to split the bills proportionally because he is putting the roof over your heads? So basically if you were looking a proportional split then you are contributing towards the mortgage. He’s a cheeky fucker at best and financially abusive at worst.

I don’t say that lightly OP, but you are not considering leaving because you can’t afford it- and by the way he is currently behaving you never will.

look on the CMS calculator see what you’d be entitled to there. I think potentially a nice little flat for you and your child would make for a much nice life than living in a big house with this pig.

Farmageddon · 24/11/2023 10:24

This is infuriating to read - why aren't you more angry at him OP? You seem to think that he doesn't realise what he is doing here, but he absolutely does. You've been shafted and you have allowed it to happen. Get angry for yourself and your son - both of your futures are at risk here.

Would you ever treat your partner this way, if the tables were turned and you earned more than him? Would you watch him struggle while you squirrelled away money and equity that he has no claim to, would you blame him for his financial situation even though he has little choice? Presumably not, because it's cruel and you're not an arsehole. This man chooses to treat you like this, with contempt because he doesn't care about your wellbeing.

Jackiebrambles · 24/11/2023 10:20

Keep posting OP. Do you have someone in real life who you could talk to - mum or dad, siblings?

I know you are worried about the roof over your Ds’s head. But honestly. What a shit roof, a gilded cage that neither of you have any claim or ownership of. That’s spiraling his mother into penury.

Does he know about your cc debt?

Grimchmas · 24/11/2023 10:18

I want DS to have the best life and I wonder if I should just put up to keep this roof over his head.

your DS quality of life is dependent on a lot of things, but this specific roof over his head vs a much cheaper one, isn't a factor. At all.

on the other hand your quality of life and his would be much improved by you having your own financial security.

Look you don't have to leave him. What you do need is the option to be able to if it suits you.

I've suggested bills be proportionate before but he says he has higher outgoings than me due to "putting the roof over our heads" and DSD education.

Then tell him you can't afford 50% of the bills on this house and that if he is unable to pay proportionately it would be best if you both downsized to live within your means. BOTH of your means.

<cue him rolling around the old emotional abuse scripts>

"Regardless, I cannot afford to continue to pay 50% of the bills on this house AND 100% of the childcare and costs associated with our son. When you're ready to sit down and talk about this with respect and love, let me know."

bombastix · 24/11/2023 10:14

Think carefully OP. This is not just your child but your own future. You will be drifting into actual poverty when you are older unless you make a plan for yourself and your child.

LaviniasBigBloomers · 24/11/2023 10:12

Oh my love, your last update! He refuses to wear condoms and yet DS was 'unplanned' - that's what happens when you have unprotected sex!

Honestly I've just read your updates rather than the thread and the picture I have is of a complicated and slightly narcissistic man who is 'all front' as we say up here. It's important for him to be seen as a 'good guy' - hence paying over the odds on CMS (although you only have his word for it that he is doing that and basic CMS is laughable), buying drinks, lovebombing you and paying school fees.

He's not a good man though and over the long term he's gaslit you 100% into a horribly precarious financial position. I bet deep down he's fuming that his ex dared to leave/has in a sense taken him to the cleaners and so will not let himself get into that financial situation again...

Does your work have an employee assistance programme? If so, check out to see if you can get free counselling. You need a bit of proper support to work out what to do next. What I would say though, is when a woman realises she'll be financially better off apart from her partner it can be the straw that breaks the donkey's back. I bet CMS is more than your 'half' of this 'roof'.

Dixiechickonhols · 24/11/2023 10:10

Op I hope you can speak to someone in real life like a close friend or sister about your situation.
‘Putting up with it’ for ds isn’t putting his best interests first.
Part of being a parent is trying to ensure a stable life not living on a knife edge.
You split tomorrow, you and your child are homeless - what is your plan - do you have a deposit to rent?
He dies in a car crash tonight. You don’t even know if he has a will. If he’s left house to eldest child and his death in service and pension to her you are both homeless and your dc has nothing from his father’s estate. You’d need money and evidence to pursue an inheritance act claim via a solicitor - if he’s not been contributing to his upbringing it’s not straightforward.
Like another poster says fast forward 16 years and your dc has an offer from a top uni but only min loan due to father’s income but father won’t contribute. You can’t afford the thousands a year top up on your wage so he has to go local and not where he wants to.
Think about mental impact on your dc - sis has top private school and Durham uni for example v he has local comp and ex poly. Sister has lots of foreign school trips v you can’t even afford scout camp. That’s not a healthy situation for a child or teen.

MargotBamborough · 24/11/2023 10:03

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 24/11/2023 09:08

With the additional information (no sex, not sharing a room or even a floor), you aren’t his partner, you are live in staff that he’s conned into paying for the privilege.

If you stay, your son will be significantly financially disadvantaged over you leaving. That’s not ‘having the best life’, that’s you enabling your partner’s abuse of you and your son - and yes, that’s exactly what is happening here.

If you leave, he has to pay for his son. If you don’t, he doesn’t and clearly won’t.

Exactly this.

If the OP was a live in nanny then technically it could be argued that her partner was "putting a roof over her head", but not really because this would be part of her salary. She would also expect to receive part of her salary in cash, and for the family to cover any additional expenses incurred in working for the family and looking after their children, such as family food shops and petrol. She wouldn't expect to be getting into debt because it was costing her more to work for the family than they were paying her.

What has actually happened here is that her partner lived with her rent free in a property that she owned, which enabled him to rent out his own property and pay off the mortgage, as well as putting savings aside to allow him to buy himself a big swanky house, which she agreed to based on his vague promises that she would also benefit because the big swanky house would be in both their names.

Then having got her pregnant and effectively trapped her, he used the money he had made from living with her rent free to buy himself that big swanky house, didn't put her on the deeds as promised, forced her to run down her own cash reserves which she got from selling her own property by solely funding her own maternity leave for the child he created, and is now forcing her to pay half the bills for his big swanky house as well as food for him and his child to eat and petrol for the lifts she is giving his child, as well as the entire nursery bill for their shared child so she can work, and she's getting deeper and deeper into debt each month.

And what is he doing in return?

Fuck all, except graciously allowing her to live in the big swanky house which he was only able to buy thanks to her, with absolutely no stake in it or financial security whatsoever and no ability to build up her own running away fund/nest egg because he is bleeding her dry each month.