Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP doesn't help with baby costs?

387 replies

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 15:25

Hi

I've been with my DP for 8 years. He has a 13 year old DD from a previous relationship and we have one DS together and he is 2. He wasn't planned not sure if it's relevant.

We live together, his DD is with us 5 nights in every 14. He has been split up from DSD mum since she was 2 and rightly has always paid maintenance.

My AIBU is we now have a child together. The house we live in is DP name. He has a much better paying job than me, over 100k and I earn 30k.

I pay half of all bills and for food shopping but DP won't let me pay towards mortgage.

I pay for DS childcare so I can work, I have not a lot left over. Things are very tight.

DP pays maintenance above CMS level to DSD, and DSD also attends private school at a cost of 2.5k a month roughly which DP pays for. DSD mum had a similar job to me and earns similar from what I understand.

I think it's great that he does this for his DD and that he's in a position to, when we first met I thought it was so much more attractive then a man trying to dodge paying for the child.

But I can't help but feel our DS isn't being treated the same as DSD. It now feels like he's trying to dodge paying anything for OUR child. DP doesn't give me even a penny towards any activities, clothing, nursery etc for DS.

He says that he puts a roof over our head and that's enough, and that it's fair?

I've asked about if in his head he's planning to do the same with private school in future for our DS but he's quite vague.

AIBU to feel like my DS is being treated unfairly?

OP posts:
Tontostitis · 23/11/2023 18:56

You need to deduct 50% of nursery costs plus a reasonable amount fir your joint child from the amount you pay for bills. Don't ask just for permission just do it and say moving forward you have to pay fir bith of your children. Secondly you need to clear the cc and start saving towards a deposit. He is nit guaranteeing your future so you need to. If he argues just repeat I need to guarantee my own future and you need to pay for your child. Don't argue don't go into detail just repeat the same mantra. If you don't respect yourself he absolutely won't.

theunbelievabletruth · 23/11/2023 18:51

... and this folks is the scenario where you check and triple check your contraception cover and then get the MAP sorted if there were ever to be an 'accident' .

OP is completely screwed because she needs to pay for and give time to a child that her 'd' p pays no financial part in raising. Putting a roof over your head is bollocks .. he would pay for the house anyway with just him in it - but this way you subsidise him with food and bills and then compound the lunacy by taking his child to school and facilitating his ability to earn the big bucks for his own pocket .

Ask him to put you on the house deeds . Hell - tell him how financially vulnerable you feel. A good man would care about those things . A twat who is feathering his own nest would not . If it's the latter then leave but leave with all the financial info to make and pursue a chunky CMS claim .

SweetFemaleAttitude · 23/11/2023 18:49

I feel obliged to make it work because of my child

I'm not sure what sex your child is, but if she's a girl, how would you feel if she got herself a bloke who financially abused her and allow her to become extremely vulnerable?

Her dad already treats her like shit and she's a baby really.

She will grow up thinking that this is how relationships function.

If your child is a boy, he is being treated like shit by his dad while he's very young. He will grow up thinking making women weak in relationships is normal and will repeat the pattern of his dad, treating his own child as baggage.

If you do anything for your child, please show them what healthy relationships are and that they can escape toxic situations if they want to.

You are bring your kid up in a fucked up dynamic which is only going to get worse the longer you stay.

PurpleBugz · 23/11/2023 18:36

I had similar with my ex. Fell in love with him because he was a great dad to my step kids. Moved in together and he wouldn't share finances. I was his free maid and nanny for his house and step kids. Our baby was planned and the disparity shocked me! I have no idea why he wanted a baby and treats baby so different. I think he thought I'd be trapped if I had a baby. Well I left. Now he pays me maintenance (slightly more than CMS says he owes) and I feel so well off because I became use to paying for everything when we were together. Initially he never saw the baby but now he does a bit and I suspect the next younger skinny pre baby bodied woman is being suckered by how good a dad he is and being lined up to act as nanny housekeeper for my child.

IMO childcare is a household bill. Raise it with your partner that he needs to contribute. Point out while you love DSD you are not her parent and you are doing school runs etc. Your career is being impacted by childcare responsibilities and his isn't. Maybe a conversation will sort the problem. Maybe you should inform him you will be paying for 2.5 days childcare and you will be leaving child with him the other days or he can pay the childcare. Even 50/50 isn't really fair with the difference in your wages. If he agrees to this I'd then consider your future security and push for marriage. But don't stay if you have no money each month just to be taken advantage of and treated as a skivy. I'm immensely better off financially now I'm single- because I get child benefit 25% off council tax and the maintenance.

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 18:33

@Goldbar that's exactly how it feels, it crept up on me.

I'm not sure why he won't split nursery at least 50/50 but expects other bills to be. It's like anything to do with DS is my responsibility.

I feel like DS and I are second class citizens.

Saving to move out isn't something I can do. I'm in 3k CC debt trying to keep afloat.

For the poster that asked, I am safe. By cross I mean just verbal argument. Calling me ridiculous, ungrateful, probably moving onto the silent treatment after.

OP posts:
BigTedLittleTedCardboardBox · 23/11/2023 18:31

When you sold your house was it with the idea you'd be buying together? I can't get over why you'd sell it otherwise. You could have rented it out and had it to fall back on. If you did think the new house was going to be joint at the point you sold it, and he's also talked about putting your name on the deeds since buying it I'd definitely talk to a solicitor in case you can make a claim on it. At this point there's nothing else to lose.

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 18:25

I love my DSD she truly is a lovely girl and she is my DS sibling, he loves her to pieces and I'd never want to punish her or make her feel like I didn't care about her by not collecting her or making her feel different to DS. It's not her fault her parents have chosen the education they have for her.

OP posts:
AnneElliott · 23/11/2023 18:24

Why are the household bills split 50/50 but nursery fees aren't? Surely it's 50/50 of both at the very least?

But I agree he's using you op.

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 18:23

I know deep down I've messed up.

When I met him I viewed him as a good man that went over and above for his child. He seemed so decent.

It's only since we've had our own child that the disparity has dawned on me.

The pregnancy wasn't planned, but he said he supported me in whatever I chose.

He sees childcare as my issue, never got a straight answer as to why. He always defaults to the fact that he pays for the house.

I actually believed him when he said he was working and saving for our future together.

He was never married to DSD mum and if I asked about marriage he would just say he loves me but he's never wanted to be married.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 23/11/2023 18:16

I just can’t understand why you would entertain this behaviour

I guess none of us like to think that those who we've put our trust in and committed to building a life with (and what greater commitment can there be then having a child together, which is essentially a tie between you for at least 18 years if not life?) would screw us over. So I can completely understand how one thing led to another, with the OP feeling increasingly uneasy, until she woke up one day and said "hang on a minute...".

Goldbar · 23/11/2023 18:11

I don't want to give up my job, it's important to me and surely I'd be even more insecure then? I really doubt he'd give me any "spending money".

Definitely don't give up your job. You'd be completely trapped then. This is not someone you want to be dependent on.

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 18:10

Sorry I've just been busy with the little one, trying to read all now.

@C1N1C I didn't say 100k, I said OVER 100k. I was trying to be vague but given the responses I thought I would just clarify how much it is. I'm not trying to bolster.

We obviously now live in a far nicer hoose than I could ever afford on my own. He does like to remind me of this, hence his thinking that I have it great.

But I live in a nice house that's not mine. I feel like I'm struggling and I'm poor.

I feel obliged to make it work because of my child.

I don't want to give up my job, it's important to me and surely I'd be even more insecure then? I really doubt he'd give me any "spending money".

OP posts:
2catsandhappy · 23/11/2023 18:06

I don't suppose by any chance you have a parent or sibling with a spare room?
He flat out lied to you to entice you to the big house. Call it changing the goal posts. He is being vague because he doesn't want to admit his plans don't include you. He is treating you so shabbily and his child too.

One advantage of not being married is you can leave, claim UC and get CM. Your 30K is not to be sniffed at.

Heyahun · 23/11/2023 18:06

oh no what a mess - start arranging how you will get your own place and move out - you could end up with nothing here

live on your own with your child and claim maintenance from him - you'll be better off

whogivesacarrot · 23/11/2023 17:56

I’d be leaving and putting in a claim for cms

he doesn’t sound like a great partner or dad so I’d stop wasting my time with him

justalittlesnoel · 23/11/2023 17:55

So he earns 150k - depending on pension contributions, takes home maybe 6-7k a month. Overpays a mortgage on a 500k house so let's guess 2k a month, 2.5k a month on school fees, whatever maintenance costs say another 1-2k - that's almost all of his salary gone. Are you sure he's actually spending that much?!

HollyJollyRobin · 23/11/2023 17:50

Unless you see a future in which you are both in the same, fair position...as well as your child...I would seriously think about a future without him.
If he hasn't appreciated you and your son by now, it's unlikely this will ever happen. You may both be better off if you left him. I'm also gobsmacked that he hardly sounds any time along with your son.

legolandlovers · 23/11/2023 17:49

He pays the mortgage to HIS house. Omg this is crazy get yourself out of there

Luxell934 · 23/11/2023 17:47

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 15:41

He won't pool finances.

We've lived together for 6 years.

Before we lived here we lived together in my house which was owned by me.

He didn't pay any bills or contribute other than the odd food shop but my mortgage and bills were small as it was a starter home so I didn't mind so much.

He also said he was saving so we could buy a house together and that I would benefit from his savings.

When I sold my house I bought a new car (£10k) with the equity and paid off some debts. The rest of the equality I had to use to help get through my maternity leave as he didn't help with a penny towards that and I still had to pay half the bills and for food.

Stupid, I know. I wish I hadn't spent the equity.

I’ve only been on Mumsnet for about 6 months but there is literally a post similar to this every single week without fail. Man won’t share finances, woman paying for everything for the child and she isn’t on mortgage or deeds. It’s almost unbelievable.

So he lived with you but didn’t contribute to mortgage and bills despite earning £150k. He said you were going to buy a house together after you sold yours but somehow ended up buying one all by himself and won’t let you contribute to the mortgage?
And despite him earning £150k you spent your savings on your maternity leave and pay for everything for your son.

I just can’t understand why you would entertain this behaviour. The biggest red flag would be him buying the house alone, surely that would be ringing alarm bells for you??

category12 · 23/11/2023 17:47

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 15:57

I have tried talking about finances with him but he gets very cross with me as says I'm being unfair as he pays the mortgage.

Jeez, but he will have a house at the end of it - while you have given up yours and spent the equity on maternity leave to have your child together? For whom he barely contributes?

You've got into a right mess here, OP.

AngelAurora · 23/11/2023 17:43

Leave get your own house and claim the maintenance off him.

SapphOhNo · 23/11/2023 17:42

He's put you and you've allowed yourself to be in a very tenuous position.

If he is prepared to treat you like this then you should really consider whether you should stay with him.

cestlavielife · 23/11/2023 17:38

C1N1C · 23/11/2023 17:20

Regardless, that is not going to be 40k... I get what you're saying, but there will always be an imbalance until school starts. It's not that he's 'not' paying for that child... the money is just called something else.

OP has stated she's not allowed to pay mortgage. Say he takes that 10k he's putting towards mortgage and puts it into the 2 y/o and lets OP put that into the mortgage... same money.

Only if her name is on the property deeds
Shd has zero claim (unless spends ££££ on lawyer to claim beneficial interest and she does not have ££££ )

therealcookiemonster · 23/11/2023 17:37

After reading so many posts like this... I am wondering if penises have some sort of magical properties to confound even the most capable, intelligent and educated women (i myself have been known to make poor decisions in such contexts, so no judgement). more research should be done on this.

I am truly sorry for what you are going through OP. please see him for what he is. if you want to stay with him, he should marry you. otherwise, you will permanently in this position. he should pay 4/5ths of all bills including childcare. that would be the MINIMUM. currently you are not getting anything, but he is extorting you

titchy · 23/11/2023 17:32

I'm sorry but you are an utter utter fool. He is massively screwing you over.

Swipe left for the next trending thread