Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that net immigration…

596 replies

Libertass · 23/11/2023 13:14

Of 745,000 people a year isn’t what the 17 million people who voted for Brexit in 2016 thought they were voting for?

YABU = Yes, this is what Leave supporters voted for.

YANBI = No, they didn’t vote for this.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
needtonamechangeforthis1 · 25/11/2023 11:30

Neriah · 23/11/2023 14:55

everyone says ‘this is what the majority voted for’ but it wasn’t, because nobody was told what the repercussions would be.

Oh no, you were told. You were all told. You werwe warned over and over and over. And even if you weren't, there was a wealth of information available for anyone who looked for it. Whining now that nobody told you what you were voting for is simply an admission that you are too bloody stupid to be allowed to vote. Every single person who voted was an adult over the age of 18 with, reputedly, mental capacity. You got EXACTLY what you voted for. Ignorance is no excuse.

😂😂😂

We so need a like button on here!!!

User135644 · 25/11/2023 10:14

Looblou72 · 24/11/2023 08:26

Absolutely, I live in Yorkshire and your description of Essex sounds identical to where I live. The increase in traffic every year, the new housing estates being built everywhere, every journey anywhere is an arduous struggle, the 4 week wait for simple blood tests at doctors, months of waiting for a dentist, hospital referrals not happening for 6-12 months upwards etc. That people can’t accept that the UK can’t go on like this is beyond me, if net migration continues at this level we’ll have 7.5 million more people here in 10 years, where the hell are they all going to live?

I agree but on the other hand so many of England/UK's existing towns are ghost towns and dilapidated, particularly on the coast and have been neglected since the collapse of old industry. The concentration of people in England is so centralised, particularly in the south east because everything has revolved around London for so long and with house prices/COL in London in particularly, many Londoners move out to the suburbs. A lot of places in England have seen population declines over the last century or post-war. Germany for example has a much more balanced economy over regions and distribution of their population.

Why don't we properly rebuild these places before building new towns or concreting over the rest of our green land for soulless housing estates in areas with poor infrastructure.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 25/11/2023 10:01

jasflowers · 25/11/2023 08:52

Well, as we both agree obesity is a huge strain on NHS, why are UK rates so high? why after 13 years isn't it being addressed and will industry pressure stop action on booze, sugar & processed foods?

We shouldn't have a Health Sec with very close family links into the sugar industry, regardless of the colour of the govt.

Because the approach has to be targeted.

Look at this first. Quite a blunt instrument.

https://digital.nhs.uk/news/2022/health-survey-for-england-2021

Now compare with this.

https://digital.nhs.uk/news/2022/new-analysis-of-health-behaviours-by-ethnicity-published-by-nhs-digital#:~:text=Chinese%20women%20(22%25)%20and,obese%20did%20not%20vary%20greatly.

It gives you more detailed information.

Just targeting obesity doesn't make sense, just as it doesn't make sense to target drinking across the whole population.

Quarter of adults in England are obese, new survey of public health shows: statistical press release  - NHS Digital

Around a quarter of adults in England were obese in 2021, according to the latest Health Survey for England. The report also found that around half of adults (49%) drank alcohol at least once a week, and about one in eight (12%) were current cigar...

https://digital.nhs.uk/news/2022/health-survey-for-england-2021

MuckyElbows · 25/11/2023 09:01

SwishSwishBisch · 23/11/2023 14:06

Any Brexit voter who is currently whining that ‘this isn’t what we voted for’ can cry me and everyone else a huge, enormous river.
You were all told what you were voting for was nonsense. Smoke, mirrors & lies.
You reap what you sow

Ooo you’re hard

let’s see how hilarious it is when the far right are voted in - because that’s where it’s heading

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 08:58

Obesity isn’t down to a sugar tax or similar. It can just be a tax on the poor as wealthier can just choose better more expensive food. And making people pay more doesn’t really stop the behaviour, it just makes them poorer, more stressed and more likely to want unhealthy food.

Education and health, both devolved, and overall lifestyle are bigger factors. So what are S and W doing that they have higher rates?

jasflowers · 25/11/2023 08:52

Well, as we both agree obesity is a huge strain on NHS, why are UK rates so high? why after 13 years isn't it being addressed and will industry pressure stop action on booze, sugar & processed foods?

We shouldn't have a Health Sec with very close family links into the sugar industry, regardless of the colour of the govt.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 08:48

jasflowers · 25/11/2023 08:42

Come on, at least come up with your own original slurs pls!!! :)

Point here is that without its own independent border immigration training taxation and industrial strategies (all then effect its public health policies) Wales just isn't an independent country, nothing to do with the opposition, simple fact.

Wales is a fairly small country, people in Cardiff/Newport are very close to Bristol, significant tax differences on eg food would lead people to travel and/or a black market, common sense really.

I doubt very much Labour will do much more on public health, there is no longer the money, the resolution foundation talked about how the Tories NI cuts & inflation will lead to huge real terms cuts in departmental funding, whoever gets in next year.

Data on obesity is a slur? True it’s not original I didn’t come up with figures on how many are.

I know people want to not have facts, but obesity is an issue.

We’ll see which way it goes. Given the pressure lack of health puts on all, and that it’s higher there, maybe we’ll see a reduction on a change of gov, or we’ll get closer to S and W

jasflowers · 25/11/2023 08:46

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 08:34

Funding is higher per had. Sadly it doesn’t help with health enough. Still higher obesity

Hopefully we won’t emulate after next GE

Its a 2 or 3% difference, NHS Wales say this is due to how data collected from GP practices, no idea if true but the trend across the UK is UP, as it has been for many years.

Unfortunately, will put pressure on the NHS for decades to come, needs addressing.

jasflowers · 25/11/2023 08:42

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 08:12

Actually Wales have introduced some food measures that do not align, I doubt people will drive that far anyway.

Scotland has higher taxes generally

Looking at stats they are more unhealthy, more obese, and with higher per head funding.

Sometimes I wonder if people ignore the reality because it doesn’t fit their version of the opposition will be so wonderful

Come on, at least come up with your own original slurs pls!!! :)

Point here is that without its own independent border immigration training taxation and industrial strategies (all then effect its public health policies) Wales just isn't an independent country, nothing to do with the opposition, simple fact.

Wales is a fairly small country, people in Cardiff/Newport are very close to Bristol, significant tax differences on eg food would lead people to travel and/or a black market, common sense really.

I doubt very much Labour will do much more on public health, there is no longer the money, the resolution foundation talked about how the Tories NI cuts & inflation will lead to huge real terms cuts in departmental funding, whoever gets in next year.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 08:37

PiggyFlounce · 25/11/2023 08:33

Or a wall, maybe, American style.

Oh yeh that’s it that’s why they’re struggling more with health, no wall

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 08:34

Funding is higher per had. Sadly it doesn’t help with health enough. Still higher obesity

Hopefully we won’t emulate after next GE

PiggyFlounce · 25/11/2023 08:33

Elastica23 · 23/11/2023 13:32

I think most of them thought we were leaving Europe - sailing out into the middle of the Atlantic, perhaps.

There was definitely a lot of talk about controlling borders. Perhaps they thought we could just build a fence.

Or a wall, maybe, American style.

jgw1 · 25/11/2023 08:32

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 08:12

Actually Wales have introduced some food measures that do not align, I doubt people will drive that far anyway.

Scotland has higher taxes generally

Looking at stats they are more unhealthy, more obese, and with higher per head funding.

Sometimes I wonder if people ignore the reality because it doesn’t fit their version of the opposition will be so wonderful

Given that funding in Wales and Scotland is linked to that in England by the Barnett formula, the devolved governments have little they can do if the government in Westminister decides as it has done consistently over the past 13 years to cut spending on public services.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 08:12

jasflowers · 25/11/2023 07:59

Wales and Scotland aren't separate countries, they couldn't for example, introduce a sugar tax as people would just drive to England, they'd need to become independent countries, with their own border/custom controls, which i assume you re not in favour off?

I sometimes wonder whether people use the Wales Scot argument just to rubbish the opposition, either that or they don't realise we are still the United Kingdom.

Actually Wales have introduced some food measures that do not align, I doubt people will drive that far anyway.

Scotland has higher taxes generally

Looking at stats they are more unhealthy, more obese, and with higher per head funding.

Sometimes I wonder if people ignore the reality because it doesn’t fit their version of the opposition will be so wonderful

jasflowers · 25/11/2023 07:59

EasternStandard · 24/11/2023 18:48

Are people healthier in Wales or Scotland?

Not sure they are under those devolved health systems

Wales and Scotland aren't separate countries, they couldn't for example, introduce a sugar tax as people would just drive to England, they'd need to become independent countries, with their own border/custom controls, which i assume you re not in favour off?

I sometimes wonder whether people use the Wales Scot argument just to rubbish the opposition, either that or they don't realise we are still the United Kingdom.

jasflowers · 25/11/2023 07:55

However, in my view, it is the incompetence and ideological stance of our current government that is the main problem here, and not net migration per se

Absolutely!
They don't seem to have any coherent policies, Cleverly now say "Rwanda isn't the be all and end all in regard to stopping small boats"

But statements from the Sunak/Braverman say the exact opposite.

Something is seriously wrong with migration at the moment, we have huge skills shortages, yet record high migration, 3x higher than in 2010.

Clavinova · 24/11/2023 21:04

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2023 20:48

Are you sure none of them are hoping to lead their party?

I expect all of them would prefer to be in government next year rather than leading the opposition.

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2023 20:48

Are you sure none of them are hoping to lead their party?

Clavinova · 24/11/2023 20:45

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2023 20:21

Presumably that means Badenoch, Cleverly, Braverman, Mordaunt, Berry, Clarke, Rees Mogg all take full responsibility for Truss and Johnson.

Perhaps - but none of the people you listed are in the running to be prime minister next year. I have no regrets that Boris Johnson became prime minister - we're you hoping for Jeremy Corbyn instead?

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2023 20:21

Presumably that means Badenoch, Cleverly, Braverman, Mordaunt, Berry, Clarke, Rees Mogg all take full responsibility for Truss and Johnson.

Clavinova · 24/11/2023 20:09

jgw1
I assume you are not familiar with the concept of collective cabinet responsibility?

I am - Keir Starmer should take full responsibility for but Jeremy Corbyn.

jgw1 · 24/11/2023 20:06

Clavinova · 24/11/2023 20:04

jgw1
Presumably the current Home Secretary and government also don't think that migration to the UK is too high, otherwise they would have done something about it by now.

The current Home Secretary has only held the position for two weeks but the previous Home Secretary did make some changes as mentioned by previous posters;
https://www.timeshighereducation.com/student/news/international-students-no-longer-able-bring-dependants-uk-student-visas

I assume you are not familiar with the concept of collective cabinet responsibility?

Clavinova · 24/11/2023 20:04

jgw1
Presumably the current Home Secretary and government also don't think that migration to the UK is too high, otherwise they would have done something about it by now.

The current Home Secretary has only held the position for two weeks but the previous Home Secretary did make some changes as mentioned by previous posters;
https://www.timeshighereducation.com/student/news/international-students-no-longer-able-bring-dependants-uk-student-visas

Clavinova · 24/11/2023 19:31

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2023 19:05

Doubt those lorry drivers would want to come here given the fun & games at our ports since Brexit (and knowing that those checks will only get more stringent when they finally fully implement it).

www.reuters.com/world/europe/britain-delays-post-brexit-border-checks-eu-goods-till-2024-2023-08-29/

Maybe we should rely more on our railways? We've got a great track record there (pun intended).

9 May 2023 — Two years on from acute shortage of truckers, the sector has resolved the crisis through higher wages and skills 'boot camps'

https://www.ft.com/content/13a0a9f5-5db6-488c-9860-18bd74fd2572

We should be working towards a higher wage economy although some might disagree because of the initial cost rises.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/11/2023 19:15

jasflowers · 24/11/2023 19:05

I thought the thread was about net migration, not purely overseas students.

On workers, did EU citizens bring in their parents etc no, we filled these shortages with annual net migration of about 200 to 250k.

We left the EU and now have to face the new reality of huge numbers of migrants from many different cultures, bringing family dependents who will never leave the UK, meaning we'll need more migrants to look after them and so on.

We aren't just taking HCPs from dev countries, we are taking them from countries against UN rules as these countries are so poor.

I d go with "what to do in the interim" but we aren't doing this, not at all and many of the ones we do train, leave the NHS, so we take more from other countries.

The thread is about net migration, but the post you quoted was specifically about students and their dependants.

And yes, we made a stupid decision to leave the EU and it certainly hasn't reduced out net migration figures at all. I remain deeply frustrated about that decision but I can't change it now.

And yes, it's ridiculous that we aren't training more doctors and nurses, and that we're not doing enough to keep the ones that we've got. We desperately need a change of government in order to address these issues.

However, in my view, it is the incompetence and ideological stance of our current government that is the main problem here, and not net migration per se.