Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that net immigration…

596 replies

Libertass · 23/11/2023 13:14

Of 745,000 people a year isn’t what the 17 million people who voted for Brexit in 2016 thought they were voting for?

YABU = Yes, this is what Leave supporters voted for.

YANBI = No, they didn’t vote for this.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Clavinova · 23/11/2023 20:51

2016MyLove
There's an agreement in place and EU countries can send immigrants to another with no issue.

16 January 2023
Germany unable to send back most migrants under 'Dublin' rules.

https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/46133/germany-unable-to-send-back-most-migrants-under-dublin-rules

26 April 2023
Dutch court blocks migrant returns to Italy, citing human rights concerns.

https://www.euronews.com/2023/04/26/dutch-court-blocks-migrant-returns-to-italy-citing-human-rights-concerns

8 June 2023
Ireland has to make a financial contribution of €1.5 million to the European Union for breaching a refugee housing agreement with the bloc.

https://www.aa.com.tr/en/politics/ireland-to-pay-penalty-over-failure-to-accommodate-refugees-under-eu-agreement/2917689

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 23/11/2023 20:42

I don’t really understand how immigrants are to “blame” for undercutting labour costs and therefore taking all the low pay jobs.

Because any government or employer could easily prevent that by setting and paying everyone a decent wage. If immigrants are being paid less, that’s our own damn fault for paying them less. Pay them the same as a local and let everyone compete on skills and productivity instead.

HannibalHeyes · 23/11/2023 20:26

Perhaps they weren't very good with numbers?

A bit like Brexshiteers...

Clavinova · 23/11/2023 20:25

HannibalHeyes
I would imagine the "6 million" were already living here...

Is that why the campaign group was named the3million?

Clavinova · 23/11/2023 20:20

unlimiteddilutingjuice
it's the natural outcome of France not helping us secure our borders anymore

France is helping to secure our borders because we've been paying them to do so for many years - we have bilateral agreements with France irrespective of EU membership;

Irregular migration: A timeline of UK-French co-operation

https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-9681/

HannibalHeyes · 23/11/2023 20:17

Asylum seekers are not illegal, no matter how much Tory politicians want you to think they are.

I would imagine the "6 million" were already living here...

Matronic6 · 23/11/2023 20:15

Winter2020 · 23/11/2023 18:44

I voted for Brexit and I have no interest in thr colour of someone's skin.
I have an interest in our immigration being regulated.
I expect a fair few of the people coming from India or Nigeria are working in our NHS and care services and I'm grateful for their service to our country.

NHS saw a rise of about 50,000 employees in 2022. Which is far short of 750,000.

So do you feel you got what you wanted?
Has Brexit enabled migration to be adequately regulated?

Clavinova · 23/11/2023 20:07

Fleetheart
this is all legal migration so nothing to do with boats

The ONS figures include asylum seekers;

we have improved our methods – most notably the inclusion of asylum seekers

Angrycat2768
The Brexit voters were told a lie about uncontrolled borders being the fault of the EU

Has anyone mentioned yet that 6 million people applied to the EU settlement scheme? Where did they all spring from?

khw666 · 23/11/2023 20:03

EasternStandard · 23/11/2023 17:49

You’ll probably find it increasingly hard to live somewhere that isn’t dealing with migration pressures and associated pressures

There's rioting in Dublin tonight as I write this. It is very scary.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 23/11/2023 19:56

The Brexit voters were told a lie about uncontrolled borders being the fault of the EU, when it was always within the government's gift to control. Now that all the Europeans have gone home we have such severe shortages of staff that we have to import people from overseas. Turns out immigration wasn't the reason Brexiteers grandchildren couldn't get jobs after all. This has nothing to do with the boats or asylum seekers. It's people legally here on visas given to them by the Home Office. If they wanted to, the government could have changed the rules any time they wanted. Including before Brexit as the people coming are non EU citizens. Particularly with an 80 seat majority.

This is the long and the short of it. The increased migration isn’t entirely a consequence of Brexit, but anyone who believed the Tories when they said the EU was the reason they couldn’t reduce immigration was a gullible fool.

The Tories love immigration, as much as they pretend not to. For starters it keeps house prices and rental prices high. They get fat off a swelling population.

MummytoAAandX · 23/11/2023 19:52

It was a vote to leave the EU, not to stop immigration...most of which is keeping our infrastructure going

aviatorsrus · 23/11/2023 19:43

This

Winter2020 · 23/11/2023 18:55

Neriah · 23/11/2023 14:01

Of 745,000 people a year isn’t what the 17 million people who voted for Brexit in 2016 thought they were voting for?

Not only are you being unreasonable, but you are also being as stupid as all those other people who voted for Brexit to protest immigration. Because immigration was NEVER on the ballot! Free movement and immigration are entirely different things. The Treaty of Rome enabled free movement. Brexit also enabled "free movement" - mostly of low paid and hard working people who filled the crappy low paid jobs that British born workers didn't want (and still don't want) back to European countries, and caused the current labour shortage in so many of our industries.

If you want to discuss immigration then you'll need to find a vote on that subject. There wasn't one in 2016.

Edited

"crappy low paid jobs"
Because people willing to come and live in crap conditions for low wages was plentiful.

You are advocating exploiting people willing to do this? Because the other side of that coin which people often state is that full time eork should pay enough to house and feed you adequately.

You shouldn't have to live in a caravan and work with no toilets to pick fruit for example and consumers (of agricultural produce/care/hospitality) should expect to oay enough to give someone suitable recommence for the job.

Remainers happy to admit they want cheap labour to exploit?

Deathwillbebutapause · 23/11/2023 18:54

Indeed. It seems to be the Remain voters on this thread who are weirdly fixated on race and how brown people might be, as "fififafa" rather crassly measures and defines the world.

Winter2020 · 23/11/2023 18:44

Fififafa · 23/11/2023 13:51

I can see why you’re throwing your toys out of the pram when you realise that all Brexit has done is replace mainly white(EU) migrants with mainly brown(Non-EU migrants).
The vast majority of immigration was from non-EU countries , 968,000 with the largest groups being from India and Nigeria.

I voted for Brexit and I have no interest in thr colour of someone's skin.
I have an interest in our immigration being regulated.
I expect a fair few of the people coming from India or Nigeria are working in our NHS and care services and I'm grateful for their service to our country.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 23/11/2023 18:37

@youngones1 and what is wrong with settled people in a country wanting decent wages and work? If people from Zimbabwe were upset about migrants from South Africa putting strain on their economy and civic resources would you think this was out of order, or is it only people in the U.K. you think shouldn’t expect a living in the country they are settled in?

Winter2020 · 23/11/2023 18:36

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 23/11/2023 13:38

It's not what they thought they were voting for.
But it's the natural outcome of France not helping us secure our borders anymore.

From the BBC: 15 Nov 2023
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-53699511

"As of 13 November, 27,284 people had crossed the English Channel in 2023. In 2022, 45,755 migrants made the crossing, the highest number since figures began to be collected in 2018. In total, more than 100,000 people have come to the UK this way since 2018."

The number of people coming across the Channel is substantial but it's nowhere near 745,000

I agree we would need to understand this number more to have an opinion on it.

I voted for Brexit, but contrary to your assumptions I expect, if the number is so high because people were invited for refuge from war in Ukraine (or anywhere) or left Hong Kong at our invitation I have no issue at all.

What we can't accommodate is everyone on Earth who believes Britain would give them a better life. Despite remainers banging on about how shit Britain is an awful lot of people from around the world believe living here would give them a better life.

Migrants in a dinghy sail in the Channel toward the south coast of England

How many people cross the Channel in small boats and how many claim asylum in the UK?

Prime Minister Rishi Sunak says that "stopping the boats" coming to the UK is a key priority.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-53699511

Jasmin1971 · 23/11/2023 18:35

In talk about migration pressure; We have not seen anything yet. Climate change will cause mass migration on a scale nobody has yet seen. I do worry for people, I really do!

Xenia · 23/11/2023 18:32

High immigration has meant wages have stayed low and we have little housing and 7m on NHS waiting lists.
High immigration for North London Tory and Labour politicians means they can get cleaners and other servants easily therefore they only see positive effects.

youngones1 · 23/11/2023 18:31

A lot of them wanted foreigners to stop taking their jobs...

Mycatsgoldtooth · 23/11/2023 18:29

Gritty south east London with no social
issues…. Hmmmmm. Greenwich? Blackheath? I doubt it’s Slade Green or Erith

QueenCamilla · 23/11/2023 18:08

@BansheeofInisherin

In fact, I'll paint a picture for you of my local "doctors". They are dark faces in the HMOs on my street. One of the HMOs was a "grow-house" run by African migrants. I found out about it when I had to call the police one night when a rival gang started a raid on their operation. The migrants fled and the house has been boarded up since.

The house opposite mine I think holds temporary problem tenants - somehow related to immigration as they're all male, barely any English, usually Asian. I can't work in my front garden without someone of them swanning over and reminding me that in their culture it's a man's job what I'm doing. They'll also freely ask for my relationship status. I get offered to buy stolen goods regularly. One of the "local" residents demolished my brick garden wall whilst I was at work at night.

At the end of my small residential street is what's known as "The wall". It's a low brick wall adjacent to a petrol station where hordes of foreign men sit about all day every day, drinking, smoking and staring at women. It is incredibly intimidating to pass by a group of 20 men like that. I go around the long way just to get to the shops I need.

And this is a quiet, residential, Victorian street. Used to be all families, so the elderly residents say.

When I needed a new wall to replace the demolished one, I opted for black Victorian railings and insisted on sharp arrow tops. When you live at the receiving end of "doctors", you learn to build the right walls quickly.

I don't benefit from bullshitting about this. So I do wish the privileged would return some human respect and pull their heads out of their bloated arses. Just to have a peek around for a minute or two.

User135644 · 23/11/2023 18:08

MaybeSmaller · 23/11/2023 13:36

And what percentage of those are the illegal immigrants vs people with skill sets that there's a shortage of? And how many of the Brexiteers have those skill sets and are looking for work?

None of that matters.

It's 745,000 people.

It's nearly the equivalent of a city the size of Leeds being added to the UK population each and every single year FFS. It's totally and utterly unsustainable, even if the people are all nice (and I'm sure they aren't ALL nice). The UK can't even house and provide essential services to the people we have here already.

Quibbling about that is like seeing someone's house is flooded and asking whether it's drinking water or sewer water.

It’s hilarious that despite Brexit, we have seen the largest ever level of net migration.

Oh yeah a right bloody side splitter. What a peach you are.

Edited

The problem is the Tories are happy to import all these people because of 'growth growth growth' but they never build the infrastructure to deal with it.

And Labour weren't much better but they at least invested in public services.

JaneyGee · 23/11/2023 17:53

Net immigration last year was 745,000. And bear in mind, that's the official figure. I wonder what the true figure is? If you add in illegal immigrants, it's probably closer to a million.

I'm in rural Essex, and our quality of life is rapidly deteriorating. There are simply too many people jammed into too small an area. The traffic is so bad I hardly bother going out. I've given up yoga after work because it takes me too long to get there, and in the Spring I never bother visiting local beauty spots. Even if I could face the traffic I'd never get parked. Frankly, we're probably two years away from having to book time slots to use the roads. My local woods have been destroyed to make way for a disgusting new estate, and at the other end of the village a second massive estate is being built, including blocks of flats. The traffic is awful now, so god knows what it will be like when all those new houses are occupied. But it's never enough. No matter how many vile rabbit hutches they squeeze together, we always need more, more, more.

People need to understand that this isn't going to stop. Yes, the birthrate is dropping in Europe and Asia, but it's dropping from a massive height. And it isn't dropping everywhere. Africa's birthrate is so high the African population is going to double by 2050. The population of Manchester is 550,000. If this continues, we will have to build a new Manchester every year. WHERE??? Forget arguments about identity and multiculturalism. It's simply a question of space. The left will do anything rather than crack down on immigration. As soon as this issue is raised, they weasel out of it by going on about the lack of investment in social housing and schools and GP surgeries, and so on. But I don't want more houses and schools and GP surgeries. I want more fields and trees and space and silence and light.

BansheeofInisherin · 23/11/2023 17:50

I live in a gritty part of SE London. Anyway, I get you @QueenCamilla. You are the right sort of immigrant, and everyone else isn't. Not an unusual view these days.