Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to spend the same amount on presents

84 replies

Natspenc · 23/11/2023 09:51

So SIL now has 3 kids and we have 2. She wants us all to spend £15 on each kid but as she now has 3 I want to split it evenly and spend £10 on each of hers.
husband thinks I’m being rude and tight but I don’t see why we should be spending £15 more than her forever.
AIBU? Or should we spend the same amount?

OP posts:
cardibach · 23/11/2023 10:35

I can't ever imagine agreeing a price like that. I get something people will like, within a vague overall budget. Some may get way more one year. It evens out over a lifetime.

Sceptre86 · 23/11/2023 10:33

Good god, buy whatever you can afford. So don't stick to x amount but whatever you are happy to. It doesn't have to be so transactional.

Your sil is a CF I get it so is mine. She's similar with her son requesting items for his birthday yet they never ask any of mine(I have 3 to their 2) what they would like. I've taken to chuckling when nephew requests things outwith our budget and say that's a gift your parents can get you.

Re your brother I would have just said spend whatever you are happy too without feeling resentment. 2 of my siblings have no kids yet and they buy for 4 nieces and nephews, the gifts will stop when ours are 18 but then their own (should they have any) will be younger so it all evens out in the end.

My mantra is to spend what I am happy with without causing resentment.

thetworonnies · 23/11/2023 10:33

I'm childless. Definitely going to stop buying for my nieces and nephews! What a mug I've been.

Santaiswashinghissleigh · 23/11/2023 10:33

Are you actually envious she has 3 dc?

Twentypastfour · 23/11/2023 10:32

If you can’t afford it, then don’t do it.

If you can however, it seems ridiculous to quibble about £15 especially when it comes to children. My DC are the only children in both mine and DH’s wider families. They still get bought things even though we obviously can’t reciprocate to children that don’t exist.

Also does £15 mean exactly £15? I’d take it to mean in the region of £15… so £10-20 give or take. It would seem ridiculous and wasteful to buy a load of crap to hit the £15 target exactly, far better to buy something you think the child wants which might cost less, might cost more.

Natspenc · 23/11/2023 10:30

gosh didn’t realise how negative everyone would be.
I guess it’s the principle and it came about as last year my brother who has 1 kid said he was spending twice as much as me so I realised that was mean so told him to spend half the amount on my kids so we spend the same.
money is tight this year so I guess I am thinking about money more.
I am also annoyed as she always seems to give hand me down second hand toys as presents and then requests things for her kids more than the amount we have said

OP posts:
FiveShelties · 23/11/2023 10:30

Don't tell me, you changed username for this as it was identifying.😂

Santaiswashinghissleigh · 23/11/2023 10:29

When I was pregnant with dc 3 my sil told me in front of my dc that she was stopping buying now as 3 dc was ridiculous. She went on to have 6 after I divorced her db. She was a nasty cow also op...

TheNoodlesIncident · 23/11/2023 10:24

So SIL now has 3 kids and we have 2. She wants us all to spend £15 on each kid but as she now has 3 I want to split it evenly and spend £10 on each of hers.

She can't dictate how much you spend. That's simply not her decision to make. Fair enough if it was a suggestion only but even so, you don't have to capitulate.

I do think you're being miserly though. How unfair to take it out on the kids when they have no control over how many siblings they have. It's different for the actual parents - my sister has two and struggles to keep the spend/value to the kids as close as she can get, because she wants to be fair to her two dc.

I only have one dc but when I buy for sister's two, I try to keep the amount similar for the same reason. What I DON'T do is look at how much DSis is spending on my one and calibrate the amount I'm spending based on that. It's just daft. They are people in their own right, not instruments of spending.

Floatlikeafeather2 · 23/11/2023 10:12

In the same spirit, if you have your way, your sil could say it's not fair that your children will get "better" presents than hers for ever. Just because she's suggested it, you don't have to agree to it anyway but quibbling over £15 does make you seem a bit mean. What would you do if she has another child - split the £30 4 ways? If you genuinely can't afford it (tho your husband seems to think it's not an issue), buy what you can afford. I can't get my head around making these things seem like business. I guess it depends on your particular family dynamics. In any case, we all stopped when each kid got to 18 so it wasn't for ever.

BarbaraofSeville · 23/11/2023 10:08

Alohapotato · 23/11/2023 10:05

It's just 15£ once a year... tell me you are cheap without telling me.

Maybe the OP is short of money, or is sick of the waste, or any other legitimate reason for questioning Christmas present buying.

OP could you suggest that you don't exchange gifts at all? Then you can spend your money on your DC and they spend their money on theirs according to respective budgets and appetite for even more shopping for presents.

PuttingDownRoots · 23/11/2023 10:06

Buy a joint gift for the whole family if it bothers you so much. Or stop getting gifts for each other if you dislike it that much

myotherkidisacassowary · 23/11/2023 10:05

Who cares, it’s £15. Unless that’s unaffordable for you (in which case tell her the amount needs to be lower or stop doing presents completely) it’s literally just not worth caring about.

Alohapotato · 23/11/2023 10:05

It's just 15£ once a year... tell me you are cheap without telling me.

SadlyACupOfTeaDoesNotSolveEverything · 23/11/2023 10:05

This has to be a reverse.
I have 3, DSis1 has 4, DSis2 has 2 and Dbro has none. Dbro still buys for all 9!

Conkersinautumn · 23/11/2023 10:04

I mean, she could have more kids!. They are individuals and you should treat your niblibgs fairly BUT I do think you can set your own budget, there's no need to 'match' those in the family.

EleMar · 23/11/2023 10:03

DH and I have only started to think about TTC - there was a strong possibility of us being child free. Husband has 3 nephews / nieces - so for the past 10 years we have been giving birthday presents and Christmas presents to all 3 (plus little gifts when visiting, or Easter eggs etc.). Didn't cross my mind not to just because we don't have kids (obviously if money was tight we might have considered a different approach but not because we don't have kids ourselves)

KinS24 · 23/11/2023 10:02

Children are individuals. Not part of a set. You have an individual relationship with each child as their aunt. Same as your sister does with yours. YABU

sollenwir · 23/11/2023 10:02

Is this a reverse?
As others have said, buy them all something within the 10-15 range, that won't get much anyway these days.

Rugbee · 23/11/2023 10:01

Ah the Christmas spirit is alive and well

nancy75 · 23/11/2023 10:01

If you didn’t have kids would their kids get nothing?

KatBurglar · 23/11/2023 10:01

What a depressing and begrudging mindset you have, @Natspenc.

user1492757084 · 23/11/2023 09:59

Fifteen per person is what I would do.

For next year you might like to stick with the limit and have each child draw a name out of a hat and have each child purchase one gift for one other.
Or all relatives pool their gift money towards one gift for each child.

It is stingy to cut back and have some children getting better presents.

Iwannaliveinstarshollow · 23/11/2023 09:57

Sorry OP, but that is full on Scrooge.

It's not the kids fault they have more siblings than your children do. All they will see is that auntie and uncle Natspenc aren't as generous as their own parents. I think it's really poor behaviour for the sake of a few quid.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/11/2023 09:57

Meany