Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to spend the same amount on presents

84 replies

Natspenc · 23/11/2023 09:51

So SIL now has 3 kids and we have 2. She wants us all to spend £15 on each kid but as she now has 3 I want to split it evenly and spend £10 on each of hers.
husband thinks I’m being rude and tight but I don’t see why we should be spending £15 more than her forever.
AIBU? Or should we spend the same amount?

OP posts:
BoredOfBeingTired · 23/11/2023 18:14

Natspenc · 23/11/2023 10:30

gosh didn’t realise how negative everyone would be.
I guess it’s the principle and it came about as last year my brother who has 1 kid said he was spending twice as much as me so I realised that was mean so told him to spend half the amount on my kids so we spend the same.
money is tight this year so I guess I am thinking about money more.
I am also annoyed as she always seems to give hand me down second hand toys as presents and then requests things for her kids more than the amount we have said

Everyone is negative because the actual issue doesn't relate to your original post!
If you are spending £45 on brand new toys and she (for example) spends £10 on some used tat for your children of course its unfair.
Ignore the list and spend a fiver on each child, if she says anything just explain that she wasn't keeping her end of the bargain.

TheNoodlesIncident · 23/11/2023 17:42

... she will send us a link to an exact present more than the amount she has stated. And then give us a toy she has had for years and so doesn’t spend anything.

Well, now. This is different from what you originally seemed annoyed about.

In this scenario, I would be inclined to send her in return a list of items your dc would like in the stated price bracket. If she hasn't got it already, she might have to try to get it second hand. I would try to get any requests that her dc have second hand if you can. Vinted or eBay may be useful. If you can't find those items cheaper than her link, buy them something else you think they'd like. Alternatively buy vouchers for an amount you feel OK with and give them those in a gift card.

I don't like stinginess towards children but your SIL seems happy to be tight to your kids, so why should you push the boat out for hers? You can't make her be decent about kids' presents, she can't make you buy anything, you are in charge of your Christmas spending.

MrsMarzetti · 23/11/2023 11:27

£5 child ! So your 2 can have a book and chocolate but the other 3 can only have a book. Glad you weren't my Aunt.

imnotwhoyouthinkiam · 23/11/2023 11:25

Middleagedmeangirls · 23/11/2023 09:56

When things that are meant to be gifts instead become transactions where groups or individuals swap goods they think are of equal value they stop becoming presents and become trading.

This is so against the spirit of Christmas that I think you should, as a family, rethink giving gifts at all.

I agree with this.

I have a budget for my nieces and nephews. My siblings have a budget for theirs, which includes my DC. I have no idea how they relate to each others budgets.

My Grandad used to give us £50 per household. This means my house got £50 between 3. My brother got £50 between 5. Obviously that was better for me than him.

This year he's paying for us to all go out for a meal. It will cost more for my brothers family than mine. That doesn't make it unfair. It's just the way it is.

Crikeyalmighty · 23/11/2023 11:23

When Xmas becomes transactional it totally misses the point and I'm afraid I don't do 'requests'

I will be making up a lovely stocking for my sons girlfriend of 5 months because she doesn't have a lot and I know will love the bits I've found- and I enjoy doing it - do I expect her to get us something- not remotely !

Twentypastfour · 23/11/2023 11:15

So she literally never buys your children presents?

Either reply back to her list immediately “thanks so much for this! Here is the list for my two, everything around the £15 mark as discussed. They’d love anything from this list please.” - she can hardly be annoyed as she’s sending you a list first.

Or just try and source things from her list or things similar to that on her list second hand too. Maybe even tell her on present exchange “I’m always so impressed you manage to give us second hand each year so I’ve given it a real go to be better for the environment this year and managed to get yours second hand too! I love this tradition we have.” Etc.

In this discussion of budgets does it never come up that she doesn’t spend anything?

Calmdown14 · 23/11/2023 11:12

And just tell her you've already bought them gifts if she sends specific instructions. Suggestions is handy but she can't demand it

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 23/11/2023 11:12

Just send her a message back saying "Don't worry about the gift suggestion. I was super organised this year and have bought the gifts already!"

And then buy whatever you fancy when it is on special so you can spend less!

Calmdown14 · 23/11/2023 11:10

I aim for about £15 for my nieces but it is never exact to the penny

Sometimes I get something more expensive on a good offer so one will be slightly under and the other will be slightly over.

As long as the level of gift is comparable and something that suits them I don't see it matters exactly what it cost.

Do an Argos 3for 2 or two for £15 and get them a similar level of gift while remaining pretty much in budget.

ColleenDonaghy · 23/11/2023 11:08

I think you buy for the child, not the family. If there were another sibling with one child you probably wouldn't begrudge the cousin £15 so don't penalise the children for having siblings.

Obviously don't spend money you don't have, but assuming you have the £15 don't be so bloody tight.

PippyLongTits · 23/11/2023 10:54

You don't have to tell anyone your budget and you don't have to stick to a prescribed list of requested items.

Christmas lists should be taken as suggestions only, not mandatory obligations. Nothing bad happens if you don't stick to the list.

Dweetfidilove · 23/11/2023 10:53

😂😂😂😂

Gillypie23 · 23/11/2023 10:51

Stop being so petty.

Catza · 23/11/2023 10:49

Natspenc · 23/11/2023 10:43

I do see how it seems so Scrooge now and I only think it has only come about because of her. I never used to be like this. … she never lets us buy what we want to buy her kids - she will send us a link to an exact present more than the amount she has stated. And then give us a toy she has had for years and so doesn’t spend anything.

What do you mean "she never lets you". Does she physically prevent you from getting an alternative present, does she purchase a present herself and then takes you to small claims court for the cost reimbursement? Please stop being so helpless. Nobody can prevent you from doing whatever you want to do.
"Hey sis, this is the list of gifts I want you to buy for my children"
"Thank you but we already bought them gifts"
End of

dixeypeach · 23/11/2023 10:49

I aim to spend £20 each on my siblings and their children. I've just ordered all their presents. Some of the kids stuff was £14 and some £18 they will all get their presents and a selection box and that will be that. The adult ladies I got the same thing (hair care) £17.50 each I will go to primark and buy them a pack of scruchies to go with them now that might go over the £20 but I save on the kids stuff so it all balances out in the end. And the best thing is nobody will know how much I spent on each because their not going to ask for receipts are they.

Op I think your over thinking it. But then all something that looks the same value and get on with your Xmas.

CrazyBaubles · 23/11/2023 10:47

So it's her attitude, not the money that's annoyed you.
That's fair - but you need to address that in some way.

Send her links to things for your dc - make sure they're in budget but send them asap.

Also, why do you buy the gift she tells you to? My SIL uses a kids wish list for my nieces but we aren't expected to buy exact things from it - it's there for us to get ideas on what the girls would like. Then we buy what we want, using the budget we want to spend.

If the link if for a puzzle for example, look for something similar, in budget and get that.
Or go through your kids toys and give that.

Schum · 23/11/2023 10:47

I think it’s fine. I have 4 kids, my SIL has 2. I spend £20 a child on hers and she spends £10 each on mine. No issue, I definitely wouldn’t expect her to spend more in total on mine.

Wanttobeok · 23/11/2023 10:46

I have 1 child, my brother has 3.

We spend £25 on each child. So I pay £75 and they pay £25. Doesn't bother me in the slightest 🤷‍♀️

To be honest I'm crap at budgeting and love buying present so always go over the £25 anyway

Natspenc · 23/11/2023 10:43

I do see how it seems so Scrooge now and I only think it has only come about because of her. I never used to be like this. … she never lets us buy what we want to buy her kids - she will send us a link to an exact present more than the amount she has stated. And then give us a toy she has had for years and so doesn’t spend anything.

OP posts:
Keeva2017 · 23/11/2023 10:42

Wow, you must be a runner for Aunty of the year award.

wednesday32 · 23/11/2023 10:41

Select gifts from a store that has 3 for two. You still spend £30 and each child will have a gift worth £15-solved.

SpringingJoy · 23/11/2023 10:40

My dad's dead. Dh's isn't.

This year I'm going to spend double on my mum from the family budget to make sure it's equal and that the same is being spent on each set of parents. The same about can be split between dh's two parents so that it's fair.

Dh can tell his mum that she only gets half the amount spent on her as my mum does, I'm sure that won't cause any upset at all.

TolkiensFallow · 23/11/2023 10:37

I’m with your husband. Seems a bit odd. Can’t you just have a ball park figure?

Catza · 23/11/2023 10:37

I don't know how families even get to the point where they arrive at specific budgets for gifts. I have never had to provide the receipt for things I buy for my family, or anyone else, for that matter.

Twentypastfour · 23/11/2023 10:35

I am also annoyed as she always seems to give hand me down second hand toys as presents and then requests things for her kids more than the amount we have said

Well put a stop to this?

So either-
a) start requesting things back
b) tell her that you will just get something you think her DC will enjoy, not from her list; or
c) try and source the things she’s suggesting second hand too?

Or a mixture of all three?

I don’t see what’s wrong with second hand. Some of my DC’s presents this year will be second hand, some won’t be. It literally just depends on what I can find. If I’m looking for a particular toy and I can find it on Vinted, win win.