Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be confused about "healthy eating"

133 replies

Van34 · 23/11/2023 09:22

It's not that I don't understand what foods are and aren't healthy (or so i thought). But I have no idea how to eat healthily. Bear with me.
I used to have a jacket and tuna (with a dash of mayo) but then I was told that it was as unhealthy as sandwiches. So then I tried salads but remain hungry no matter how much I had. Went onto soup but was then told that they are also unhealthy and ultra processed. What should I have?
I understand moderation but portion sizes are minute. One portion of cereal is enough for a toddler. That's not going to fill me up until lunchtime. Is a slice of toast healthy? It used to be a staple breakfast when I was growing up. Or should we be having something else (not a tiny portion if cereal)
We eat home cooked food everyday, no ready meals. But are they healthy? Chilli, steak and chips, chicken in pittas, fajitas, mince and dumplings. All staples from childhood and all filling. But are they healthy? I know what's in them so they should be...
It's a minefield. No red meat. No wine. Low sugar. Low salt. Low carb. High fibre. Low fat. No fat. High protein. Low cal. But so many of these diet foods are processed....
I am so confused about it all.

OP posts:
GarlicMaybeNot · 23/11/2023 17:48

BarbaraofSeville · 23/11/2023 09:34

I used to have a jacket and tuna (with a dash of mayo) but then I was told that it was as unhealthy as sandwiches. So then I tried salads but remain hungry no matter how much I had. Went onto soup but was then told that they are also unhealthy and ultra processed

Have you ever thought that some people are telling you nonsense? I'd be wary about asking for advice about food on here as it will drag out the orthorexics who think that people should eat nothing but home made organic protein and veg, but the reality is that Michael Pollan's advice that was 'Eat real food, not too much, mostly plants' just about covers it, taking into account the 80/20 rule - it's what you do most of the time that matters but there's plenty of scope for what you eat to not stick 100% to the letter, however you define it.

Just make sure you eat plenty of veg, some fruit but not loads, mostly unprocessed and be realistic about portion sizes. You don't need to eat toddler size portions, but you shouldn't pile your (large dinner) plate high either.

Plus if you are hungry in the morning, eat more then. If you do this, you'll probably naturally eat less later on because you won't be starving hungry all day. If the common 'eat little or nothing all day in anticipation of a big dinner' way of eating doesn't work for you, don't eat like that.

Edited

be wary about asking for advice about food on here as it will drag out the orthorexics

This. A hundred times this!

There are people who eat nothing but processed, manufactured, added-ingredients foods, low in nutrition but high in trans fats, fillers and salt. Those are the people who might benefit from some healthy diet advice.

No-one with an averagely mixed diet needs to micro-tweak it to the extent you describe. If you're concerned, eat more veg. Make sure you get enough protein. That's it.

Catza · 23/11/2023 17:34

therealcookiemonster · 23/11/2023 16:37

that is really interesting. I went to UCL and we covered a good amount on nutrition and most of the colleagues I have worked with have been good (maybe I have been lucky, but then I have mainly worked in tertiary centres). and as a patient requiring a special diet myself have received solid advice from consultants .... but happy to accept this is not the norm.

I consistently hear from doctors I work with that they don't have a first clue about nutrition. Although, not a doctor myself, we were told about the NHS drive to use every consultation as an opportunity to promote healthy lifestyle, smoke cessation and healthy eating but there was nothing in my clinical degree even remotely resembling nutrition training. So not sure how we are expected to promote it. Personally, I took CPD courses as well as lean heavily on my experience of sports nutrition. But yes, I believe it is sadly not the norm.

therealcookiemonster · 23/11/2023 16:37

Catza · 23/11/2023 15:08

Nutrition is not adequately covered in medical school. Results from Macaninch, et al. (2020)
Out of 853 survey participants
"Most felt their nutrition training was inadequate, with >70% reporting less than 2 hours. "
"Only 26% of doctors were confident in their nutrition knowledge"
"74% gave nutritional advice less than once a month, citing lack of knowledge (75%) as the main barriers"
In specialist services, dieticians typically cover nutritional aspects of managing a condition.

that is really interesting. I went to UCL and we covered a good amount on nutrition and most of the colleagues I have worked with have been good (maybe I have been lucky, but then I have mainly worked in tertiary centres). and as a patient requiring a special diet myself have received solid advice from consultants .... but happy to accept this is not the norm.

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 23/11/2023 16:16

One single potato - especially a baked one with its skin on - is NOT too many carbohydrates for an adult human to eat at once. If anyone's being "ridiculous" here, it's those claiming that eating any carbs = bad, or the reason for diabetes. Cutting out refined sugar (esp in the form of sugary drinks) and fried stuff (like crisps, chips etc) would be more sensible than avoiding all carbs.
OP: please ignore the cranks. Keep making home-cooked food and avoiding ultra-processed crap. Eat as wide a range of different vegetables as possible.

WillowCraft · 23/11/2023 15:16

stayathomer · 23/11/2023 11:21

was listening to a nutritionalist the other day and she was saying people are getting too much conflicting ideas out there. She said eg mayonnaise is unhealthy if you put lashings and lashings on but a thin layer is fine, a spoon of ketchup it’s also fine it’s just the people who cover everything in it. Sandwiches also fine! She recommended grainy breads but said white bread in moderation is also grand. She finished up with how unhealthy extreme dieting is and how carbs can be cut down on but not cut and how people need a store of fat, especially coming into winter.

A store of fat coming into winter? Only if you are planning to hibernate, surely. Winter or summer makes no difference in the modern world, food is freely available year round, there is no difference in lifestyle. And anyone with a BMI in the healthy range has a store of fat anyway....

Catza · 23/11/2023 15:08

therealcookiemonster · 23/11/2023 12:25

you must have met some pretty awful doctors! obviously depending on specialty but it's in the medical school curriculum and GPs should have a good working knowledge of nutrition. most phyisicians are pretty well versed and often have expertise on nutrition relating to their specialty as well eg. renal diet for renal physicians etc.

Nutrition is not adequately covered in medical school. Results from Macaninch, et al. (2020)
Out of 853 survey participants
"Most felt their nutrition training was inadequate, with >70% reporting less than 2 hours. "
"Only 26% of doctors were confident in their nutrition knowledge"
"74% gave nutritional advice less than once a month, citing lack of knowledge (75%) as the main barriers"
In specialist services, dieticians typically cover nutritional aspects of managing a condition.

Stroopwaffels · 23/11/2023 14:48

According to My Fitness Pal, a medium jacket potato with tuna mayo is about 390 - 400 calories. Obvs will vary depending on the amount of mayo and size of potato. The calories required to maintain weight for a woman is 1500-2000 (again will vary depending on activity level). For weight loss, you're usually recommended 1200 calories.

So a lunch of your jacket potato and tuna mayo is a third of your daily calories if you are trying to lose weight, less than a third if you are not trying to lose weight. That is an IDEAL amount of calories for a lunch. leaves you 800 - 1100 calories to use over whatever else you eat in the day, drinks etc.

This demonisation of carbs is really very odd.

CharlotteBog · 23/11/2023 14:23

PinkRoses1245 · 23/11/2023 14:09

I would say that a jacket potato and tuna for lunch, then a full portion of cooked dinner, is a lot of calories. Depending on your activity level obviously. i work from home and usually don't have lunch, just a few snacks. if you have a desk job, you don't need three full meals.

That doesn't make the jacket potato unhealthy though.
Eating too many calories is unhealthy whether they come from celery or glace cherries.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 23/11/2023 14:15

I agree, messaging around healthy foods is so inconsistent and confusing! I work with someone who swears blind fruit is bad for you because it contains sugar.

But OP I really wouldn’t ask on MN about food issues, ever. Too many posters have undiagnosed eating disorders and there’s also been an increase in pro-ana posts

PinkRoses1245 · 23/11/2023 14:09

I would say that a jacket potato and tuna for lunch, then a full portion of cooked dinner, is a lot of calories. Depending on your activity level obviously. i work from home and usually don't have lunch, just a few snacks. if you have a desk job, you don't need three full meals.

Van34 · 23/11/2023 14:04

No major health conditions (diabetes etc). Suspect PCOS but have to wait until summer next year for my referral to consultant. Also have a GI condition that the Dr's have been unable to diagnose for many years. The Dr seems to think that the cure for both of these is for me to eat healthy and lose weight (I am chunky but not obese) I much thinner when I met DH and had similar issues. The whole jacket soup sandwich conversation stemmed from one of those Dr's visits.
"Oh well you need to eat healthy, that will help your symptoms"
"I do? I have a jacket and tuna for lunch most days or a tin of soup"
Recoils in horror "Jacket potatoes aren't healthy"
She was then unable to give me a better alternative. Wish I was there to see her lunch....

OP posts:
Jumpingthruhoops · 23/11/2023 13:52

Van34 · 23/11/2023 10:47

Sorry guys i did respond but it's disappeared.
It was the Dr that told me a jacket is unheathly. I have a couple of health complaints that they are blaming on eating an unhealthy diet... but then won't tell me what they think is healthy. I cook fresh every night. OK, portions might be a bit large, but it is all fresh food (no jar sauces) its not like we have pizza and kebab each night. Our fridge is restocked with meat and veg each week. Could live without a freezer and have a small staples pantry.

You say you have health complaints. Are you taking medication for these?

I ask because I started taking medication for the first time in my life a few years back and I put on weight - having always eaten relatively healthy. Not loads, but enough to bother me.

I discovered that this was for a few main reasons:

  1. My hormones were out of whack.
  2. The meds affect how I metabolise certain foods
  3. The meds were making me deficient in certain vitamins and minerals.

To address this, I started taking a multivitamin, crucially at the same time as my meds, to counter whatever they're doing. And I discovered Metabolism tea, to address that issue and balance my hormones, too.

The result: The weight fell off.

In short, you seem to be eating healthy enough, so I'd look into what else might be at play. Hope this is helpful.

therealcookiemonster · 23/11/2023 12:25

Catza · 23/11/2023 10:56

Doctors are not trained in nutrition. Call them out on their own bullshit.
"Jacket potato is unhealthy"
"Why do you say it Doc? What specifically is unhealthy about it"
"Well, you know... erm... "
" Please be specific"
"Well, erm... carbohydrates and all that"
"Ok doc, are you aware that nutritional guidance recommends we have complex carbohydrates in every meal?"
"Well, erm... I am not exactly a specialist in nutrition"
"Can I please have a referral to a dietician. I would really like to discuss my diet with someone knowledgeable"

you must have met some pretty awful doctors! obviously depending on specialty but it's in the medical school curriculum and GPs should have a good working knowledge of nutrition. most phyisicians are pretty well versed and often have expertise on nutrition relating to their specialty as well eg. renal diet for renal physicians etc.

Crikeyalmighty · 23/11/2023 12:25

@aswarmofmidges i totally agree -

Triffid1 · 23/11/2023 12:22

Catza · 23/11/2023 12:12

Well, by that logic I should have had diabetes by now.. I eat in excess of 200g carbs a day. I am healthy weight, have 20.5% fat mass, heart rate of an athlete and no indication of high sugar in my recent bloods.
It may be wise to limit carbs if you already have diabetes. On the other hand, I am not aware of any RCTs that show direct relationship between consuming carbs and developing diabetes. In fact, as far as I am aware, the biggest risk factor for diabetes is obesity and one can become obese by eating any food group (including "healthy foods") in unusually large quantities over time.

Edited

Yes, this. I have PCOS. My mother had type 2 diabetes. I am definitely at risk and have insulin resistance so there is a strong argument that I must be careful of carbs.

For people in the population who are at lower risk, there's no reason to believe that eating carbs will give them diabetes.

Risk factors include genetic factors (family history and I believe people of certain backgrounds are more inclined to it), and significant excess weight in particular. If you do not have those factors, you are relatively unlikely to get Type 2 diabetes.

This kind of hysterical generalisation is a huge problem.

therealcookiemonster · 23/11/2023 12:21

Starrmix · 23/11/2023 10:30

60g is like a full days worth of carbs for me. It’s nothing to do with “diet culture”. Just health and concerns about developing diabetes. You need to keep your blood sugar down or you end up being diabetic.

our bodies is very capable of maintaining normal blood sugar levels when we eat carbs. yes simple carbs can cause blood sugar spikes, but that is not a predictor of diabetes.

Mercurial123 · 23/11/2023 12:14

MN is the last place I would ask for diet advice. It's full of people who have jumped on the low carbs, high protein bandwagon, and have a fear of UPF foods. Everything is about moderation.

Catza · 23/11/2023 12:12

Starrmix · 23/11/2023 10:30

60g is like a full days worth of carbs for me. It’s nothing to do with “diet culture”. Just health and concerns about developing diabetes. You need to keep your blood sugar down or you end up being diabetic.

Well, by that logic I should have had diabetes by now.. I eat in excess of 200g carbs a day. I am healthy weight, have 20.5% fat mass, heart rate of an athlete and no indication of high sugar in my recent bloods.
It may be wise to limit carbs if you already have diabetes. On the other hand, I am not aware of any RCTs that show direct relationship between consuming carbs and developing diabetes. In fact, as far as I am aware, the biggest risk factor for diabetes is obesity and one can become obese by eating any food group (including "healthy foods") in unusually large quantities over time.

aswarmofmidges · 23/11/2023 12:11

Exactly- which means we can't really offer advise or say her opinion is right and her doctor is wrong

Elastica23 · 23/11/2023 12:09

aswarmofmidges · 23/11/2023 11:57

Did you miss the update where she says her doctor told her the jacket potatoes were not ok for her particular health conditions?

We don't know what health conditions she has.

CharlotteBog · 23/11/2023 12:05

aswarmofmidges · 23/11/2023 11:57

Did you miss the update where she says her doctor told her the jacket potatoes were not ok for her particular health conditions?

That a doctor said this and that the OP has some health conditions would have been really useful to know up front.

Or maybe we should add caveats to every single response we write on face value.
This is my advice unless - you were told by a doctor/have health conditions/are ND/have a very important drip feed etc

aswarmofmidges · 23/11/2023 11:57

Did you miss the update where she says her doctor told her the jacket potatoes were not ok for her particular health conditions?

Mirrormeback · 23/11/2023 11:54

OP trust your instincts and stop listening to idiots who don't know what they're talking about

Baked potatoes, tuna and salad is a normal healthy meal

FoxyLocksie · 23/11/2023 11:52

Generally speaking, the closer a food is to its natural state, the "healthier" it is for you to eat.
So, try to stick to foods that are unprocessed or minimally processed as much as possible for most of the time.

A bowl of highly processed cereal alone will not sustain you until lunchtime and may spike your blood sugar up too high, causing a subsequent dip. You could try adding chopped nuts and/or seeds to it and having natural yogurt with it instead of milk. Or have porridge instead, or something else, such as an omelette.

I make my own granola (recipe from Michael Moseley's Clever Guts book), which is very simple to make and have it with yogurt and a handful of berries.

Elastica23 · 23/11/2023 11:43

I'd focus on five things:

  • Plenty of veg, particularly green and cruciferous vegetables
  • Not too much food overall
  • Plenty of fibre
  • Keep things with added sugar to a minimum- obviously sweet things like cakes and biscuits
  • Keep ultra processed food to a minimum

Other than that unless you have any particular conditions - some people can't eat fibrous food, some people need to reduce starchy carbs due to blood sugar, some need to reduce cholesterol - there is no need to cut out whole food groups or reduce particular macro nutrients.

Swipe left for the next trending thread