Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Someone telling everyone I have autism when I don’t have it

90 replies

Winterinwonderland · 23/11/2023 08:28

In addition to my full time job I am a volunteer and executive trustee for a charity.

The charity chair set up a chat with a large number of people in it and told them I have autism. I do not have autism.

He also told them I had incidents at home. This was news to me having had no incidents at home.

A third party replied on the chat stating that I do not have autism and that there had not been any incidents at home. He was getting me mixed up with someone else.

He refused to accept this and has carried on telling everyone I have autism.

I have issued a GDPR SAR and Article 16 notice.
He has now blocked my access to IT systems and suspended me not following the governing document.

The other trustees have told him to make a rectification notice and apologise but he has refused. He has also been told the suspension was illegal and not authorised by the trustees.

This man has several complaints against him lodged with the charity commission for a large catalogue of issues. We all have our interviews this week.

AIBU take legal action against him for defamation or should I let it go. I am not willing to pursue the charity for obvious reasons.

OP posts:
Winterinwonderland · 23/11/2023 20:13

Thanks everyone for your views and opinions. I actually have already started the data protection route already.

All the trustees are backing me but as I said there have been mass resignations. There are around ten complaints lodged with the charity commission already. I had my interview and it’s being escalated now. All his conduct has been documented and CC are fully aware.

OP posts:
Samee20 · 23/11/2023 18:58

You should speak to a lawyer about it, I would consider it as a defamation not because there is something wrong with the diagnosis, its because you don't have it and it's as simple as that. Even if a person did have any condition he doesn't have any rights to spread that information. Aren't medical records confidential? So unless a person explicitly gave him permission to give their medical conditions to the world, it should not be given. It seems like he is associating autism and "having incidents at home" which in itself is discriminatory. Just read this on Internet "Health and care records are confidential so a person can only access someone else's records if they are authorised to do so. To access someone else's health records, a person must: be acting on their behalf with their consent, or. have legal authority to make decisions on their behalf (i.e. power of attorney),". Its better to enquire about all these with a solicitor who specialises in this.

PostItInABook · 23/11/2023 18:20

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 23/11/2023 16:27

@DumboHimalayan Autism is a disability, and to be diagnosed with it you need to have impairments which have a significant impact on your everyday functioning

Utterly incorrect. My DD has Autism and her what you call impairments' (Hmm) do not have any kind of significant impact on her every day functioning at all! Stop spreading false information

Then she shouldn’t have been diagnosed. It’s literally part of the diagnostic criteria.

Skyl1ne · 23/11/2023 18:09

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels

No you are incorrect. To get a diagnosis symptoms need to impact daily functioning.

slore · 23/11/2023 18:01

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 23/11/2023 16:27

@DumboHimalayan Autism is a disability, and to be diagnosed with it you need to have impairments which have a significant impact on your everyday functioning

Utterly incorrect. My DD has Autism and her what you call impairments' (Hmm) do not have any kind of significant impact on her every day functioning at all! Stop spreading false information

Well good for you, but please take a minute to show consideration for the majority of people with autism who are significantly impaired by their condition. This includes me. And there are people vastly more affected than me - some people with autism need constant 2-1 supervision, wear nappies and helmets, and cannot speak - do you ever think about them from your ivory tower?

If your daughter's needs are among the lowest, you should pipe down.

slore · 23/11/2023 17:55

It's not about saying autism is an insult, or that disabilities are bad. (I have autism and ADHD and am disabled by them).

What he's saying is really harmful - he is giving an account of your life and your needs that is wholly inaccurate.

He made you out to have a condition and circumstances in such a way that would imply that you have significant care needs and vulnerabilities. Because he is doubling down, and punishing you, he is also now making you look like a liar and destroying your credibility and reputation.

I think this counts for slander, especially as he was asked to rectify his mistake but refused - but you'd probably need a lot of money to go there.

He sounds like a very dangerous man: somebody who would rather destroy somebody's reputation and punish and exclude a charity volunteer, than to "lose face" by accepting he made a simple mistake. Narcissists are like toddlers and pathologically can't deal with any kind of shame, their egos can't handle it. Hence never admitting to mistakes.

He is also willing to broadcast confidential details of medical problems and home life of his volunteers. Could this be a breech of GDPR? Could you get the person he mixed you up with onside?

I would complain about him and go as high up as you can: complain to every high-up staff member in the charity you can think of, and write public reviews warning people about your experience volunteering there.

You could also report his behaviour to the police as malicious communications; there's no harm in reporting, the police will either be interested or they won't.

Don't worry about harming the charity, this man's presence will be doing far more harm than you, and is likely responsible for their staffing issues.

Jewelspun · 23/11/2023 17:24

Is he trying to discredit you so that you will leave?

Is it because he has a relative or friend he wants to take your place or have you offended him personally in some way you don't know of and he hates you?

RedToothBrush · 23/11/2023 16:43

https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/law-and-courts/discrimination/taking-action-about-discrimination/taking-action-about-harassment/

It’s also discrimination if someone harassed you because they made a mistake about your protected characteristics. For example, it’s discrimination if you and your housemate are straight but your landlord made offensive jokes about you being gay. This is called ‘discrimination by perception’.

Also
If someone who works for one of these organisations harasses you, the organisation is also responsible for the discrimination. For example if your colleague harasses you, your colleague and your employer are both legally responsible.

If you’re using a business or service and another customer harasses you, it isn’t usually discrimination. It might be discrimination if the customer keeps harassing you and the business or service knows about it but doesn’t stop them.

He is harassing you on the basis of perceived identity. He is disclosing information he knows to be false or if it was true would fall under Data Protection. He has been asked to cease and desist and has continued and has treated you unfairly on the basis of this protected characteristic in a discriminatory way. The charity has a duty to protect you. If they do not, you have case against both them and him on a personal level.

The duty I believe falls to the Trustees to ensure the charity is run properly and within the law. A chair who is discriminating on the basis of identity is potentially breaking the law and the Trustees have a duty to remove him because the Equality Act.

If you resign rather than attempting this, you leave the charity in a position where there is risk to the public and you are potentially not upholding your duties as a trustee to leave knowing this. So you technically are legally bound to take some action or potentially could be held liable if something were to happen to others along similar lines because you were fully aware of this man discriminating. It's unlikely to ever go like this (especially as the report to the charity commission would probably cover your arse) BUT if you do take your role as trustee seriously you should pursue the charity and/or him because your duty is to safeguard the public / to ensure the charity is run within the law - including the EA.

You do have a conflict of interest going on here because you are both victim and technically liable for his behaviour.

I would throw all the other trustees under the bus if they fail to back you up...

Check what you can do about harassment

Check if the harassment is discrimination under the Equality Act 2010, and if you can take legal action about it.

https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/law-and-courts/discrimination/taking-action-about-discrimination/taking-action-about-harassment

IWIllDoItNowInAMinute · 23/11/2023 16:38

It’s unprofessional of him to disclose personal information about people. Even if it were true I can’t understand why he thought it was their business to know, especially bringing your home life into it. It sounds a horrible situation for you. I would just make it clear to everyone who has been told that it’s not true and that you are concerned about him, and flip it around. This might sound generalising (because it is), but I know a few people who are diagnosed autistic and are high functioning and it’s still obvious they are on the autistic spectrum. Surely people will recognise you don’t have characteristics of being autistic anyway and recognise that he is wrong when you tell them he is wrong.

DumboHimalayan · 23/11/2023 16:30

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 23/11/2023 16:27

@DumboHimalayan Autism is a disability, and to be diagnosed with it you need to have impairments which have a significant impact on your everyday functioning

Utterly incorrect. My DD has Autism and her what you call impairments' (Hmm) do not have any kind of significant impact on her every day functioning at all! Stop spreading false information

Go and read the criteria. If you have an issue with the language, take it up with them.

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 23/11/2023 16:27

@DumboHimalayan Autism is a disability, and to be diagnosed with it you need to have impairments which have a significant impact on your everyday functioning

Utterly incorrect. My DD has Autism and her what you call impairments' (Hmm) do not have any kind of significant impact on her every day functioning at all! Stop spreading false information

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 23/11/2023 16:20

I'm sorry he's lied about you having 'issues' at home but even if you did have Autism, that's not something that would require an apology as though it's a fucking insult! That in itself is insulting to those of us with Autistic children....!

RedToothBrush · 23/11/2023 16:17

Ponderingwindow · 23/11/2023 16:06

Even if you did have autism, he doesn’t have the right to share that information with anyone.

even if you tell your employer your medical information, it is still your choice if that information is shared with other employees, clients, or contacts.

Exactly. Sharing that information breeches confidentially if it's true and constitutes harassment and bullying if he knows it to be untrue. In both cases it's discriminatory because he treats someone more poorly on the basis of a protected characteristic and thinks that's acceptable behaviour.

DumboHimalayan · 23/11/2023 16:11

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/11/2023 15:52

We will have to agree to differ. I'm a solicitor and I do not believe under the current defamation laws and that given that autism is a protected characteristic then there would be any hope whatsoever of proving defamation in the circumstances outlined by the OP.

Fair enough; you're educated to a much higher level than me on this, and I do agree that pursuing it in court is likely to be a fruitless and expensive move. But I'm surprised if things can be ruled out as defamatory just because people technically shouldn't discriminate on that basis, if the reality is that people are treated worse when thought to have that characteristic. It seems… idealistic.

Ponderingwindow · 23/11/2023 16:06

Even if you did have autism, he doesn’t have the right to share that information with anyone.

even if you tell your employer your medical information, it is still your choice if that information is shared with other employees, clients, or contacts.

RedToothBrush · 23/11/2023 15:59

He's bullying and harassing. Frame it as that.

You have been labelled as one thing, which is incorrect and he has then undermined you and tried to restrict your access to things for no reason. When you have tried to correct him he has ignored and has continued to belittle you. If you did have autism he would be discriminating against you deliberately because he sees being autistic as a reason a valid to treat you in this way.

Defamation is the wrong way to go.

This is all about the correct framing. He is trying to control others and bully and intimidate them out of the organisation. He is placing the organisations reputation in jeopardy. As a trustee you should have the power to boot him on this basis not the other way around.

Remember the Equality Act prevents discrimination on the basis of perceived identity - therefore you can't discriminate against a women because she 'might get pregnant' - this includes women who aren't pregnant and who can't get pregnant for fertility reasons - this includes even if it's known this woman has fertility issues, expresses a clear desire not to get pregnant or any other reason you can think of. Equally you can't discriminate against someone because you think they are gay (even if they are perfectly straight). The discrimination is based on the actions taken on basis of identity. You can refuse service because you think someone is gay even if they turn out to be perfectly straight.

If he thinks he can treat someone who generally has autism in this way, that's not acceptable. If he is harassing you and bullying you by saying he believes you to be autistic and treating you differently as a result that's harassment, bullying and potentially discriminatory behaviour. He's using discrimination as a way to deem you and to remove tasks from you.

As a charity you have the duty to ensure fair and equal treatment under the Equality Act. If he is demonstrating he treats people who he believes to be autistic differently and in a poorer way that's not ok. It's discrimination.

He needs retraining at best.

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/11/2023 15:52

DumboHimalayan · 23/11/2023 14:57

Defamation is about reputation damage. Reputation is a social thing. If most people in society, having been told a certain thing about you, would be less likely to use your services, or less likely to trust you, or less likely to think you're competent, then your reputation has been damaged — whether or not those people are actually correct to think that way about people with that characteristic. If it's false information, and it damages your reputation, then it's not unreasonable to consider it defamation. Acknowledging this wouldn't require the court to believe or state that autistic people are actually lesser people or not equal to others, just that society as a whole is such that having something like this said about you can damage your social standing or reputation.

I agree it would be a total ballache to pursue in court with no guarantee of success, but as an autistic diabetic who is not heterosexual, I have no issue acknowledging that it can be harmful to one's reputation to have these things thought/known to be true of you. There are people who think less of me because of these things. So I've no objection to someone being upset and considering it defamation when someone falsely attributes these characteristics to them.

We will have to agree to differ. I'm a solicitor and I do not believe under the current defamation laws and that given that autism is a protected characteristic then there would be any hope whatsoever of proving defamation in the circumstances outlined by the OP.

DumboHimalayan · 23/11/2023 14:57

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/11/2023 13:06

I'm not disputing that. I'm pointing out that from a legal perspective you have to prove that damage was caused and that it was done with malice.

Autism, whilst impacting some people severely, does not mean that you are a lesser person. The same applies to calling someone gay. Asking the court to find defamation in saying someone is autistic is like asking them to agree autistic people are not equal to others.

Defamation is about reputation damage. Reputation is a social thing. If most people in society, having been told a certain thing about you, would be less likely to use your services, or less likely to trust you, or less likely to think you're competent, then your reputation has been damaged — whether or not those people are actually correct to think that way about people with that characteristic. If it's false information, and it damages your reputation, then it's not unreasonable to consider it defamation. Acknowledging this wouldn't require the court to believe or state that autistic people are actually lesser people or not equal to others, just that society as a whole is such that having something like this said about you can damage your social standing or reputation.

I agree it would be a total ballache to pursue in court with no guarantee of success, but as an autistic diabetic who is not heterosexual, I have no issue acknowledging that it can be harmful to one's reputation to have these things thought/known to be true of you. There are people who think less of me because of these things. So I've no objection to someone being upset and considering it defamation when someone falsely attributes these characteristics to them.

Winterinwonderland · 23/11/2023 13:32

I have professional indemnity insurance

OP posts:
Willyoujustbequiet · 23/11/2023 13:14

AbacusAvocado · 23/11/2023 09:34

@x2boys - I don’t disagree with you, I just don’t think she could win a defamation case. I also think she needs to be very careful how she frames any complaint about this or some people will perceive her as saying autism is bad.

I agree.

I think there is a lack of awareness of the law regarding defamation in some of these replies. The costs are prohibitive if nothing else.

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/11/2023 13:06

x2boys · 23/11/2023 10:30

Autism is a disability and as such can be very disabling to some people being gay is not a disability.

I'm not disputing that. I'm pointing out that from a legal perspective you have to prove that damage was caused and that it was done with malice.

Autism, whilst impacting some people severely, does not mean that you are a lesser person. The same applies to calling someone gay. Asking the court to find defamation in saying someone is autistic is like asking them to agree autistic people are not equal to others.

Zooeyzo · 23/11/2023 10:58

What does he achieve by saying this? Are you filling a disability quota or something?

Agapornis · 23/11/2023 10:58

Rather than expensive legal action for defamation, you could 1. Report the GDPR breach to the ICO 2. Report the equality law offence to the police. If either case goes anywhere it will support the Charity Commission to take any action. However, the Charity Commission has very little power, so don't count on that. The trustees do have power to get rid of him, so they shouldn't resign.

Prettypaisleyslippers · 23/11/2023 10:46

Find another charity more worthy of you.

x2boys · 23/11/2023 10:30

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/11/2023 10:14

This

To prove defamation is to be able to prove that harm has been caused to your reputation. You would be asking the court to rule that being autistic is a negative thing. A court will not do that. Would you object to being called gay for example?

Defamation cases are incredibly expensive and difficult to win at the best of times.

It's a rabbit hole you don't want to go down.

Autism is a disability and as such can be very disabling to some people being gay is not a disability.

Swipe left for the next trending thread