Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who you agree with re childcare

140 replies

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:00

dh doesn’t want to consider a childminder, he thinks there may be problems with reliability and also the mix of ages may be a problem.

I think it might be good to at least look.

Wondering what others would do when you just don’t agree.

OP posts:
Caerulea · 23/11/2023 08:39

I should have explained in my OP. I don’t massively want to be a sahm.

I would prefer something more one on one than a nursery, though haven't done it myself eitherway. How soon do you have to decide? You might feel differently once baby is here.

MyCatIsPlotting · 23/11/2023 08:39

We use a childminder. I think both childminders and nurseries have different advantages. Trust is a key element with a childminder - you need to find one you like and who you feel comfortable with.

I much prefer childminders for babies and younger toddlers as they can give your child a really good amount of individualised attention in a way I’m
not confident all nurseries can (just because of numbers). Their numbers are capped as well - I think it’s up to three under-5s and up to six children in total, including the childminder’s own. Avoid childminders who cover multiple schools for the school run if they take after school children - I didn’t want mine spending huge chunks in the car.

I do think preschoolers can really benefit from bigger group experience. Also, with a childminder there’s a single point of failure - we have to cover her holidays. Ours is never ill and has only closed due to illness when she had Covid. She also has a backup arrangement with another childminder in case of emergency.

My experience is nurseries are quicker to send home children who are off-colour rather than ill. They may have longer opening hours but are less flexible - I worried about what would happen in the case of public transport failure with a nursery, as we don’t have family who could pick up in an emergency.

Ohforfox · 23/11/2023 08:38

I have a childminder and she is phenomenal. She really cares about all of the children & makes sure they are happy. My DD loves going there & although she is older, the babies are so settled and content & they love my DD & follow her around. I knew instantly when I met her that she would be a good match. I also visited other childminders who we didn't gel with so it depends on the individual I think! I obviously prefer a childminder but my main reasons are:

  1. it's a homely environment
  2. the mix of ages is lovely
  3. they can be out in the garden/at the park/soft play/museums whenever they want, sleep when they need, eat when they want. It's not as rigid.
  4. it's more personal, my childminder would send me photo/videos of DD during the day when she was young.
  5. they really know your child & 'celebrate' the wins with you. I know sickness is a worry for you but I've never found this to be a problem.
  6. you build that trust with one person/maybe 2 if they have an assistant.

Your husband should arrange to meet a few CM's and visit a few nurseries then make a decision.

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:37

I’m not trying to insist on anything, I’m just considering what is best for her.

OP posts:
YourNameGoesHere · 23/11/2023 08:36

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:34

I should have explained in my OP. I don’t massively want to be a sahm. I’m currently on maternity leave. We’re looking at some options for when I go back to work. At the moment she has a nursery place but I’m hesitating and DH is reluctant to consider a childminder.

If she has a nursery place confirmed then why are you still trying to insist on alternative childcare? I'd be thankful she had already secured a space and consider the job ticked off.

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:34

I should have explained in my OP. I don’t massively want to be a sahm. I’m currently on maternity leave. We’re looking at some options for when I go back to work. At the moment she has a nursery place but I’m hesitating and DH is reluctant to consider a childminder.

OP posts:
Bearbookagainandagain · 23/11/2023 08:34

It depends what you need, we didn't even consider a childminder for the same reason as your husband. The mixed aged groups means a lot of time spent in a chair or car for a baby, on school runs etc.

I also felt more comfortable with the idea of leaving my 6-months old with several carers rather than 1, they get more support and can have a break of things get tough with a baby.
And finally we wouldn't have saved any money with a childminder since we needed full time 7:30-5:30.

In 2 years, my friends who chose childminders all had to change 2-3 times because of issues with how their child were treated, or because the childminder let them down for another family.

SecondUsername4me · 23/11/2023 08:33

Childminder is way more likely to take your dc when they have coughs and minor colds. Nursery won't let them through the door.

YourNameGoesHere · 23/11/2023 08:33

Popetthetreehugger · 23/11/2023 08:24

I think look to see what’s even available! You may not have luxury of choice.

This ^^ when DS needed to go to childcare there was no childminders taking on new children so we could only choose a nursery and of those nurseries only 2 had spaces for the days we needed.

This was similar for all those I know at the time getting childcare and I doubt it's changed much here in the last 3 years if anything I'd suspect it's got worse and there's even less choice.

SecondUsername4me · 23/11/2023 08:32

Sorry he doesn’t want me to be a sahm

Do you want to be one?

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:32

@SecondUsername4me but there’s no point visiting if he won’t even consider it. He just keeps saying people at work who use childminders are always off due to problems with childminders. Not in a horrible abusive way. He just doesn’t think it’s a good idea.

@Caerulea this is for when I go back to work and it is part time so all good.

OP posts:
JustMarriedBecca · 23/11/2023 08:32

I think you need to look at both. My Mum was a childminder and she and my Dad have attended the weddings of several of the kids we grew up with. The family became good friends and we even holiday-ed with them. Now their kids kids are friends with mine. It's been lovely (obviously Mum had other kids who we did lose contact with). I know several former teachers who are now childminders and if they lived locally, I'd 100% have them look after our kids in an EYFS setting.

That said, when we put our two in EYFS we ended up going for a nursery. Cost was higher but the setting was better than local childminders, and reliability and hours were better for our jobs.

You have to at least look at both rather than discount immediately I think.

Caerulea · 23/11/2023 08:28

Is there a reason why OH doesn't want you to stay at home with the baby?

SecondUsername4me · 23/11/2023 08:28

Best plan is to both go and visit the options that have spaces.

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:26

I’m not against nurseries, but it’s for a baby so wondered if she might prefer a more one to one setup. Don’t mind really.

OP posts:
Iscreamtea · 23/11/2023 08:24

There are good and bad childminders and good and bad nurseries. Child would be fine with either if they are good. My personal preference would be childminder for an under 3 because I like the home environment and think you can build a more personal relationship with them. From 3 I'd want them in pre-school or nursery because I think there are big benefits at that age.

Popetthetreehugger · 23/11/2023 08:24

I think look to see what’s even available! You may not have luxury of choice.

Sceptre86 · 23/11/2023 08:23

How wmold is the child? Any special needs? How many days childcare do you need, is it full days or half days? Who would do pick ups and drop offs? Surely all of that info would help you decide what will work best for your family?

My dh wasn't keen on using a childminder as he felt nursery was a better option Our dd thrived in the nursery setting but I think our ds would have been better with a childminder. We work around each other for dd2 ao no childcare needed but if we did I know some great childminders that I would have looked at instead of a setting like nursery.

NameChangeBonus · 23/11/2023 08:21

Is this because he would prefer a nursery? Nurseries are my preference too and I would never even have considered a childminder so I do get where he is coming from. Are you similarly against nurseries.

When DH and I don’t agree, then whichever of us feels most strongly on the topic gets their way!

NoCloudsAllowed · 23/11/2023 08:21

Ime older kids at 3-4 are either entirely uninterested in babies or very sweet with them. And babies love watching older children.

aswarmofmidges · 23/11/2023 08:21

Childminder with a mix of ages can be great - a more natural set up and also many will do school drop and pick up and holidays for the children they had as babies so the child gets continuity and you get help for the difficult primary years

NoCloudsAllowed · 23/11/2023 08:20

Why not do some visits and ask around and see what you think?

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:20

Sorry he doesn’t want me to be a sahm, it’s just he thinks nursery .

Different ages … still a difference between a baby and 3 / 4 year old though. Just trying to consider options.

OP posts:
NoCloudsAllowed · 23/11/2023 08:19

Re reliability - we had childminder from 1-3years then a year or so of nursery.

Nurseries in my experience are more likely to send kids home if they're a bit coldy/out of sorts - some take their temp even when they're not showing any signs of illness. Our childminder was much more flexible. And in COVID it was much better as nursery closed every time someone got a cough!

Orangello · 23/11/2023 08:19

So what does he propose then? Nothing? Child will look after themselves?