Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who you agree with re childcare

140 replies

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:00

dh doesn’t want to consider a childminder, he thinks there may be problems with reliability and also the mix of ages may be a problem.

I think it might be good to at least look.

Wondering what others would do when you just don’t agree.

OP posts:
BeeDavis · 23/11/2023 09:10

If anything, I’d say my childminder is way more reliable than a nursery! She doesn’t just send him home for silly stuff like I see people say on here about nurseries. Hes not with a mix of different aged kids they’re all the same age that go.

Fluffyc1ouds · 23/11/2023 09:09

I agree with a PP who said how their child isn't immediately sent home from the childminder if they're under the weather, while a nursery will. I don't think there was a single occasion we had to pick DS up in the day. Our childminder would snuggle DS up on the sofa with a film, cuddle him if he needed it and message me about Calpol. They weren't so fussy. Older kids are usually at school so it's only little ones at their house. DS made some lovely friends.

If the childminder was going to be off for an appointment or holiday we had plenty of notice. We would sometimes book our holidays for the same dates as it meant we didn't need to pay childcare for that period. Yeah, sometimes his childminder would be off sick, but it wasn't often at all.

Positives for us were the home environment so I felt much better leaving him there while I worked. They would go on lots of days out to the park, zoo, aquarium, beach, etc. His childminder became an extension of our family and she knew DS so well.

We did also use a nursery for a year (alongside the childminder), and it was much better than I expected. But felt a lot less personal than the childminder.

strawberry2017 · 23/11/2023 09:01

Childminders are usually very reliable because it's their living and they aren't going to do anything that effects their income.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/11/2023 09:01

I agree with DH. We didn't even look at childminders for several reasons and it's same now that I'm pregnant with twins, people keep suggesting a nanny because with 3 under 2, it will work out cheaper than nursery but we much prefer nursery.

Nosleeptheo · 23/11/2023 09:00

Personally for me nursery was the better option I work full time but dp is satd. For me a childminder can call in sick (which is unavoidable) however nursery that's covered unless extreme circumstances. At nursery in a baby room the ratio is really low and they also have a key work so will get one to one time if that's what you are worried about. You both need to talk and pro and con each of them to see what works best for you

ColleenDonaghy · 23/11/2023 08:58

Sounds like you're just having a wobble, which is very normal as you get closer to the end of mat leave.

We never considered child minders due to sickness, holidays etc. I also don't like the idea of mixed age groups and babies being brought out on school runs etc. For other people, that will be a pro rather than a con so it's very personal.

Ours have both been at nursery 5 days a week from about 10 months and have loved it. Eldest now at school with kids she's known since the baby room and youngest will be the same.

Somewhatchallenging · 23/11/2023 08:57

I wanted a childminder. She was fabulous. She had her own baby the same age as mine, and a little boy in reception. It was a great situation that worked well.

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:56

To @HomeBird43 sorry

OP posts:
Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:55

I think that’s dh worry and nine really but so many seem to think childminders better for babies

OP posts:
TomatoSandwiches · 23/11/2023 08:54

A good experienced childminder would be my choice for a baby, it's much closer to being at home with a parent and I think that's more beneficial to the child and more suitable at such a young age.

YourNameGoesHere · 23/11/2023 08:54

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:46

believe me I know Smile that’s why we got the nursery place sorted months ago. But I do think I’m allowed to ponder things online, anonymously and if there’s no space anywhere then that’s largely pointless. But I don’t want to not do what’s best for children because I didn’t even look iyswim (typing one handed so hope that makes sense!)

It makes sense but if you sorted childcare months ago then I'd wonder if it wasn't actually you just having the natural worry about going back to work rather than about the type of care?

It's natural to wonder if you're doing the best but if you always second guess yourself then you'll end up tying yourself in knots.

I'm sure the nursery you've chosen is fabulous and she will thrive there and this is just a case of you wondering if the grass would have been greener.

HomeBird43 · 23/11/2023 08:54

my sister in law used a few different childminders and had ridiculous experiences with all of them. Opening the door in her pjs having clearly just woken up. Calling in sick at the last minute because her dog was unwell. Friends telling her that they’d seen her childminder not properly supervising the kids at soft play because she was too busy with her pals. Kids being upset on drop off because something had clearly happened to upset them but she never found out the truth because there was no one else there. Eventually she switched to nursery and never looked back.

we had a wonderful experience at nursery. Honestly. I know there are excellent childminders too but it’s too hit or miss for me.

MerryMarigold · 23/11/2023 08:52

In Nursery your child will have one key worker so they will be able to bond with someone specific. Also there will be colleagues keeping an eye, correcting any mistakes which may be made.

However, childminders are often older and more experienced. You would have to trust them as there is no one to keep an eye.

You could do Preschool plus a childminder and get the best of both worlds - but only from 2 years old.

groveparker0 · 23/11/2023 08:51

One good thing about childminders is the continuity of care. My son started at the childminder when he was 10 months old and she looked after him all the way through school until my job changed when he was in the juniors, and we didn't need childcare any more. It meant she knew him so well. And I never worried about school holidays or days off for elections or inset days or staggered starts to reception, etc - it was all covered.

Also ours was friendly with lots of other childminders so when she had an operation once or when she went on holiday, there were others to step in to cover - who the kids knew because they went to groups and activities together.

Mumof2teens79 · 23/11/2023 08:49

If one of you is dead set against an idea and the other isn't that bothered then it's not worth forcing the idea.
If you were dead seat against a nursery you would have a problem but you aren't so just respect his opinion.

I had a CM as a child....but my mum already knew her.
When we had first DD we only looked at nurseries...I didn't know any CMs and it's a huge step/trust letting someone you don't know look after your first baby in their home....at least with a nursery there are multiple staff members, and other families/parents so it's not just you trusting an individual iyswim

But then circs changed and after using nurseries for 3+ yrs we looked at a CM who could eventually do school pick ups for oldest and have youngest full time. By then I was more confident as a parent, DD1 could tell us what she did when there, and I knew people in the area who knew different CMs and could give honest opinions.

The lady we went with was Fab, but is swings and roundabouts.
She could do school pickups, but we had to coordinate holidays around her holidays. The mix of ages is great in some ways, but activities are not all going to be targeted at your child.

HomeBird43 · 23/11/2023 08:48

Nursery all the way.

childminders call in sick. Which is fine but I already had to factor in my own kids’ sickness absence in taking time off work and I didn’t really have the capacity to factor in somebody else’s.

wholecupcake · 23/11/2023 08:47

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:26

I’m not against nurseries, but it’s for a baby so wondered if she might prefer a more one to one setup. Don’t mind really.

Then you both need to decide childminder/nursery wherever has space!

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:46

believe me I know Smile that’s why we got the nursery place sorted months ago. But I do think I’m allowed to ponder things online, anonymously and if there’s no space anywhere then that’s largely pointless. But I don’t want to not do what’s best for children because I didn’t even look iyswim (typing one handed so hope that makes sense!)

OP posts:
A1b2c3d4e5f6g7 · 23/11/2023 08:46

Have you seen the baby room at your nursery, and how old will your baby be?

We deliberated the same and went for nursery in the end. His key worker is amazing, and they do so many activities, music circles, singing, dancing, sensory play, outdoor play etc as it's all aimed at the same age. He's developed so much being there, and loves going in. The baby room is small and cozy. He's now in the toddler rooms which are busier and noisier, with lots going on.

They do send him home with illness, but to be fair, when they've sent him home he has been poorly.

We're actually due another baby in a month or two, but have been doing the most we can financially to keep him in nursery as much as possible while we're on leave. Just because he loves it so much and we don't want him to miss out and be bored at home.

YourNameGoesHere · 23/11/2023 08:45

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:42

You might not be meaning this @YourNameGoesHere but you’re coming over as very confrontational.

I'm not meaning to be confrontation but honestly so many people think they have choice and in reality there isn't much choice in early years childcare. If you have a nursery place for the days you need you're actually doing very very well.

It's so important to realise that sometimes there isn't a choice which is why I was asking if there were actually childminders with spaces because if there isn't then surely even if you want to use a childminder you can't.

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 23/11/2023 08:43

I've used both.

DD went to a childminder from 12 months to 2.5 years.

Childminder was good and more like a nursery set up. The age mix wasn't a bad thing. Helped her speech and development if anything. The pluses are you know who's dealing with your child. You get to know them as people and they do you. Your child forms a good relationship also. They are often more flexible. Ours had a policy of charging extra if you were late but never enforced it if it was an ocasional stuck in traffic incident. They'll also take children who are a little unwell more flexibly. They are also generally cheaper. Downsides are yes they are more unreliable. If you have limited leave and an employer who is unsympathetic to childcare issues and no family backup, personally i would avoid. Ours wasn't bad but she took about 6-7 weeks leave a year, plus some off days. These were often in school holidays too so a bit of a pain for annual leave. There was the times she or her children were sick so short notice days off. Also resources wise i'd say they were a little more restricted with what they had and time for each child was sometimes more limited. Although they did get more outings and seeing the real world at local parks and play groups.

DD transferred to a nursery at 2.5. It's an excellent nursery. They have above the required staff for ratios so more 1:1 time for learning and care. Resources are good and varied. Preschool had a qualified early years teacher. There's more structure ready for school. It has longer hours and is only closed 1 week a year. So my leave is now used for actual leave when i want it. Downsides its hard to keep track of who DD has caring for her. Although she has a key worker therss a lot of staff. I find the limited age she interacts with negative to an extent as keeps her a bit sheltered from the world. The cost is astronomical (over 70 percent of my wages). Theyre also a bit more strict on sickness. Sent DD home with a temp of 38.3c and absolutely fine in herself. Also note our nursery is excellent. They pay a real living wage and invest in staff. Staff turnover is very very low. But we do pay for that. This is not the case for alot of nurseries. Some are basically dumping grounds for children with staff who don't care less and management who are awful, though some childminders are also terrible. Do not trust ofsted. We saw and outstanding nursery and it was far from it. Disinterested staff. Terrible organisation and children went outside once a week!

The only way is to go and see. If you have an excellent childminder near you and a rubbish nursery its a no brainer. DH needs to be open to both options and explore them and you both need to think about what you're looking for be it somewhere nuturing, outside play, social interaction. Or just reliable childcare that is always open. Only you know what you want.

Bearbookagainandagain · 23/11/2023 08:42

SecondUsername4me · 23/11/2023 08:33

Childminder is way more likely to take your dc when they have coughs and minor colds. Nursery won't let them through the door.

That's absolutely not true.
Our nursery follow the NHS guidelines for contagious diseases, and will rarely refuse kids as long as they are well enough to be with the group. They will also give Calpol in case of mild fever. Other are stricter but they will show their sickness policy at registration.

Childminders make up their own rules and in my circles will not take any sick child ever.

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:42

You might not be meaning this @YourNameGoesHere but you’re coming over as very confrontational.

OP posts:
Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:41

She’s here, she’s sitting nex to me now Smile I don’t know, probably will go with nursery. I just don’t feel 100% about it but then I probably wouldn’t about anything.

OP posts:
YourNameGoesHere · 23/11/2023 08:40

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:37

I’m not trying to insist on anything, I’m just considering what is best for her.

Presumably you both thought the nursery was best for her when you visited it and made arrangements to send her there though? So what's changed since then?

Are there actually any childminders in your area with room to take your daughter on the days you need and at the start date you need, if not then it's all bit of a moot point anyway?