Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who you agree with re childcare

140 replies

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:00

dh doesn’t want to consider a childminder, he thinks there may be problems with reliability and also the mix of ages may be a problem.

I think it might be good to at least look.

Wondering what others would do when you just don’t agree.

OP posts:
Alarae · 23/11/2023 11:55

So my daughter went to a childminder up to 3.5, then moved to nursery. Her childminder was fantastic for her when she was young, they developed a really close bond and she thrived. It was evident though when she turned 3 that she had outgrown the setting- she needed more social stimulation with other kids and more challenges which a nursery could provide.

I would echo other commentators though and say if you can't easily take time off should your childminder fall ill, take holidays etc, then you should go for the security of nursery. We had odd weeks off with our childminder throughout the year which was easy enough to manage, but we have also had a period of an unexpected two weeks when she closed for health concerns, and we were left trying to work around our daughter from home (which we are lucky enough to be able to do so).

I always liked the 'home from home' aspect with a childminder while my DD was young but I think it only works up until 2.5-3ish and then a nursery setting is better.

dianashilling · 23/11/2023 11:48

I wouldn't use a childminder. No accountability - who knows wtf they are doing with your child all day with no other adults around.

givemushypeasachance · 23/11/2023 11:27

There are good and bad childminders, and good and bad nurseries. And some childminders work really well for some parents, but wouldn't work so well for others, and same again for nurseries. It depends what your circumstances are, their circumstances are, and what your priorities are.

For some people they really care about their kids getting out on trips regularly, or the setting having lots of wooden Montessori style toys, or offering a good range of vegetarian food, or the fact that baby ballet classes and baby French are offered during the nursery day. Or the main priority is a homely setting with someone who's like an extra grandma, or the convenience of a childminder who lives two minutes walk down the road compared to a 20 minute drive to the nursery. Some nurseries may be the cliche teenagers on minimum wage with lots of staff turnover, others will be a small family-run setting that older staff have worked at for 20 years. Maybe you're not keen that the childminder you're looking at does a school run each day so a baby is in tow on those trips, or maybe you think that's nice and they're out on a walk every day and can gradually get used to the idea of school as they're older. Maybe reliable coverage is key: that there is a very small chance of the nursery setting being closed, versus a childminder who may be more likely to be ill and unable to work. Or equally a childminder may be happy to take a child who's a bit under the weather but okay on calpol, versus a setting with a policy that if a child has a temperature that's it sent home with no notice and they're not allowed back for 48 hours.

Basically don't rule anything completely in or out until you've taken a good look at all the options and have spoken to lots of people to compare and contrast different options!

Two cents from me - my sister started my niece at an oustanding nursery, she was getting on well there but was sent home "with a temperature" pretty much every week for a month though she always seemed fine when they got her home. They ended up finding a childminder locally who they absolutely love.

zeeboo · 23/11/2023 11:20

We had a childminder and it was wonderful. I felt it was the closest thing to me being at home with her. The mix of ages etc meant it was like she had another family when she wasn't with us. I can't really get my head around your dh's problems with childminders, all subsequent children are looked after around other children of different ages.

Anothenamechange · 23/11/2023 11:00

It really depends on how old your child is. I went back to work when DD was 4 months so she went to a cm 3 days a week who we still have, and who she adores like family. I wouldn't have wanted to put her in nursery at that age, it felt too big, busy and not enough 1-1 time. Lots of children love the smaller environment, some thrive in a busier, nursery environment or become ready for it and need to graduate to one. Only you know your child well enough.

Yes, nurseries have the year-round childcare but the ones my friends use are notorious for sending children home at the first sniffle, whereas my cm is much more laid back and will keep her if she's a bit snotty(unless it's an infectious disease, of course) So I would discount the argument that childminders are unreliable! And if they are ill/on holiday, most will have a list of backups. Mine takes three weeks holiday a year so we just go away then as well. You need to view some and follow your instinct.

skgnome · 23/11/2023 10:41

For what’s worth my DD went to nursery and then with a childminder when she started school
the nursery has the advantage that you don’t have to find alternative childcare when one of the staff members are on holiday or sick (so yes it can be more reliable)
the childminder had the advantage of a more homely feel (pros and cons)
the nursery I used encouraged some mix between all kids and the staff was quite consistent- so all the staff working with DD got to know her really well

NotLactoseFree · 23/11/2023 10:31

It sounds to me like the problem is that you've made a decision and now you're not sure and he thinks he gets a veto. I don't think he has the right to veto. But neither do you.

I think that a veto without any real information beyond, "what people at work" say is ridiculous. If you want to consider a childminder, you should both go to look at a couple together. he might well still consider a nursery a better option and you might then have a further debate but he does rather sound like he thinks its a decision he gets to have the final say on which is not okay.

Catza · 23/11/2023 10:30

Difference in ages won't be a problem for me similarly as it wouldn't be a problem in your own home if you had multiple children. So I am not sure what specific concerns he has about this aspect.
IF you don't agree, then the obvious choice would be to look at all available options so that you can make an informed decision.

user1471523870 · 23/11/2023 10:26

We also opted for nursery for my 9 months old son (he's 5 now) based on the fact I didn't trust one single person to look after my son and I disliked the fact most childminders in the area had children of different ages (meaning simply that they needed to provide for different needs, getting toddlers to groups, doing school runs, all of this with my son in tow). And also I needed reliability in case of holidays/sickness, which only a nursery could offer.
We picked a small nursery, with a fantastic baby room. We are still in touch with his key worker, who provided amazing care for him but who also had back up when needed, was supervised and followed a strict routine and reporting process. My son was in the baby room with another 3-4 children, 2 key workers between them and the nursery manager in and out. Lots of 1-2-1 time, great feedback on anything from what he ate/nappies/naps to development, and I knew he was safe within the boundaries of the nursery (baby room or garden).

Silveroriole · 23/11/2023 10:09

Steve Biddulph's book Raising Babies, based on research and including the references, believes that the one-to-one relationship provided by a good childminder far outweighs the opportunities of nurseries. It's well worth reading imo.
Don't worry about older children being cared for... It's a natural part of home life for all second and subsequent children and babies tend to enjoy the extra attention and activity.
In your situation, could you visit any available childminders and nurseries yourself and choose one or two of each sort that you like? Then insist that you both go to visit them to make a joint decision that you're both happy with. It'll be easier when you see for yourselves rather than based on other people's opinions.

mindutopia · 23/11/2023 10:01

I think you could consider all your options if you are unsure. Personally, we did not look at childminders. There were none particularly close and I didn't really like the idea of not having enough hands on deck in an urgent situation. I think a childminder with a poorly toddler or who is trying to supervise several other children is not going to, say, have the time to tend to a sleeping or poorly baby the way I would have wanted. But the nursery we chose had 4-5 staff members available at all times. While 2-3 might be outside with the older ones, there was always more than one set of hands around to provide comfort or rock to sleep or just someone to keep an extra set of eyes on a situation. Even the best CM can't be everywhere at once.

Personally, I also didn't like the idea of a CM driving around with mine in the car (to go to groups or do school runs). We live rurally so to get anywhere means a 20 minute drive. It seemed like an unnecessary amount of time spent in the car and frankly, the added risk of additional driving, etc.

We wanted a nursery with the staff support and facilities that provided. The one we chose had amazing outdoor space and a mud kitchen and did forest school every week and had occasional special visitors for events, etc. which is more than a CM or we ourselves could provide, and that was great. I think it's worth considering all options (a nursery will be more reliable) because you need to choose somewhere that feels right and that may not be obvious until you see it.

Mumsgirls · 23/11/2023 09:57

Each child is different. My dc ,an only, went to nursery for a week and got so upset, vomited in car, each day, on the way. Tried a wonderful childminder and all well. Child had been in lock down and at two was not ready for a nursery set up. ,think it was too big and noisy. Child minder eased path to school based nursery at 3 with no problems.Now goes to wrap around with childminder from choice , not need to be with her friends. You know your child. Good luck

Ittastesvile · 23/11/2023 09:54

We have a few childminders around here which are set up almost like a mini nursery - have multiple members of staff and around 9 children. I found that was a good compromise for us, is that a possibility for you?

Starrmix · 23/11/2023 09:47

I preferred nursery. Much safer. It’s a secure workplace with cameras and multiple staff. I don’t know why anyone would send their kids to a childminder in a private property which isn’t as secure and has no cameras, no restrictions on who can walk in and out, and only one member of staff so there’s nobody to report malpractice.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/11/2023 09:43

Nursery.

wishingiwas20something · 23/11/2023 09:43

Depending on age of child, I’d go for a nursery or preschool. My experience via other mums is that nursery will offer a more comprehensive service as there’s a number of people delivering it, not an individual.

SecondUsername4me · 23/11/2023 09:43

As you've already got nursery sorted, then maybe just go with it. If she isn't settling, or you and dh feel it's not right once she's had a proper try at it, revisit it.

Coolblur · 23/11/2023 09:39

We always used childminders when DS was young. In part because it was the only affordable option for childcare that was flexible enough to accommodate my shift pattern. But I liked the smaller group of children, the more personal relationship the childminder had with the kids than they would get at nursery, and that DS got to mix with children of different ages (he's an only child). Also the home from home environment is great.
He made some very good friendships through going to a childminder that are still going strong years later.

Like any childcare though, it pays to do your research. Look online to find out what childminders are required to do.
Visit first and get a feel for the person and environment.
Ask what they do with the children, what food they serve (if they provide it), do they do school/nursery runs etc (don't be put off by this, the kids often love being in the car with others).
Can you see their registration, insurance, first aid certificates, etc; anything you know they should have? (All of these should be readily available and demonstrates they take their job safety commitments seriously).
Ours had a portfolio of things each child had done while in her care (I believe this sort of thing is a requirement, in Scotland at least, though everyone does it differently).

As for reliability, ask how often they have taken an unplanned day off. They should be able to answer honestly and not be evasive.
Nurseries aren't necessarily better in this respect because of the ratios. Plus there's more chance of your child picking up bugs themselves, or being refused entry for a sniffle. Childminders tend to take a more sensible approach in my experience.

Lackinginspiration1 · 23/11/2023 09:33

Not all childminders will do TFC/funded hours. I preferred nursery for mine after reading a few dodgy ofsted reports of my local childminders

Beautifulwintermornings · 23/11/2023 09:28

To add. I've had two dc in nursery.

They are both absolutely fine now. The sort of problems I had with nursery were, constant bugs and hen they first start, nursery will sometimes send them home over daft reasons. One of my dc got nappy rash a few times, but he did poo for England I don't think it was entirely their fault as he was often going several times. They said they always checked him first!

Nursery was 8-6 and no flexibility beyond. My second dc was less able to cope with childcare and drop offs could be very upsetting. As I said he's completely fine now no lasting effects.

The more I think back though all in all it wasn't too bad but these things can feel major at the time when you're a tired mum just gone back to work.

GnomeDePlume · 23/11/2023 09:23

We had different CMs for DC1 and DC2.

DC1 went to CM from 6 weeks old. CM was brilliant. She was an older lady with grown up DCs and GCs. She was an amazing lady, very sensible. She didn't drive so she and DC1 walked or took the bus everywhere.

CM retired when DC1 was 3 and started at nursery.

DC2 went to a different CM. Okay, a bit more chaotic than our first one. She had children of her own who were lovely but it just made for a busier household.

Both CMs were reliable.

Beautifulwintermornings · 23/11/2023 09:17

I didn't want to consider a childminder either because I knew someone who'd had some very bad experiences. It massively put me off. I was concerned about putting all my trust into one person.

However, having been through two children in nursery. Nursery isn't perfect. I'd say some children suit it more than others. I can see how a good childminder could work really well if you and your child have a good relationship with them and you trust them.

So if I was having a baby now I would at least consider it I think.

Jk987 · 23/11/2023 09:16

yellowlane · 23/11/2023 08:16

I preferred nursery due to more flexibility about holidays. With childminder they will usually close for 2-3 weeks per year so they can take a (deserved) holiday. As there's nobody to cover parents have to. If childminder is unwell again no cover.

We visited CM's and nurseries and chose a nursery that was small and homely. D stayed there until they went to school.

Most people get 4+ weeks annual leave so 2-3 weeks is doable especially if some of its shared with a partner.

Jk987 · 23/11/2023 09:15

I believe childminders are better for the baby stage eg. From 9 months. It's much more personal, homely and family like.

Sartre · 23/11/2023 09:12

Depends how easily you can take days off work if the childminder is off sick. This is why we ultimately always went with a nursery because I can’t take days off at all, especially at short notice. I have to literally be dying to take a day off. We don’t have family nearby to step in either so we needed reliable childcare. Nurseries always have back up staff if one is sick but a childminder is just a solo person, that was the deciding factor for us.