Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who you agree with re childcare

140 replies

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:00

dh doesn’t want to consider a childminder, he thinks there may be problems with reliability and also the mix of ages may be a problem.

I think it might be good to at least look.

Wondering what others would do when you just don’t agree.

OP posts:
luckylavender · 24/11/2023 08:49

I mean us. It worked out well for us as a family.

luckylavender · 24/11/2023 08:49

I understand where he's coming from. I never entertained the idea of a Childminder and preferred a Nursery. It worked out well for me.

Thegrassaintgreener · 24/11/2023 08:42

We put our son in nursery. Immediately hated it and moved him to a childminder within a few months. I did meet 5 before finding 'the one' :)

Of the 5 years we had our childminder across both of our children, she had a grand total of 3 days sick.

The best thing about a childminder was that they went out and about almost daily. To the local park, to groups, to the farm, to the allotment.

Anyway, you could start with a nursery and always change to a childminder!

Lifeisapeach · 24/11/2023 08:38

Child minders are better in the long term when you need to consider wrap around child care and not all schools offer after school clubs. I’d rather my child was with a childminder than a noisy nursery all day.

spriots · 24/11/2023 08:32

@Grestin I definitely think that if you're only working two days a week, your DH should do most of the sick days that fall on those days because you will be picking up most of the sick days by default on your non working days

Grestin · 24/11/2023 08:13

@Ohtobetwentytwo - I have got some reservations about the nursery we have her down for although she probably will end up going there.

We do tend to split emergency childcare depending on who is around and what’s on. I am only going back for two days a week (was three days before) and rightly or wrongly since I am only in for half a week there is definitely little tolerance to me having to be off for any reason. So for example if dc is sick Monday morning and I am off Monday and Tuesday and they are my working days that means I’m off for the whole week while if I was full time it would only be half the week. (Im doing my one handed posting again so I hope that makes sense!)

To be fair to the nursery they’ve never sent home for silly reasons as far as I can see but of course it will happen and would at any setting and I recognise that.

OP posts:
Ohtobetwentytwo · 24/11/2023 08:07

There is a lot of talk at that age about what's best for children. It's kind of part of the fun about the baby years. The main thing is whatever you choose you want to feel like they care about your child.

If you expect him to do 50% of the emergency childcare when his experience is that childminders are unreliable, you will get friction in your relationship - he will be thinking he told you so and you insisted so it should be your problem. If you think he expects you to do all emergency childcare then perhaps that isnt a problem for you?

Is he actively looking at childcare options or just vetoing your carefully researched suggestions?

Grestin · 24/11/2023 08:06

Thanks. I have to admit I didn’t really consider a childminder for first dc. Mostly because I just didn’t feel 100% comfortable with leaving a non verbal child alone with someone I didn’t really know. It’s obviously not to say that I think anything bad would have happened but you just can’t know, and I know some like the different ages but I think it can make life difficult eg managing different naps and so on.

I am just a bit worried about the nursery due to staffing turbulence. I’m sure it will be fine though.

OP posts:
spriots · 24/11/2023 08:06

Jk987 · 23/11/2023 09:16

Most people get 4+ weeks annual leave so 2-3 weeks is doable especially if some of its shared with a partner.

It's not so much that as that childminders want to take that usually in the school holidays because they usually have school age children.

If you have under 5s, you generally want to use your leave during term time

sunflower85 · 24/11/2023 07:59

I used a childminder initially, but after a number of months I took my son out and put him in a nursery and never looked back!

I found my childminder so unreliable, my holidays were never my own as I had to hold them to cover her time off, constant phone calls at work to say he was sick and needed picking up and when I collected him there was absolutely nothing wrong with him, and the final straw came when I was at her door to drop him off one morning and she said she was sick and needed the day off. She was up and dressed, and her son was up and dressed ready for school, and never at any point did it occur to her to lift the phone and tell me? Never again! The nursery was a breath of fresh air!

Jk987 · 23/11/2023 18:56

Caerulea · 23/11/2023 08:28

Is there a reason why OH doesn't want you to stay at home with the baby?

The reason could be that it's 2023.

Grestin · 23/11/2023 17:15

Thanks all, it’s hard to make a decision.

i think recruitment and retention at the nursery is an issue because it’s a bit off the beaten track. So there are quite a few staff changes which isn’t ideal. Just considering options.

OP posts:
cannaecookrisotto · 23/11/2023 16:47

I've used the same childminder since DD was 9 months old. She's 6 now.

Best decision I ever made. They're ofsted registered to.

She absolutely loves it, is like one of the family, their own children invite her over for sleepovers sometimes so I get weekend freebies 😂.

They go on days out to places, gets fed really well and does loads of activities.

Never had a problem with sickness. They take the usual 4 week holidays (don't charge for this) and I plan around it as I get plenty of notice.

They've never once not been able to have her due to sickness (except that spell in covid where they had to close).

I love them.

Jap26 · 23/11/2023 16:46

I agree with your husband, reliability is an issue but also safeguarding. In a nursery there are many pairs of eyes on the children. Especially with a very young child I worry about the lone working nature of childminders. Also childminders are not qualified to the same level as nursery staff. They have to attend a short introductory course as opposed to a full and relevant childcare qualification.

HAF1119 · 23/11/2023 16:45

It's good for you both to feel comfortable

Baby under 1 year, childminder I felt - when mine was over 2 we moved him to nursery, but could have done it younger. Mine was with 2 older boys at the minder and they doted on him, they are still friends now.

Once he went to nursery he made friends both older younger and the same age

All depends on what you both like the idea of

I did find when it came to toilet training etc it was easier with nursery rather than someone in their home

We've had nice experiences with both settings. He's just left nursery back to a different minder recently due to being too old for nursery.

Bear in mind with a minder they may get a bit bored once walking and more social, but it's a while until that happens. Mine liked the group interactions

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 23/11/2023 16:42

When we used a childminder who had her own children our DC loved playing with hers and really thrived with the consistency.

However your DH is correct. Whenever one of her DC was ill she cancelled childcare for that day/week, so it was quite a disrupted form of childcare for us.

Do remember, however, that if your DC haven't mixed a lot with other children as yet then there is a strong chance that they are more likely to catch lots of bugs at nursery so will have a fair amount of time off anyway in the first 6-12 months.

Grestin · 23/11/2023 16:02

It’s probably fair enough - just weighing on what’s best but there are practical considerations I can’t ignore.

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 23/11/2023 15:59

You can ask him to meet with some childminders. However, I share his concerns and would only use one as a last resort.

Grestin · 23/11/2023 15:54

Thanks for replies. This is a hard decision, it isn’t necessarily about childminder vs nursery, I just don’t feel confident in my decision at this time!

OP posts:
remindersofhim · 23/11/2023 15:22

If you're on the fence then it makes sense to go with the nursery.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 23/11/2023 13:59

When my son was small I thought a nursery was better because you weren't just relying on one person.

Once my son went to school, I used a childminder a couple of days a week for after-school care, which worked well. And he went to her in the summer holidays before he started school as well and his conversation and verbal communication improved massively during that period - having a mix of ages is a good thing I think.

This was what worked for us, but it will depend on the child, the nursery, the childminder and what you need workwise.

Finchgold · 23/11/2023 13:35

Best to visit a few options of both. Availability may dictate your choice. I wanted a childminder but ended up with nursery 1-3, then school nursery 3-4 and preschool nursery with childminder pickup 4-5. Childminder was amazing, like another grandparent. LO still goes afterschool and holidays.

spriots · 23/11/2023 13:23

We went for a nursery. We did look at a couple of childminders but:

All had their own children at home as well - understandable that's a big perk of the job but I didn't love the idea

All had the TV on all day/most of the day - never even saw a TV in any nursery we looked round

All took holidays in school holidays - totally reasonable from their pov but we didn't want to have to use up annual leave during school holidays when ours were preschool age

None would do food for my DS who has food allergies - all of the nurseries were happy to, we didn't really want to do packed lunches every day

Appreciate this varies from area to area but that was our experience

Emi199 · 23/11/2023 12:56

We’d write down the possible solutions but none of the non-negotiable eg having a childminder would be a non-negotiable for me personally but I can understand the advantages. Then we’d list the pros in one column and the disadvantages in the other during a discussion and go from there. Thank goodness we were totally aligned on this one as it’s an important decision.

Concannon88 · 23/11/2023 11:58

I dont think there will be an issue with reliability and lots of people love them because there is a personal touch and the children are often treated like family. I was always out off through my paranoia that there wouldnt be anyone there policing them like in a nursery.