Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who you agree with re childcare

140 replies

Grestin · 23/11/2023 08:00

dh doesn’t want to consider a childminder, he thinks there may be problems with reliability and also the mix of ages may be a problem.

I think it might be good to at least look.

Wondering what others would do when you just don’t agree.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SouthLondonMum22 · 26/11/2023 13:44

BIossomtoes · 26/11/2023 13:36

You can’t force someone to do paid work if they don’t want to either. 🤷‍♀️

Of course you can because they don't have to be supported financially, it's a choice. Both need to be happy with the choice, if one isn't happy then it will just lead to resentment either way.

spriots · 26/11/2023 13:42

BIossomtoes · 26/11/2023 13:36

You can’t force someone to do paid work if they don’t want to either. 🤷‍♀️

You sort of can though by not supporting them financially

If course that isn't how most married couples make decisions

BIossomtoes · 26/11/2023 13:36

SouthLondonMum22 · 26/11/2023 13:22

Even if that was the case, you can't force someone to take on the financial load by themself if they don't want to.

You can’t force someone to do paid work if they don’t want to either. 🤷‍♀️

SouthLondonMum22 · 26/11/2023 13:22

Caerulea · 26/11/2023 10:38

I was asking cos there are many possible reasons. At that point in the thread OP hadn't mentioned that she didn't want to be a sahm either, just that her OH didn't want to her to. So it was more of a wellbeing question

Even if that was the case, you can't force someone to take on the financial load by themself if they don't want to.

Baconisdelicious · 26/11/2023 10:47

I agree that childminders generally are less reliable than a nursery because of illness and holiday reasons. However, I used one years ago and she worked in a group and if ill and spaces elsewhere, your child was able to swap for a couple of days. They did lots of things as a big group, particularly days out, and made lots of friends that way. The only downside was they price fixed amongst themselves so were a little more expensive than others locally.

Caerulea · 26/11/2023 10:38

Jk987 · 23/11/2023 18:56

The reason could be that it's 2023.

I was asking cos there are many possible reasons. At that point in the thread OP hadn't mentioned that she didn't want to be a sahm either, just that her OH didn't want to her to. So it was more of a wellbeing question

Ohtobetwentytwo · 25/11/2023 23:06

That makes sense.

If DH will be taking the most time off I'd concede and go with a nursery to keep the peace.

But obviously you need to both now need to put in 50% of the effort until you find one you agree both like and feel happy with.

I loved our nursery but still felt wobbly about it. Could it just be that? X

Zanatdy · 24/11/2023 20:45

Grestin · 24/11/2023 08:13

@Ohtobetwentytwo - I have got some reservations about the nursery we have her down for although she probably will end up going there.

We do tend to split emergency childcare depending on who is around and what’s on. I am only going back for two days a week (was three days before) and rightly or wrongly since I am only in for half a week there is definitely little tolerance to me having to be off for any reason. So for example if dc is sick Monday morning and I am off Monday and Tuesday and they are my working days that means I’m off for the whole week while if I was full time it would only be half the week. (Im doing my one handed posting again so I hope that makes sense!)

To be fair to the nursery they’ve never sent home for silly reasons as far as I can see but of course it will happen and would at any setting and I recognise that.

In my experience I was off so much when both babies joined nursery as they caught everything going

Lifeisapeach · 24/11/2023 20:32

If you think you’ll need to rely on wrap around childcare at any point then would definitely consider a childminder. I know so many people (and seen on MN too) they’re schools offer wrap around care and when it comes to it, they don’t have the funding/staffing etc and they’re left with nothing.

childminders cook too on request. I’ve only ever had to provide a packed lunch and that’s because they head out during the day.

Like any childcare setting they are vetted too.

Childcare.com will show you local childminders in your area and you can message them etc to work out what schools they cover.

I’ve had our childminder 10 years, and only two years left before my kids will be too old to go. She’s like a family member and offered so much stability over the years.

Casperroonie · 24/11/2023 19:17

The child minders we had were a god-send. They knew my child really well and really looked after her. I think they had a lovely bond. They were also super flexible, stepping in in an emergency and always quite relaxed.

I looked at nurseries too but felt they were impersonal and wasn't comfortable leaving my baby there.

watchingtheworldwithwoe · 24/11/2023 15:10

I think your best bet is to have a look at nurseries and see if you find one that fits what you're looking for. Similarly with childminders. We found a great nursery which only had 4 children to 2 members of staff in the baby room. This meant our child had the best of both worlds. All activities remained age appropriate and the younger ones would sometimes go in to the toddler room for things like story time, music circle time etc. however, the staff ratio would remain the same and staff from baby room weren't used to 'make up the numbers' for the toddler room if that makes sense?

pumpkintart · 24/11/2023 15:06

We went with a childminder for flexibility, if we were running a bit late it wasn't a disaster. She would also do evenings if you asked and early morning for a lady who worked shifts.

Our little one went there from being around 1 so she was happy to help with toilet training, took him on errands with her it was like his second home. I found child minders much more flexible and more individual levels of care.

Xmasdaft2023 · 24/11/2023 14:38

I’ve done both… nursery I couldn’t fault them! Now, Childminder does drop off/pick up from local nursery. If I’d have got a space for mine from when I returned to work I’d have hands down chosen childminder. Much more personal imo and though I’m tied to her holidays that hasn’t yet mattered to me (and she’s never taken time off sick).
I’d encourage looking at both! Mine is now 4.5, he has friends ranged from baby to 10yo via childminder (none from private nursery when he left at 3) and truly loves each one of them, I see it for myself when we bump in to any of them at any time and they’re all hugs and chatting, it’s lovely to see the bond they all have 😍
I will say a childminder will be hard to come across for a baby age as they’re only allowed a certain number under a certain age so I’d get looking now just incase you find one x

Emeraldrings · 24/11/2023 10:43

I don't think nurseries are that reliable though. If too many staff are off sick they cancel sessions. This has happened where I work and as a parent.
Strangely when I used a CM she didn't cancel a single session and she let me know at the start of the year when she was on holiday and I just booked the same time off.
Surely most of the day it'll only be young children there and I know some (although pretty rare)that don't do school runs.
But if he doesn't like your idea tell him to sort something out but you will be working from x date on x days at x times and then in a couple of days ask him what he's sorted

Coolblur · 24/11/2023 10:33

StillWantingaDog on the contrary, we found childminders to be far more flexible than nurseries who wanted set days/half days, or payment for a space on any day you may require regardless of whether you used it.
A childminder is more likely to be able to accommodate unusual work patterns, whereas a nursery only caters to 8-4/9-5 weekday workers.
Neither are really able to accommodate last minute changes, unless they have space, and the staff in the case of a nursery, to do so.

StillWantingADog · 24/11/2023 10:27

There are def some excellent childminders around but they won’t be as flexible as a nursery. For our nursery we had two “set” days but could add and swap around within reason- few CMs would be able to accommodate this and as pp said they have set holidays. Depending on when these are that could be problematic.

Illness is a concern- you could always get a call at 8am saying they are ill. Very unlikely with a nursery as they move staff around to make sure their ratios are ok

CMs are cheaper though.

personally I wouldn’t have an issue with mixed ages. During the school day they will all be younger than school age, obviously. Some CMs I know take the kids on all kinds of adventures. Not all do.

There are excellent CMs and excellent nurseries. And not so good versions of both too.

Canyoubelievethesepeople · 24/11/2023 09:58

My son started as part time nursery, part time childminder largely as a result of the concerns your DH had about childminders.
It quickly became apparent he preferred the childminder- more homely environment, more flexibility for his routine. He ate and slept better at the childminder. We interviewed several nurseries and childminders before choosing.
We find our childminder very reliable because if they don’t work, they don’t get paid! Yes, we take our holidays when they take theirs, but as part of the interview process you can identify when they take them and if it suits you.
With the shortage of places you need to get organised whichever you choose!

Looneytune253 · 24/11/2023 09:31

I've had this convo many times recently. I'm a cm and have a really good relationship with the families I work with. I understand d it's so difficult for parents to choose a cm sometimes especially if the cm is a stranger. I will say tho, if you find the right one it can be amazing. I have a parent who has recently moved over from a nursery and she's been so complimentary about what a different experience they've had compared to how they were treated at the nursery. The child is so much happier and has a great bond already. I understand it can be a very difficult decision to make but if you meet a few and see how you feel and whether there's someone you click with.

FWIW I have the immune system of an ox and I'm never off sick tho I do take holidays well planned out in advance.

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/11/2023 09:17

thelonemommabear · 24/11/2023 09:03

I've always used childminders

  • considerable cheaper - 30%
  • friendly home environment
  • very reliable
  • more flexible on types of contract

I didn't like nursery as they seemed to have a constant revolving door of bored looking young people who worked there - not a lot of consistency of care givers - nurseries are much bigger so found the administration side of it very impersonal.. not a lot of outdoor time. Hit and miss with food

My twins are with an amazing childminder who has a staff member as well so it's like a mini nursery and they get out to loads of activities at the local library, put on language lessons, forest school lessons, visits to places like the fire station train station etc - things that a large nursery simply couldn't do whereas a childminder with 4 kids can

It does really depend on the nursery.

The only teenager at the one we use is one who is studying, the rest are all older, experienced and some have been there for years. DS started there at 3 months, he'll be 1 in a few weeks and still has the same keyworker.

They have plenty of access to outdoor spaces, the baby room has its own outdoor space. They also take them outside to things such as feeding ducks at the nearby park.

In nursery, they have people come in and do classes such as baby yoga and baby signing. To celebrate their 'outstanding' Ofsted result, they had a mini petting zoo come to the nursery grounds for the children to enjoy.

I'm happy to pay through the nose for it, it's truly excellent.

BIossomtoes · 24/11/2023 09:13

Jk987 · 23/11/2023 18:56

The reason could be that it's 2023.

The reason is more likely to be that they need two wages coming in. Just like we did in 1973. 🙄

Grestin · 24/11/2023 09:04

Food is actually one of the things that leans me towards nursery - I do love not having to cook anything on nursery days!

OP posts:
thelonemommabear · 24/11/2023 09:03

I've always used childminders

  • considerable cheaper - 30%
  • friendly home environment
  • very reliable
  • more flexible on types of contract

I didn't like nursery as they seemed to have a constant revolving door of bored looking young people who worked there - not a lot of consistency of care givers - nurseries are much bigger so found the administration side of it very impersonal.. not a lot of outdoor time. Hit and miss with food

My twins are with an amazing childminder who has a staff member as well so it's like a mini nursery and they get out to loads of activities at the local library, put on language lessons, forest school lessons, visits to places like the fire station train station etc - things that a large nursery simply couldn't do whereas a childminder with 4 kids can

Grestin · 24/11/2023 08:55

Oh that’s really interesting @regularmumnotacoolmum

It was some posts on here that had me wondering, and a friend of mine said the childminder set up worked really well for her.

OP posts:
regularmumnotacoolmum · 24/11/2023 08:54

I thought I'd love childminders but it was a nightmare. Nursery provided more accountability, variety in stimulation and consistency in care for us.

Grestin · 24/11/2023 08:53

@Lifeisapeach we’d only need a max of two days in before / after school care though and not for very long. I’m actually not sure at all any childminders do pick up or drop offs from the school they’d go to although I haven’t looked into it. Unless they lived in the village I doubt they would, it’s off the beaten track a bit.

OP posts: