Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who should have got up?

284 replies

Autieangel · 23/11/2023 07:14

Dh and I went to bed around 945 last night. I couldn't sleep and at about 1030 I heard a loud bang in the house. Like a crashing noise. We have 4 year old ds in his bedroom and a dog downstairs.

I woke dh who said it was probably nothing. I thought one of us should check in case it was to do with our son.

Dh refused so I checked the house alone and concluded our son had put toys on his bed and must have kicked some off.

I was annoyed that dh left it to me and essentially went back to sleep while I walked round the house alone.

Who's unreasonable here?

OP posts:
cmaalofshit · 23/11/2023 13:44

YABU.
You keep updating and with each update you put more and more emphasis on "it could have been an intruder" when your initial post said I thought one of us should check in case it was to do with our son
I'd be annoyed if I was your DH and you'd woken me up to get me to go and check the house because you heard a noise which you thought was to do with our son. You should have just got up without waking DH, checked son and gone back to bed.
How do you think people who live alone cope if they hear a noise in the night?
You are being completely OTT.

Nowherenew · 23/11/2023 13:32

I heard a crash , listened for a minute, woke husband. Suggested we should go and look. He said it was probably nothing, I said what if it's ds . DH said if your worried go look. I did look I think it was a toy (a heavy metal one) as I couldn't see another explanation.

The fact that you thought it was DS and said this to DH, means that YABU.

If you thought you heard the front door open or someone downstairs and told DH this, then it would be different.

If someone had broken in then all you had to do was shout for DH.

There was no need for him to go and check with you or instead of you.

Screwballs · 23/11/2023 13:26

OP I feel like you are just updating continuously to force your perspective. People are entitled to not agree with you. You are being OTT, nothing happened, end of. Let it go.

Autieangel · 23/11/2023 13:22

Also I guess a factor is where you live and previous experience. I live in a fairly'rough' area and was burgled twice as a child both times while we were in the house. As an adults I've had 3 car burglaries and 1 attempted house burglary as well as one theft at work.

OP posts:
Scarlettpixie · 23/11/2023 13:19

You say in your OP that you thought someone should check in case it was something to do with DS. No reason you couldn’t check that (as the awake person) and in fact you did and it was a toy. You didn’t tell your DH that you thought their might be an intruder or presumably he would have got up. He didn’t hear the noise remember as he was asleep so had no reason to think it was anything other than what you suggested.

I wonder how you think single parents like me go on (or those whose partners work nights (former me).

And as for asking if it would have been DH’s fault if the intruder had attacked you? No, it would be the intruders fault ffs.

Imperfectp3rf3ction · 23/11/2023 12:55

If you genuinely felt worried or anxious it maybe was an intruder he may have acted differently and you should have the security that he would . However that thought probably didn't even enter his mind so I wouldn't think he would be over joyed to go check something trivial. What was your chat like?we're you panicked ? Scared ? Or hust regular If you thought it had come from kid tbf I would have just sprinted at a large bang. There's a weird feeling when an intruder is actually in your house you feel it different or at least in my experience

Autieangel · 23/11/2023 12:48

Lots of interesting and some frankly bonkers replies as one would expect from Mumsnet!

So to clear a few things up-

I do not possess ninja like qualities like unfortunately. I heard a crash , listened for a minute, woke husband. Suggested we should go and look. He said it was probably nothing, I said what if it's ds . DH said if your worried go look. I did look I think it was a toy (a heavy metal one) as I couldn't see another explanation.

The dog is crate trained so would not be much use to ward off burglars although hopefully he would bark. Didn't bark at the sudden noise right above his head tho. Not at all aggressive to new people in the house.

Some posters ideas around feminism is frankly mind boggling. Women should not have to be the same as men to be treated equally. It explains a lot about why so many women try (and fail) to do it all. We need to stop this narrative.

I think as the stronger person dh should have gone to look in case it was something nefarious. We have been together 15 years and I can count on one hand how often I have heard a noise in the night. Once it was a shelf that collapsed. Once it was an intruder and we called the police (they didn't actually get in the house). Once we didn't identify the noise.

OP posts:
Nowherenew · 23/11/2023 12:40

MelsMoneyTree · 23/11/2023 11:57

You do need statistics when you're advising sending women into a situation where they are more at risk than men. If you're confronting someone during the night then they are not the type of burglars who chose to break in when the house was empty.
It's not the same as men fighting in the street. Especially since a significant proportion of home burglaries are committed by people known to the victims. The risk is completely different from drunk men on nights outs getting into fights with each other.

It was toys being knocked over, there was no danger.

If there was any danger then DH was in bed and OP could have shouted up to him.

SweetBirdsong · 23/11/2023 12:34

DH and I have seperate bedrooms - he snores and it's worked well for us for some 15 years or so. He does night shift, every third week, and finishes at 6.00am. He gets in at around 6.20-6.30am, and watches TV for a bit, has a hot chocolate, and then goes to bed around 7.30am. I tend to get up around 8.30am to 9am (I work from home.)

Anyway, he was on nights last week, and came in at 6.20am. I got up for a pee at 6.55am, then went back to bed for a bit as I was tired and needed another couple of hours. (I had worked til midnight the night before!)

15 minutes after I went back to bed - 15 minutes after! DH knocks on my fucking door, and comes in and said 'birdsong. BIRDSONG, are you getting up? I heard you up about 5 minutes ago and thought you were getting up.' It was 15 minutes later, not 5! And I had gone back to sleep! Angry He woke me out of my slumber and I couldn't get back to sleep. It made me tired and fatigued all day. I could have lamped him. I said 'no I am not getting up!' and turned my back.

'Oh well see you later then' he said. Then he continued... 'oh by the way, I just thought I'd let you know Steve at work is up for a disciplinary next week for what happened last week.' I was seething. Not only did he wake me, when it was only 7am, and he must have known I had gone back to bed, but also, he tried to engage in conversation with me. I ignored him, and he said 'talk to yourself eh? Never mind!' And he slammed the door!

When he got up at 4pm he had a face like thunder. He was still pissy that I had ignored him. I said 'tell you what, tomorrow, when you get up for a pee at lunchtime, I will wait 15 minutes and then open the door and start talking to you! Then slam the door when you ignore me because I have woken you from your sleep.' Idiot! Hmm

tr;dr. YABVU @Autieangel Waking someone for no reason is a shitty thing to do. I would have been fuming if I had been your husband!

Panaa · 23/11/2023 12:33

There's nothing wrong with wanting a man who has that protective instinct.

Equality to me doesn't mean that in a relationship we can't have different roles, strengths and weaknesses.
.
I like a man to be manly.

Frequency · 23/11/2023 12:26

My H when I lived with him was a whimp. I'd have had a better chance of scaring off intruders. He would have been more likely to start crying and offering to show them where the good china was Grin

If I genuinely believed there were intruders in the house I would call the police and gather everyone in the kid's room. I wouldn't risk confronting them. Stuff is stuff. It can be replaced. Even when H was in the midst of alcoholism and depression and I completely loathed him he would have been more important to me than stuff.

If I was only worried about a noise and believed the possibility of intruders was minor I would have crept down with the dog and my phone with the intention of sneaking back upstairs to call the police.

I live alone now with my DDs but big dog sleeps downstairs. Intruders tend to be men. Due to the lockdown and being a house full of women, men are a novelty to my dog. The only men he knows well are H and DDs ex who have taught him that men play wrestle on the floor. He gets stupidly excited when men come to the house. Uncontrollably so, because it does not happen often enough to proof his training.

He is stupidly friendly. I am under no illusion that he would chase away any intruders but he's big, very bouncy and part Beagle so has a strange obsession with having hands and arms in his mouth.

If anyone entered who didn't know him all they would see is a massive black beast running full pelt at them with its mouth full of teeth open. I think that would be enough to make any intruder reconsider Grin

MsRosley · 23/11/2023 12:25

I didn't want to go alone as my dh is twice my size and works out in the gym 4 times a week so is much better equipt to deal with an intruder than me. My preferred choice would have been to go together.

Damn right, OP. Ignore the arseholes who tell you otherwise.

Autieangel · 23/11/2023 12:25

AnneLovesGilbert · 23/11/2023 10:48

If you’re awake and hear a sound that may be something to do with a young child surely you jump straight out of bed to check they’re okay - as that’s the sole priority - and worry about waking other people, catastrophising and apportioning responsibility and blame at a later point.

I’ve done that. DH has done that. Sitting around pondering suggests it’s not that concerning.

And what sort of children’s toy falling at night makes a loud crash that could also be an intruder? Come on.

So he has a tin box (like a old fashioned biscuit tin) that he keeps small toys in. That was on the floor spilled open so I assume it got kicked off the bed . Didn't wake ds tho.

OP posts:
Imperfectp3rf3ction · 23/11/2023 12:25

What kind of dog ?

MrsMarzetti · 23/11/2023 12:24

If i thought it was my child i would have shot out of bed like a rocket, i would have had no need to wake my DH but if i thought it was an intruder i would have sent him as he is a big scary mountain with a great left hook.

Isthisexpected · 23/11/2023 12:10

Talkingtothecat247 · 23/11/2023 12:00

I would react on impulse, and do my best to avoid that happening.
I don't know without going over every possible scenario.
I am just saying what I would do in impulse. I wouldn't even stop to think.

I'm not saying my response is the right one either. It probably isn't. (I have got plenty of things wrong in the past that I have sadly lived to regret).
I'm just saying what would be instinct.

Ah okay I understand you. It's so interesting. My impulse, having been burgled, is to assume it's happening again and wake my husband to protect us whilst I take the children into the bathroom and call for help. Thankfully has been false alarms!

CarpetSlipper · 23/11/2023 12:09

He didn’t hear the noise therefore he didn’t think it was a big deal. You heard a noise that woke you up, it came from your child’s room so you went and checked. Everything was fine. YABU for making this into an issue when it isn’t.

Mothership4two · 23/11/2023 12:08

MelsMoneyTree · 23/11/2023 11:20

They're not feminists. They don't understand feminism and they're deeply invested in pretending there are no physical differences between men and women. They've been hovering around here for ages because they hate that women have a place on the internet. Now they fill their time giving shit advice and being aggressive to women. And yy they have such cossetted lives, they can't imagine someone breaking into their homes. Cossetted, online, think men and women are the same ... I wonder who on earth they could be? It's a mystery.

I am a feminist and although I haven't attacked the OP I don't understand her viewpoint or yours frankly. I would have gone to investigate myself as I have done loads of times over the years. If I had heard someone breaking in, then obviously I would have woken DH and, as I stated upthread, if she had said to her DP that she thought someone was in the house I am certain he would have got up immediately. She didn't, she heard a noise and must have had an idea that it wasn't coming from downstairs and her dog wasn't barking. It's a bit of a nonevent and now OP is annoyed that her sleeping husband didn't do what she asked even though he was right - it was nothing. I wish I was cossetted, I don't hate women - very much the opposite, I don't hover I often post (I should probably hover a lot more than I do!) and can very much imagine a man up to no good and how scary that is. I don't think the majority of posters are being particularly aggressive to the OP. You'll always get one or two on any MN thread even if it's about something benign! I think it is a fairly common scenario that a lot of posters have been in and dealt with by themselves. A minor incident of a toy falling off a bed which OP went to investigate and probably then went back to bed and sleep.

Butsheisnot · 23/11/2023 12:01

I'd have woken my husband up. He wouldn't mind. Nor would I mind if he woke me.

Seems a fairly normal response to be honest.

Glad I don't live with someone who would be 'furious' with me for waking them.

I've also been burgled while my whole family and I were asleep upstairs. They took everything possible from downstairs, took the car keys and used our car, which was in our garage, as their getaway car with all our stuff in it. So it really does happen.

Talkingtothecat247 · 23/11/2023 12:00

Isthisexpected · 23/11/2023 11:56

Makes no sense. How are you going to help your child if you're knocked unconscious first?

I would react on impulse, and do my best to avoid that happening.
I don't know without going over every possible scenario.
I am just saying what I would do in impulse. I wouldn't even stop to think.

I'm not saying my response is the right one either. It probably isn't. (I have got plenty of things wrong in the past that I have sadly lived to regret).
I'm just saying what would be instinct.

MelsMoneyTree · 23/11/2023 11:57

Nowherenew · 23/11/2023 11:52

You don’t need to a source or statistics to understand that a man confronting another man is going to cause more issues than a woman.

How often on nights out do men start fights with other men vs starting fights with women.

Most intruders don’t attack unless they feel threatened or that’s what they came to do.
As a PP said most break ins happen during the day because they don’t want to risk a confrontation.

You do need statistics when you're advising sending women into a situation where they are more at risk than men. If you're confronting someone during the night then they are not the type of burglars who chose to break in when the house was empty.
It's not the same as men fighting in the street. Especially since a significant proportion of home burglaries are committed by people known to the victims. The risk is completely different from drunk men on nights outs getting into fights with each other.

Isthisexpected · 23/11/2023 11:56

Talkingtothecat247 · 23/11/2023 11:28

If there was a loud crash and my child was in a separate room, I wouldn't have even stopped to think about intruders.
I'd have been out of bed and into my child's room like a shot to check they were okay.
I would rather risk an intruder hurting me, than getting to my child.

That said I'm a single parent, so there is no-one else to do it.

Makes no sense. How are you going to help your child if you're knocked unconscious first?

MadamVastra · 23/11/2023 11:54

bitchatty · 23/11/2023 07:19

he should be starting a thread about you waking him up over a dropped toy

🤣🤣

CornTheCob · 23/11/2023 11:53

Your dog didn't start barking, that tells you that it's not an intruder.
Unless you have a dog who thinks Billy Burglar is his new best friend.

Nowherenew · 23/11/2023 11:52

MelsMoneyTree · 23/11/2023 11:13

'A man going downstairs and confronting someone is more likely to end in a situation going from bad to worse.
A woman going down is less likely to cause a confrontation.'
Do you have a source for this @Nowherenew ? Because it sounds like you just made a sweeping statement with no basis in fact. I don't know of any research that says an intruder already in a house is less likely to attack a female householder. But there is research that shows a female householder is more likely to be sexually assaulted or raped by a home intruder.

You don’t need to a source or statistics to understand that a man confronting another man is going to cause more issues than a woman.

How often on nights out do men start fights with other men vs starting fights with women.

Most intruders don’t attack unless they feel threatened or that’s what they came to do.
As a PP said most break ins happen during the day because they don’t want to risk a confrontation.