Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that people who are "Anti Woke"

187 replies

AntiWoke · 23/11/2023 06:27

are the people who would like free reign to be racist, sexist, mysogenistic, homophobic. In short, people who want to be able to say whatever they like, even if offensive to some groups of people?

OP posts:
DropDeadFreida · 23/11/2023 07:54

I agree with the example given by @Teatrayderby. I had exactly the same happen at work. Joined a task group set up specifically to support and champion women in the workplace, and the very first meeting was nearly hijacked by a white man who spent the entire time trying to talk over people and whispering to the colleague next to him about 'intersectionality' and how we needed to make sure that we did not silence 'marginalised groups'.

I guess the fact that on more than one occasion he attempted to interrupt me (a working class lesbian who is part of an ethnic minority group and is also a first generation immigrant with English as a second language) was neither here nor there. Having to sit there and listen to this disruptive man attempt to explain intersectionality to me was infuriating.

Summerbay23 · 23/11/2023 07:52

I very much hate the word woke (seemingly used negatively to describe anyone who has an inclusive view on pretty much anything). So I tend to call out use of the word woke by saying I don’t understand what that means and asking specifically what issue/view is causing concern and having a discussion on that.

Disorderla · 23/11/2023 07:52

I actually think that some modern practices are making racism, sexism, any-phobia much worse.

I am seeing it around me.

People who were generally tolerant of trans people and didn’t see any issue with letting a few confused people live how they wanted as it didn’t hurt anyone else - now angry and horrified by being screamed at that reality isn’t real and lesbians should enjoy female cock.

I think racism is getting worse too. All the ‘privilege’ and ‘cultural appropriation’ arguments are doing seems to be segregating races apart from each other, sticking them into neat boxes. Increasing the ‘us vs them’ feelings.

My brother and his husband have had to stop going to pride events. They refuse to take their children there as it has become infested with, in their words, ‘sexually deranged weirdos’. Dressed as dogs, displaying any fetish they want in public and twerking in front of children…pride used to be about showing the world that gay people were humans who wanted normal lives and to love who they did ‘just like you’.

That is definitely affecting feelings towards the LGBT community

ilovesooty · 23/11/2023 07:48

I can't take people seriously who lazily throw the word "woke" around as a catch all insult. As a PP says, it's usually the same people who previously bleated about PC.

Tulipsroses · 23/11/2023 07:48

Tantai · 23/11/2023 07:35

I’m not sure what I’d be classed as…anti-entertainment-woke?

I consider myself a feminist but have disliked some of my favourite games, movies and franchises being infested with shit for brains writers.

I don’t think it’s because there is increased diversity or women in lead roles, but because the writers are either too young, stupid or idealistic to do it properly. The diversity becomes the focus and aim rather than just a part of a well thought out plot. It’s held up as a ‘look at this’ and it’s infantilising and boring.

Take the Aliens franchise from the 70’s/80’s, Ripley was a brilliant hero. The fact she was a woman wasn’t the only point of her character. Another recent character who does this well is Phoebe from Ghostbusters:Afterlife. I don’t know about you but I never even used to pay any attention when other ethnicities were included in movies/shows back then, they were just another character.

Compare that to the cringe ‘girl power’ scene in Avengers:Endgame or the latest Lord of the Rings: Rings of power series. The writers seem to think it’s enough to go ‘look…GIRLS’ or ‘behold…a BLACK person’. And then don’t bother with telling a good story, that isn’t the aim.

They are only concerned with preaching at the audience.

I absolutely agree with you. Movie has become a box ticking exercise. And the funny aspect about the box ticking are banal stereotypes where a gay person has to act gay or a black actor would always emphasize their struggle. It's so one sided and limited that it's impossible to watch anymore.

Wotsitfappe · 23/11/2023 07:47

In my experience people who use the term wkras a negative use it to dismiss the hard won rights we have re gender, disability, sexuality etc. So yanbu.

LadyBird1973 · 23/11/2023 07:47

And there's always this accusation that if you hold a different pov to the currently fashionable or accepted one, that you are lacking education or don't understand the concept of privilege. Plenty of very well educated people hold views that others might find offensive. It's a lazy cop out.

LadyBird1973 · 23/11/2023 07:44

I would describe myself as predominantly socialist, if I had to put a label on at all. But I do think the price of freedom is hearing opinions that you might personally find offensive.
Obviously it's not nice to be deliberately insulting or hurt others feeling, however no one has a right to go through life not ever hearing an opinion they find offensive - certainly not at the cost of others' democratic right to express their personal views. If I have to choose, then I choose to hear things I personally dislike, in order to protect that freedom. Otherwise, what is freedom?

I'm not homophobic, racist or misogynistic but I don't really care that much if other people are - I'd rather know who I'm dealing with. And that's the beauty of free speech - it gives us all a heads up, so we can decide whether we want to keep company with those whose values are different to our own.
^
Societal change comes about through freedom of expression - hiding what people really think doesn't make opinions change, it just entrenches them as the person who isn't allowed to speak, feels oppressed. That isn't healthy or productive in improving society.

People should be free to swim against the tide, to demonstrate if they want to, to peacefully protest^.

The trouble with 'woke' is that those people aren't content to hold and sit their own viewpoint. They want to prevent anyone else from having a different opinion. No one in this country should be losing their job because of their personal or political beliefs. The whole trans debate is a clear demonstration of where woke has gone wrong.

Tantai · 23/11/2023 07:35

I’m not sure what I’d be classed as…anti-entertainment-woke?

I consider myself a feminist but have disliked some of my favourite games, movies and franchises being infested with shit for brains writers.

I don’t think it’s because there is increased diversity or women in lead roles, but because the writers are either too young, stupid or idealistic to do it properly. The diversity becomes the focus and aim rather than just a part of a well thought out plot. It’s held up as a ‘look at this’ and it’s infantilising and boring.

Take the Aliens franchise from the 70’s/80’s, Ripley was a brilliant hero. The fact she was a woman wasn’t the only point of her character. Another recent character who does this well is Phoebe from Ghostbusters:Afterlife. I don’t know about you but I never even used to pay any attention when other ethnicities were included in movies/shows back then, they were just another character.

Compare that to the cringe ‘girl power’ scene in Avengers:Endgame or the latest Lord of the Rings: Rings of power series. The writers seem to think it’s enough to go ‘look…GIRLS’ or ‘behold…a BLACK person’. And then don’t bother with telling a good story, that isn’t the aim.

They are only concerned with preaching at the audience.

itsallnewnow · 23/11/2023 07:35

BillionaireTea · 23/11/2023 06:42

Yes, I'd say that's the size of it.

Oversll, they are people with a limited capacity (or education) to reflect on their own privilege - like fish who don't understand what water is.

They are people who think that the high level of comfort they feel in society, just feeling OK saying whatever is in their heads, is normal. They don't notice that it is a privilege. So they feel that suddenly being asked to guard their tongues, or shift their way of being, is a new thing - an insult to their freedom and ability to operate in the world. And it does feel like that, so I sympathise with those people's sensations.

However they don't understand that other people (who are different from them) already were living in an unwelcoming world where they couldn't speak freely/have been judged/are constantly harmed by culture and its assumptions.

What "woke" does is redresses the balance.

So, some people feel a but more awks in the world for a while...in order that others, who have been, historically, systemically under-valued and felt less comfortable, can feel... a bit more welcome. A bit more normal. A bit more ok for being themselves.

This is misunderstood though and when you say "look at your own privilege" anti-woke people indignantly think "But I don't have privilege! I'm not rich! I work hard! I don't get something for nothing!". This isn't what privilege is. Privilege is the ability to feel normal in the world without having to constantly think about what you're doing.

So the anti woke person says "People are such snowflakes they can't handle a joke about identity!" and marvel at the weakness and over sensitivity of others. They are not considering - literally not "awake to" all the work already being done by the person with the "less normal identity" just to get through the day. So the joke is the last straw, not a tiny nothing.

I agree with this, unfortunately I think the context of the word privilege in English means it isn't really a good choice to describe that feeling. Ideally, we need another word separate from privilege which conveys typically wealth and something that shows they have been censored previously, may not be any more if you see what I mean.

Firebug007 · 23/11/2023 07:34

Ohthatsfabulousdarling · 23/11/2023 06:34

Not in all cases. I do think that a line needs to be drawn somewhere.
I am not a racist, I am not homophones, I am not a bigot, I can even to an extent understand trans issues- and always try to be respectful of people and their feelings, however when there comes a time where people say, I identify as a cat... I do think there is a problem.

I also see, that as people are becoming more accepting, which is universally, a good thing, people's power to speak up is being greatly reduced. The freedom of speech is disappearing at the very same time that laws are being passed to stop peaceful protest. In concerned that were being lulled into a situation where it becomes impossible to speak out if you have strong views on anything.

People aren't becoming more accepting though, it's just their voice at being able to express their views honestly is being taken away 🤷‍♀️ people are becoming less tolerant IMO.

Dontmesswiththeyakult · 23/11/2023 07:24

No, I do not agree. But then, we may have differing ideas on what constitutes 'woke'. Most of the views held by self-proclaimed 'woke' individuals I know just sounds like childish nonsense to me. The kind of people who are permanent victims and take a vicious delight in finding offence in the most innocuous of statements.

MotherofPearl · 23/11/2023 07:24

@BillionaireTea Your post is really thoughtful and has given me new insight on this.

I feel conflicted on this. Sometimes I do feel exasperated by aspects of what some might consider the 'woke' agenda, but then I also notice that the people and groups who are most vociferous in denouncing 'woke' are really right-wing and repugnant to me, so that does give me pause for thought. Maybe it needs to be taken on a case by case basis, as what comes under the umbrella of 'woke' seems to be a very disparate set of issues.

jemenfous37 · 23/11/2023 07:23

@AntiWoke 😅😅

SurprisedWithAHorse · 23/11/2023 07:20

In short, people who want to be able to say whatever they like, even if offensive to some groups of people?

Your OP will be offensive to some people (if I didn't know better, I might even suspect that was the intention). Is that OK?

Thisilldo · 23/11/2023 07:19

I don’t want my teenage daughter having to share a changing room with a fully intact male. It’s abhorrent and will eventually lead to a tragedy. If you want to call me names to justify the danger you are putting young girls in them so be it. I don’t care. Your opinion is nothing to me.

AntiWoke · 23/11/2023 07:16

jemenfous37 · 23/11/2023 07:09

Free-rein
Unless you are a monarch. Even then, you may be constricted by the constitution/government of your country.

I knew when I was writing "Reign" that it didn't look right 😀

OP posts:
jemenfous37 · 23/11/2023 07:09

Free-rein
Unless you are a monarch. Even then, you may be constricted by the constitution/government of your country.

Nonoatchristmas · 23/11/2023 07:09

Depends what you mean by ‘woke’ to start with. As others say, the word has lost all usually meaning. It’s a bit odd to describe yourself as ‘woke’, these days it often seems to be a label used by straight white people who like to appropriate the causes of those who are neither. ‘Ally’ is another word that has lost all meaning as well.

Snoozysnoozy · 23/11/2023 07:04

"Woke" is just the new "PC gone mad" however it can describe the kind of person that has the "right" views and sees 'isms and 'phobias everywhere. For example the trans debate, there's a discussion needed but the "Woke" side will try and shut down any argument that trans women aren't women even at the cost of women's safety. That said the anti woke side will include racist, homophobic etc people.

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/11/2023 07:04

I agree with @CampsieGlamper there about "privilege". I don't mind the idea of being mindful that bring white, straight, NT and from a family with a good work ethic (though not money) has given me a smoother path in life than might have otherwise been the case but I do get a bit tired of being told that as a consequence I have no right to be annoyed or upset by any issues I do have as some have it so much worse. Two threads recently debating the "Karen" thing both went the same way with those of us maintaining it IS now, in it's current UK usage a misogynistic term, were criticised as "privileged" for not recognising it's original American usage with racist connotations and that we were somehow minimising black womens' experience by expressing our frustration at it being used to shut up confident women.

Chuffaluffa · 23/11/2023 07:03

@thevegetablesoup Wait til you work with an Indian team and learn about Indian stretching time.

CampsieGlamper · 23/11/2023 07:02

The term "woke" started in the US amongst black people who felt a link between race, poverty, women's rights, power imbalance. It was imported here and adopted/ subsumed initially into liberal activists against all injustice or zealot, puritanical, perpetually offended. It is used by those against zealotry as a stick.
Words change their meaning or are changed when appropriated. The "woke" will no doubt approve at black people reappropriating the n word. But - who says "gay" to mean jolly, happy and fun?

thevegetablesoup · 23/11/2023 06:58

Some (usually American) woke equality and diversity materials I have seen are downright racist imo. Eg those which define things like punctuality as a white supremacist concepts. It's like the soft bigotry of low expectations on speed.

CampsieGlamper · 23/11/2023 06:57

But is it right to say "privilege" is being in the majority? This is a devisive and alienating term.
Take race - the UK is 80% white as a whole. Some areas have a majority black, some have a majority Indian/Pakistani/Bangladeshi. Some have a higher Polish / Eastern european population.
Censuses not only in the UK but in all countries where it is legal report around 4% homosexual and another 4% not declined as either straight or homosexual.
Should term as arrogantly scornful as "privileged" be used to define a majority. No.