Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that people who are "Anti Woke"

187 replies

AntiWoke · 23/11/2023 06:27

are the people who would like free reign to be racist, sexist, mysogenistic, homophobic. In short, people who want to be able to say whatever they like, even if offensive to some groups of people?

OP posts:
AlisonDonut · 23/11/2023 08:46

Both extremes want to weaponise the issue into an absolute dividing line and reject the concept of a compromise outcome.

Only one of these extremes is behaving like extremists. The other 'extreme' just wants to be able to talk about the reality of human existence including what a compromise might look like.

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 08:44

PallyRoe · 23/11/2023 08:35

Yes. Like the trans activists posting porn under J.K.Rowlings tweet displaying a drawing from one of her fans, a child.

Or telling numerous women to ‘choke on their girl dick’ and demanding women who don’t agree with them be beheaded or beaten with a prettily decorated baseball bat.

I think people are ‘anti-woke’ because of the sheer lunacy of many of the viciously ‘woke’ activists who seem to have no issue using sexual violence, violence, sexism or racism against the ‘wrong’ people.

The hypocrisy of many young ‘woke’ people acting like belligerent fascists is not lost on the sane, whichever side of the political spectrum they fall on.

Their pure hatred and lack of critical reasoning skills when coming across an opinion they don’t like is also mildly terrifying.

I think debate clubs, where you need to learn how to construct an argument even for a side you disagree with, should become mandatory.

I don't know if you're deliberately trying to prove my point, but your lengthy post is a demonising of one extreme position from the point of view of another extreme position. It's exactly what's wrong with the Woke/Anti-woke construct.

Ok, we can take the trans issue. There's a minority on either end of the extreme slinging stones and arguing that anyone with a view somewhere in the middle is automatically a member of the opposing extreme. I doubt the extreme views represent more than 10% of the population in total. Most of society are somewhere in the middle thinking both are extremists, and harbouring varying sympathies with both extremes at the same time on different aspects of the issue. Both extremes want to weaponise the issue into an absolute dividing line and reject the concept of a compromise outcome.

PosterBoy · 23/11/2023 08:42

Do you mean anti-woke = pro-free speech?

I'm definitely in favour of free speech with very few limits, and being offensive isn't one of them. Would you really want it to be a criminal offence to offend people? I find that offensive ... oh no! Off to jail for you.

Woke is just a buzz word that's already switched from a positive to a negative and will soon be replaced by some other buzz word.

AlisonDonut · 23/11/2023 08:40

Alot of people who crown themselves 'Woke' also are happy to say 'Death to TERFs/Kill the TERFs' and to stand in front of signs calling for TERFs to be guillotined.

It's a bit like the 'Antifa' who march against Fascists but when actual real life Fascists are right there, facing them in the actual street, it's women they decide are the baddies. For being IN THE SAME STREET.

WeeSleekitCowrinTimrousBeastie · 23/11/2023 08:38

"Woke" and "anti-woke" are just meaningless insults

I wouldn't want to be asst with either.

PallyRoe · 23/11/2023 08:35

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 08:27

In short, people who want to be able to say whatever they like, even if offensive to some groups of people?

No, they're just arseholes and you'll find them on both sides of the Woke/Anti-woke debate.

Yes. Like the trans activists posting porn under J.K.Rowlings tweet displaying a drawing from one of her fans, a child.

Or telling numerous women to ‘choke on their girl dick’ and demanding women who don’t agree with them be beheaded or beaten with a prettily decorated baseball bat.

I think people are ‘anti-woke’ because of the sheer lunacy of many of the viciously ‘woke’ activists who seem to have no issue using sexual violence, violence, sexism or racism against the ‘wrong’ people.

The hypocrisy of many young ‘woke’ people acting like belligerent fascists is not lost on the sane, whichever side of the political spectrum they fall on.

Their pure hatred and lack of critical reasoning skills when coming across an opinion they don’t like is also mildly terrifying.

I think debate clubs, where you need to learn how to construct an argument even for a side you disagree with, should become mandatory.

lljkk · 23/11/2023 08:33

Woke or anti-woke are vague catch phrase isn't it, which rallies the tribes, like "politically correct!" and "critical race theory!"... and dare I say it "Every day sexism." The people who most use it can point to the fewest clearest examples of it being an actual problem attributable to the thing they complained about.

In my head I assume that anyone complaining about 'wokeness' means to say "You should tolerate my intolerance of kindness and consideration without criticism". Criticism is not an infringement on free speech, btw.

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 08:27

In short, people who want to be able to say whatever they like, even if offensive to some groups of people?

No, they're just arseholes and you'll find them on both sides of the Woke/Anti-woke debate.

ShenleyWillow · 23/11/2023 08:26

The word woke is unhelpful, meaningless drivel

AncientBallerina · 23/11/2023 08:25

I think the original concept of ‘woke’ has bean culturally appropriated by a load of irritating, preachy, virtue-signalling, posturing, privileged white people.

Takethehintandfuckoff · 23/11/2023 08:23

OP. I bet you’d be the first person to tell other people not to generalize about a group that you approve of.

I assume your anti-woke grouping includes all the people who have opinions you don’t like, which, of course, in your world, makes them all evil and bad, and not really human.

i’m not sure the worst examples of your anti-woke group are any more close minded than you are.

I don’t really know to whom you are referring in this post as you haven’t defined your terms, and it’s obviously a goady post, so your opinion, whatever it is and whoever it’s about, is worthless. HTH

Pooooochi · 23/11/2023 08:22

I probably get trounced as anti woke.

I don't believe twaw. I don't want my daughter sharing a youth hostel room with someone with a penis or a body thats grown taller and stronger than hers through male puberty. I don't want a woman only shortlist to include a 45 year old who has been educated and built a career for 20+ years in a male body then changed gender identity at 43, who has never experienced or going to experience menstruation, menopause, birth trauma etc.

I also dislike when some US racial issues are assumed to be the same in the UK, when our demographics & culture are very, very different, our police don't routinely carry guns, black people are a much smaller proportion of the population, we don't have the same history of segregation in schools for eg, and people from the Indian subcontinent are a much more significant minority here, which brings a different set of issues with religion among other things.

AlisonDonut · 23/11/2023 08:22

Those that are 'woke' and rail against the 'anti-woke' and label them as the worst dregs of society are the same people that turn up to rallies having not a single clue about what it is they are rallying against.

As Helen Staniland says, the agenda is the only one that refuses to say what their agenda is, lest they incriminate themselves.

Definitions don't come easy to them. So OP, if you want to stir up an 'Anti-Anti-Woke' groundswell, at least define your terms.

What are you saying 'Woke' is?

What are you saying 'Anti-Woke' is?

And what is it you Anti-Anti-Woke people are struggling for?

SisterhoodNotCisterhood · 23/11/2023 08:18

Sorry, posted too soon. Link is one of my favourite examples of why people are swaying towards anti-woke stance.

SisterhoodNotCisterhood · 23/11/2023 08:17

📸 Watch this video on Facebook www.facebook.com/share/v/q4ayqoKpzLg4c9DL/?mibextid=KsPBc6

JamSandle · 23/11/2023 08:15

No I disagree. It's moved away from reality/science and started to deny fact. That's why I can't get on board with it.

Justgotbackhome · 23/11/2023 08:12

What scares me is how far some people are prepared to go. PP mentioned the fact that some people (women) have been sacked, had to go through expensive and stressful court cases and employment tribunals because they don't go along with the belief that humans can change sex or that it is acceptable for males to compete against females in contact sports, for example.
Look at what has been happening in Scotland this week with the 3rd (and finally successful) attempt to screen a film that some people don't like.
This week women in Oregon talking about their sex based rights have been attacked and seriously assaulted by men and the police refused to intervene. Where is the line? When did it become ok to assault and batter people with whom you do not agree? Is it ok for the police to take the side of the people doing the assaulting?
Uni of Edinburgh - another attempt to screen 'Adult Human Female' today | Mumsnet

Women physically (many middle aged and older) attacked by transactivists in Portland. | Mumsnet

Uni of Edinburgh - another attempt to screen 'Adult Human Female' today | Mumsnet

[[https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-edinburgh-east-fife-67476387 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-edinburgh-east-fife-67476387]] '*A group...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4948240-uni-of-edinburgh-another-attempt-to-screen-adult-human-female-today?reply=130917776

wildwestpioneer · 23/11/2023 08:10

Ohthatsfabulousdarling · 23/11/2023 06:34

Not in all cases. I do think that a line needs to be drawn somewhere.
I am not a racist, I am not homophones, I am not a bigot, I can even to an extent understand trans issues- and always try to be respectful of people and their feelings, however when there comes a time where people say, I identify as a cat... I do think there is a problem.

I also see, that as people are becoming more accepting, which is universally, a good thing, people's power to speak up is being greatly reduced. The freedom of speech is disappearing at the very same time that laws are being passed to stop peaceful protest. In concerned that were being lulled into a situation where it becomes impossible to speak out if you have strong views on anything.

I was going to say about this same thing as this poster.

sgvibes · 23/11/2023 08:08

You'd need to have a definition of woke first.

I always thought woke meant not being prejudiced, being kind, etc.

But these days it also seems to include being misogynistic since all the proudly woke people I know are trans allies.

I'm not right wing at all, always voted labour, not racist, I'm kind and caring and want everyone to be able to live their lives in peace.

But...I know people can't change sex, I don't believe in gender stereotyping and I'm standing firm against women being compromised/single sex spaces being invaded. To all my woke friends I'm now a massive right wing bigot.

MorningHood · 23/11/2023 08:07

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 07:57

Woke and Unwoke are used to make it appear a binary choice of the extremes, when it's a spectrum and most people, most of the time, have views that lie somewhere between - although generally to either side of the middle rather than sitting on the fence. Neither term has much meaning except to the person using it at the time.

It's part of the decline of mainstream politics and philosophy, and a key part of the drive to divide us into opposing tribes. Communication, understanding and compromise are complex, and the political agenda is to push us into simple binary "You're with us, or against us" oppositions.

Well put🙌🏻

MorningHood · 23/11/2023 08:05

BillionaireTea · 23/11/2023 06:42

Yes, I'd say that's the size of it.

Oversll, they are people with a limited capacity (or education) to reflect on their own privilege - like fish who don't understand what water is.

They are people who think that the high level of comfort they feel in society, just feeling OK saying whatever is in their heads, is normal. They don't notice that it is a privilege. So they feel that suddenly being asked to guard their tongues, or shift their way of being, is a new thing - an insult to their freedom and ability to operate in the world. And it does feel like that, so I sympathise with those people's sensations.

However they don't understand that other people (who are different from them) already were living in an unwelcoming world where they couldn't speak freely/have been judged/are constantly harmed by culture and its assumptions.

What "woke" does is redresses the balance.

So, some people feel a but more awks in the world for a while...in order that others, who have been, historically, systemically under-valued and felt less comfortable, can feel... a bit more welcome. A bit more normal. A bit more ok for being themselves.

This is misunderstood though and when you say "look at your own privilege" anti-woke people indignantly think "But I don't have privilege! I'm not rich! I work hard! I don't get something for nothing!". This isn't what privilege is. Privilege is the ability to feel normal in the world without having to constantly think about what you're doing.

So the anti woke person says "People are such snowflakes they can't handle a joke about identity!" and marvel at the weakness and over sensitivity of others. They are not considering - literally not "awake to" all the work already being done by the person with the "less normal identity" just to get through the day. So the joke is the last straw, not a tiny nothing.

That’s a very narrow and patronising attempt to explain things..

Assumes anyone you consider ‘anti-woke’ doesn’t understand the concept of privilege and all those you deem lacking privilege are victims and need to be protected from them.

You’re perpetuating myths and stereotypes of ‘anti-woke’ people all being one homogenous group, which helps no one and accords zero cultural progress.

Perhaps you need to ‘wake up’.

Tantai · 23/11/2023 08:05

@Tulipsroses absolutely.

I was excited for Doctor Who lately as I had hopes a new writer might save the show. Unfortunately he did an interview where he revealed one of the best villains is going to be changed.

Davros was a part human/part Dalek who had become this way because he had been severely injured in an accident. They are now scrubbing this and making him just a guy who walks around…because it’s offensive to people in wheelchairs.

For a start, who apart from an immense dickhead is equating an alien in a floating death robot to someone in a wheelchair…

I could understand the problem if one race or group of people is only ever shown as ‘bad’.

But there are plenty of disabled superheroes (Professor X, Daredevil etc.) And it is actually greatly infantilising and offensive to say that any group of people simply cannot play a villain, ever.

pacora · 23/11/2023 08:01

As Ricky Gervais said "just because you are offended doesn't mean you're right"

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 07:57

Woke and Unwoke are used to make it appear a binary choice of the extremes, when it's a spectrum and most people, most of the time, have views that lie somewhere between - although generally to either side of the middle rather than sitting on the fence. Neither term has much meaning except to the person using it at the time.

It's part of the decline of mainstream politics and philosophy, and a key part of the drive to divide us into opposing tribes. Communication, understanding and compromise are complex, and the political agenda is to push us into simple binary "You're with us, or against us" oppositions.

LolaSmiles · 23/11/2023 07:57

Here's my difficulty.

The people claiming to be "anti woke" are usually people who are right wing and quite intolerant of many groups. They've just found a useful boogyman in the blue haired student politics style bubble of the left because even people who find the anti-woke people's views awful, will probably also roll their eyes at some 20 year old lecturing 50 year old women about the menopause.

Equally, there is a certain side of the progressive left who are very invested in painting themselves as the good guys, often at the expense of listening to othere. They live in echo chambers, write off any view that isn't theirs as hateful or bigotry or unsafe, and then in the name of tolerance seem worryingly keen to shut down discussion that doesn't fit their world view. This is probably what a lot of people picture when they hear people talking about the woke groups.

Meanwhile I think there's a lot of people who care about inequality, but don't fit with either of the groups because we're not self-absorbed, not concerned with our own egos and know things are often complicated.

Swipe left for the next trending thread