Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that people who are "Anti Woke"

187 replies

AntiWoke · 23/11/2023 06:27

are the people who would like free reign to be racist, sexist, mysogenistic, homophobic. In short, people who want to be able to say whatever they like, even if offensive to some groups of people?

OP posts:
DogInATent · 23/11/2023 09:19

SurprisedWithAHorse · 23/11/2023 09:07

The extreme is labelling anyone that disagrees with you with the most extreme positions of the opposing side.

That's funny, because it appears to be exactly what you're doing when you pretend that calling someone an extremist is comparable to death threats, posting porn on threads about children's art and denying physical reality.

But not everyone who disagrees with you is doing/saying those things.
So why do you label the entire opposing argument with just the extremes?

Debates get pushed into these extreme positions because it's the easiest path to maintaining the argument and maintaining the identity of existence that individuals have attached to it.

Now I do agree with you that some debates have a greater degree of polarisation on one side than the other. The TRAs have been backed into a corner and lost the plot, the whole biological reality thing is going to bite them on the balls about a decade down the line when we start seeing sex-specific conditions under-detected in that section of the population. They might be joking this year about getting called for cervical smears, but when they realise they're not being called for prostate screening and there's a statistically significant rise vs. the male population in general we'll see what the attitude is then. But I am not going to demonise every TW as a porn-spamming, granny-punching rapist just because they're a TW.

lifeturnsonadime · 23/11/2023 09:18

Extreme GCs dehumanise anyone slightly understanding of TR, the extreme TRAs dehumanise anyone with even slightly GC views. Neither extreme of this debate wants compromise. Anyone in the middle ground, who see even a few valid points on both sides and/or are turned off by the dehumanising/demonising of the extreme positions, is labelled as the Other by both extremes.

How do you define compromise?

Do this mean we have to let nice TW into single sex spaces?

How do you suppose that will work?

There can be NO compromise that keeps women safe, safeguarding keeps all males out to keep all women safe, even the nice ones.

Decent males, including decent TW know this and respect women.

MsRosley · 23/11/2023 09:17

Since woke brought us the gender cult which is inherently anti women and homophobic, I don't think you have a let to stand on with your silly, goady post, OP. Also critical race theory is currently retraining everyone to be obsessed with race and skin colour, and convincing non-Caucasians that hate and racism is lurking absolutely everywhere. It is deeply divisive, and inherently hypocritical.

Trying educating yourself on where all this originated, from critical theory studies in academia. Also, take a long, hard look at queer theory, and what it espouses, and you might be a bit shocked at all the 'love has no age' agenda.

Beautiful3 · 23/11/2023 09:13

That is a difficult one. I respect people are different. However when a man with a penis identifys as a woman and believes they should share the womens sports/toilets/changing rooms, I disagree. You cannot expect people to agree with everything people want! What if a man identified as a female child and started a sexual relationship with another child?! Wrong on so many levels. You can want to be certain things, but it doesn't mean it's real.

DorsetandBeyond · 23/11/2023 09:11

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 07:57

Woke and Unwoke are used to make it appear a binary choice of the extremes, when it's a spectrum and most people, most of the time, have views that lie somewhere between - although generally to either side of the middle rather than sitting on the fence. Neither term has much meaning except to the person using it at the time.

It's part of the decline of mainstream politics and philosophy, and a key part of the drive to divide us into opposing tribes. Communication, understanding and compromise are complex, and the political agenda is to push us into simple binary "You're with us, or against us" oppositions.

Agree with this, absolutely.

The way that "Woke" deals in absolutes of I'm right, you're wrong and "no debate" feels to me like part of a wider decline in academia, philosophy and the ability of individuals to apply their own critical thought to issues.

For me (as a lifelong Labour voter, left-wing Guardian reading feminist) I started off thinking Woke must be a good thing (because it's kind and inclusive, right?) But what woke has become at the moment leaves no possibility for nuance, discussion or deep thought. It's become about creating binary tribes and thought-terminating slogans that discourage personal engagement at greater depth. I've come to find it lazy and dangerous that any voice sounded against any aspect of "Woke" is decried as a "right-wing bigot". Firstly, because so many of those voices are actually coming from those on the left or centre; dismissing them as "right-wing bigots" is simply an easy way of shutting them down instantly. And secondly, because although I've always hated the Tories, I do actually believe in democracy and people with right-wing political views are part of a healthy democracy and aren't in themselves evil. Woke seems to encourage people to lump everyone right of centre (and many on the left) directly into the Nazi camp, and thereby dismiss their voices.

As has been said a number of times up thread, with interesting examples from @Teatrayderby @DropDeadFreida @Justgotbackhome , some areas of "woke" ideology are regressing women's rights in significant and measurable ways and taking away women's ability to talk about it, without putting their safety or their jobs at risk.

I'd like to mention as well what I think is one of the other big problems, which is the lazy importing of theories wholesale without adapting them to the places they are being imported to. For example, I have Irish friends with children at an Irish school who are being taught critical race theory with no nuance to the country they are living in. They are being taught in school that as white people they are privileged and come from privilege - when, in fact, they are working-class Irish people with a family history and a nation history in the not-so-distant past of extreme poverty, abuse at the hands of the English ruling classes, death in the potato famine etc. Similarly, an elderly family member recalls teaching in Wales as a young woman and a child in her class dying (in the classroom) from malnutrition and starvation. No, they weren't slaves in chains, but we're talking about the fairly recent past and lives of severe hardship, suffering and lack of agency - importing critical race theory wholesale is overly simplistic and completely ignores class and the huge impact it has had on generations.

NinjaGin · 23/11/2023 09:10

LadyBird1973 · 23/11/2023 07:44

I would describe myself as predominantly socialist, if I had to put a label on at all. But I do think the price of freedom is hearing opinions that you might personally find offensive.
Obviously it's not nice to be deliberately insulting or hurt others feeling, however no one has a right to go through life not ever hearing an opinion they find offensive - certainly not at the cost of others' democratic right to express their personal views. If I have to choose, then I choose to hear things I personally dislike, in order to protect that freedom. Otherwise, what is freedom?

I'm not homophobic, racist or misogynistic but I don't really care that much if other people are - I'd rather know who I'm dealing with. And that's the beauty of free speech - it gives us all a heads up, so we can decide whether we want to keep company with those whose values are different to our own.
^
Societal change comes about through freedom of expression - hiding what people really think doesn't make opinions change, it just entrenches them as the person who isn't allowed to speak, feels oppressed. That isn't healthy or productive in improving society.

People should be free to swim against the tide, to demonstrate if they want to, to peacefully protest^.

The trouble with 'woke' is that those people aren't content to hold and sit their own viewpoint. They want to prevent anyone else from having a different opinion. No one in this country should be losing their job because of their personal or political beliefs. The whole trans debate is a clear demonstration of where woke has gone wrong.

Fantastically well put. Thank you for articulating this so well.👏

Errrrrrm · 23/11/2023 09:10

Brahumbug · 23/11/2023 06:33

Inciting violence against people is, quite rightly, a crime. Being merely offensive should never be a crime. After all, a lot of opinions on Mumsnet could be considered offensive, but I wouldn't want to shut down other people's points if view.

This!

I get offended / hurt feelings all the time. That’s my problem. Doesn’t mean others should lose their careers over it or get arrested or whatever. (Women encounter misogyny every day.)

But the woke brigade want to police and suppress the speech of anyone who disagrees with them, and also destroy livelihoods. That is fanaticism. It’s sinister and threatens the entire basis of the Western way of life. Without civilised debate between groups who hold different opinions, there can be no civilisation. The woke brigade can’t comprehend that, they just think that they’re right and everyone else is wrong. 😂 They need to go back to primary school and learn how to talk politely to people they disagree with.

LastTrainEast · 23/11/2023 09:09

"people who want to be able to say whatever they like"

Yes those pesky people who think Free Speech matters.

Why can't we just ask you each time what opinions are allowed.

Speech that breaks the law (incitement to violence etc) is already covered so you're referring to speech that you personally don't like and want banned.

You have made the case for the growing numbers of anti-woke quite nicely, thank you.

EasternStandard · 23/11/2023 09:07

SurprisedWithAHorse · 23/11/2023 08:50

Most of society are somewhere in the middle thinking both are extremists

What is extremist about saying that women don't have penises and you can't change your sex?

And how many GC women have you seen issuing death threats and sharing porn on threads about children's costumes and artwork?

Agree with you @SurprisedWithAHorse

@DogInATent why is biological reality ‘extreme’ to you?

Also same question again related to women who understand their sex class matters more than gender

And how is that equivalent to death threats, punching 70 year old women in the face and male violence?

SurprisedWithAHorse · 23/11/2023 09:07

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 09:04

The extreme is labelling anyone that disagrees with you with the most extreme positions of the opposing side.

Extreme GCs dehumanise anyone slightly understanding of TR, the extreme TRAs dehumanise anyone with even slightly GC views. Neither extreme of this debate wants compromise. Anyone in the middle ground, who see even a few valid points on both sides and/or are turned off by the dehumanising/demonising of the extreme positions, is labelled as the Other by both extremes.

You can see the same polarisation happening on multiple complex issues - Israel/Palestine, Brexit, immigration, etc. It's the reduction ad nauseum of complex issues into Us vs Them tribal warfare. It's dumbing down, because solving the complex issues of living together in modern society make your brain hurt, and might mean having to share your cake with others.

The extreme is labelling anyone that disagrees with you with the most extreme positions of the opposing side.

That's funny, because it appears to be exactly what you're doing when you pretend that calling someone an extremist is comparable to death threats, posting porn on threads about children's art and denying physical reality.

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 09:04

SurprisedWithAHorse · 23/11/2023 08:50

Most of society are somewhere in the middle thinking both are extremists

What is extremist about saying that women don't have penises and you can't change your sex?

And how many GC women have you seen issuing death threats and sharing porn on threads about children's costumes and artwork?

The extreme is labelling anyone that disagrees with you with the most extreme positions of the opposing side.

Extreme GCs dehumanise anyone slightly understanding of TR, the extreme TRAs dehumanise anyone with even slightly GC views. Neither extreme of this debate wants compromise. Anyone in the middle ground, who see even a few valid points on both sides and/or are turned off by the dehumanising/demonising of the extreme positions, is labelled as the Other by both extremes.

You can see the same polarisation happening on multiple complex issues - Israel/Palestine, Brexit, immigration, etc. It's the reduction ad nauseum of complex issues into Us vs Them tribal warfare. It's dumbing down, because solving the complex issues of living together in modern society make your brain hurt, and might mean having to share your cake with others.

Kitanai · 23/11/2023 09:02

firstpasttheposter · 23/11/2023 08:53

How can anybody still be saying this? After the whole 'gas the Jews' incident it should be clear why many of us are not on board with the woke hatred and sh$t stirring very thinly disguised as 'antiracist'.

Exactly.

You know damn well the exact same clueless people going along to those marches would be horrified at ANYONE who attended a march where it was known in advance that a ‘minority’ would be shouting:

’gas the blacks’

or

‘kill the trans’

or

‘murder muslims, rape their daughters’.

Their hypocrisy and blind hatred to anything deemed ‘not on the right side’ is shocking. Same with the trans stuff, they try to pretend ‘both sides are extremes’ when only one is calling for ACTUAL violence and hatred.

At one of the marches two young British women were interviewed and asked what they thought of the Hamas attacks on Israel on the 7th of October. The response was ‘they didn’t, did they?’

They didn’t even KNOW about it and quickly scooted off after googling.

Diamonde · 23/11/2023 08:58

are racist!

Diamonde · 23/11/2023 08:57

firstpasttheposter · 23/11/2023 08:53

How can anybody still be saying this? After the whole 'gas the Jews' incident it should be clear why many of us are not on board with the woke hatred and sh$t stirring very thinly disguised as 'antiracist'.

Most people who declare themselves anti racist are.

StockpotSoup · 23/11/2023 08:57

Anyone who describes themselves as “anti-woke” is someone I’d walk into traffic to avoid.

AlisonDonut · 23/11/2023 08:56

It is all so circular.

'Anti woke people are homophobic'

What can be more homophobic than being woke enough to give gay and lesbian kids drugs and mutilate their bodies to fit what society thinks boys and girls should be like, and rendering them infertile and broken? And these are the people that call themselves 'woke'?

Nah pal. You can shove your woke where the sun doesn't shine.

Diamonde · 23/11/2023 08:55

Can you give some examples of what you are trying to say here?
I genuinely have no clue what your point is.

In gender politics, the people described as 'woke' are not people who are looking for middle ground. They do not want to debate.

Do you understand that or is that still needing clarification?

firstpasttheposter · 23/11/2023 08:53

How can anybody still be saying this? After the whole 'gas the Jews' incident it should be clear why many of us are not on board with the woke hatred and sh$t stirring very thinly disguised as 'antiracist'.

AlisonDonut · 23/11/2023 08:53

Diamonde · 23/11/2023 08:49

'The other side' is not extreme as I'm not engaging in hate crimes etx

But to say that they want compromise- is that supposed to be some kind or sarcasm? No, they don't. Look at gender politics as the best example.

Can you give some examples of what you are trying to say here?

I genuinely have no clue what your point is.

justasking111 · 23/11/2023 08:53

When just stop oil prevent people getting to hospitals/work I lose sympathy.

When BLM destroy historical statues I'm annoyed because history educates us the good and bad.

When Pride is hijacked and families are afraid to take part I'm angry.

When trans infiltrate government education and demand primary school children learn about advanced sexual activity I'm furious.

If that turns me from being a lifelong liberal to anti woke because I m against people being hurt/injured by a cause because uneducated extremists have hijacked it. Then so be it

Tulipsroses · 23/11/2023 08:53

What is puzzling to me is cynical blindness of the woke movement. For some reason it's offensive nowadays to tell a Jewish anecdote but acceptable to shout "From the river to the sea" implying a second holocaust.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 23/11/2023 08:50

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 08:44

I don't know if you're deliberately trying to prove my point, but your lengthy post is a demonising of one extreme position from the point of view of another extreme position. It's exactly what's wrong with the Woke/Anti-woke construct.

Ok, we can take the trans issue. There's a minority on either end of the extreme slinging stones and arguing that anyone with a view somewhere in the middle is automatically a member of the opposing extreme. I doubt the extreme views represent more than 10% of the population in total. Most of society are somewhere in the middle thinking both are extremists, and harbouring varying sympathies with both extremes at the same time on different aspects of the issue. Both extremes want to weaponise the issue into an absolute dividing line and reject the concept of a compromise outcome.

Most of society are somewhere in the middle thinking both are extremists

What is extremist about saying that women don't have penises and you can't change your sex?

And how many GC women have you seen issuing death threats and sharing porn on threads about children's costumes and artwork?

Diamonde · 23/11/2023 08:49

AlisonDonut · 23/11/2023 08:46

Both extremes want to weaponise the issue into an absolute dividing line and reject the concept of a compromise outcome.

Only one of these extremes is behaving like extremists. The other 'extreme' just wants to be able to talk about the reality of human existence including what a compromise might look like.

Edited

'The other side' is not extreme as I'm not engaging in hate crimes etx

But to say that they want compromise- is that supposed to be some kind or sarcasm? No, they don't. Look at gender politics as the best example.

museumum · 23/11/2023 08:47

Anti-woke isn’t always pro free speech. In my professional area the anti-woke are very keen on silencing any public mention of who benefitted from trans Atlantic slavery or that the British empire may have been anything other than a benevolent force for good.

if those of us who want to look at history from all sides and not always glorify the victor are “woke” then so be it

Mirandathepandaisontheverandah · 23/11/2023 08:46

"Woke" is one of many words that have lost any real meaning in modern discourse. See also - socialist, fascist, far left, far right, Liberal, colonise et al.

But if the threshold for "anti woke" is, as the OP implies, the right to be able to say a thing even if it may offend some groups of people, then I would indeed be anti woke and proud of it.