Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that people who are "Anti Woke"

187 replies

AntiWoke · 23/11/2023 06:27

are the people who would like free reign to be racist, sexist, mysogenistic, homophobic. In short, people who want to be able to say whatever they like, even if offensive to some groups of people?

OP posts:
Megifer · 23/11/2023 09:41

Nah, I'm just fucked off with those who get "triggered" by absolutely everything.

"Oooh I worked really hard today"
"I couldn't work hard today because I'm ill, are you saying I'm a lazy workshy twat? Are you saying people who can't work don't have a tough life? You really should think about what you say"
"OK goodbye"

🙄

MsRosley · 23/11/2023 09:40

Why are these organisations recommending same-sex facilities in the West and single-sex facilities in the rest of the world?

Because they're virtue-signalling, self-serving hypocrites who are just plain dumb.

Helleofabore · 23/11/2023 09:40

“But I am not going to demonise every TW as a porn-spamming, granny-punching rapist just because they're a TW.”

Is anyone on MN doing this? Or are you talking about elsewhere? Who do you believe is doing this, who are these extreme people?

DropDeadFreida · 23/11/2023 09:38

And one other point I would like to make is that certainly in the context of women's rights, it has been interesting to see just how racist and colonial the rhetoric is.

A perfect example of this comes from WHO: they published a report not that long ago that basically called for the importance of having single-sex toilets and facilities, and gave examples of countries like Nepal where according to their research, VAWG is rife and they need these spaces to be safe.

Is this not the same organisation that was pushing the TWAW agenda and championing same-sex facilities in the West?

So is it that Western men are less likely to rape and abuse women? Are Western men more evolved, kinder and egalitarian than men elsewhere? Why are these organisations recommending same-sex facilities in the West and single-sex facilities in the rest of the world?

Helleofabore · 23/11/2023 09:37

Sayitaintso33 · 23/11/2023 09:34

But MN has never (well very, very rarely) given a thought to teenage boys sharing a changing room with a fully intact gay male.

Now is that woke, anti-woke or just plain bigoted.

I am not sure whether you think MN should be discussing this as you see this as a safeguarding fail or whether you don’t think we should be discussing this ? Can you clarify please?

BethDuttonsTwin · 23/11/2023 09:36

BethDuttonsTwin · 23/11/2023 09:23

They’re the absolute same thing and the sooner people wake up to that and what the “woke” religion actually is, the better.

Edited

This post was in regard to the poster who said that it’s cancel culture they have a problem with. They’re two cheeks of the same arse.

EasternStandard · 23/11/2023 09:36

coliqua · 23/11/2023 09:30

I'm just tired of all of it.

Can't we just try to be decent, reasonable, and kind? And know everyone gets it wrong a lot because we are all busy and tired and flawed? Most people are ok really. Some people are bonkers or horrible. But we outnumber them. I have friends who are trans and friends who are radical feminists. I have carefully and reasonably discussed these issues - even at work - with people with opposing views and agreed compromise positions that respects people. This is possible! In academia I understand it's very risky to have political or intellectual debates, that's a different matter : I have friends who have lost their jobs for doing this.

But for most people, in real life it's fine. It's really ok. Get off Twitter and speak to people. Most people are ok.

Women can say no to males in their spaces and be ‘kind’ (or not as they wish)

It is entirely reasonable for women not to consent.

Sayitaintso33 · 23/11/2023 09:34

Thisilldo · 23/11/2023 07:19

I don’t want my teenage daughter having to share a changing room with a fully intact male. It’s abhorrent and will eventually lead to a tragedy. If you want to call me names to justify the danger you are putting young girls in them so be it. I don’t care. Your opinion is nothing to me.

But MN has never (well very, very rarely) given a thought to teenage boys sharing a changing room with a fully intact gay male.

Now is that woke, anti-woke or just plain bigoted.

anotherside · 23/11/2023 09:32

@firstpasttheposter

Doesn’t mean others should lose their careers over it or get arrested or whatever. (Women encounter misogyny every day.) But the woke brigade want to police and suppress the speech of anyone who disagrees with them

You're correct to call out this cancel culture/shutting down of free speech stuff. But you ought to recognise that right wing factions also use these methods nearly as much as those on the left and have also done so historically.

So the authoritarian mindset transcends left-right. But when it’s employed on the right to shut down, say, voices on the climate debate, the Israel-Palestine conflict, or just giving a fair airing to socialist views in general without labelling their proponents as “terrorists supporting” or “Anti American/British” etc etc - that sort of stuff doesn’t cause any uproar, because the authoritarians concerned have no problem shutting down that sort of free speech and these authoritarians hold far more power and influence than the Woke Brigade on X.

DropDeadFreida · 23/11/2023 09:31

I think the example by @DorsetandBeyond is really important. We need nuance above all else when teaching and discussing these issues. This ridiculous tribalism is so damaging, and the world is not black and white.

On a personal level, attempting to discuss this issue with some people of my acquaintance has been so upsetting for me in the past, because on the few occasions I tried to relate my own experiences I was shut down because my viewpoint of tolerance and debate did not fit their mould of what a person like me 'should' be saying.

My family came to this country to escape actual fascism. Not this contemporary form of 'I don't like what you say so you're a fascist' but actual attempts at genocide, gassing people, raping women and burning down homes kind of fascism. So hearing white, English, middle class people who have never even travelled beyond Western Europe and the US try and explain oppression to me and tell me I am wrong has been nothing short of galling.

It's one of the reasons I started coming on to Mumsnet in the first place-it's one of the only places (outside of my close friendship group) where these topics can be discussed freely.

These people are not interested in truth, justice and equality, they are looking for a tribe, and the performative nature of social media is the perfect breeding ground for this.

I say this as someone who would always vote Labour, even canvassed for Labour, was a member of a union and very political. I am not anymore. Speak to anyone who grew up in a home country like mine and you will soon realise that we have seen this type of discourse many times: people pitting themselves against each other, suppressing debate, threatening abuse and violence towards dissenters, forcing marginalised groups to go underground. What does that sound like? It doesn't end well.

coliqua · 23/11/2023 09:30

I'm just tired of all of it.

Can't we just try to be decent, reasonable, and kind? And know everyone gets it wrong a lot because we are all busy and tired and flawed? Most people are ok really. Some people are bonkers or horrible. But we outnumber them. I have friends who are trans and friends who are radical feminists. I have carefully and reasonably discussed these issues - even at work - with people with opposing views and agreed compromise positions that respects people. This is possible! In academia I understand it's very risky to have political or intellectual debates, that's a different matter : I have friends who have lost their jobs for doing this.

But for most people, in real life it's fine. It's really ok. Get off Twitter and speak to people. Most people are ok.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 23/11/2023 09:30

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 09:19

But not everyone who disagrees with you is doing/saying those things.
So why do you label the entire opposing argument with just the extremes?

Debates get pushed into these extreme positions because it's the easiest path to maintaining the argument and maintaining the identity of existence that individuals have attached to it.

Now I do agree with you that some debates have a greater degree of polarisation on one side than the other. The TRAs have been backed into a corner and lost the plot, the whole biological reality thing is going to bite them on the balls about a decade down the line when we start seeing sex-specific conditions under-detected in that section of the population. They might be joking this year about getting called for cervical smears, but when they realise they're not being called for prostate screening and there's a statistically significant rise vs. the male population in general we'll see what the attitude is then. But I am not going to demonise every TW as a porn-spamming, granny-punching rapist just because they're a TW.

But not everyone who disagrees with you is doing/saying those things.

And nobody is claiming that they are.

But you're trying to equate the "extremists" on both sides as being somehow as bad as each other. And calling someone an extremist isn't actually comparable with threatening to murder someone, trying to hijack a children's art threat with pornography or denying biological reality.

And now you're just trying to shift and deflect from the really rather dishonest false equivalence you're peddling. The point isn't that NATAALT, the point is that you're trying to paint two types of people as "just as bad as each other" when they clearly aren't. It's not even extremist to call someone an extremist, much as you clearly wish it were.

Do you think people are actually fooled by this intellectual dishonesty of yours?

skyknight · 23/11/2023 09:29

I associate woke with being anti Jewish, anti-white, anti-women, anti-science, aggressive and homophobic, so yes I am anti-woke.

Thinkbiglittleone · 23/11/2023 09:27

It depends on your opinion of woke. But yes I do think some people throw the word around as they have no viable argument or point of view on a subject without being racist. Everytime I see it used, I do disregard that person opinion slightly.

MsRosley · 23/11/2023 09:26

I think everyone who proudly proclaims they are woke should be asked this question: you're on the seventh floor of a burning building and the fire brigade has finally arrived. The stairs are alight, and the only way to save you is to be carried out of a window and down a long ladder. Do you want the person carrying you to be
a) a big burly bloke who got the job because he's a big burly bloke who can carry people out of burning buildings
b) a diversity hire who ticked all the boxes regarding gender, ethnicity, sexuality etc

EasternStandard · 23/11/2023 09:24

The whole ‘both sides’ thing needs to be put in the bin

It’s rolled out at every occasion, even when women are attacked by men

LastTrainEast · 23/11/2023 09:24

"Both extremes want to weaponise the issue into an absolute dividing line and reject the concept of a compromise outcome."

I think you mean appeasement not compromise.

Where women back down and retreat each time for fear of the consequences of disagreeing. Further and further back and down.

BethDuttonsTwin · 23/11/2023 09:23

They’re the absolute same thing and the sooner people wake up to that and what the “woke” religion actually is, the better.

EasternStandard · 23/11/2023 09:22

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 09:19

But not everyone who disagrees with you is doing/saying those things.
So why do you label the entire opposing argument with just the extremes?

Debates get pushed into these extreme positions because it's the easiest path to maintaining the argument and maintaining the identity of existence that individuals have attached to it.

Now I do agree with you that some debates have a greater degree of polarisation on one side than the other. The TRAs have been backed into a corner and lost the plot, the whole biological reality thing is going to bite them on the balls about a decade down the line when we start seeing sex-specific conditions under-detected in that section of the population. They might be joking this year about getting called for cervical smears, but when they realise they're not being called for prostate screening and there's a statistically significant rise vs. the male population in general we'll see what the attitude is then. But I am not going to demonise every TW as a porn-spamming, granny-punching rapist just because they're a TW.

Who said ‘every TW’ anyway?

I don’t think much at all about those who stand back up to them, as long as they recognise that ‘both sides are extreme’ is bollocks, can’t be evidenced and is an attempt to say women are behaving in extreme ways as men

All not true.

anotherside · 23/11/2023 09:21

Of course there are extreme examples and indivudals who take things too far. But generally speaking the people who froth about “woke” strike me as just being angry about their lot full stop, and are looking for am easy scapegoat.

It’s the right wing equivalent of the socialist moaning that his life is crap because the system is rigged in favour of the rich. Rather than taking personal responsibility and trying to make the most of what you have, it’s more comforting to blame the system for ones’ failings. So instead of things being rigged in favour of the elite/rich, now everything’s rigged in favour of trans people/immigrants etc etc

The modern right cheered on by the victim mentality of the Daily Mail & co spend far more time whinging “it’s so unfair!” than the left ever did. 😅

firstpasttheposter · 23/11/2023 09:20

Errrrrrm · 23/11/2023 09:10

This!

I get offended / hurt feelings all the time. That’s my problem. Doesn’t mean others should lose their careers over it or get arrested or whatever. (Women encounter misogyny every day.)

But the woke brigade want to police and suppress the speech of anyone who disagrees with them, and also destroy livelihoods. That is fanaticism. It’s sinister and threatens the entire basis of the Western way of life. Without civilised debate between groups who hold different opinions, there can be no civilisation. The woke brigade can’t comprehend that, they just think that they’re right and everyone else is wrong. 😂 They need to go back to primary school and learn how to talk politely to people they disagree with.

One of the most annoying things about woke is that I've found myself on the side of people I don't actually like and generally don't agree with because I think it's so vindictive that they've lost their livelihoods. I have to keep reminding myself that actually I don't share that person's views, otherwise I might end up becoming quite reactionary and unpleasant, which is not the person I want to be.

Helleofabore · 23/11/2023 09:20

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 08:44

I don't know if you're deliberately trying to prove my point, but your lengthy post is a demonising of one extreme position from the point of view of another extreme position. It's exactly what's wrong with the Woke/Anti-woke construct.

Ok, we can take the trans issue. There's a minority on either end of the extreme slinging stones and arguing that anyone with a view somewhere in the middle is automatically a member of the opposing extreme. I doubt the extreme views represent more than 10% of the population in total. Most of society are somewhere in the middle thinking both are extremists, and harbouring varying sympathies with both extremes at the same time on different aspects of the issue. Both extremes want to weaponise the issue into an absolute dividing line and reject the concept of a compromise outcome.

What is rather enlightening is asking people who they see as the ‘extreme’ end of that particular issue.

Because sometimes those who declare that they are in the middle are in reality agreeing with feminists campaigning for the prioritisation of sex where sex matters however they either don’t understand that they agree to such a large extent because people in media, politics or other places conveying the message have portrayed feminists as extreme. Or those declaring they are in the middle while agreeing with a group being relegated to the extreme end don’t like the way feminists talk. They don’t like the bluntness because they want to continue to feel they are kind and tolerant and view bluntness as being unkind and intolerant.

As with other posters asking for a definition of what the OP considers ‘woke’ is, it becomes just as important to ask people what they believe is the extremes they are talking about.

lifeturnsonadime · 23/11/2023 09:20

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 09:19

But not everyone who disagrees with you is doing/saying those things.
So why do you label the entire opposing argument with just the extremes?

Debates get pushed into these extreme positions because it's the easiest path to maintaining the argument and maintaining the identity of existence that individuals have attached to it.

Now I do agree with you that some debates have a greater degree of polarisation on one side than the other. The TRAs have been backed into a corner and lost the plot, the whole biological reality thing is going to bite them on the balls about a decade down the line when we start seeing sex-specific conditions under-detected in that section of the population. They might be joking this year about getting called for cervical smears, but when they realise they're not being called for prostate screening and there's a statistically significant rise vs. the male population in general we'll see what the attitude is then. But I am not going to demonise every TW as a porn-spamming, granny-punching rapist just because they're a TW.

Right but do you think that women should have single sex spaces & sports or don't you?

Sartre · 23/11/2023 09:19

I’m not ‘anti-woke’ but am vehemently against cancel culture. I’m a uni lecturer and we have to fight hard to keep certain literature on the reading lists because of the language and themes it contains. Bearing in mind a lot of it was written 100-200 years ago but it’s difficult within a university nowadays not to cause someone some minor offence.

Within one of the modules I teach, I make it clear that being offended isn’t an argument and the whole point of the module is to engage students in critical thought. If they don’t like one of the theorists, they need to tell us why and actually argue.

I don’t think anyone should be deleted because their views don’t match up with the so-called ‘woke generation’. Everyone’s view is valid and if we disagree, we need to critically evaluate why and come back with an actual response. Flailing around saying ‘I’m offended’ isn’t an argument.