Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that people who are "Anti Woke"

187 replies

AntiWoke · 23/11/2023 06:27

are the people who would like free reign to be racist, sexist, mysogenistic, homophobic. In short, people who want to be able to say whatever they like, even if offensive to some groups of people?

OP posts:
MsRosley · 23/11/2023 12:23

Helleofabore · 23/11/2023 12:14

I would like to know what 'compromise' looks like to doginatent when they say "Neither extreme of this debate wants compromise."

Because this is also seems to be a dishonest tactic that is used by some and I don't know if doginatent is using that tactic here.

The 'compromise' stance often gets rolled out with the 'both sides' approach and I have never found that the compromise is workable, however, I have found that the 'compromise' is what feminists have been proposing as a solution for maybe a decade, maybe more. However, that is not usually acknowledged by those trying to use the 'both sides' approach.

Let's have a look at what might be the compromise that they have in mind. Third spaces comes to mind. Why third spaces and not unisex spaces? Because unisex spaces have been shown in the past to be unsafe for women. They are also proposed by people who have never yet had to use a female toilet for anything but peeing apparently. Because it neglects to consider the many uses of a female toilet that women have that require privacy because doors will not close (prams or broken locks or wheelchairs etc) or because of the activities that are done in the open space near the sink or hand drier.

Third spaces have been suggested by feminists for a very long time. And summarily rejected.

Another 'compromise' could be said to be the current position that the government has taken. That some male prisoners with no history of sexual abuse can be housed in the female prisons. Why is this this compromise acceptable at all? Is the time to exclude a male only after they have committed a sex crime? Is that the way safeguarding processes work? Or have we as a society created safeguarding processes that exclude all male people from female single sex spaces in the past based on male risk factors?

Allowing 'some' male people in also then continues what is in essence abuse of women who are now locked in with a male person and they cannot escape. When they are victims of horrific abuse perpetrated by other male people and are now not only living in prison, but living in prison where they are constantly on guard against those male people who they are forced to live with.

Again, a compromise that has been accepted by some but is continuing to subject vulnerable women to great harm.

There are a list of things that people firmly believe are 'compromises' that really are not when you analyse the outcomes of those. They are absolutely 'compromises' but the people who are harmed the most are the women and girls. Still. I do wonder what doginatent means when they say this.

I am always suspect of those people declaring there are 'compromises' to be had and then declaring 'both sides' are extreme. It seems often to be either ill thought through scenarios that people with little understanding propose or it is what has been suggested by feminists, and many people on MN, but that the person saying 'both sides' are extreme doesn't like the blunt language. Blunt language which when they pushed to discuss, they cannot disagree with but feel mean and unkind in using. It is more 'I don't want to be seen as being like those mean women over there even though I agree, I just wish they would be kinder in their language'.... without realising that using 'kind' language has allowed such ambiguity to be accepted in our policies and laws in the first place.

I am always suspect of those people declaring there are 'compromises' to be had and then declaring 'both sides' are extreme.

I think it's a total cop-out. People who spout that drivel just don't want to actually think about the issue, often because they're terrified they'll discover the terfs were right all along. By pretending there's extremists on both sides, they can stay in a smug, complacent 'centre' feeling good about themselves and how very reasonable they are.

Verv · 23/11/2023 12:20

I'm anti-woke and im a female homosexual so no, I dont think that I can be described as a sexist homophobe.

I find "woke" to be utterly homophobic and ridiculously misogynistic, not to mention deeply racist a lot of the time.

Helleofabore · 23/11/2023 12:14

I would like to know what 'compromise' looks like to doginatent when they say "Neither extreme of this debate wants compromise."

Because this is also seems to be a dishonest tactic that is used by some and I don't know if doginatent is using that tactic here.

The 'compromise' stance often gets rolled out with the 'both sides' approach and I have never found that the compromise is workable, however, I have found that the 'compromise' is what feminists have been proposing as a solution for maybe a decade, maybe more. However, that is not usually acknowledged by those trying to use the 'both sides' approach.

Let's have a look at what might be the compromise that they have in mind. Third spaces comes to mind. Why third spaces and not unisex spaces? Because unisex spaces have been shown in the past to be unsafe for women. They are also proposed by people who have never yet had to use a female toilet for anything but peeing apparently. Because it neglects to consider the many uses of a female toilet that women have that require privacy because doors will not close (prams or broken locks or wheelchairs etc) or because of the activities that are done in the open space near the sink or hand drier.

Third spaces have been suggested by feminists for a very long time. And summarily rejected.

Another 'compromise' could be said to be the current position that the government has taken. That some male prisoners with no history of sexual abuse can be housed in the female prisons. Why is this this compromise acceptable at all? Is the time to exclude a male only after they have committed a sex crime? Is that the way safeguarding processes work? Or have we as a society created safeguarding processes that exclude all male people from female single sex spaces in the past based on male risk factors?

Allowing 'some' male people in also then continues what is in essence abuse of women who are now locked in with a male person and they cannot escape. When they are victims of horrific abuse perpetrated by other male people and are now not only living in prison, but living in prison where they are constantly on guard against those male people who they are forced to live with.

Again, a compromise that has been accepted by some but is continuing to subject vulnerable women to great harm.

There are a list of things that people firmly believe are 'compromises' that really are not when you analyse the outcomes of those. They are absolutely 'compromises' but the people who are harmed the most are the women and girls. Still. I do wonder what doginatent means when they say this.

I am always suspect of those people declaring there are 'compromises' to be had and then declaring 'both sides' are extreme. It seems often to be either ill thought through scenarios that people with little understanding propose or it is what has been suggested by feminists, and many people on MN, but that the person saying 'both sides' are extreme doesn't like the blunt language. Blunt language which when they pushed to discuss, they cannot disagree with but feel mean and unkind in using. It is more 'I don't want to be seen as being like those mean women over there even though I agree, I just wish they would be kinder in their language'.... without realising that using 'kind' language has allowed such ambiguity to be accepted in our policies and laws in the first place.

inamarina · 23/11/2023 12:07

MsRosley · 23/11/2023 09:17

Since woke brought us the gender cult which is inherently anti women and homophobic, I don't think you have a let to stand on with your silly, goady post, OP. Also critical race theory is currently retraining everyone to be obsessed with race and skin colour, and convincing non-Caucasians that hate and racism is lurking absolutely everywhere. It is deeply divisive, and inherently hypocritical.

Trying educating yourself on where all this originated, from critical theory studies in academia. Also, take a long, hard look at queer theory, and what it espouses, and you might be a bit shocked at all the 'love has no age' agenda.

Also critical race theory is currently retraining everyone to be obsessed with race and skin colour, and convincing non-Caucasians that hate and racism is lurking absolutely everywhere. It is deeply divisive, and inherently hypocritical.

Interestingly, I‘ve been seeing more and more social media accounts of Black women who disagree with the CRT approach, like Ada Akpala for instance. Another interesting voice is Africa Brooke, and also Amala Ekpunobi in the States.

BethDuttonsTwin · 23/11/2023 12:00

Horrace · 23/11/2023 10:57

I think it's the opposite.
The people who regard themselves as woke are the most sexist, racist, homophobic ignorant and most closed minded individuals ever.
I am constantly astounded by their lack of openness for discussion and ability to listen to others and really listen.

This!

inamarina · 23/11/2023 11:41

DogInATent · 23/11/2023 09:04

The extreme is labelling anyone that disagrees with you with the most extreme positions of the opposing side.

Extreme GCs dehumanise anyone slightly understanding of TR, the extreme TRAs dehumanise anyone with even slightly GC views. Neither extreme of this debate wants compromise. Anyone in the middle ground, who see even a few valid points on both sides and/or are turned off by the dehumanising/demonising of the extreme positions, is labelled as the Other by both extremes.

You can see the same polarisation happening on multiple complex issues - Israel/Palestine, Brexit, immigration, etc. It's the reduction ad nauseum of complex issues into Us vs Them tribal warfare. It's dumbing down, because solving the complex issues of living together in modern society make your brain hurt, and might mean having to share your cake with others.

Extreme GCs dehumanise anyone slightly understanding of TR

How exactly are they dehumanising them?

Horrace · 23/11/2023 10:57

I think it's the opposite.
The people who regard themselves as woke are the most sexist, racist, homophobic ignorant and most closed minded individuals ever.
I am constantly astounded by their lack of openness for discussion and ability to listen to others and really listen.

LadyBird1973 · 23/11/2023 10:53

@JaniceJanice I absolutely agree with you in the job front. I should have said that in my post. Everyone has a responsibility to behave professionally in their workplace and adhere to our non discrimination laws. No one needs to be sharing their political (or other) beliefs at work, they should just be doing their job.

I have long disagreed with the allowances made for pharmacists not to hand over a morning after pill if they don't believe in abortion, for example. This is part of their job and MAP is legal in this country. How dare they deny women medication to which we are entitled.

luckylavender · 23/11/2023 10:51

Teatrayderby · 23/11/2023 06:30

No not necessarily. The woke agenda is obscuring good equality work.

The 'woke agenda' is propagated by people who are 'anti woke'.

skyknight · 23/11/2023 10:47

The absurdity of woke means that people think misgendering someone is the equivalent to the contents of Mein Kampf yet calling for the ethnic cleansing of an entire people is just a mild opinion accompanied by a shoulder shrug.

Darkdiamond · 23/11/2023 10:46

I have quite traditional, conservative views and am quite right leaning in a lot of my opinions. I also believe that everyone deserves respect and everyone has the right to live their life as they wish, regardless whether I personally 'approve' of their lifestyle or not. Everyone has the right to their own opinion and should be able to express it freely, understanding that not everyone may like it.

Everyone has their own story to tell, and actually, I try not to speak about things outside of my experience. I've no idea what it's like to grow up as a black boy in the UK. I don't know what it's like to struggle with my gender identity. I don't understand the day-to-day challenges a woman faces within certain cultures that I'm not part of.

However, some things are factual realities which cannt be changed no matter how much people wish them away (like biological sex), and ignoring their importance can have grave consequences. When the focus is less on giving people the grace to live their life as they wish, and actually becomes an issue of children being taught that if a boy plays with Barbies he is maybe really a girl, a line has been crossed.

When the issue becomes less about opening opportunities for people from ethnic minorities, but now paints all white people as inherent racists by Virtue of being white, then I get frustrated.

When some people want to refer to themselves as the opposite sex, but then I have to declare my pronouns at a work meeting even though nobody has ever mistaken me for a man my entire life, that's when things get silly.

For me, I believe that we should all be giving a certain level of grace to others to live out their own journey, but that certain traditional values aren't completely meaningless because they don't suit everyone. When it switches from living and letting live, to a situation where certain groups are now framed as not only victims, but that everyone outside that group has to alter their behaviour in a way that unfairly impacts them, that's when 'woke' culture annoys me.

To me, the unhealthy woke culture means using a certain group's issues in order to make the greater population behave in a way which often 1) undermines factual reality or common sense and 2) actually keeps the underprivileged group in bandage to whatever the issue is that they're experiencing.

I've tried to explain this as best I could.

I find the notion that people who disagree with what is known as 'woke' culture are just bigoted thickos to be very indicative of the simplistic and reductionist ways that the 'woke' actually think.

inamarina · 23/11/2023 10:42

PallyRoe · 23/11/2023 08:35

Yes. Like the trans activists posting porn under J.K.Rowlings tweet displaying a drawing from one of her fans, a child.

Or telling numerous women to ‘choke on their girl dick’ and demanding women who don’t agree with them be beheaded or beaten with a prettily decorated baseball bat.

I think people are ‘anti-woke’ because of the sheer lunacy of many of the viciously ‘woke’ activists who seem to have no issue using sexual violence, violence, sexism or racism against the ‘wrong’ people.

The hypocrisy of many young ‘woke’ people acting like belligerent fascists is not lost on the sane, whichever side of the political spectrum they fall on.

Their pure hatred and lack of critical reasoning skills when coming across an opinion they don’t like is also mildly terrifying.

I think debate clubs, where you need to learn how to construct an argument even for a side you disagree with, should become mandatory.

The hypocrisy of many young ‘woke’ people acting like belligerent fascists is not lost on the sane, whichever side of the political spectrum they fall on.

Fully agree with this. It‘s interesting how some people don’t see a problem with the desire to police others‘ attitudes and even punish people for 'wrongthink'.
As for the J.K.Rowling example - it was really mind boggling for me to see, after all the abuse she had received from TRAs for stating a pretty common sense opinion, how earnest social justice influenceers (often young women) would still present her as the problematic one.

inamarina · 23/11/2023 10:31

AncientBallerina · 23/11/2023 08:25

I think the original concept of ‘woke’ has bean culturally appropriated by a load of irritating, preachy, virtue-signalling, posturing, privileged white people.

I agree that the meaning of the term 'woke' seems to have changed, I don’t think it’s just down to virtue-signalling white people though.
I‘ve seen people of different ethnicities use it as a tool to create division unfortunately.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 23/11/2023 10:27

Sayitaintso33 · 23/11/2023 10:16

Sorry I'm probably derailing the thread, but I see it as a safeguarding fail that is never considered. We seem to spend a lot of time protecting our daughters from men but not enough protecting our sons.

Gay men as a class are not a statistical and demonstrable threat as far as I'm aware. Obviously some of them are violent or sex offenders but not enough to justify segregating them from straight men for changing facilities.

The same can't be said for the level of threat men as a class pose to women. As TRAs so often refuse to acknowledge, the threat of wholly untransitioned (with the understanding that no human can change sex whatever they do) males in female spaces is not related to their being trans, it's related to their being male.

Sayitaintso33 · 23/11/2023 10:16

Helleofabore · 23/11/2023 09:37

I am not sure whether you think MN should be discussing this as you see this as a safeguarding fail or whether you don’t think we should be discussing this ? Can you clarify please?

Sorry I'm probably derailing the thread, but I see it as a safeguarding fail that is never considered. We seem to spend a lot of time protecting our daughters from men but not enough protecting our sons.

anotherside · 23/11/2023 10:12

The debate on free speech is hampered by many issues, a couple come to mind,

  1. Hypocrisy and self-interest.
    If some lecturer says that MLK was “nothing but a wife beating sociopath” or Mandela “a no good terrorist sympathiser” or whatever and is subsequently fired, the right wing tabloids will be calling this a disgrace of freedom of expression and Woke out of control in universities across the land. The next day another professor calls Churchill a “disgusting mysoginist racist” and those same papers will be CALLING for that lecturer to be fired and saying Woke is out of control at universities across the land (same villain you see!)

  2. No universally agreed definition of hate speech (or certainly not one that is culturally agreed upon). Is or offensive language? Dehumanising language? Language that encourages violence against a group? Etc.

Dweetfidilove · 23/11/2023 09:57

AncientBallerina · 23/11/2023 08:25

I think the original concept of ‘woke’ has bean culturally appropriated by a load of irritating, preachy, virtue-signalling, posturing, privileged white people.

Yes, the culture of appropriating movements is the newest ‘trend’, sadly.

Elastica23 · 23/11/2023 09:56

Yes, I think you are right, OP.

It's just the same as people saying Political Correctness Gorn Mad ten years ago.

JaniceJanice · 23/11/2023 09:54

LadyBird1973 · 23/11/2023 07:44

I would describe myself as predominantly socialist, if I had to put a label on at all. But I do think the price of freedom is hearing opinions that you might personally find offensive.
Obviously it's not nice to be deliberately insulting or hurt others feeling, however no one has a right to go through life not ever hearing an opinion they find offensive - certainly not at the cost of others' democratic right to express their personal views. If I have to choose, then I choose to hear things I personally dislike, in order to protect that freedom. Otherwise, what is freedom?

I'm not homophobic, racist or misogynistic but I don't really care that much if other people are - I'd rather know who I'm dealing with. And that's the beauty of free speech - it gives us all a heads up, so we can decide whether we want to keep company with those whose values are different to our own.
^
Societal change comes about through freedom of expression - hiding what people really think doesn't make opinions change, it just entrenches them as the person who isn't allowed to speak, feels oppressed. That isn't healthy or productive in improving society.

People should be free to swim against the tide, to demonstrate if they want to, to peacefully protest^.

The trouble with 'woke' is that those people aren't content to hold and sit their own viewpoint. They want to prevent anyone else from having a different opinion. No one in this country should be losing their job because of their personal or political beliefs. The whole trans debate is a clear demonstration of where woke has gone wrong.

I’m disabled (wheelchair user and chronically ill), ND, and I’m a dyke- over all I agree with you.

People will always have views and opinions about my ‘lifestyle’, marriage, body, presence in the world, parenting ability, sex life, salvation and intellect- which I consider to be on a spectrum from bullshit- downright abhorrent.

They are allowed to hold those opinions and to express them in appropriate spaces (to their mates down the pub, on line, in their church or worship group, over dinner with their mum or whatever)- I’m allowed to think they are colossal wankers. This is how it’s always been and should be- I don’t like ablist homophobes but I don’t have to like everyone.

Where I would disagree with you is on the job front- if I pitch up at the doctor for a smear test or an sti test and she refuses to do it because ‘lesbians can’t get those things because they don’t have real sex’ (this has actually happened to me, it’s not an invented scenario), then I have no issue complaining and making a big fuss- it’s her job to do it, the fact she doesn’t believe lesbian sex is real sex is irrelevant.

The same goes for teachers at school- they can think what they want, but if they stand in front of a class and tell them they will go to hell if they are gay (another thing that has happened to me) then they don’t deserve to have that job.

anotherside · 23/11/2023 09:49

@firstpasttheposter

Agree. It’s the same forces and mindset that came for Donald Trump that came Jeremy Corbyn. It’s nothing to do with free speech or where the limits of free speech should be. They are power plays, pure and simple. “I don’t like what you say or stand for and I hate how popular you are. Unfortunately my arguments aren’t working so I’ll just get you cancelled”.

Dweetfidilove · 23/11/2023 09:47

Nah!

Wokeness as it is now has diluted every serious cause I’ve seen people fight for.

Now everyone is so distracted by all the reasons they feel slighted, we’re making far less progress in equality- be that race, sex, sexual orientation, disability etc.

I've even heard my teenagers complaining that everyone is so busy being offended, no one has any rights anymore 🤷🏽‍♀️. All a bloody distraction.

firstpasttheposter · 23/11/2023 09:45

anotherside · 23/11/2023 09:32

@firstpasttheposter

Doesn’t mean others should lose their careers over it or get arrested or whatever. (Women encounter misogyny every day.) But the woke brigade want to police and suppress the speech of anyone who disagrees with them

You're correct to call out this cancel culture/shutting down of free speech stuff. But you ought to recognise that right wing factions also use these methods nearly as much as those on the left and have also done so historically.

So the authoritarian mindset transcends left-right. But when it’s employed on the right to shut down, say, voices on the climate debate, the Israel-Palestine conflict, or just giving a fair airing to socialist views in general without labelling their proponents as “terrorists supporting” or “Anti American/British” etc etc - that sort of stuff doesn’t cause any uproar, because the authoritarians concerned have no problem shutting down that sort of free speech and these authoritarians hold far more power and influence than the Woke Brigade on X.

I didn't write the quote you put up. But, yes, I agree with you. One of the most frustrating thing about woke is that they say 'cancel culture is a right-wing myth'. I try to tell them, 'this will come and get you too' and they don't believe me. Perhaps they will believe me now? Look at all those young people in America who've been fired before they even started their jobs. A number of actors have lost parts in films or been dropped by their agencies. Sure, some of the things they've said are awful, but this is how conflicts work, people see horrific violence and loss and they get upset. Diane Abbott is still suspended. I can't stand the woman, but she's a democratically elected MP.

Tulipsroses · 23/11/2023 09:44

MsRosley · 23/11/2023 09:26

I think everyone who proudly proclaims they are woke should be asked this question: you're on the seventh floor of a burning building and the fire brigade has finally arrived. The stairs are alight, and the only way to save you is to be carried out of a window and down a long ladder. Do you want the person carrying you to be
a) a big burly bloke who got the job because he's a big burly bloke who can carry people out of burning buildings
b) a diversity hire who ticked all the boxes regarding gender, ethnicity, sexuality etc

Using your analogy I would add:
Laying on the operating table would you want your surgeon to be privileged Oxbridge educated white male who is the best at his job or a person that ticks all the boxes.

DropDeadFreida · 23/11/2023 09:42

DropDeadFreida · 23/11/2023 09:38

And one other point I would like to make is that certainly in the context of women's rights, it has been interesting to see just how racist and colonial the rhetoric is.

A perfect example of this comes from WHO: they published a report not that long ago that basically called for the importance of having single-sex toilets and facilities, and gave examples of countries like Nepal where according to their research, VAWG is rife and they need these spaces to be safe.

Is this not the same organisation that was pushing the TWAW agenda and championing same-sex facilities in the West?

So is it that Western men are less likely to rape and abuse women? Are Western men more evolved, kinder and egalitarian than men elsewhere? Why are these organisations recommending same-sex facilities in the West and single-sex facilities in the rest of the world?

That should say unisex rather than same-sex!

anotherside · 23/11/2023 09:41

To elaborate further on the above, I’d say a good 80%+ of right wing politicians & commentators are massive hypocrites when it comes to the cancel culture/free speech debate. When the shoes on the other foot, and a left winger speaker is investigated by police for an innocuous comment, or banned for criticising the Israeli government, or held for years without trial by the US government, or branded a traitor/terrorist stmoathiser for not cheerleading the latest war for oil , etc etc - they don’t blink an eyelid. So it’s not about a free speech at all - it’s just a power struggle. An authoritarian is an authoritarian.