Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that people who are "Anti Woke"

187 replies

AntiWoke · 23/11/2023 06:27

are the people who would like free reign to be racist, sexist, mysogenistic, homophobic. In short, people who want to be able to say whatever they like, even if offensive to some groups of people?

OP posts:
coliqua · 23/11/2023 23:56

@EasternStandard such a strange response to me. It's almost like you had ten rounds of a conversation with yourself and just wrote the end of it.

This stuff is what I am tired of.

I never said anything about women and males and consent. You've made it all up in your head and projected it on to me. Just...just know you are doing it, I guess.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 23/11/2023 17:16

Teatrayderby · 23/11/2023 06:30

No not necessarily. The woke agenda is obscuring good equality work.

Exactly this.

I am probably pretty woke, but also would be considered a card carrying TERF as I put womens rights in sport over "gender identity".

Also, shutting down people such as calling them racist leads to things like Brexit. You have to work with people, not against them.

DropDeadFreida · 23/11/2023 17:11

@GailBlancheViola I think it's because every single proposition is ideological rather than based in reality. Maybe communism as a concept is amazing? But when you add human greed, desire for power etc then that changes the reality.

Just like in ideological terms, it would be amazing if we lived in a society where single-sex spaces were not necessary, but unfortunately we do not live in that society.

And rather than focusing on the route causes of problems, it's actively choosing to ignore the massive pitfalls to keep advocating for systems and ways of living that have never been successful once human nature and patriarchy are added into the mix. And it's the most vulnerable in society that continue to pay the price. But hey, a banner is a banner and speaking in absolutes is easy when in your mind it applies to 'those people over there'.

GailBlancheViola · 23/11/2023 16:26

DropDeadFreida · 23/11/2023 16:18

@inamarina it's interesting because communism is another topic where so many people seem to be advocating for it as a political system, and yet when challenged, are not able to articulate why. And also when referred to all the communist systems that have come before and still currently exist, vehemently cry out that that's not the type of communism for which they advocate. So then what is it? And at that point it's conversation over! It's utterly baffling to me.

Always find it fascinating that those who espouse communism don't actually want to live in a Country that aligns with their ideals - for thee but not for me seems to cover it.

DropDeadFreida · 23/11/2023 16:18

@inamarina it's interesting because communism is another topic where so many people seem to be advocating for it as a political system, and yet when challenged, are not able to articulate why. And also when referred to all the communist systems that have come before and still currently exist, vehemently cry out that that's not the type of communism for which they advocate. So then what is it? And at that point it's conversation over! It's utterly baffling to me.

blacksax · 23/11/2023 15:47

It all depends what you mean by the definition of the word 'woke' though, doesn't it? Suffice to say that many people think the term 'woke' stands for ever-so-trendy bandwagon wankspeak.

Beeinalily · 23/11/2023 15:26

I've always hated the term because it sounds like bad English to me. slopes off to pedants' corner

SuspiciousSue · 23/11/2023 15:16

Bore off OP. I don’t like trans people and I’m not afraid to say it. If that offends people then so be it. Trans women are not women. It offends me that trans women think they are women and are parodying us, it works both ways 🤷‍♀️

inamarina · 23/11/2023 15:13

JaniceJanice · 23/11/2023 09:54

I’m disabled (wheelchair user and chronically ill), ND, and I’m a dyke- over all I agree with you.

People will always have views and opinions about my ‘lifestyle’, marriage, body, presence in the world, parenting ability, sex life, salvation and intellect- which I consider to be on a spectrum from bullshit- downright abhorrent.

They are allowed to hold those opinions and to express them in appropriate spaces (to their mates down the pub, on line, in their church or worship group, over dinner with their mum or whatever)- I’m allowed to think they are colossal wankers. This is how it’s always been and should be- I don’t like ablist homophobes but I don’t have to like everyone.

Where I would disagree with you is on the job front- if I pitch up at the doctor for a smear test or an sti test and she refuses to do it because ‘lesbians can’t get those things because they don’t have real sex’ (this has actually happened to me, it’s not an invented scenario), then I have no issue complaining and making a big fuss- it’s her job to do it, the fact she doesn’t believe lesbian sex is real sex is irrelevant.

The same goes for teachers at school- they can think what they want, but if they stand in front of a class and tell them they will go to hell if they are gay (another thing that has happened to me) then they don’t deserve to have that job.

Well said.
I‘m an immigrant, and I know that some people will have issues with some aspects of immigration, while others might be against it in general.
The former might well have a point worth discussing, and the latter won’t magically change their opinion just because it’s considered unacceptable in a progressive society.

firstpasttheposter · 23/11/2023 14:48

Orangeandgold · 23/11/2023 14:36

The word woke has been used in the wrong context for the past few years and it is frustrating for the true activists/leaders/change makers/ good people that are putting in good work.

I personally belong to a few “marginalised” “intersections” and often I am told I’m involved in “good” work that people would define as “woke” (it’s not woke - I just care) and get very very bored of the whole movement because it has turned into a bunch of people that are playing “saviour” and speaking on behalf of issues they often know nothing about. Or are going about the wrong way to “help”.

Also everybody has prejudice. I know we all want to be saints but we all carry prejudice and need to be open minded enough to learn and be corrected.

There's some truth to the idea that you can be unaware of problems because you are 'privileged' enough to have to deal with them personally. What's frustrating is when people say 'go and check your privilege' instead of just explaining what they need. My privilege isn't anybody else's business (I probably have problems myself that you wouldn't understand, but I'm just not going on about them!) I want to know what the problem is and how I can help. Sure, that feels a bit unfair because you're the one that's suffering and you have to make the effort to explain what the problem is, but that's the old-fashioned way of making progress. If I go and try to 'educate myself' about every possible problem people could be facing, I'll end up an awful busybody and probably get it all wrong anyway.

CaramacFiend · 23/11/2023 14:44

AntiWoke · 23/11/2023 06:27

are the people who would like free reign to be racist, sexist, mysogenistic, homophobic. In short, people who want to be able to say whatever they like, even if offensive to some groups of people?

No, they're the people that don't want to shower with strangers of the other sex or indulge children that identify as farm animals lol.

AlisonDonut · 23/11/2023 14:41

Orangeandgold · 23/11/2023 14:36

The word woke has been used in the wrong context for the past few years and it is frustrating for the true activists/leaders/change makers/ good people that are putting in good work.

I personally belong to a few “marginalised” “intersections” and often I am told I’m involved in “good” work that people would define as “woke” (it’s not woke - I just care) and get very very bored of the whole movement because it has turned into a bunch of people that are playing “saviour” and speaking on behalf of issues they often know nothing about. Or are going about the wrong way to “help”.

Also everybody has prejudice. I know we all want to be saints but we all carry prejudice and need to be open minded enough to learn and be corrected.

How does one determine who is 'true woke' and who isn't?

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 23/11/2023 14:41

Brahumbug · 23/11/2023 06:33

Inciting violence against people is, quite rightly, a crime. Being merely offensive should never be a crime. After all, a lot of opinions on Mumsnet could be considered offensive, but I wouldn't want to shut down other people's points if view.

This

i should have said in my post I draw the line at harrasment and violence. Opinions - no.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 23/11/2023 14:39

The thing is with ‘being offensive’ is it’s really very subjective. I find many things offensive but I’m not so arrogant as to think that I have the god given right never to hear another opinion but my own. In fact I’d rather hear them, then I can challenge them and be aware that this person has this view. I also have opinions that, to me seem perfectly logical - such as one cannot change sex. To some, this is a violent and proactive statement. But who wins?

I would rather have a society where we deal with a few bigoted louts than have a ‘one thought’ Orwellian society where One Opinion is only allowed per topic and no one is allowed to hold a differing opinion.

BethDuttonsTwin · 23/11/2023 14:39

“Be corrected”

Well that’s the problem isn’t it? Who does the correcting? How do we know who is On The Right Side, what is the correct belief system and therefore should be in the position of dishing out “correction” because right now these positions seem to be self appointed.

Orangeandgold · 23/11/2023 14:36

The word woke has been used in the wrong context for the past few years and it is frustrating for the true activists/leaders/change makers/ good people that are putting in good work.

I personally belong to a few “marginalised” “intersections” and often I am told I’m involved in “good” work that people would define as “woke” (it’s not woke - I just care) and get very very bored of the whole movement because it has turned into a bunch of people that are playing “saviour” and speaking on behalf of issues they often know nothing about. Or are going about the wrong way to “help”.

Also everybody has prejudice. I know we all want to be saints but we all carry prejudice and need to be open minded enough to learn and be corrected.

Pooooochi · 23/11/2023 14:21

But MN has never (well very, very rarely) given a thought to teenage boys sharing a changing room with a fully intact gay male.

Of course it has. It's not just about the risk of sexually predatory behaviour.

Its the physical imbalance, on a population level, between post pubertal men & women. Men are taller, stronger, faster. A woman is more vulnerable in the changing room situation. Which is why we are not bothered about sharing the changing room with lesbians.

Goldenbear · 23/11/2023 14:08

Firebug007 · 23/11/2023 07:34

People aren't becoming more accepting though, it's just their voice at being able to express their views honestly is being taken away 🤷‍♀️ people are becoming less tolerant IMO.

Yes, where are these people in the world that are becoming more accepting? In the west we are witnessing the erosion of our democracies look at the win in Netherlands election yesterday! I think the woke/non woke talk is pushing this fierce side taking.

Twelveisthebestnumber · 23/11/2023 14:01

LadyBird1973 · 23/11/2023 07:44

I would describe myself as predominantly socialist, if I had to put a label on at all. But I do think the price of freedom is hearing opinions that you might personally find offensive.
Obviously it's not nice to be deliberately insulting or hurt others feeling, however no one has a right to go through life not ever hearing an opinion they find offensive - certainly not at the cost of others' democratic right to express their personal views. If I have to choose, then I choose to hear things I personally dislike, in order to protect that freedom. Otherwise, what is freedom?

I'm not homophobic, racist or misogynistic but I don't really care that much if other people are - I'd rather know who I'm dealing with. And that's the beauty of free speech - it gives us all a heads up, so we can decide whether we want to keep company with those whose values are different to our own.
^
Societal change comes about through freedom of expression - hiding what people really think doesn't make opinions change, it just entrenches them as the person who isn't allowed to speak, feels oppressed. That isn't healthy or productive in improving society.

People should be free to swim against the tide, to demonstrate if they want to, to peacefully protest^.

The trouble with 'woke' is that those people aren't content to hold and sit their own viewpoint. They want to prevent anyone else from having a different opinion. No one in this country should be losing their job because of their personal or political beliefs. The whole trans debate is a clear demonstration of where woke has gone wrong.

This. I would have struggled to write down how I feel so eloquently but Ladybird1973 has done so instead.

inamarina · 23/11/2023 13:50

DropDeadFreida · 23/11/2023 09:31

I think the example by @DorsetandBeyond is really important. We need nuance above all else when teaching and discussing these issues. This ridiculous tribalism is so damaging, and the world is not black and white.

On a personal level, attempting to discuss this issue with some people of my acquaintance has been so upsetting for me in the past, because on the few occasions I tried to relate my own experiences I was shut down because my viewpoint of tolerance and debate did not fit their mould of what a person like me 'should' be saying.

My family came to this country to escape actual fascism. Not this contemporary form of 'I don't like what you say so you're a fascist' but actual attempts at genocide, gassing people, raping women and burning down homes kind of fascism. So hearing white, English, middle class people who have never even travelled beyond Western Europe and the US try and explain oppression to me and tell me I am wrong has been nothing short of galling.

It's one of the reasons I started coming on to Mumsnet in the first place-it's one of the only places (outside of my close friendship group) where these topics can be discussed freely.

These people are not interested in truth, justice and equality, they are looking for a tribe, and the performative nature of social media is the perfect breeding ground for this.

I say this as someone who would always vote Labour, even canvassed for Labour, was a member of a union and very political. I am not anymore. Speak to anyone who grew up in a home country like mine and you will soon realise that we have seen this type of discourse many times: people pitting themselves against each other, suppressing debate, threatening abuse and violence towards dissenters, forcing marginalised groups to go underground. What does that sound like? It doesn't end well.

Thank you for sharing your personal experience!

My family came to this country to escape actual fascism. Not this contemporary form of 'I don't like what you say so you're a fascist' but actual attempts at genocide, gassing people, raping women and burning down homes kind of fascism.

I can relate to that, even though luckily my family didn’t have to escape full-blown fascism. They came from a communist country though, so I am (as well as my family) somewhat allergic to groupthink and (attempted) indoctrination.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 23/11/2023 13:48

CheatingCheetos · 23/11/2023 06:37

Not necessarily, no.

“Woke” has lost all meaning anyway, it’s thrown around now at anyone and everything.

A month or so back I saw a newspaper describe HS2 as “woke”.

Edited

It has replaced "political correctness gone mad" as the stock phrase trotted out by racists, xenophobes, regressive neanderthals, and every other form of bigot whenever they encounter something they don't like.

I automatically disregard anyone who uses "woke" as an insult or to imply a negative, because it's clear they have no comprehension of what the term actually means, and they are invariably the biggest "snowflakes" going themselves despite all the wailing and moaning they'll do about "lefties", "do-gooders" and so on.

GailBlancheViola · 23/11/2023 13:47

But MN has never (well very, very rarely) given a thought to teenage boys sharing a changing room with a fully intact gay male.

What exactly are you trying to say here @Sayitaintso33 ?

havingabadhairday · 23/11/2023 13:43

My main experience of wokeness in real life was being lectured on how you should never make assumptions about people by someone who assumed they were talking to a room of middle-class, heterosexual, 'cis' women.

And this is one of the problems - the loudest self-proclaimed Woke people seem to be hellbent on actively damaging the whole concept.

Helleofabore · 23/11/2023 12:53

You could well be right MsRosley.

i wonder if we will find out what the ‘extreme’ view is and what the compromises are.

They could well be referring to genuine transphobic people, of which there are some. They are motivated by hatred and not by pushing back on conflicts impacting on the sexed based rights of girls and women. And they may be also referring to reasonable compromises that can be made, most likely already suggested, and that are workable and do respect and protect women and girls too. Hence asking the questions.

WhatYouWearing · 23/11/2023 12:49

@AntiWoke your contribution to this thread has been woefully lacking. You really need to define your meaning.

I'm anti-woke because it no longer has the same meaning to me now than previously (and I'm a tofu munching vegan!)

Swipe left for the next trending thread