Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that people who are "Anti Woke"

187 replies

AntiWoke · 23/11/2023 06:27

are the people who would like free reign to be racist, sexist, mysogenistic, homophobic. In short, people who want to be able to say whatever they like, even if offensive to some groups of people?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Frustratedfatty · 24/11/2023 17:33

I have been reading more about the lgbtqia+ acronym on the back of this thread because some of the terms confuse me.
I read that ‘2 spirit ‘ is included in this acronym and was intrigued to read about the 2 spirit group of people that existed in some 1st nation peoples. However I also read a warning that a non 1st nation person using the 2 spirit identity is culturally appropriating an identity.
And that is where I decided to stop reading …..
I agree that some of this stuff is detracting from the important work that needs to be done to ensure that each child in our society has equal access to opportunity and doesn’t face barriers in their education and career and in the justice system.
And some of it is just bollox imported from the USA.

CoffeeCantata · 24/11/2023 16:36

DropDeadFreida
but if you saw her social media you would think she was the original freedom fighter or something. Sending her 'solidarity' to all and sundry from her very comfortable life of not actually doing anything worthwhile to support people.

And isn't that the very definition of 'virtue signalling'? I'm guessing that people who think of themselves as woke disapprove of that term, but to me it expresses exactly what you've described: loud public declarations of 'the right view' with absolutely no cost to oneself. I've seen it so often! People who don't actually do anything to help, or make any sacrifices, but think they're superior because they spout the accepted narrative on any particular matter.

I object to the the term 'woke' because it sort of hijacks all kinds of reasonable attitudes (anti-racism, criticism of colonialism, concern about equality etc) as if only the recently-woke espouse these views, when in fact all fair-minded people do - but they don't go shouting about it.

An example was the National Trust putting pressure on their volunteers to wear rainbow lanyards. The irony is that I might agree with nearly everything a woke person might think - but I absolutely would not wear a badge, lanyard or slogan declaring it. It's so insulting - implying that unless you are making a public declaration of your liberal views,, you must be a bigot.

(Great posts, DropDead.)

firstpasttheposter · 24/11/2023 09:41

DropDeadFreida · 24/11/2023 09:02

@firstpasttheposter but if you saw her social media you would think she was the original freedom fighter or something. Sending her 'solidarity' to all and sundry from her very comfortable life of not actually doing anything worthwhile to support people.

When we were still sort of friends, there was a coup in my home country after a long period of attempts at ethnic cleansing, and you can imagine the panic and worry of that sort of event. It was all over the news, she knew where I was from and not once did she check in with me to see if I was okay, my family were safe etc. And yet I was still expected to be an active audience member to her monologues on equality, racism etc - you genuinely cannot make it up!

Sounds like she did you a favour when she dropped you as a friend!

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 24/11/2023 09:26

CoffeeCantata · 24/11/2023 07:54

Pooooochi
I also dislike when some US racial issues are assumed to be the same in the UK, when our demographics & culture are very, very different, our police don't routinely carry guns, black people are a much smaller proportion of the population, we don't have the same history of segregation in schools for eg, and people from the Indian subcontinent are a much more significant minority here, which brings a different set of issues with religion among other things.

This is how I feel. I'm not taking on responsibility for the US's awful racist history, thank you. To suggest that race issues in the UK are akin to the shocking attitudes in say, the southern states of the US is ridiculous. I've never been a racist and I'm not accepting the woke narrative that somehow I must be!

I have 2 main objections to the term'woke'. One is that no-one bothers to define it - they just weaponise it. And secondly, it's an American term which came out of an American situation.

Well said on both posts.

I lived in the US. There are deeply concerning levels of institutional racism.

Whilst in the UK we are not perfect Its not the same here and I hate this pressure to adopt the same stance. It’s just indicative of how the US expect everyone to be US-centric

I remember when George Floyd died, in my local city centre there was a protest of a load of people lying on the floor repeating “I can’t breathe”. Annoying bastards getting in the way of everyone - I felt like saying what are you doing, or protesting, and to who?

MsRosley · 24/11/2023 09:19

Littlepinkstarsbyradish · 24/11/2023 03:55

For someone who says they’ve done lots of learning about the term “woke” I think you’ve skipped over/negated a big part of it
being “woke” was all about opening eyes to the systemic and institutional barriers to black people.
As it found a wider audience/usage it became used for wider purposes (before being weaponised by certain parts of the media)

but in my mind “anti-woke” means denying structural inequality. Which is just incomprehensible to me….
you can measure structural inequality!
CVs with Indian or African names are less likely to be called to interview (shown in multiple studies across multiple countries)
women are judged to be dominating a discussion if they speak for more than 25% of the time, but men speaking the same amount are not judged to dominate, etc

if you’re anti-woke (imo) you’re genuinely either resistant to learning new information, or you’re an arse

I'm well aware of the origins of word, but unlike you I do not accept that critical race theory is coherent. Yes, you can measure structural inequality, but jumping to 'obvious' conclusions that it is caused by structural racism is what has done so much damage. For instance, certain ethnic groups actually do better that Caucasians in countries like the US and UK - Indians and Chinese are among the highest earners. So it is clear that the explanation for poorer outcomes say in black populations is not necessarily that the UK and US are full of racist bigots. If you break down the Black populations, you see huge differences in performance by country of origin, with Nigerians often being much more successful than West Indians. What is so often ignored in CRT and woke ideology is that culture within a population is clearly a huge factor in career success and income.

There are very many other things wrong with woke ideology (and I'm not even going to get into queer theory, because that is a raging hell pit of stupidity and perversity). One of the most egregious is how woke thinking actually killed many black and asian people in the pandemic. When it became obvious that a hugely disproportionate number of black and asian doctors and nurses were dying of Covid, media and institutions immediately jumped to the conclusions that it was due to structural inequality. Which was patently ridiculous as many of those doctors were on high incomes and could easily afford a healthy lifestyle. While everyone was happily assuming that this was proof what an awful racist country we have in the UK, they were blithely ignoring the real explanation: that having dark skin minimised production of vitamin D in northern climates, and having low vitamin D status made you much more vulnerable to severe and even fatal Covid infection. So, well done those well meaning woke idiots. They obscured the biological reasons for ethnic vulnerability with virtue signalling nonsense, and people died as a result.

Interesting you bring up women and discussions. I agree with you on this one, men are allowed to dominate in discussions. But how do you think statistics like the one you quoted change if those men identify as women? Would they immediately start talking less, do you think?

If you're tribally woke (imo), you’re genuinely either resistant to learning new information, or you’re an arse.

DropDeadFreida · 24/11/2023 09:02

@firstpasttheposter but if you saw her social media you would think she was the original freedom fighter or something. Sending her 'solidarity' to all and sundry from her very comfortable life of not actually doing anything worthwhile to support people.

When we were still sort of friends, there was a coup in my home country after a long period of attempts at ethnic cleansing, and you can imagine the panic and worry of that sort of event. It was all over the news, she knew where I was from and not once did she check in with me to see if I was okay, my family were safe etc. And yet I was still expected to be an active audience member to her monologues on equality, racism etc - you genuinely cannot make it up!

DropDeadFreida · 24/11/2023 08:55

@BillionaireTea thank you but no apologies necessary. I don't think you sound colonial, just the fact that you're engaging with this topic shows that you're willing to hear other people's perspectives. And I think that's half the current battle unfortunately, somewhere along the line people just stopped listening to each other.

BillionaireTea · 24/11/2023 08:48

@DropDeadFreida I apologise if I'm sounding colonial or like it's a game. I can understand your perspective and I've been trying to do reading so that I'm not asking people who are living things I have not lived to educate me. The task force and the other examples you gave are fucking awful.

CoffeeCantata · 24/11/2023 07:54

Pooooochi
I also dislike when some US racial issues are assumed to be the same in the UK, when our demographics & culture are very, very different, our police don't routinely carry guns, black people are a much smaller proportion of the population, we don't have the same history of segregation in schools for eg, and people from the Indian subcontinent are a much more significant minority here, which brings a different set of issues with religion among other things.

This is how I feel. I'm not taking on responsibility for the US's awful racist history, thank you. To suggest that race issues in the UK are akin to the shocking attitudes in say, the southern states of the US is ridiculous. I've never been a racist and I'm not accepting the woke narrative that somehow I must be!

I have 2 main objections to the term'woke'. One is that no-one bothers to define it - they just weaponise it. And secondly, it's an American term which came out of an American situation.

firstpasttheposter · 24/11/2023 07:48

DropDeadFreida · 24/11/2023 07:09

@BillionaireTea @Littlepinkstarsbyradish in theory yes, what you both describe was the original intended focus - dismantling inequality - but as with most movements, it has now been taken over and colonised by the most privileged in society to bear down on everybody else. It is another tool used by the most privileged to make those less privileged less safe, and has made a mockery of the genuine good work that was being done in the context of equality.

The only people who have ever made me feel uncomfortable discussing issues around inequality have been white, middle class, English people for precisely this reason. Precisely because of their privilege. They can play at the equality game and have these ideological discussions without really having a dog in the race, and can then go home and not worry about it. While people like me have to not only constantly deal with racism, homophobia etc. but are now made to have to sit there and listen to them talk about it like it's a game. And back in the day you at least then didn't have the added salt in the wound of these sorts of people talking over you and at you and spewing their nonsense about a topic that has far more nuance than they could ever perceive.

It's like being colonised.

And my options are to not say anything, to say something and be accused of being phobic, or pour my own heart out and share my own very painful experiences in order to try and get them to listen. Do you know what the emotional toll of that is? I once had one particular woman who was this type to a tee attempt to try and compare what was worse: sexual trauma in wartime or physical torture in wartime. Nobody she had known had ever been through either. And she was speaking about this in such a cavalier fashion because again, you can do when it's not about you. Not realising that members of my family have been tortured and have those physical and mental scars. These topics are like games to a lot of these 'warriors' and it causes so much pain for others. And that particular woman eventually stopped speaking to me because when I started debating her she decided I was phobic! I guess I'm the uneducated native and should just trust that she knows best.

Why would anybody even start a discussion about whether two absolutely abhorrent things are worse than the other! How does somebody's mind even get there?

CoffeeCantata · 24/11/2023 07:48

StockpotSoup · Yesterday 08:57

Anyone who describes themselves as “anti-woke” is someone I’d walk into traffic to avoid.

I would do the same with anyone who was daft, naive, self-righteious and simple-minded enough to describe themselves as 'woke'.

Definition, please. If it means being liberal, humane and respecting others - fine. But we don't need a new word for that. I suspect it means much more unpleasant things and the woke people I've met have been the most intolerant, judgmental, narrow-minded and bigoted types - a definite backwards step in our culture.

DropDeadFreida · 24/11/2023 07:18

LlynTegid · 24/11/2023 07:12

The kind of people the OP refers to should be called racist if they are, homophobic if they are, or perhaps bigoted as a general term.

This. Racism and homophobia are illegal, and they should absolutely be treated in accordance with the law.

LickleLamb · 24/11/2023 07:18

This is the OP's first thread - her only comment on MN is on this thread, one about her spelling of rein.
Wind up?

DropDeadFreida · 24/11/2023 07:18

Oh and I've just remembered: with the task force that was set up at my work to champion women in the workplace, our head of department (a woman) eventually made a man its chair. Now that in itself may not be an issue for some, but what was utterly insulting is that this man already had a handful of complaints from more junior women in the department about his misogynistic behaviour and instances of sexual harassment. Which the head knew about!

He was eventually let go, after nearly 20 official complaints against him. Guess which complaint led to his dismissal? The one made by another man who witnessed his behaviour on one occasion.

I quit the task force as did a lot of others. But I'm sure the HoD included the work of the task force in her CV as an example of her fight for equality!

LlynTegid · 24/11/2023 07:12

The kind of people the OP refers to should be called racist if they are, homophobic if they are, or perhaps bigoted as a general term.

DropDeadFreida · 24/11/2023 07:09

@BillionaireTea @Littlepinkstarsbyradish in theory yes, what you both describe was the original intended focus - dismantling inequality - but as with most movements, it has now been taken over and colonised by the most privileged in society to bear down on everybody else. It is another tool used by the most privileged to make those less privileged less safe, and has made a mockery of the genuine good work that was being done in the context of equality.

The only people who have ever made me feel uncomfortable discussing issues around inequality have been white, middle class, English people for precisely this reason. Precisely because of their privilege. They can play at the equality game and have these ideological discussions without really having a dog in the race, and can then go home and not worry about it. While people like me have to not only constantly deal with racism, homophobia etc. but are now made to have to sit there and listen to them talk about it like it's a game. And back in the day you at least then didn't have the added salt in the wound of these sorts of people talking over you and at you and spewing their nonsense about a topic that has far more nuance than they could ever perceive.

It's like being colonised.

And my options are to not say anything, to say something and be accused of being phobic, or pour my own heart out and share my own very painful experiences in order to try and get them to listen. Do you know what the emotional toll of that is? I once had one particular woman who was this type to a tee attempt to try and compare what was worse: sexual trauma in wartime or physical torture in wartime. Nobody she had known had ever been through either. And she was speaking about this in such a cavalier fashion because again, you can do when it's not about you. Not realising that members of my family have been tortured and have those physical and mental scars. These topics are like games to a lot of these 'warriors' and it causes so much pain for others. And that particular woman eventually stopped speaking to me because when I started debating her she decided I was phobic! I guess I'm the uneducated native and should just trust that she knows best.

BillionaireTea · 24/11/2023 07:03

Bless you @JeeezeLouise no I run a large organisation at the absolute intersection of all these debates.

So many of us on this thread (including me!) are coming across to one another as partial and naive - both around woke, anti-woke and 'anti-anti-woke'. I think it's because we have all taken different facets of it as our start point. Early in the thread people asked for definitions - like so much cultural stuff the definition is where it's contested.
I took the angle about the idea of privilege. Others have rightly said that that idea is quite divisive and hasn't landed well in culture generally.
@Littlepinkstarsbyradish said that for her, structural inequality is what woke signifies, so for her it's a helpful concept, and that's probably a more useful way of thinking than me banging on about privilege. But others have said that the institutional capture of radical ideas has made woke "not work" for us any more, so it's not something they use any more to highlight those structural things.

Still more folks obviously feel that "woke" is a dog whistle for the extremist MRA space, so you can't "be woke" now without giving up your gender critical philosophy- which is unacceptable to many of us.

And some people are purely rolling their eyes at the idea you have to be virtue signalling and trendy.

Other people are worried that woke means you can't have free speech.

All I'd say is that all the big powers in society - those who want to keep their power and not let us have any - tech, oil, military industrial complex more broadly, patriarchy, the party political system - they all win when we fight with each other about terms. When we are divided.

JeeezeLouise · 24/11/2023 06:31

BillionaireTea · 23/11/2023 06:42

Yes, I'd say that's the size of it.

Oversll, they are people with a limited capacity (or education) to reflect on their own privilege - like fish who don't understand what water is.

They are people who think that the high level of comfort they feel in society, just feeling OK saying whatever is in their heads, is normal. They don't notice that it is a privilege. So they feel that suddenly being asked to guard their tongues, or shift their way of being, is a new thing - an insult to their freedom and ability to operate in the world. And it does feel like that, so I sympathise with those people's sensations.

However they don't understand that other people (who are different from them) already were living in an unwelcoming world where they couldn't speak freely/have been judged/are constantly harmed by culture and its assumptions.

What "woke" does is redresses the balance.

So, some people feel a but more awks in the world for a while...in order that others, who have been, historically, systemically under-valued and felt less comfortable, can feel... a bit more welcome. A bit more normal. A bit more ok for being themselves.

This is misunderstood though and when you say "look at your own privilege" anti-woke people indignantly think "But I don't have privilege! I'm not rich! I work hard! I don't get something for nothing!". This isn't what privilege is. Privilege is the ability to feel normal in the world without having to constantly think about what you're doing.

So the anti woke person says "People are such snowflakes they can't handle a joke about identity!" and marvel at the weakness and over sensitivity of others. They are not considering - literally not "awake to" all the work already being done by the person with the "less normal identity" just to get through the day. So the joke is the last straw, not a tiny nothing.

Are you at university?

Littlepinkstarsbyradish · 24/11/2023 03:55

MsRosley · 24/11/2023 00:15

It's pretty ironic that your username was written by Graham Linehan, who has definitely had enough of woke. Incidentally, he is not racist, or xenophobic or a regressive neanderthal, nor a bigot. Neither am I, and I'm a 'leftie', as is Graham.

Contrary to what you imagine, I have spent a lot of time learning exactly what woke actually means, how it originated from critical theory, its long march through the institutions and how it has now metastasised into a quasi religion. I have spent hours listening to people like James Lindsay explain it in minute and fascinating detail. Have you?

Feeling superior is not the same as being superior. You'd do well to reflect on that.

For someone who says they’ve done lots of learning about the term “woke” I think you’ve skipped over/negated a big part of it
being “woke” was all about opening eyes to the systemic and institutional barriers to black people.
As it found a wider audience/usage it became used for wider purposes (before being weaponised by certain parts of the media)

but in my mind “anti-woke” means denying structural inequality. Which is just incomprehensible to me….
you can measure structural inequality!
CVs with Indian or African names are less likely to be called to interview (shown in multiple studies across multiple countries)
women are judged to be dominating a discussion if they speak for more than 25% of the time, but men speaking the same amount are not judged to dominate, etc

if you’re anti-woke (imo) you’re genuinely either resistant to learning new information, or you’re an arse

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 24/11/2023 01:03

It’s free rein, but yes.

SurvivorsInc · 24/11/2023 01:02

I think it depends. You can be woke about some things but not others.

Isittimeformynapyet · 24/11/2023 00:59

SurprisedWithAHorse · 23/11/2023 08:50

Most of society are somewhere in the middle thinking both are extremists

What is extremist about saying that women don't have penises and you can't change your sex?

And how many GC women have you seen issuing death threats and sharing porn on threads about children's costumes and artwork?

Nothing.

I think @DogInATent is saying the same as you - that there are many of us being classed as extremists when we're not.

Having said that, this is the most complicated thread I've ever seen on here. A lot of the posts appear to be saying one thing, and then suddenly seeming to contradict themselves.

This is a fucking minefield!

Soggycocopops · 24/11/2023 00:50

BillionaireTea · 23/11/2023 06:42

Yes, I'd say that's the size of it.

Oversll, they are people with a limited capacity (or education) to reflect on their own privilege - like fish who don't understand what water is.

They are people who think that the high level of comfort they feel in society, just feeling OK saying whatever is in their heads, is normal. They don't notice that it is a privilege. So they feel that suddenly being asked to guard their tongues, or shift their way of being, is a new thing - an insult to their freedom and ability to operate in the world. And it does feel like that, so I sympathise with those people's sensations.

However they don't understand that other people (who are different from them) already were living in an unwelcoming world where they couldn't speak freely/have been judged/are constantly harmed by culture and its assumptions.

What "woke" does is redresses the balance.

So, some people feel a but more awks in the world for a while...in order that others, who have been, historically, systemically under-valued and felt less comfortable, can feel... a bit more welcome. A bit more normal. A bit more ok for being themselves.

This is misunderstood though and when you say "look at your own privilege" anti-woke people indignantly think "But I don't have privilege! I'm not rich! I work hard! I don't get something for nothing!". This isn't what privilege is. Privilege is the ability to feel normal in the world without having to constantly think about what you're doing.

So the anti woke person says "People are such snowflakes they can't handle a joke about identity!" and marvel at the weakness and over sensitivity of others. They are not considering - literally not "awake to" all the work already being done by the person with the "less normal identity" just to get through the day. So the joke is the last straw, not a tiny nothing.

So true.👍

MsRosley · 24/11/2023 00:15

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 23/11/2023 13:48

It has replaced "political correctness gone mad" as the stock phrase trotted out by racists, xenophobes, regressive neanderthals, and every other form of bigot whenever they encounter something they don't like.

I automatically disregard anyone who uses "woke" as an insult or to imply a negative, because it's clear they have no comprehension of what the term actually means, and they are invariably the biggest "snowflakes" going themselves despite all the wailing and moaning they'll do about "lefties", "do-gooders" and so on.

It's pretty ironic that your username was written by Graham Linehan, who has definitely had enough of woke. Incidentally, he is not racist, or xenophobic or a regressive neanderthal, nor a bigot. Neither am I, and I'm a 'leftie', as is Graham.

Contrary to what you imagine, I have spent a lot of time learning exactly what woke actually means, how it originated from critical theory, its long march through the institutions and how it has now metastasised into a quasi religion. I have spent hours listening to people like James Lindsay explain it in minute and fascinating detail. Have you?

Feeling superior is not the same as being superior. You'd do well to reflect on that.

XenoBitch · 24/11/2023 00:02

Being offended should not be a crime. Hurt feelings should not be a crime.
Yet the "woke" folks think that having your hurty feelings hurt should mean the offender should be hung, drawn and quartered.

Swipe left for the next trending thread