Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it unreasonable for a partners family to have no relationship with DC from previous relationship

166 replies

spok111 · 22/11/2023 16:13

Would you be okay with your partners or spouses family having no relationship with your children from a previous relationship outside of being polite / friendly when happen to be face to face.

I.e. not getting a birthday card for them, only asking if they had a good one when they see them next which could be weeks after, being fantastic and really involved with joint DC but having no real relationship at all with stepchildren, arranging days out with joint DC but never suggesting SC go etc..

Basically would you accept in your relationship or marriage, your partners family having nothing to do with your children from a previous relationship outside of being polite when face to face.

OP posts:
Jayne35 · 23/11/2023 09:28

I do buy cards and small gifts for my step grandchildren for birthdays and Christmas, they also are invited for meals and parties at home, but I don’t always include them in days out, they already have multiple grandparents including great grandparents plus spend every other weekend at their Dads so I mostly try to arrange things then. It might sound awful but I can’t afford activities for 5, occasionally we will all do a zoo trip or something but not often.

Dweetfidilove · 23/11/2023 09:28

I wouldn’t want to be in a relationship like this.

I have been a stepchild for 30 years, and if I don’t tell you, you wouldn’t know.

To my stepdad I have always been his daughter and he’s always been my dad. His family accepted and treated us like his children and my mom’s family fully embraced him and his children.

I’ve been single for some time and I’ve really never been tempted to blend, because I would have nothing less for my child. My sister always said my stepdad set such a high standard, it would make it difficult for her to settle for anything less.

Sartre · 23/11/2023 09:26

I wouldn’t accept this because I have personal experience with it and it was absolutely awful.

My parents split when I was a baby and mum met someone a couple of years later, then had my brother when I was 6. My brother’s Dad became abusive shortly after he was born towards me, made it clear he detested me and would beat and emotionally abuse me. Fun times.

Worst part was, his family just never accepted me. For Christmas they would wrap up something from around the house like an old diary or cheap bit of jewellery, no thought put in whatsoever and they were not poor. My brother would get some super expensive present. Obviously I noticed this as I grew older and it was hurtful because the only thing I had done wrong was exist. They’d go on holiday without me too when I was a teenager leaving me home alone. You don’t forget that sort of thing.

So long rant over, if I split with DH and met someone else I wouldn’t put up with their family being twats towards my DC.

Dweetfidilove · 23/11/2023 09:22

caringcarer · 22/11/2023 20:24

I was very lucky because both my exh and my parents were dead but my now DH took my DC on as his own and his parents did too. They bought my DC birthday and Xmas gifts and Easter eggs and because they lived by the seaside they invited my DC up to stay with them for a week each year. FiL would take a week off and they'd take my DC to the beach or out on a boat ride or petting zoo every day. Also MiL cooked all their favourite foods. She's a great cook. DH and I got a week's holiday alone somewhere romantic. My kids are grown up now and FiL has died but my DC independently go up to see MiL 150 miles away 3 or 4 times a year each and always take her a bunch of flowers. Mil lives alone and loves their company. They take her out for a cream tea or sometimes just go to the beach for an ice cream. They have ne er forgotten her kindness to them and they all call her Gran too.

This is so wholesome and how it should be (ideally) 😊

BIossomtoes · 23/11/2023 09:17

MrTiddlesTheCat · 23/11/2023 07:21

My inlaws have always treated my DD as their granddaughter even after DS came along. I find it very strange that people think it's ok to treat a child in their family like they're a stranger who's wandered in by mistake.

I agree. My parents treated my stepchildren as their grandchildren. Both my stepsons were pallbearers for my parents, that speaks volumes about how close the bond was.

Jasmine222 · 23/11/2023 09:11

I'd also lose respect for my parents if they only doted on their "real" grand child and made no effort with their step grand children.

Jasmine222 · 23/11/2023 09:09

I would personally find it very sad. I have a step-Gran and she's the only Gran I ever knew. I have step-nieces and treat them the exact same way as my real nieces. I'm 100% team "Your Dh" here.

WhatNoRaisins · 23/11/2023 08:08

There's too many variables. A lot of families live far apart and don't see each other that often. I didn't feel close to my own extended family that I rarely saw so I certainly wouldn't expect much of a bond between unrelated in laws and children in this situation.

The flip side of this is the fact that if there was a split then you'd never see your step relatives again. I can see why some might not want to get too attached.

GreyhpundGirl · 23/11/2023 07:52

I don't think it's unreasonable if they are being polite when they see them but there a lot of variables. E.g do they live locally/ you see them.ofren?.How old were they when you got with your partner? My husband's wife had two teens when they got together (no children together).My dad doesn't know when their birthdays and might see them.once a year if he visits my brother or there's a family gathering( we all.live in very different parts of the country) They already have their own extended family🤷‍♂️

Bandolina · 23/11/2023 07:38

I think it's relevant here that step DC live primarily with their mum and have a relationship with her parents. They don't spend a lot of time with OP let alone her parents. They have maternal grandparents involved in their lives already who could choose to take time to Disney and not invite OP's child.

If it was a scenario where the step DC are mainly resident with OP and their dad then all the children should ideally be treated the same by everyone especially if they are young. I don't think that is the case here

It is irrelevant to the argument DH's parents are not here as neither set of children therefore have paternal grandparents but both have maternal grandparents. He is asking for the step DC to have more sets of involved grandparents than OP's DD will have.

10HailMarys · 23/11/2023 07:35

It really depends.

My brother’s ex-wife already two small children when they met and we all just accepted them as our family from the start really. They lived with him and his ex full time and didn’t have much of a relationship with their biological dad. My brother and his ex had more children together too. We continued to see them along with my brother’s biological kids when my brother and his wife separated and it would never occur to me not to call them my niece and nephew. My parents consider them grandchildren.

My sister’s partner also had two kids when she met him. They were in their teens at the time and there was a shared custody arrangement I believe but I have literally never even met them! My parents have met them a couple of times. My sister has a great relationship with them but when my sister met her partner, they were all living 400 miles away and we rarely saw them, and when we did it was always on weekends when the kids weren’t there so that we could stay overnight. When they became adults my sister and her partner moved again and now only see the kids (now late 20s) two or three times a year themselves. My sister and her partner don’t have any kids together.

MrTiddlesTheCat · 23/11/2023 07:21

My inlaws have always treated my DD as their granddaughter even after DS came along. I find it very strange that people think it's ok to treat a child in their family like they're a stranger who's wandered in by mistake.

Loubelle70 · 23/11/2023 07:16

The problem could arise that when everyone gets together that your children will feel left out if other biological kids have presents etc and yours dont. If that was a case, i would stop taking my children and just be pleasant back, that's it.

Velvian · 23/11/2023 07:12

I think you have to bear in mind how the power dynamics shift. My ILs were as you describe with my DS1. Obviously, as DC 2 and 3 have grown, their allegiance is more towards their brother, it makes it quite uncomfortable when ILs come over as they are not integrated into our whole family and it leads to questions from the DC.

I think for future relations and a time when the older generation will need more consideration from the younger generations, they should treat the SC as children of the family.

WhatK8DidNext · 23/11/2023 06:57

I think it’s sad.

Brother has two stepsons and I treat them the same as my biological neice - my children consider them cousins and my parents consider them grandchildren!

Love and attention doesn’t have to be rationed and it’s up to the adults to build that relationship - what reasons could possibly be valid to exclude children? The kids didn’t choose this situation.

Precipice · 22/11/2023 23:27

I mean your partner decided to accept a new child into their life, their family did not

Why not apply that also to biological or adopted children? After all, the partner chose to have a child or to adopt a child, while their family did not choose this. Would it then be reasonable for grandparents to ignore the grandchild, because they didn't decide to accept the child's appearance in their family?

WillowCraft · 22/11/2023 23:22

I suppose if your parents rarely see them then maybe they aren't aware of it as such although that will change as the 3 year old talks more. I do think it's a bit of a shame. It's going to drive a wedge between your child and their half siblings which can only be detrimental as they get older. When they are all adults the grandparents will be irrelevant but their half siblings will hopefully be their lifelong support.
It sounds like you don't really care about your stepchildren and would rather they didn't intrude on "your" family. I would take a long term view on this and think about what is best for your own child, putting aside your own awkwardness about these children. If you take the lead, maybe your parents will make more of an effort

LlynTegid · 22/11/2023 20:27

I'd wonder why and it would be a concern to me, if they were as with the OP, children.

Though what is described is nowhere near as bad as those dads who refuse to have any involvement and deny being the father.

caringcarer · 22/11/2023 20:24

I was very lucky because both my exh and my parents were dead but my now DH took my DC on as his own and his parents did too. They bought my DC birthday and Xmas gifts and Easter eggs and because they lived by the seaside they invited my DC up to stay with them for a week each year. FiL would take a week off and they'd take my DC to the beach or out on a boat ride or petting zoo every day. Also MiL cooked all their favourite foods. She's a great cook. DH and I got a week's holiday alone somewhere romantic. My kids are grown up now and FiL has died but my DC independently go up to see MiL 150 miles away 3 or 4 times a year each and always take her a bunch of flowers. Mil lives alone and loves their company. They take her out for a cream tea or sometimes just go to the beach for an ice cream. They have ne er forgotten her kindness to them and they all call her Gran too.

spok111 · 22/11/2023 20:05

Can I ask genuinely what is sad about it? DSC have never, to my knowledge, been bothered by the lack of relationship with my family or about not being taken on holidays by them. They are just other people that they don't really know that well.

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 22/11/2023 19:18

spok111 · 22/11/2023 18:09

If they were taking one to Disney land and not the other I wouldn't be happy

It's funny you should say that as my parents are doing exactly this with our DC and filters DC next year. SC aren't going as they have no relationship really with my parents so would never occur to anyone that they'd go too.

I can see why they wouldn't pay for non relatives but I think it's sad

Menora · 22/11/2023 19:12

I’ve seen this scenario on here before

I think it’s fine unless your DH goes, as then that would be quite shitty of him not to take them

as he isn’t going I think it’s fine. You can do things with your family that don’t include the SC. My family do include my SC in gifts at Xmas but maybe not a holiday that DP wasn’t even coming on

saraclara · 22/11/2023 19:09

I think there's a huge difference between a child who lives with their parent and step parent, and a child who only spends every other weekend with them.

I wouldn't expect the family of the step parent in the latter case to have much involvement at all.
In the first case they're likely to see them more regularly in the general scheme of things, so I'd hope that there'd be more of a connection.

HenriettaVienetta · 22/11/2023 18:50

Personally, I don't think it unreasonable that kids that have no direct relationship to them aren't going, especially if they are paying.

They have grandparents. They don't need any more, or an 'equal' standing with their wider stepfamily. Does their mum have a new partner? Are they involved there? It isn't possible to have that number of relatives and actually have a genuine close relationship with all of them.

CremeEggSupremacy · 22/11/2023 18:48

I think if it was the case that person A is in a relationship with person B and person B has kids but there's no joint kids between person A and B, it wouldn't be unreasonable for person A's parents to not be that bothered with them. But when person A and B have their own kids as well as person B's kids...idk, I do think it's nice if person A's parents then make a bit more effort IMO