Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it unreasonable for a partners family to have no relationship with DC from previous relationship

166 replies

spok111 · 22/11/2023 16:13

Would you be okay with your partners or spouses family having no relationship with your children from a previous relationship outside of being polite / friendly when happen to be face to face.

I.e. not getting a birthday card for them, only asking if they had a good one when they see them next which could be weeks after, being fantastic and really involved with joint DC but having no real relationship at all with stepchildren, arranging days out with joint DC but never suggesting SC go etc..

Basically would you accept in your relationship or marriage, your partners family having nothing to do with your children from a previous relationship outside of being polite when face to face.

OP posts:
Jasmine222 · 23/11/2023 10:35

I think ultimately as you can see from the responses on this thread, you're not in the wrong but your DH definitely isn't either and it must be pretty sad for him seeing as he doesn't have his own parents. I don't get why he and the two kids aren't coming to Disneyland too? It's not hard to make more effort when something is hurting your spouse.

betterangels · 23/11/2023 10:34

Yes. Because I would have chosen to involve myself with a man who had children. My parents didn't make that decision and so I wouldn't force them to have emotional attachment to children that were in no way anything to do with them.

I'd feel this way. They're polite when they meet.

spok111 · 23/11/2023 10:31

BTW we do have the kids on Christmas every other year, we just don't spend it with wider family. We just spend it together at home. If we did spend it with wider family I'm sure they'd get DSC something.

Its the same with birthdays, I'm sure if my family saw DSC on or close to their birthday they'd get then something but as they rarely see them then they don't.

OP posts:
ElevenSeven · 23/11/2023 10:30

Nope, kind and polite when face to face is fine.

Some people don’t want to acknowledge that they have an ended up in a blended setup, and want everyone else to bend over backwards to make it look as if it isn’t so.

spok111 · 23/11/2023 10:29

Pinkpinkpink15 · 23/11/2023 10:12

@spok111

i think it's sad in your situation because they don't have their Dad's parents & family, only family on their mums side. If your family had chosen to step up your DH would feel he/they had family on his side too.

But you can't make people feel what they don't.

The kids might not be bothered by it, but that doesn't mean their lives wouldn't have been richer for having more involvement from your family.

By the same token our DC has no paternal grandparents either though. All children involved only have maternal grandparents.

I genuinely have never gotten the impression for DSC that they are bothered or upset. They are of course a lot older than our joint DC so it's easier for the things they get or do to not be such an issue, obviously DSC aren't bothered by a plastic toy that DC may receive for example or a trip to soft play with grandparents.

Appreciate bigger things like disney may be different and can be enjoyed by all but I certainly wouldn't expect my family to pay for DSC that they barely see or know.

We are going on a family holiday as well later in the year so I don't see it as a problem, DSC go away with their mum at different times. So holiday amounts tend to be generally the same.

I can't force a relationship and I don't agree with DH enough (or at all to be perfectly honest though I'm trying to see his POV) to deprive our child of the loving relationship they have with my family simply because
they don't act the same with children they have no bond with. Perhaps if they were here more often and it was natural that they spent more time together things would be different but as it is i think they probably only come face to face once or twice every few months because they live mainly with mum and obviously our 2 days aren't spent with my family, they are spent together or with DH and them.

OP posts:
Bookworm1111 · 23/11/2023 10:28

I wonder if it feels to your DH that his kids don't count within your wider family, and that feeling trickles down to him the same way? His DC are being treated with ambivalence at best, cruel exclusion at worse, and you don't seem to care it bothers him. This is the kind of thing that can eat away at a marriage.

Ponoka7 · 23/11/2023 10:25

@Pinkpinkpink15 but then what if the no Christmas day contact was challenged? How would that go down with the Mother? We don't know if she's happy as things are and glad she doesn't have to give her children to people who aren't related to her. In-laws wanting contact with children can cause issues.

Ponoka7 · 23/11/2023 10:23

Having bonded with children who've joined the family via step parents and thinking of one as my GC, to then lose all contact, going forward I'd always put a boundary in place. I think posters are missing that you only have them twice a week and never on Christmas etc. Would your DH have been ok with having to fit visits with your family into contact? That's how relationships are built. He's feeling it because he has no parents, otherwise it would be too much to see everyone. The now 10 and 13 year old aren't going to start to view your side as close family. The ship has sailed. Financially will they need anything from your family? Is that a worry for him?

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/11/2023 10:13

They have their own grandparents. Friendly when they see them is fine.

Pinkpinkpink15 · 23/11/2023 10:12

spok111 · 22/11/2023 20:05

Can I ask genuinely what is sad about it? DSC have never, to my knowledge, been bothered by the lack of relationship with my family or about not being taken on holidays by them. They are just other people that they don't really know that well.

@spok111

i think it's sad in your situation because they don't have their Dad's parents & family, only family on their mums side. If your family had chosen to step up your DH would feel he/they had family on his side too.

But you can't make people feel what they don't.

The kids might not be bothered by it, but that doesn't mean their lives wouldn't have been richer for having more involvement from your family.

Willowview · 23/11/2023 10:11

@spok111 it seems to me that communication is key here, DH has reached out to you and you are considering everybody's feelings around the existing relationships. Fair play to you, it's doesn't sound easy.

However, what has worked for everyone in the past is not necessarily the best dynamic moving forward, again, you're considering this, again, it's tricky.

How do you feel about a holiday that doesn't involve your SC, you know them too. Could you suggest an alternative holiday for DH and SC?

Sayitaintso33 · 23/11/2023 10:08

Presents are not that important, the other 363 days of the year are.

At the very least step grandchildren should be treated affectionately. They are part of the family and it is affection (love is preferable) that binds families together.

Younghearts · 23/11/2023 10:04

@myotherkidisacassowary I really agree with you here. OP has a 3 year old and are married. When you marry someone with children, you accept them as part of your life. No, your parents were not the ones marrying him but morally I would expect my mum and dad to love and respect me enough to accept my life with a man who has children from a previous relationship and yes I would expect them to make an effort with my step children.

I’m not saying it’s something that happens over night, I wouldn’t expect them to take SC in as their own grandchildren the first day they meet but the fact you’re married and have a 3 year old shows you’ve been together long enough for your parents to come round to the idea and spend time with them.

Morally it doesn’t sit right with me that you’re leaving DH and your step kids at home whilst you go to Disneyland with your child and your family. It feels too much of a divide.

DH is obviously upset by this and in my OWN opinion I am on his side here. I think I would expect more from my parents.

TheFamilyBump · 23/11/2023 10:03

Every family situation is different and many people obviously don’t see an issue with little interaction between SC and a new extended family. In my case, my brother remarried and his new wife had a daughter from a previous marriage. From the point they got together and we were introduced, her daughter became a niece to us and grandchild to my parents. It never occurred to me that she would be anything other. She is as loved and treated the same as all my other nieces and nephews. I appreciate people holding back with a new relationship, not wanting to invest in a relationship with the children only to be hurt if the relationship failed, but we never gave that a thought and simply welcomed her into our family and have enjoyed seeing our new niece grow into the beautiful woman she is now. At the end of the day as long as the children are not hurt by having a different relationship with your parents to their siblings, everything is kept polite and friendly and your family dynamic works, then great.

Wolvesart · 23/11/2023 09:57

It depends on all sorts of things. My Dad’s neighbours talk constantly about their son’s stepson and are really fond of him. My bro married at 42, he was much older than I am and my SIL had 2 children who were then adults. So, the step nephews and I have children technically in different generations that are much of a muchness in age. My bro loved being a grandad and I love being an auntie (they don’t call me a great auntie)

myotherkidisacassowary · 23/11/2023 09:54

A lot of people on mumsnet are going to say that the family owe your kids nothing and aren’t required to do anything for them. From a legal perspective they’re right.

But from a moral one? It doesn’t sit right with me. How hard is it to make a bit of space at the table for children? I’m not saying they have to get absolutely equal amounts of attention and expense, but it costs very little to be warm, thoughtful and inviting to children. Presents on birthdays and at Christmas don’t have to be a huge deal or expense. If you can afford it I don’t know why you wouldn’t do the little things you can to make a child’s life happier and warmer.

Jumbalya0367 · 23/11/2023 09:52

I think it depends on the family. I’m very close to my SM’s family, especially one of her sisters, and have my own relationships with them outside of her .They have always bought me gifts and also now for my children. My SNan always checks in on me and I her, always expected to be at family events.
Not as close to SDads family but they are lovely and welcoming and again I have always been given gifts and invited to family events etc.
I do have both sets of biological Gparents but my stepfamilies are just extra people to love, and to love me and my children.
Saying all of this I don’t ever expect anything they do for me, I suppose it was easier I came in at such a young age maybe? Before any of their bio grandkids were born

chickencat5 · 23/11/2023 09:50

As a child in this situation I don't care my step fathers family don't view me as family. It was hard when we were young and not included as it meant mum had to stay with us and send my step father alone. Now I'm older I wish they would open up to us, for my step father, he's my dad, my child's grandfather and I'm sad he can't share this with his family. But he says it's getting easier now, they accept in words which I think helps him, but I honestly don't want a relationship with them and never have.

Tandora · 23/11/2023 09:44

I wouldn’t be ok with this, no and I think it fucking sucks tbh. But mumsnet orthodoxy is this is totally fine, and the natural order of things. If it does happen to upset the kids , they just have to be helped to get over it apparently.
Tbh I think it says a lot about your in laws and who they are as people.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 23/11/2023 09:42

There’s several step dc’s in my family. They all just get embraced as part of the family. Which they are.

YellowRibbon710 · 23/11/2023 09:41

My DH has been in my life for 10 yrs and is step parent to teen DC. He's quite clear that DC is his son and his family should accept that. And they do because they love DH and respect his choices and they now love my DC too.

I chose a partner that fully understood the role of step parent.

curaçao · 23/11/2023 09:39

So does it work both ways? Does your hubby 's ex have a relayionshop with your children?

Snoopysimaginaryfriend · 23/11/2023 09:38

If I have understood this properly, your DSC don’t really know your parents. Would they even feel comfortable going on holiday with them? Would their mum even allow it?
I probably wouldn’t let my father in law take my DDs away because he’s only met them a handful of times and they’re ‘full blood relations.’
On the flip side my mother in law will often take my DSD away with them without us and has never done that with my DDs who are her grandchildren as well 🤷‍♀️ she did it before they were born and it’s never changed.

pastaisgod · 23/11/2023 09:33

I wouldn't expect the same treatment or relationship they've got with their bio grandkids but I do think it would be kinder to involve them in things like Xmas gifts just so they aren't obviously being left out.

cheddercherry · 23/11/2023 09:30

So having been a step child it didn’t bother me tbh that my stepmums family were not that close to me as I had my own grandparents, they were polite etc and I was fine going round but it would have been weird if they were overly familiar as I saw them so infrequently.

My stepdad however brought me up and his family are my family and I consider him to be the “dad” in my life. So totally depends on context.

My BIL had stepkids who were ranging from 7-18 when he met their mum and he then had a child with their mum. The eldest two were basically adults so I used to include their names on cards etc but beyond that weren’t super close in an Aunty way (I’m not that far off their age tbh). However my SIL youngest daughter was 7 and I never wanted her feeling left out so if my DS or niece (her younger sister) were doing something/ getting something I always made sure she had the same. I felt she’d notice not being treated the same, whereas her older sisters obviously wouldn’t expect the same as kids being so much older.

I think it more matters if the child notices a difference and feels excluded rather than if you “should” force a relationship.