Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it unreasonable for a partners family to have no relationship with DC from previous relationship

166 replies

spok111 · 22/11/2023 16:13

Would you be okay with your partners or spouses family having no relationship with your children from a previous relationship outside of being polite / friendly when happen to be face to face.

I.e. not getting a birthday card for them, only asking if they had a good one when they see them next which could be weeks after, being fantastic and really involved with joint DC but having no real relationship at all with stepchildren, arranging days out with joint DC but never suggesting SC go etc..

Basically would you accept in your relationship or marriage, your partners family having nothing to do with your children from a previous relationship outside of being polite when face to face.

OP posts:
LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 23/11/2023 13:37

There aren't any step children in our family but it's an interesting question to ponder.

We all have so many different places that we're coming from and our experiences - and posts - are heavily coloured by that. Thinking about it, if the step children have parents, grandparents and wider family whom they are involved with then they perhaps wouldn't 'miss' a relationship with their step-family?

I suppose much depends on the age and the make-up of the families but unless there's some sort of problem, people don't pay this much heed. I would treat any child with kindness and I wouldn't hold them in different regard for cards, presents, and perhaps days out (if the relationship is there) but, when it comes to inheritance, what then?

That's the big question and it would really not be appropriate to treat children and step-children the same. That doesn't mean that I wouldn't leave them something but no, they're not the same exactly. I would get around this by leaving to my children only - and they can do the same with their own children and step children. It's their party after all.

notlucreziaborgia · 23/11/2023 13:31

Maray1967 · 23/11/2023 13:27

Then you should be paying for your DSC to go too. I wouldn’t allow this unless DSC have been or are going with their mum. So cruel for some DC to go and not others.

The fuck? 😂

they don’t all have the same family common, and as such their experiences and opportunities will be different. It isn’t up to OP to pay out for her stepchildren to go on a trip they haven’t even been invited on. Her parents want to take their children and grandchildren on a special trip, and there’s nothing wrong with that.

Maray1967 · 23/11/2023 13:28

helpfulperson · 23/11/2023 13:20

I think the description I saw recently of queen camilla's relationship with the Wales children is the right default position for all these complicated relationships. she is not their step grandmother but she is a kind funny grown up that they see, particularly at family events.

My step mum is my DCs granny - that’s how we view it. She organised their Christmas and birthday gifts usually, not my Dad.

Maray1967 · 23/11/2023 13:27

spok111 · 22/11/2023 18:15

Me and DSis are going, DH isn't.

Then you should be paying for your DSC to go too. I wouldn’t allow this unless DSC have been or are going with their mum. So cruel for some DC to go and not others.

Nordlo · 23/11/2023 13:21

I think the fact that DHs parents are dead matters quite a lot. It sounds like your DH doesn't feel like family to them and he and his children have been rejected. It's a shame that no one made an effort over 5 years for the grandparents to get to know two small kids. 2 days a week contact isn't insignificant and a more than most. So I can see why to him it seems a purposeful and hurtful division. I'm a stepmum and my parents have always given to DSC on birthdays and Christmas despite not even living in the same country. It's an act of unity as a family. It hasn't gone that way for your DH. It's just a shame really but it doesn't sound like after 5 years anyone is open to his feelings including you.

helpfulperson · 23/11/2023 13:20

I think the description I saw recently of queen camilla's relationship with the Wales children is the right default position for all these complicated relationships. she is not their step grandmother but she is a kind funny grown up that they see, particularly at family events.

curaçao · 23/11/2023 12:52

It’s a privilege and a joy to have a relationship with a child
Well you might think that way, but i dont think everyone would agree .The prospect of building a relationship with a random non-related child would not bring me any joy.

Cas112 · 23/11/2023 12:45

I mean it's a bit sad and a shame but as long as they are respectful to your children and not causing them harm you would just have to accept it. Your partner took them on, not his family

notlucreziaborgia · 23/11/2023 12:43

Your DH can’t demand that of your family any more than he can demand you consider your stepchildren to be your children (or conversely, demand that his children consider you to be their mother). It isn’t the fault of your parents that your stepchildren don’t have paternal grandparents, and nor is it their responsibility to compensate for that.

I would absolutely stand your ground. Don’t deny your child opportunities, because that can easily backfire too. There was a thread recently where the OP’s younger children were angry and resentful over being denied a relationship with their father’s family because they didn’t take on her child as a grandchild.

Blended families are different to nuclear ones, and the children of them aren’t going to share every family members. They’re not always going to have the same opportunities and/or experiences with the same people.

Pinkpinkpink15 · 23/11/2023 11:52

Ponoka7 · 23/11/2023 10:25

@Pinkpinkpink15 but then what if the no Christmas day contact was challenged? How would that go down with the Mother? We don't know if she's happy as things are and glad she doesn't have to give her children to people who aren't related to her. In-laws wanting contact with children can cause issues.

@Ponoka7

what ?

I didn't mention Christmas Day??

StardustGiraffe · 23/11/2023 11:40

TheFamilyBump · 23/11/2023 10:03

Every family situation is different and many people obviously don’t see an issue with little interaction between SC and a new extended family. In my case, my brother remarried and his new wife had a daughter from a previous marriage. From the point they got together and we were introduced, her daughter became a niece to us and grandchild to my parents. It never occurred to me that she would be anything other. She is as loved and treated the same as all my other nieces and nephews. I appreciate people holding back with a new relationship, not wanting to invest in a relationship with the children only to be hurt if the relationship failed, but we never gave that a thought and simply welcomed her into our family and have enjoyed seeing our new niece grow into the beautiful woman she is now. At the end of the day as long as the children are not hurt by having a different relationship with your parents to their siblings, everything is kept polite and friendly and your family dynamic works, then great.

Yeah but I imagine it's very different in a situation where the SC is a resident child so there would be plenty of opportunity to see the SP's family.

If my SC's lived with us rather than came every other weekend then of course they'd likely see my family more and know them better. When you've got very limited time, bonding SCs with the SP's family is not usually a priority.

StardustGiraffe · 23/11/2023 11:35

I think it can be hard to visualise from out the outside, but the reality is that many SCs have little to no interaction at all with their step-parents family due to logistics.

My DP has SCs every other weekend and time in the holidays, and that limited time is used to see their own family, not my parents. They also live far away so not practical to pop in often although they have met a couple of times.

It's not a case of cutting them out or not caring about them, but purely that time with SCs is spent doing what they enjoy and seeing their family - not purposely taking time away from that so they can bond with my family.

If my family were to see them on Christmas Day then they would definitely get them a little gift to open, but tbh they never would see them on Christmas Day as if we do have the children on Christmas Day then obviously we'd spend it with their own grandparents and cousins etc.

WhatNoRaisins · 23/11/2023 11:20

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 23/11/2023 11:08

Well, you only get the relationship that you facilitate. If your family never see them, how could they have a relationship? If your DH wanted them to be part of your wider family then he needed to have prioritised incorporating them into that family more.

Maybe it's a generational thing, my parents are disappointed that I don't have a relationship with any of my extended family but as you said, they did pretty much nothing to facilitate it. It's like they thought it would just happen.

This isn't even a blended family issue, it's a you can't make something out of nothing issue.

BowlOfNoodles · 23/11/2023 11:16

They've no obligation at all me personally tho I'd of sent a birthday card.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 23/11/2023 11:08

Well, you only get the relationship that you facilitate. If your family never see them, how could they have a relationship? If your DH wanted them to be part of your wider family then he needed to have prioritised incorporating them into that family more.

ElevenSeven · 23/11/2023 11:04

If not the communication with the kids could be clear from the get go... "Tom and Sue are little brother's grandparents, just like you have Nana and Grandpa Mum's-side. So brother gets presents and goes on hols with them the same way you do". No fuss, no drama.

This should be the default without a conversation, surely. This is just common sense.

WowOK · 23/11/2023 11:02

I can see why DH is upset. He's sad that his kids don't have that extra love / support network.

I've been the doting aunt to step niblings. I was there aunt for 14 years. When my brother and his ex split she was very clear her kids are nothing to do with me/us (unless it's a Christmas or birthday, and then we are family and it's not their fault the relationship ending). When the kids had their own kids the suddenly contact me independently wanting a relationship. Ibdid a lot for the niblings but she (ex) obstructed a relationship with my nephew (again unless it involves spending money on gifts. He hasn't had trips to the zoo, theme park, sea side like her kids had.

Anyhow, I wouldn't invest my heart or my time into kids that I'm not related to again.

AgreeWithPP · 23/11/2023 10:57

I find it baffling that people don't communicate about things like this BEFORE getting married, having more kids etc. There are obviously a lot of variables and I think as previous posters have said it makes a big difference who they live with most of the time. I just think if I were in a new relationship discussions would happen. Husband could have said "I want our families to be fully blended, I don't want my older kids to be left out, would your family be on board with that?" If it was a dealbreaker he could have walked away early. If not the communication with the kids could be clear from the get go... "Tom and Sue are little brother's grandparents, just like you have Nana and Grandpa Mum's-side. So brother gets presents and goes on hols with them the same way you do". No fuss, no drama.

askmenow · 23/11/2023 10:56

spok111 · 22/11/2023 18:15

Me and DSis are going, DH isn't.

Given DH isn't going to Disney, then really imho SC shouldn't be going either.

It's a lot of responsibility to ask of unrelated people to take SC on extended trips in the absence of a parent.

ElevenSeven · 23/11/2023 10:56

Kirstyshine · 23/11/2023 10:53

I don’t understand why we always think of these relationships/interactions as being the pseudo-grandparents doing all the giving & the children the taking. It’s a privilege and a joy to have a relationship with a child, and I can only imagine fear at them being whisked away, come relationship breakdown, as an understandable reason to hold back. Life often gets smaller as we get older, what a joy if more children/young people come along.

Not all children are joyful. Some are very hard work.

Kirstyshine · 23/11/2023 10:53

I don’t understand why we always think of these relationships/interactions as being the pseudo-grandparents doing all the giving & the children the taking. It’s a privilege and a joy to have a relationship with a child, and I can only imagine fear at them being whisked away, come relationship breakdown, as an understandable reason to hold back. Life often gets smaller as we get older, what a joy if more children/young people come along.

Bookworm1111 · 23/11/2023 10:48

spok111 · 23/11/2023 10:42

I think they are as kind and welcoming with DSC as they are with any children they aren't related to and don't see much. They don't consider them grandchildren (or niece / nephew). Obviously whether people think that's right or not varies. Personally I don't think they need to, especially as DSC never seem bothered.

But they aren't just any children. They are the siblings of your family's grandchild/niece/nephew and they are the children of your family's son-in-law/brother-in-law - surely that makes them deserving of a birthday card at the very least? A small box of chocolates at Christmas? You say your DSC don't seem bothered but how do you know for sure? Your DH bringing it up is a sign that they probably are.

spok111 · 23/11/2023 10:42

Sayitaintso33 · 23/11/2023 10:39

It is not polite to be unwelcoming, cold or distant with step grandchildren.

Politeness is more than not swearing at them.

I think they are as kind and welcoming with DSC as they are with any children they aren't related to and don't see much. They don't consider them grandchildren (or niece / nephew). Obviously whether people think that's right or not varies. Personally I don't think they need to, especially as DSC never seem bothered.

OP posts:
spok111 · 23/11/2023 10:40

Jasmine222 · 23/11/2023 10:35

I think ultimately as you can see from the responses on this thread, you're not in the wrong but your DH definitely isn't either and it must be pretty sad for him seeing as he doesn't have his own parents. I don't get why he and the two kids aren't coming to Disneyland too? It's not hard to make more effort when something is hurting your spouse.

Because its a trip arrange and paid for by my parents for mine and Dsis' children, outside if school hols. I can't expect them to pay for DSC and also re arrange the whole thing to go in the more expensive school holidays as well. I don't know why they would or be expected to do that for children they see a handful of times if that a year.

As I say I am trying to see DHs POV but I'm also not going to deprive our DC of opportunities with their own family because of it.

OP posts:
Sayitaintso33 · 23/11/2023 10:39

betterangels · 23/11/2023 10:34

Yes. Because I would have chosen to involve myself with a man who had children. My parents didn't make that decision and so I wouldn't force them to have emotional attachment to children that were in no way anything to do with them.

I'd feel this way. They're polite when they meet.

It is not polite to be unwelcoming, cold or distant with step grandchildren.

Politeness is more than not swearing at them.