Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it unreasonable for a partners family to have no relationship with DC from previous relationship

166 replies

spok111 · 22/11/2023 16:13

Would you be okay with your partners or spouses family having no relationship with your children from a previous relationship outside of being polite / friendly when happen to be face to face.

I.e. not getting a birthday card for them, only asking if they had a good one when they see them next which could be weeks after, being fantastic and really involved with joint DC but having no real relationship at all with stepchildren, arranging days out with joint DC but never suggesting SC go etc..

Basically would you accept in your relationship or marriage, your partners family having nothing to do with your children from a previous relationship outside of being polite when face to face.

OP posts:
Happilyobtuse · 24/11/2023 14:39

My sister married a man who had 2 children from a previous marriage. He has joint custody so the kids live with them 50% of the time. They have one dc together. My parents live abroad but always treat all children the same when they see them in terms of gifts, treats etc. They are children and do not need to feel left out when among family. When my sis travelled abroad to see my parents, her step children were not allowed to go as their mother did not want them to travel so far without her, the kids are aged 14 and 10. So only my sisters child went. My parents still bought lots of gifts for the other two children and sent it for them. Always treat children with love, and if your parents can’t afford to take all the kids to Disney then you and your partner should save and take the other two kids too. Playing favourites within a family is not nice.

Kerantli · 24/11/2023 14:32

my PILs ask how my kids are doing, but don't have much more of a relationship with them.
I'm not bothered by it to be honest, I didn't expect much at the beginning of mine and DP's relationship, and as my kids have 2 sets of grandparents already and didn't really need a 3rd set.

harrietspectre · 24/11/2023 14:27

Obviously this will depend on the actual situation, but in this one where DSC don't actually live with this parent and only stay 2 days a week, it's obviously going to be less noticeable that step parents family they never really see treats them differently than it would be to a child who lives there 100% of the time and has no other side of the family.

harrietspectre · 24/11/2023 14:25

yellowlane · 24/11/2023 14:18

Nope I wouldn't. My dsis had a child at 20, dad didn't want to know and has never met child. She met her now husband (tiger her 15 years) about a year after and he took child on as his own as did his parents, siblings, grandparents etc. they all dote on him. My dsis has 2 more children and they're all treated exactly the same. My heart would break if I thought he was being treated differently.

Surely there is a bit of nuance involved though. Your sisters child had no father, her new partner has essentially become that child's father in a way a lot of step parents who's DSC have another involved parent, do not. I'm also assuming her child lived with them 100% of the time too.

Gingerbee · 24/11/2023 14:22

My Granny and extended family treated my cousins and step cousins. They were a couple of years older than me and I never realised they weren't my biological cousins. I do remember that my aunty and uncle did make so much more fuss of 'their' child.

harrietspectre · 24/11/2023 14:21

I think how much or if at all this affects you as a child must differ from person to person.

I'm a stepchild, I have never had much involvement at all with his parents. Never even met his dad and he's been married to my mum for 12 years. I've met his mum but she's not my grandma, I have those already.

It has never ever occurred to me that I should be hurt or damaged by the fact some woman I barely know and who isn't my grandma, doesn't treat me like her granddaughter.

I love my stepdad to pieces, he's not my dad, I have a great one of those already, but he's a valued and brilliant family member of mine who has always treated me well. Tbh the relationship with him is the only one I'm arsed about.

I must say I don't really get why someone would be damaged that their step parents family didn't treat them like a grandchild. Especially if they already have grandparents anyway. I don't see what it is they think they should be receiving from these people who aren't actually related to them or what they think they have lost by not doing so.

And the argument always falls apart for me when people go on about siblings needing to experience the same things I.e. the disney trip here. The stepchildren aren't necessarily received "less than" the shared DC because their grandparents are taking them somewhere, in the same way no one would suggest the shared DC are being treated "less than" if the DSC were taken somewhere by their maternal grandparents.

They are siblings yes, but they happen to have different families so will sometimes receive different opportunities, and that goes both ways, DSC will receive things from their mums side that shared DC will not. It's just life in a blended family surely?

I don't get why people always try and mash a blended family into a seamless nuclear mould. It seems a bit daft to me.

yellowlane · 24/11/2023 14:18

Nope I wouldn't. My dsis had a child at 20, dad didn't want to know and has never met child. She met her now husband (tiger her 15 years) about a year after and he took child on as his own as did his parents, siblings, grandparents etc. they all dote on him. My dsis has 2 more children and they're all treated exactly the same. My heart would break if I thought he was being treated differently.

NeedToChangeName · 24/11/2023 14:09

caringcarer · 22/11/2023 20:24

I was very lucky because both my exh and my parents were dead but my now DH took my DC on as his own and his parents did too. They bought my DC birthday and Xmas gifts and Easter eggs and because they lived by the seaside they invited my DC up to stay with them for a week each year. FiL would take a week off and they'd take my DC to the beach or out on a boat ride or petting zoo every day. Also MiL cooked all their favourite foods. She's a great cook. DH and I got a week's holiday alone somewhere romantic. My kids are grown up now and FiL has died but my DC independently go up to see MiL 150 miles away 3 or 4 times a year each and always take her a bunch of flowers. Mil lives alone and loves their company. They take her out for a cream tea or sometimes just go to the beach for an ice cream. They have ne er forgotten her kindness to them and they all call her Gran too.

That's lovely

Concannon88 · 24/11/2023 14:05

Her partners not happy with it though is he?

Concannon88 · 24/11/2023 14:04

Is that not up to their mum? Hes not with her anymore so he cabt really have a say on how her and her family run things.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 24/11/2023 13:48

FriendlyGiant, how does that work with the other side of the family, husband's ex-wife, her siblings/parents (and his, if he has them) and so on? Will they make the same provision for OP's children that he is expecting OP's parents to make?

It's messy and there's huge potential for disparity.

FriendlyGiant · 24/11/2023 13:26

I am also appalled at the grandparents’ cruel behaviour. It was the responsibility of the parents (but mostly OP as it is her parents) to develop the relationship between her SC and the grandparents. That is where I think the problem lies. Two days a week and every other Christmas is more than enough time to ensure the grandparents and SC spend time together to develop a relationship. Their exclusion from the larger family over the past five years has definately been noticed by them and is being explicitly stated by the father. It is a shame that five years has gone by but relationship-building can start now.

As to the Disney trip, the SC have now been put in a no-win situation. Of course the siblings should go to Disney together, but if you pull the youngest child it will seem like punishing her. Even though it is during school, I think DH and the SC should go so the family can be together. This is another opportunity for the grandparents and SC to build memories and a relationship together.

I hope OP integrates their SC into their extended family going forward - I’ve never heard it said that children can have too many people that love them

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 24/11/2023 10:52

That is true, EmmaHeather, the parents have the responsibility. It was their choice to create a blended family up to them to make sure that all parents of the children involved are on an equal footing. Their responsibility, nobody else's.

When the responsibility part has been properly taken care of then grandparents and wider family don't need to feel manoeuvred into a role that they don't want. It's the children who suffer when people without parental responsibility are strong-armed into it.

As I said, there are no step-children in my family but there are in my husband's and I can see the sour feelings erupt from one side. We treat them the same and are scrupulous about it but, it isn't and everybody is aware of it.

I don't think family blending is all it's cracked up to be.

Emmaheather · 24/11/2023 07:08

IvfBeenWaiting · 23/11/2023 22:29

I’ve been the step child in this scenario, from the age of six, and despite it being over 30 years later I am still angry at my step mother’s parents for ignoring me and her for not challenging it.

I too have seen the very long term damage done in this type of situation (not me personally but someone close to me, now an adult). In blended families, when some children have more (attention, love, opportunities, resources Inc financial), the experience is very likely to be toxic and damaging for those who have less. Just because the children don't come across as caring doesn't mean it's not having an impact on self-worth/emotional well-being.
The parents of the children have a responsibility to balance things and ensure equity IMO.

notlucreziaborgia · 24/11/2023 01:54

Maray1967 · 23/11/2023 23:03

Sorry - but no way would I have my DSC treated like that - unless, as I said, they were getting the same trip/ treat with their other parent. I would put the family dynamics of my immediate family, that is, our kids, before what my parents wanted to do with their DGC. My mum’s friend treated her son’s stepchild exactly the same as his own children.

Someone who isn’t their grandparent isn’t treating them like grandchildren. It’s not exactly an unusual dynamic.

You’re free to do what you like with your own family, just as everyone else, OP included, are free to do what they like with theirs.

Maray1967 · 23/11/2023 23:03

notlucreziaborgia · 23/11/2023 13:31

The fuck? 😂

they don’t all have the same family common, and as such their experiences and opportunities will be different. It isn’t up to OP to pay out for her stepchildren to go on a trip they haven’t even been invited on. Her parents want to take their children and grandchildren on a special trip, and there’s nothing wrong with that.

Sorry - but no way would I have my DSC treated like that - unless, as I said, they were getting the same trip/ treat with their other parent. I would put the family dynamics of my immediate family, that is, our kids, before what my parents wanted to do with their DGC. My mum’s friend treated her son’s stepchild exactly the same as his own children.

IvfBeenWaiting · 23/11/2023 22:29

I’ve been the step child in this scenario, from the age of six, and despite it being over 30 years later I am still angry at my step mother’s parents for ignoring me and her for not challenging it.

Mummy3Plus1 · 23/11/2023 20:18

I actually think this is incredibly cruel of your parents/family to not even get a birthday card for SC. I foster my niece, if my DH family excluded her, that would be a deal-breaker for me. Your SC probably don't 'seem upset' by it because it is normal to them to be treated so poorly by your family. Your DH is absolutely in the right and if I were you I would be speaking to my family to ensure they made more of an effort in the future. You can't undo the past or change the plans for Disney but you can definitely make it clear to your family that it is upsetting DH and in the future it is expected that they are to build a relationship with SC so they can be included.

Manthide · 23/11/2023 19:19

I think if sc live with the family and only spend a couple of nights a week or every other week I wouldn't expect my parents to become involved with them but if they were a pretty much constant presence I hope they would. Your dh is being unreasonable and making an issue when there is none.

Crazycrazylady · 23/11/2023 17:52

N

Kirstyshine · 23/11/2023 16:56

curaçao · 23/11/2023 12:52

It’s a privilege and a joy to have a relationship with a child
Well you might think that way, but i dont think everyone would agree .The prospect of building a relationship with a random non-related child would not bring me any joy.

It wouldn’t be random and unrelated though? It’d be part of your son or daughter’s family.

To each their own. I’ve fond memories of my grandma, who was a step-, and my kids adore their step-granny & she them.

Whyamiherenow · 23/11/2023 16:44

I wouldn’t be ok with this. We have 1 DS together and DSD. My parents treat her as close as possible the same as DS. They put money in both their savings accounts each month (granted not the same amount but still significant). They bring them both gifts back from their travels. They spend similar on them at birthdays and Xmas. Granted we don’t have DSD full time and my parents do a lot of child care for us while we work. So I do think they take DS on more trips etc and he does get more ad hoc gifts and treats but that’s a time spent with thing not a treating differently thing.

They bought gifts etc for DSD before there was a DS.

I couldn’t imagine it being a different way. DSD is my DS sister and so is important to him. We would always want to include her and would never exclude at all if we could help it. Granted I guess this means she gets extra things financially / treats etc which I guess some people may see as being more fortunate than DS (because her mums family is lovely and generous too) but she is growing up not seeing both of her parents every day so in my view DS is still more fortunate.

However, if your parents / family haven’t made an effort to date. It will probably never happen. The ship has likely sailed. So it is something to live with.

Mycatmax · 23/11/2023 15:11

YANBU.

I can’t remember ever meeting my stepmother’s family but it may have happened. I certainly didn’t want a relationship with them. They didn’t mean anything to me.

Notamum12345577 · 23/11/2023 15:07

I think a small gift for the birthdays shouldn’t be too much for them to do though.

Almostateeagersmum2023 · 23/11/2023 13:40

Yeah that’s pretty much how it is with us, but they do have much to do with our children who are their grandchildren either tbh.

Swipe left for the next trending thread