Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it unreasonable for a partners family to have no relationship with DC from previous relationship

166 replies

spok111 · 22/11/2023 16:13

Would you be okay with your partners or spouses family having no relationship with your children from a previous relationship outside of being polite / friendly when happen to be face to face.

I.e. not getting a birthday card for them, only asking if they had a good one when they see them next which could be weeks after, being fantastic and really involved with joint DC but having no real relationship at all with stepchildren, arranging days out with joint DC but never suggesting SC go etc..

Basically would you accept in your relationship or marriage, your partners family having nothing to do with your children from a previous relationship outside of being polite when face to face.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Floofydawg · 27/11/2023 06:08

Jellytot1234 · 26/11/2023 14:39

My parents don’t buy things for my step children in the same way they do for my children because quite simply; they don’t have much interaction with my step kids. My step kids have 2 sets of grandparents as do my children. It’s unreasonable to expect other people to go above and beyond for children that have no emotional bond with them. Being polite and kind is absolutely an acceptable way to be. They don’t need to be forced to go out of their way for children that AREN’t actually their grandchildren.

Very well put. Same here.

notlucreziaborgia · 26/11/2023 16:00

Tandora · 26/11/2023 08:42

You’re free to do what you like with your own family, just as everyone else, OP included, are free to do what they like with theirs

wellll her DH apparently isnt happy with it (presumably because he’s thinking of his children). Is he part of the family and does his opinion count or is it just OP who is “free” to do exactly as she pleases regardless of the feelings of others?

He’s welcome to have a problem with it. Him having a problem with it doesn’t automatically mean that OP and her parents are wrong. It also doesn’t make it their responsibility to change in order to suit him. His opinion isn’t of greater importance than theirs.

Jellytot1234 · 26/11/2023 14:39

My parents don’t buy things for my step children in the same way they do for my children because quite simply; they don’t have much interaction with my step kids. My step kids have 2 sets of grandparents as do my children. It’s unreasonable to expect other people to go above and beyond for children that have no emotional bond with them. Being polite and kind is absolutely an acceptable way to be. They don’t need to be forced to go out of their way for children that AREN’t actually their grandchildren.

ThomasinaLivesHere · 26/11/2023 10:18

I think the circumstances matter. My sister got together with someone who had kids and she lives in a different country so my parents only met the children once, years after they’d been together. They never bought presents for the children at birthdays and Christmases as they didn’t know each other. Also the children never had any comparison to how they were treated differently to their biological grandchild. My sister has now split up with the man and so they won’t meet the children again.

I do feel for children who are in situations where they feel one sibling is getting better treatment because of who they’re biologically related to if they don’t have anything equivalent on their side.

adviceneeded1990 · 26/11/2023 10:00

No I would never accept it. My DSD was two when I met my DH and she is 100% my parents grandchild and my siblings niece. Same on her Mums side, her stepdads family include her completely. Treating children of the same family differently is just building resentment for the future and anyone who wanted to do so would not be allowed contact with my step or bio kids. My DH and his sister experienced this growing up and it’s damaged their relationships and sense of worth well into adulthood.

Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot · 26/11/2023 09:58

When I read these threads I always wonder why the expectation is on the grandparents/extended step family rather than the two people who have actually chosen to blend their family to make the big effort. Surely if you want your parents to see you all as one family then you spend time and effort to make that happen? You lead on it. YOU invest time facilitating the relationships between the children and your extended family. Otherwise you are essentially saying ‘I have some children in my life my parents don’t really see. AIBU to think they should take them to Disneyland?’

GirlsAndPenguins · 26/11/2023 09:48

Oh gosh when they are so young too. I have been that excluded stepchild, I think it’s awful. They should 100% be buying them a Christmas and birthday present unless they can’t afford it, then shouldn’t be buying for your child either. When you engage in this type of relationship the kids are part of the package so should become part of the family for all. If it were me I’d be livid with my parents

Tandora · 26/11/2023 08:42

notlucreziaborgia · 24/11/2023 01:54

Someone who isn’t their grandparent isn’t treating them like grandchildren. It’s not exactly an unusual dynamic.

You’re free to do what you like with your own family, just as everyone else, OP included, are free to do what they like with theirs.

You’re free to do what you like with your own family, just as everyone else, OP included, are free to do what they like with theirs

wellll her DH apparently isnt happy with it (presumably because he’s thinking of his children). Is he part of the family and does his opinion count or is it just OP who is “free” to do exactly as she pleases regardless of the feelings of others?

DunkinDoughnut36 · 26/11/2023 00:12

I think it’s strange tbh, if I was your parents I literally couldn’t treat them differently to my own grandchild (maybe I’m too soft?), especially knowing your husband no longer has any parents!
No way could I not even get them a card or token gift for their birthdays. And I find it odd your husband never ever spends Christmas Day with his children (unless I’m jumping the gun here and his ex is difficult and if so I hope he’s seeking legal help/taking it to court)??
They’ll grow up and remember every little thing like never spending Christmases together, not feeling involved in the family and probably all these little things as a whole resent you all in some way/shape/form.
Needs to be more effort put in all round.

Combusting · 25/11/2023 23:31

spok111 · 22/11/2023 18:15

Me and DSis are going, DH isn't.

Ah you’ve posted about this before haven’t you….

Saltandsauce · 25/11/2023 23:23

I don’t understand how you had gained two stepchildren and your parents and wider family didn’t immediately start buying them birthday/Christmas gifts? How does that happen? Especially when they were only 5 and 7? Regardless if you only see them 2 days a week and they see them once every couple of months, that’s still a lot more than a lot of children may see family.
You also keep saying that the children ‘don’t seem bothered’. Have you ever asked? Maybe your DH is annoyed by it, because they have shared with him that they are bothered about being excluded by your parents. Not from Disney necessarily, but from other celebrations you guys have.
Tbh it’s probably too late to fix now that you’re 5 years down the line, because the kids are probably already used to that feeling of being left out by your side, so not much you can do about it. I’m with your DH though.

Ponoka7 · 25/11/2023 17:05

Pinkpinkpink15 · 23/11/2023 11:52

@Ponoka7

what ?

I didn't mention Christmas Day??

But it's relevant. If the SC were treated as GC, then occasionally they'd be expected for Christmas day along with the other GC. The opportunities for the wider family to see them are limited. If they were seen differently then you've got another set of people wanting contact, holidays and school events. How it stands might suit the Mother and the children.

Santibbz · 25/11/2023 15:19

I think you just have to take it as it comes. Some of my family get my SD gifts and cards for her birthday/Christmas, and then others don’t. But I don’t begrudge the ones that don’t. And I am super grateful for the ones that do. My dad has a special place for my daughter as she is the “only girl” as I have a son and my sister has 2 sons. Although in my eyes I have 2 girls including my SD but my dad doesn’t see it that way. I don’t feel negatively towards it though, he just never expresses it around my SD and is lovely and pleasant when he is here and she’s around. He will also buy her gifts for birthday/Christmas but considers my daughter his only “granddaughter” I think it’s up to them as long as they’re not unpleasant towards your stepchild.

Catsmere · 25/11/2023 11:24

My sister always got on perfectly well with her husband's children as far as I know (those children are grandparents themselves now). I've met them once or twice, it was friendly, but that's spread out over decades and I barely remember their names. I wouldn't recognise them, nor they me.

Manthide · 25/11/2023 10:20

My aunty was pregnant with another person's child when she got together with her late husband. They were both teenagers. They got married when the baby was about 6 months old and had another child the year later. My cousin, who had absolutely no contact with their father or his family, never knew that she wasn't my uncle's child until she was 18 (though it was common family knowledge) but my uncle's parents etc always treated them differently eg buying elaborate presents for her sibling and a selection box for them. They would also take the sibling on outings etc. My uncle always treated them the same as his biological child and was a wonderful gf and ggf to their children and grandchildren. I think my uncle's family were totally in the wrong.

Uberstar · 25/11/2023 09:58

This is how it is with my family. I had children before I married my husband, so did he. We then had one together.
our daughter is treated differently by all of my husband family, they have little to do with my children from my first marriage.
but on the flip side, my sisters don’t have a relationship with his children from his previous marriage either.
we, as a couple, and blended family are all the children need. They are all treated equally by us both and I suppose that is all that matters.

Namechanged1001 · 25/11/2023 09:26

My DPs family immediately accepted my 3 children and we have been on holidays etc as a family. My future MIL loves the fact she has 3 more grandchildren to spoil and they adore her. We've been to many family gatherings and they are treated exactly the same too. I'm very grateful to all of his family but they are a big family and it suppose it comes naturally given their nature's?

For content my DP has a biological older child who he doesn't see ( one night stand, never together with birth mum, but the not seeing is not his choice) and a previous step child (who again is now an adult ) who cut all ties with him when he split from his mother which obviously broke the whole families hearts as my DP raised him from age 6.

My children do not have any contact with their biological dad due to court orders ( domestic violence etc) so I am so grateful they do have a loving "other family" that's not just from my side.

However saying the above, if they were just token polite etc to my children then I wouldn't begrudge them that. I would understand their previous pain at losing a step child already and live with it. My DP is the best dad to them and I wouldn't find it a deal breaker at all.

ElevenSeven · 25/11/2023 09:24

harrietspectre · 24/11/2023 19:29

if your parents can’t afford to take all the kids to Disney then you and your partner should save and take the other two kids too

Even if they can afford it, Disney is not a small amount of money. Who on earth would be entitled enough to expect OPs parents, who barely know DSC, to pay for them to go.. Really?!

As for OP and her DH then having to save to take DSC. Would this be the case if it were reversed? If DSCs maternal grandparents took them to disney or anywhere else, should OP and her husband immediately start saving to make sure their joint child can also go?

The children have different grandparents. They are going to occasionally receive different things and go to different places. I really don't understand the big issue.

This is not a case of DSC living their 100% of the time, having no other grandparents and a mother who's not interested. They live with their mum, have grandparents of their own who probably do things with them and have an involved mother. It's not comparable to a lot of posters examples on here of their own situations.

People go into another dimension when it involves Disney and DSC. It sends people frothing into orbit

Justaquickthankyoumessage · 25/11/2023 08:53

I wouldn't be happy. Especially if there are other children to be compared against.

I've been with my partner 6 months ish. His parents have fully taken DS into their family, they see him loads, spend time with him, buy him toys, they have said that they want him to be just like any other grandkid. It's important to me that my son is not "extra" or "outside" family. He is equal to all his family.

I think it's wrong. And even if you don't. Your partner is upset about it, surely you care about that?

billy1966 · 25/11/2023 08:35

I have had lots of children in this house over the years that are no relation of ours and I am a lot more than polite to them.

I am very warm and welcoming because of their relationship with my children.
It has always been important to me that those my children care about felt very welcome and comfortable in our home.

I think the relationship of your SC to your child should encourage your parents to be warm, welcoming, and interested in them, whenever they see them.

I would think that is just basic kindness.

The holiday is different as its an out of term treat and I think it is ok as your parents are paying.

However, I would be encouraging your husband to make your absence very special and arrange a lovely treat for his children during this time, emphasising the one on one time they will have together.

This will likely happen again, so you need to be firm with your husband that HE needs to do something very nice for his children so that they feel this is a win for them when time like this pops up.

MummytoAAandX · 25/11/2023 08:15

I'm really lucky. I have a DD from my previous relationship and my DH's family treat her like their own. She gets presents for her birthday and Christmas and my DH's parents even brought her a present back from holiday. I always massively appreciate that they include her. It means a lot to me.

Mrsg26 · 25/11/2023 07:01

I’ve been with my partner for 7 years - my daughters dad died when she was 5 so my partner is her SD and all of His family are absolutely brilliant with her, every birthday and Xmas she gets a gift, and even though my daughter is now 16 she is always invited out on days out & holidays. Similarly I have a step daughter who is 11 and she comes to us every 2nd weekend and my mum and brother ALWAYS get her gifts for birthdays and Xmas, & even Easter, even if they do not see her at these times. A gift is always dropped off for her when she next comes for the weekend. Tbh I would REALLY struggle with a family like yours treating step children different and I completely understand your DP feelings on this. They are not just your partners children, they are YOUR SC and are the siblings of their grandchild and I do think it’s a little selfish if I am honest!! Fine, not taking them on the Disneytrip I can understand but not making them feel included or part of the family is harsh and if my family did that with my step daughter I would be very annoyed. Sorry, but I’m with your DH on this one and I’d have to have a word with parents as I feel like you are facilitating this as you don’t see it as a problem yourself!! It absolutely will be as the children get older so I’d nip it in the bud now so your step kids do not feel left out as the children get older.

harrietspectre · 24/11/2023 19:29

if your parents can’t afford to take all the kids to Disney then you and your partner should save and take the other two kids too

Even if they can afford it, Disney is not a small amount of money. Who on earth would be entitled enough to expect OPs parents, who barely know DSC, to pay for them to go.. Really?!

As for OP and her DH then having to save to take DSC. Would this be the case if it were reversed? If DSCs maternal grandparents took them to disney or anywhere else, should OP and her husband immediately start saving to make sure their joint child can also go?

The children have different grandparents. They are going to occasionally receive different things and go to different places. I really don't understand the big issue.

This is not a case of DSC living their 100% of the time, having no other grandparents and a mother who's not interested. They live with their mum, have grandparents of their own who probably do things with them and have an involved mother. It's not comparable to a lot of posters examples on here of their own situations.

caringcarer · 24/11/2023 16:29

I think it makes a difference if the child already has Grandparents living or they don't because they are dead. I know my MiL told me once when my DC were teens by this time, so about 5 or 6 years after she had been their Grandma, she was happy to be Grandma to my 2 DS's because my DC didn't have any Grandparents living so she knew she was not stepping on a biological Grandparents toes. I couldn't have wished for better Grandparents than my in-laws if I'd hand picked them.

IvfBeenWaiting · 24/11/2023 15:48

harrietspectre · 24/11/2023 14:21

I think how much or if at all this affects you as a child must differ from person to person.

I'm a stepchild, I have never had much involvement at all with his parents. Never even met his dad and he's been married to my mum for 12 years. I've met his mum but she's not my grandma, I have those already.

It has never ever occurred to me that I should be hurt or damaged by the fact some woman I barely know and who isn't my grandma, doesn't treat me like her granddaughter.

I love my stepdad to pieces, he's not my dad, I have a great one of those already, but he's a valued and brilliant family member of mine who has always treated me well. Tbh the relationship with him is the only one I'm arsed about.

I must say I don't really get why someone would be damaged that their step parents family didn't treat them like a grandchild. Especially if they already have grandparents anyway. I don't see what it is they think they should be receiving from these people who aren't actually related to them or what they think they have lost by not doing so.

And the argument always falls apart for me when people go on about siblings needing to experience the same things I.e. the disney trip here. The stepchildren aren't necessarily received "less than" the shared DC because their grandparents are taking them somewhere, in the same way no one would suggest the shared DC are being treated "less than" if the DSC were taken somewhere by their maternal grandparents.

They are siblings yes, but they happen to have different families so will sometimes receive different opportunities, and that goes both ways, DSC will receive things from their mums side that shared DC will not. It's just life in a blended family surely?

I don't get why people always try and mash a blended family into a seamless nuclear mould. It seems a bit daft to me.

I would say the reason why this affected me as a child was that I’d already been through the experience of my father leaving to live with another family, I’d seen him raise two children who weren’t me or my sibling, instead of us. His family welcomed them with open arms and we shared our grandparents and aunts and uncles with our new step-siblings. My step mothers family completely ignored us, other than being polite when our paths crossed. I already felt rejected and I already felt excluded, this furthered it. I never acted visibly upset about it, it just further compounded the belief that I wasn’t worth knowing, I wasn’t worth staying for and I wasn’t worth enough.

As an adult I absolutely know those things aren’t true, but I wasn’t an adult when it happened.

I genuinely cannot fathom a situation where my child married into a family and took on a step child and I didn’t engage with them- it completely baffles me that anyone would behave that way.