Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find some Primary School teaching a bit pointless?

264 replies

Schooll · 22/11/2023 15:54

Every other day my child brings home homework asking her to identify a new type of pronoun, adjective etc.

My friend is over today too and we both work in fields that require a good standard of English. We cannot understand why we are still stressing children out with things like ‘identify the relative pronoun’, what use is this information?

Genuinely, when will my child ever need to know this and why is she spending so much time stressing over the different types when it’s unlikely to ever be needed again, unless she becomes a primary school teacher?

Am I missing something where this sort of information is actually really useful and we should still be using it to judge children’s intelligence in exams etc?

OP posts:
DIYandEatCake · 22/11/2023 18:24

Yes, it totally sucks the joy out of English language. In year 1 (age 5) my child got set the homework ‘Write a story. Next, underline all of the verbs in red, and the adverbs in green’. She could just about spell her own name and write a few words, had a massive meltdown and we gave up. At that age why not just enjoy writing words and stories and build up creative writing skills?! She also complained bitterly about spending ‘national poetry day’ in year 4 analysing poems by highlighting grammatical stuff and annotating them (instead of writing their own poems). During the lockdowns a few years ago, my son was in year 1 and they were doing ‘coordinating and subordinating conjunctions’. Year 1! What’s wrong with ‘joining words’ at that age?

LiberteEgaliteBeyonce · 22/11/2023 18:22

Understanding grammar is fundamental to understanding how your own language (as well as others) works.
How else are you supposed to know when to use an apostrophe or not? Or where or were?
Understanding the nature and the function of words in a sentence is pretty fundamental, in the same way that anatomy is a fundamental part of understanding the human body.
And this is why many English people claim to not be "good" at languages: because they have no idea how their own works.

Simonjt · 22/11/2023 18:21

Its a good foundation for developing language skills, we now live in another country, the equivalent of English lessons in first year cover these things, once they’re fairly confidentally understood by the children they start learning a foreign language as they can make a direct comparison and it makes it easier to re-arrange sentence structure in a different language as they can identify where key parts of a sentence belong.

LizzieBet14 · 22/11/2023 18:21

I teach Years 3 & 4 and the amount of grammar we have to throw at them is ridiculous!
There is way too much for them to grasp to the point where even the bright ones have forgotten what a nouns, adjectives & verbs are!!
We're setting them up to fail 😔

Towwanthustice · 22/11/2023 18:13

For whom?
A politician, maths teacher?
Mt daughter will learn this if she she goes I to that realm.
Schools are all about bums on seats, how to pass tests and being robots

nosyupnorth · 22/11/2023 18:13

It's a good foundation for language understanding. The amount of kids who when they get to studying a second language flounder because they barely understand their first, they use it on the basis of imitation/exposure with no grasp of the grammatical principles, is shocking and leaves them totally unable to work out how to apply new grammar rules etc.

Runaway1 · 22/11/2023 18:12

It’s totally pointless.

SgtJuneAckland · 22/11/2023 18:10

I went to quite an old fashioned primary school, they taught a lot of grammar. When I got to secondary in a different area, this was noticeably different to classmates from other primaries. I picked up two foreign languages quite quickly. I don't know if I have a natural talent for that, no one else in my family does, or to what extent my knowledge of one grammar system helped me to understand the mechanics of others.

Shinyandnew1 · 22/11/2023 18:09

modgepodge · 22/11/2023 18:06

But if you came across a new word - say ‘noke’ - would you have any idea how to pronounce it? I bet most people would pronounce it to rhyme with joke, because they know that o consonant e makes an /oa/ sound. I learned that as ‘magic e’ at school. Split digraph is just another way of saying magic e really. I find it useful to have the children understand that language - when my 4 year old daughter comes across a word she doesn’t recognise - say ‘joke’ and sounds it out as ‘j-o-k-e…jok-e’ I just say ‘split digraph’ and she she then says ‘j-oa-k…joke’. To me that’s useful language to understand.

Magic e was fun, engaging and easy to remember.

Split digraphs, much less so.

napody · 22/11/2023 18:06

Iamnotthe1 · 22/11/2023 16:43

Grammar is the logical and structural basis of communication. By learning grammatical rules, it's quite possible to become a highly competent writer with necessarily needing any "creative flair". It's the maths behind English and can be incredibly helpful for both adults and children if it's taught in the write way. Unfortunately, because many teachers didn't learn about grammar themselves, many of the lessons focusing on it end up becoming dry and boring. The issue is more to do with how it's taught rather than the content itself.

There are reasons that primaries have a grammar curriculum and secondaries don't. The group working on the grammar curriculum lost funding before creating a secondary one. However, it wasn't seen as a big deal because, if a child has fully understood the writing curriculum at primary, they have already reached the standard of written communication necessary for all of their time at secondary school. That's why secondaries focus more on content and the analysis of literature rather than how to write. Unfortunately, that's not how it's worked in practice and, for many children, the quality of their writing drops during Y7 and Y8, taking until Y9 to reach the same level of quality they'd already attained in Y6.

For those saying they never use algebra, you're totally wrong. It's impossible to get through a day without using it at least once. You won't, however, be aware of your use because you were taught algebra was all about xs and ys rather than what it actually is.

That explanation shows a complete lack of understanding of psychology and child development. Teaching isn't like programming a computer. Motivation and engagement come first, otherwise all is lost.

modgepodge · 22/11/2023 18:06

YourDiscoNeedsYou · 22/11/2023 17:22

YANBU. It’s completely useless. Gove ruined the primary curriculum. A year 1 child does not need to know what a split vowel digraph is. I didn’t know what a split vowel digraph was until I had a year 1 child - I managed perfectly well in academia before that.

But if you came across a new word - say ‘noke’ - would you have any idea how to pronounce it? I bet most people would pronounce it to rhyme with joke, because they know that o consonant e makes an /oa/ sound. I learned that as ‘magic e’ at school. Split digraph is just another way of saying magic e really. I find it useful to have the children understand that language - when my 4 year old daughter comes across a word she doesn’t recognise - say ‘joke’ and sounds it out as ‘j-o-k-e…jok-e’ I just say ‘split digraph’ and she she then says ‘j-oa-k…joke’. To me that’s useful language to understand.

Nanny0gg · 22/11/2023 18:00

CaptainMyCaptain · 22/11/2023 16:00

What they all said. Have they done 'fronted adverbials' yet?

As a child I read everything I could get my hands on (old person here)
My spelling and punctuation is good, my vocabulary excellent and my grammar was better than many teachers I worked with. I do credit that to the authors I read. Never had a problem with writing stories or essays. However, I wouldn't know a fronted adverbial if it bit me on the arse. I probably used them happily in my writing as a kid without having the first idea of what they are.

I also got through life up till the age of 30-something without actually knowing what a digraph was and I still don't think that's a vital piece of knowledge for a primary school child.

DiscoStusMoonboots · 22/11/2023 17:35

Bootoagoose123 · 22/11/2023 16:02

Primary teacher - I have a separate degree in an essay subject and high standard of written English (worked in copywriting etc before teaching) but I STILL have to re teach myself all this rubbish each time I get put back into Y6 to teach grammar. Absolutely daft.

Could've written the same thing myself! Former career in writing, as soon as I was plonked in Y6 I had to relearn everything I knew (and not for the better).

UndertheCedartree · 22/11/2023 17:31

Konfetka · 22/11/2023 17:23

I'm heartened to hear that the past perfect tense has not been forgotten. American English misses a lot of nuance in not using past perfect; it would be a shame if British English ditched it too.

The best way to learn it is by reading lots. Then it makes sense. Trying to teach them as a separate thing just doesn't stick so is a waste of time. I'm a pretty good writer but I have never been doing a piece of writing and thought hmm...let me write this in the past perfect tense!

picturethispatsy · 22/11/2023 17:28

YANBU.
But so much of what they learn at school is like this now.

The Tories and Gove ruined it for kids when they redesigned the primary curriculum in 2014.

All is serves to do is put children off English.

Iamnotthe1 · 22/11/2023 17:27

I find it fascinating how much of this seems to be down to: "I didn't learn it and I'm fine so kids don't need to learn it."

There are plenty of things that children learn in school that weren't taught to their parents. That's not a bad thing.

UndertheCedartree · 22/11/2023 17:26

WallaceinAnderland · 22/11/2023 16:12

It's just general knowledge and has always been taught. People ought to know the difference between a noun and an adjective. It's pretty basic really.

It wasn't taught when I was at school. But obviously you pick up what a noun or adjective is. But what they learn in school is not nouns or verbs. It's complicated 3 worded things. My DD can write really well. But could never hold these random words in her head.

Is your DC in Y6? They learn them for the SATs.

bearfood · 22/11/2023 17:24

I am an English teacher and I couldn't agree more!

Konfetka · 22/11/2023 17:23

CeciliaMars · 22/11/2023 16:12

Yes the level of SPAG that year 6s need to know is absurd. I am a primary school teacher with English language A level and 4 years of university, plus 16 years of teaching, and I still find some of the SPAG tricky. Had to teach the past perfect tense the other day and looked it up first! Not only is it very tricky for kids to understand, the time it takes to try to teach it could be used teaching something that is actually useful, fun and creative! I think primary school should be more about fostering a love of learning, rather than shoving grammar down children's necks.

I'm heartened to hear that the past perfect tense has not been forgotten. American English misses a lot of nuance in not using past perfect; it would be a shame if British English ditched it too.

Totallyanonymousplease · 22/11/2023 17:22

It’s very useful when learning other languages. It’s about learning how language is structured and made up… it could be useful when writing poetry. I think it’s useful.

YourDiscoNeedsYou · 22/11/2023 17:22

YANBU. It’s completely useless. Gove ruined the primary curriculum. A year 1 child does not need to know what a split vowel digraph is. I didn’t know what a split vowel digraph was until I had a year 1 child - I managed perfectly well in academia before that.

drowningfrowning · 22/11/2023 17:19

Towwanthustice · 22/11/2023 16:09

I was an English teacher and ATM I home school. I honestly don't fill my child's head with that crap.
Why do we need to write persuasive speeches and learn anomalies or similies?
I teach her what's important for life, like writting letters and sending emails.
Just like what do we need to learn Algebra. When do we use it?

A lot of maths is taught because it develops logic and following mathematical process. Does the average person use algebra everyday, perhaps not. But the logic and mathematical reasoning learned is used constantly

TeenLifeMum · 22/11/2023 17:08

@NoCloudsAllowed yep same here. German teacher was German an horrified we had no idea what a subordinate clause was…. still not entirely sure but I almost certainly use them. I write a fair bit for my job role and am on year 2 of a masters so I’m not stupid, just don’t retain unnecessary info.

Passepartoute · 22/11/2023 17:08

I think some grammar has its uses because it does help children to write well. If you can tell that that sentence doesn't work because, for instance, it hasn't got a verb in it, it can be quite helpful.

But all the fronted adverbial bollocks is, well, bollocks, and I find the way children are taught to write currently incredibly stilted. It happens because they have to demonstrate that they know how to use various grammatical constructions in everything they write, no matter how inappropriate it might be to the work in question. It amazes me that no-one looks at the results and realises that, grammatically splendid it might be, it reads as utter garbage and they are not teaching good writing at all.

throwa · 22/11/2023 17:07

NoCloudsAllowed · 22/11/2023 16:25

I did a level English and German, the German teachers gave us grammar lessons as we didn't know any of it. That meant I was the only one who knew about grammar when it came to my English degree.

I think Gove imagined it would be like kids learning Latin where the grammar is complex. These politicians never send their own kids to state schools.

Latin grammar is complex but doesn't go down into the fronted adverbial hole! I learned all of my grammar from Latin which made French / Italian grammar easy in comparison (and then I got to Ancient Greek and its grammar, lets just leave that there), but the point is that Latin (and Greek) grammar was all fundamental to translating the language, as so much translation depended on the word endings.

For primary school pupils so long as they are working at a level where they can recognise the difference between nouns, adjectives, verbs and adverbs etc, that's fine for a y6!