Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find some Primary School teaching a bit pointless?

264 replies

Schooll · 22/11/2023 15:54

Every other day my child brings home homework asking her to identify a new type of pronoun, adjective etc.

My friend is over today too and we both work in fields that require a good standard of English. We cannot understand why we are still stressing children out with things like ‘identify the relative pronoun’, what use is this information?

Genuinely, when will my child ever need to know this and why is she spending so much time stressing over the different types when it’s unlikely to ever be needed again, unless she becomes a primary school teacher?

Am I missing something where this sort of information is actually really useful and we should still be using it to judge children’s intelligence in exams etc?

OP posts:
Sirzy · 22/11/2023 19:18

Ds is in year 9 and said to me last week “you know I don’t think we have used fronted adverbials once since I left primary schools”

Itha · 22/11/2023 19:14

It’s all from Gove’s personal opinion. He had way more power than brains unfortunately. You wait until they start learning about such things as fronted adverbials. 😐

The sad thing is it does feel like some kind of obedience training where we force them to spend huge chunks of their time doing something that they and we both know is pointless. If only they could be doing useful things like exercise, history, drama or or maths instead 😭 Maybe even learning how to identify toxic plants and nutritious plants, something our ancestors took for granted as basic knowledge.

All this type of ‘learning’ does is breaks the trust between child and adult which is so important for learning.

And then they wonder why teens are disrespectful…

avocadotofu · 22/11/2023 19:14

twistyizzy · 22/11/2023 15:56

Thank Gove. He decided that's what kids needed to learn. State schools have to teach what's in the National Curriculum which is decided by politicians not teachers.

Edited

Exactly this!

Sherrystrull · 22/11/2023 19:13

I haven't said phonics is the only strategy children are taught. It isn't. Rigorous and scaffolded phonics works for the majority of children alongside a clear and progressive reading curriculum.

bakewellbride · 22/11/2023 19:13

I agree op and I used to be a primary school teacher.

Now I'm a mum with a child in year 1 and he has to learn 'nonsense words' for a test.

I can hand on heart say I have never needed to calculate the angle of a triangle since gcse maths and am confident I will never need to for the rest of my life. What a waste of time that was!

Shinyandnew1 · 22/11/2023 19:11

babybythesea · 22/11/2023 19:09

The problem with the reliance on phonics to the exclusion of all else is that if children don’t get on with phonics they have absolutely nothing else to work with. Because it’s taught as the only strategy, what do you do if phonics doesn’t make sense to you, or you can’t remember it? It’s not that teaching phonics is wrong but other strategies could be given air time - at the moment it’s a one size fits all approach and it doesn’t.

Absolutely-Nick Gibb is very much behind this. If phonics doesn’t work for a small percentage of children-give them MORE phonics.

babybythesea · 22/11/2023 19:09

The problem with the reliance on phonics to the exclusion of all else is that if children don’t get on with phonics they have absolutely nothing else to work with. Because it’s taught as the only strategy, what do you do if phonics doesn’t make sense to you, or you can’t remember it? It’s not that teaching phonics is wrong but other strategies could be given air time - at the moment it’s a one size fits all approach and it doesn’t.

babybythesea · 22/11/2023 19:05

i also agree with teaching grammar but not to the depth it is currently done.
It’s like saying ‘we need to teach science’ and then deciding that this means putting quantum physics and molecular chemistry in Year 3.
I’m a TA and I do a lot of support work with children falling behind. Pps have carefully explained what a fronted adverbial is in an effort to explain why learning about them is important, and just how simple it really is. That’s fine, and makes sense, if you can remember what an adverbial is. If you’ve learnt so many terms that you cannot dredge the meaning of adverbial out of your brain, then fronted adverbial means nothing more than ‘here’s something else I can’t do.’ It’s like giving someone a list of obscure mosses using the scientific names, and then being puzzled when they can’t remember it. It makes sense to me, and is logical, so why can’t you remember it? Why can’t we use the common names of common species so at least everyone knows what the key rules are and why it’s important- why does it need to be so technical? (A beautiful mixed metaphor!) What does that achieve?

And then when writing is judged on criteria like ‘how many fronted adverbials did they use’ rather than vocabulary, or did they create atmosphere, it becomes the writing equivalent of painting by numbers.

Sherrystrull · 22/11/2023 19:02

As an experienced Ks1 teacher I see the impact of rigorous and scaffolded teaching of phonics and reading. Many of our children have little language from home and aren't heard read. Phonics provides children with the greatest chance of learning to read. Yes it's not for everyone but it is for the majority. Children are also fine learning alternative graphemes and pronunciations as well as split vowel digraphs.

ReadyForPumpkins · 22/11/2023 18:55

Towwanthustice · 22/11/2023 16:09

I was an English teacher and ATM I home school. I honestly don't fill my child's head with that crap.
Why do we need to write persuasive speeches and learn anomalies or similies?
I teach her what's important for life, like writting letters and sending emails.
Just like what do we need to learn Algebra. When do we use it?

The algebra comment shows how out of touch you are with people who work in different fields.

Algebra is such a basic concept in mathematics. I can’t imagine I can do calculus without knowing algebra. Calculus is the basis of engineering and I couldn’t have completed my degree without that. I also think of many day to day problems with algebra. It’s a very logical way of presenting problems with variables and then solving it.

RaininSummer · 22/11/2023 18:47

It is very odd and probably kills all love of reading and writing. As a primary child in the late 60s and early 70s, I do not remember being taught formal grammar at all but did loads of creative writing and read copiously which has resulted in pretty good literacy (I think).

ohfook · 22/11/2023 18:45

It's a load of shit that was brought into effect in 2014 and in my opinion actively kills children's enjoyment of writing.

PartTimePartyPooper · 22/11/2023 18:43

@coxesorangepippin but grammar and reading are not mutually exclusive. Once I had learned to read, I don’t think I read much during primary school; we tended to read at home (school reading book or local library). As there was nothing on TV I spent a lot of my spare time reading. I was lucky that I had a primary teacher who noticed I was slightly brighter than average and taught me “old school” grammar - otherwise i would have drifted through the progressive free-flow education my primary school randomly dished out without much idea of the basic structure of language. As a result of being given that grammatical “toolkit” I shone among my state-school peers, got heavily into literature and got a place at Oxbridge. I don’t think my peers stood a chance really - even though some were equally as bright as me, the school was focused on creativity and “learning through self-discovery” rather than actually teaching anything.

I would be upset if things went back to that post-70s nonsense.

maybe there is a happier compromise to be had!

Shinyandnew1 · 22/11/2023 18:42

I don’t think anyone on this thread is saying primary schools shouldn’t teach grammar. I think having an excellent grasp of word types is very useful. Knowing how to construct sentences is extremely useful as well, as is punctuating them correctly. It’s how it’s done though that’s the problem.

I don’t see what’s wrong with children using the word connective-this has been replaced with conjunction for no discernible reason. Connective made sense as it connects two parts of a sentence. I don’t see why ‘expanded noun phrase’ is necessary for year 2-what’s wrong with ‘adding description to your writing with adjectives’. I don’t see why ‘fronted adverbials of time’ needs to exist. What was wrong with ‘time’ connectives/sentence starters?

Too many pointless things are forced on children when they are too young and then they get muddled up and don’t remember the basics.

Expand noun phrase= write some more adjectives!?!

Shadowsindarkplaces · 22/11/2023 18:37

I think we were taught the verb, noun, and adjectives at school, but I didn't really understand it. I looked a complete twit on a German exchange and went to an English class with my German partner, and was asked to identify them in their class reading, I didn't have a clue.
DGSs are taught all of the above mentioned, I don't have a clue what they are talking about.

coxesorangepippin · 22/11/2023 18:31

I agree with the op

Not to say that it was all better back in the day, but we learnt all this by actually reading

Instead they are teaching the theory instead, which is more tedious

PartTimePartyPooper · 22/11/2023 18:31

I was expecting this thread to be more generals - what’s the point of learning a marginal language like French when I’m a few years we will all have a simultaneous-translation headset and my child will never live or work in France? What’s the point of learning IT when AI is going to destroy all jobs as we know them?

As for formal grammar - I’m not a fan of Gove (I detest him) but learning formal grammar has helped my daughter with her grasp of complex sentence construction. She isn’t naturally gifted at English but her standard is far superior to the average year 6 pupil of my equivalent primary school in the 80s. And I do think the focus on grammar genuinely supported this.

And now, when she is pointlessly learning French and Spanish at secondary school, she is finding her grammar skills really handy to help her unlock the different grammars of the languages she is forced to learn.

So I think grammar sits pretty happily amongst all the other pointless crap we are teaching our kids!

Hamburgler666 · 22/11/2023 18:31

Also the posts about this being a state school thing. Mine is at private and they still do all of this crap there!

Madameprof · 22/11/2023 18:30

So much of what is taught in schools is pointless. Naming parts of speech is one example. Lots of the deeply theoretical maths in GCSE that has no practical application in real life is another.

I'm a grammar geek and languages person who did A-Level English. I get annoyed by people misusing apostrophes and when my husband doesn't know what an adverb is. But I STILL think there is way too much grammar being taught in primary schools. Learning to use language well through extensive reading and exposure to different types of texts is so much more important.

Hamburgler666 · 22/11/2023 18:29

WallaceinAnderland · 22/11/2023 16:12

It's just general knowledge and has always been taught. People ought to know the difference between a noun and an adjective. It's pretty basic really.

I agree. However, the problem is it goes way beyond this and is completely confusing and pointless.

I help my year 4 child with their English and I have to look up what the meaning because I have no idea!

Disillusioned11 · 22/11/2023 18:28

Fronted adverbial from the example given by previous poster

I leant about fronted adverbial earlier today.

Earlier today, I meant about fronted adverbials.

The placement matters because it changes the emphasis of the sentence. Sentence 1 - the key part is the learning. Sentence 2 - the time it was learned is given equal importance.

Using the correct terminology is important because it means children can link it. Magic ‘e’ means I only know what to do with the ‘e’
Split digraph means I know What to do with them all.

napody
I wholeheartedly disagree with the idea that teaching had to be ‘motivational and fun’ at every turn. In my opinion that is one of the fundamental failures of modern society’s view on learning. And child psychology doesn’t substantiate it at all. It’s why we have children with absolutely no resilience to anything at all. If it’s hard or requires work, they can’t / won’t do it.
Learning should be challenging. It should take effort.

SPAG becomes pointless because of the obsession with testing it as a separate ‘subject’ and so it is a tick box memory exercise not a writing tool. In most other countries, it’s taught as part of the writing process. That’s the point of it - to understand how it changes meaning and emphasis. And it essential to learning foreign languages but we don’t care about that in this country either as ‘everyone speaks English’

BogRollBOGOF · 22/11/2023 18:27

modgepodge · 22/11/2023 18:06

But if you came across a new word - say ‘noke’ - would you have any idea how to pronounce it? I bet most people would pronounce it to rhyme with joke, because they know that o consonant e makes an /oa/ sound. I learned that as ‘magic e’ at school. Split digraph is just another way of saying magic e really. I find it useful to have the children understand that language - when my 4 year old daughter comes across a word she doesn’t recognise - say ‘joke’ and sounds it out as ‘j-o-k-e…jok-e’ I just say ‘split digraph’ and she she then says ‘j-oa-k…joke’. To me that’s useful language to understand.

Alphablocks explains split digraphs nicely in an age appropriate way.

At the start of y1, my 5yo came out of school very excited because his name has a split digraph. It's a shame that he couldn't actually write his name accurately which is a pretty useful skill.

I'm not convinced that it's so essential for children aged 5-11 to learn obscure grammar that I didn't encounter until GCSE and A-level MFL, particularly when most don't encounter competent MFL teaching until y7 anyway. Grammar is useful but most of us learn functional grammar in an intuitive way anyway.

I'd rather see a love of literature being encouraged, neat writing (not specifically cursive- dyslexic cursive is deeply unhelpful as a functional writing style) and encouragement of creativity, not tickbox cram these gramatical points in.

When young people get to secondary into the foundation subjects, many have a lack of general knowledge because the primary curriculum is often heavily taught to the test because of the emphisis on SATS.

It's also difficult getting my dyslexic children to recognise their intelligence and strengths because primary school puts so much time and emphisis on what is so unnatural for them to learn.

twistyizzy · 22/11/2023 18:27

LizzieBet14 · 22/11/2023 18:21

I teach Years 3 & 4 and the amount of grammar we have to throw at them is ridiculous!
There is way too much for them to grasp to the point where even the bright ones have forgotten what a nouns, adjectives & verbs are!!
We're setting them up to fail 😔

Yes this! DD did SATS this year Yr 6 (State school) and scored 113 for both English papers. In her (Private school) Yr 7 English term assessment she only scored 10/14 because she couldn't remenber how to identify or use adverbs in a paragraph. The reason: they spent so long on the bloody Gove theory crap in Yr 6 that she has forgotten the fundamentals of how to actually use correct grammar in writing. The kids who went to the private prep and never had to know fronted adverbial scored higher because all their English work at prep was about how to use the English language rather than abstract terminology over application.

Moglet4 · 22/11/2023 18:27

WallaceinAnderland · 22/11/2023 16:12

It's just general knowledge and has always been taught. People ought to know the difference between a noun and an adjective. It's pretty basic really.

I’m an English teacher and I agree that they need to know different types of nouns, verb, adjective, adverb. However, the primary curriculum is utterly ridiculous. Drives secondary teachers utterly insane considering half the time they can’t write in paragraphs when they arrive in year 7 but they can tell you about fronted adverbials and how to spell onomatopoeia!

socks1107 · 22/11/2023 18:26

Wait till you get to high school, a lot of it is irrelevant to current life and it needs a total overhaul.
Sixth form is so much better!