Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find some Primary School teaching a bit pointless?

264 replies

Schooll · 22/11/2023 15:54

Every other day my child brings home homework asking her to identify a new type of pronoun, adjective etc.

My friend is over today too and we both work in fields that require a good standard of English. We cannot understand why we are still stressing children out with things like ‘identify the relative pronoun’, what use is this information?

Genuinely, when will my child ever need to know this and why is she spending so much time stressing over the different types when it’s unlikely to ever be needed again, unless she becomes a primary school teacher?

Am I missing something where this sort of information is actually really useful and we should still be using it to judge children’s intelligence in exams etc?

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 23/11/2023 13:21

Shinyandnew1 · 23/11/2023 11:44

Disclaimer-retired English teacher here.

Did you teach/use ‘fronted adverbials of time’?

Adverbs and adverbials phrases aren't new or particularly challenging, fronted tells you where in the sentence to put/find it, time tells you what the phrase needs to do (ie when did the sentence take place.)

Before my own kids went through school I was really concerned about the approach to grammar and that it was going to be irretrievably dense and impossible for them (and me!) In reality it's just slightly new terminology for pretty mainstream grammatical concepts.

The fronted adverbial is a cause célèbre based on a pretty clunky term for something fairly straightforward.

Alohapotato · 23/11/2023 13:18

I learnt it in my first and second language at school, then knowing what is an adverd, modal verb, pronoun, fronted adverbial, modal verb, present vs past progressive was ver useful when I learnt French and English ..

JassyRadlett · 23/11/2023 13:12

MorganSeventh · 23/11/2023 11:17

I'm 50:50 on this. On the one hand, it does sound a bit much for primary school age. On the other, I'm one of the generation of 80s children who had very little formal grammar teaching. My English is okay, but I write by 'feel' and can't necessarily describe why a sentence is ungrammatical, although I can generally recognise that it is.

We also learned nothing at all about cases, or tenses beyond past, present and future, and that has definitely held me back on foreign language learning. So on the whole, I wish I had been taught grammar young enough that I had it to unconsciously draw upon. Trying to learn it as an adult is tough.

This resonates as I'm currently trying to revisit and improve my very rusty French and I've been very grateful to have that really ingrained knowledge of direct and indirect objects so I can apply the right pronouns quickly.

Shinyandnew1 · 23/11/2023 11:44

Disclaimer-retired English teacher here.

Did you teach/use ‘fronted adverbials of time’?

LadyMacbethssweetArabianhand · 23/11/2023 11:39

I think grammar is essential to have an understanding of the rules of a language. My knowledge of grammar rules came from studying Latin in secondary school, not primary. I feel you need to know why you use language a certain way, as well as exceptions to the rule. It helped me in my study of a number of languages such as french, German, Italian, Spanish and Russian. The teaching should be done in context though. I also don't understand why you wouldn't teach persuasive techniques. Surely you would want to know if and how someone is trying to influence you? Surely you would want to understand how to persuade others of the validity of your argument?
Disclaimer- retired English teacher here.

Elly46 · 23/11/2023 11:27

WallaceinAnderland · 22/11/2023 16:12

It's just general knowledge and has always been taught. People ought to know the difference between a noun and an adjective. It's pretty basic really.

I don’t believe op is referring to nouns and adjectives but rather things like past and present perfect tense etc.

LoveableDave · 23/11/2023 11:26

British teachers are infamous for their poor grammatical knowledge (broadly speaking). Those who have mastered this stuff are in high demand

Many of those teachers will be the products of the dopey no grammar theories, I've met many teachers who are unsure of simple things, like apostrophes for example. Our English department criticised us in Maths for expecting words like parallelogram, isosceles to be correctly spelt.
I was once doing supply in a Primary school where the Head berated another supply teacher for teaching multiplication tables and she was his wife! As we were both really High School teachers we just rolled our eyes.

MorganSeventh · 23/11/2023 11:17

I'm 50:50 on this. On the one hand, it does sound a bit much for primary school age. On the other, I'm one of the generation of 80s children who had very little formal grammar teaching. My English is okay, but I write by 'feel' and can't necessarily describe why a sentence is ungrammatical, although I can generally recognise that it is.

We also learned nothing at all about cases, or tenses beyond past, present and future, and that has definitely held me back on foreign language learning. So on the whole, I wish I had been taught grammar young enough that I had it to unconsciously draw upon. Trying to learn it as an adult is tough.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 23/11/2023 11:07

CaptainMyCaptain · 22/11/2023 16:00

What they all said. Have they done 'fronted adverbials' yet?

As someone who has always been hot on grammar, and was very well taught at school, I was totally bemused by ‘fronted adverbials’ for primary children, and still am!

We had to ‘parse’ sentences, but terms were limited to noun (common or proper), verb, adjective, adverb, conjunction, preposition, etc.

IMO there’s no denying that a good grounding in grammar is very helpful for both native speech and learning foreign languages, but I often think that rather than ‘fronted adverbials’ it might be more useful to teach them where to put an apostrophe, not to mention the difference between it’s/its, your/you’re, there/their/they’re, who’s/whose, etc.
These things really are not difficult, assuming the teacher is clued up of course - sadly not invariably a given nowadays.

Deathwillbebutapause · 23/11/2023 10:53

I think knowing the correct grammatical terms matters more than being able to draw a number line for 2x - 5 > 13, but I'm in the minority.

I have worked as a language teacher overseas and unfortunately British teachers are infamous for their poor grammatical knowledge (broadly speaking). Those who have mastered this stuff are in high demand .

Cattenberg · 23/11/2023 10:45

I think the focus on fronted adverbials could actually hinder children’s attempts at writing clearly and concisely, and developing their own writing style.

Imagine if Gove was in charge of a publishing house, insisting that Margaret Atwood and Ian McEwan edit their novels to include more relative clauses and fronted adverbials.

KvotheTheBloodless · 23/11/2023 10:33

I read English at Cambridge, I have no idea what a fronted adverbial is!

Some of it is bonkers, I agree.

I do think it's important to understand basic rules of grammar though, and punctuation/spelling. Learning to write persuasively is teaching children how to influence readers, which is really important if they're going to have their voices heard.

There's a balance to be struck.

Cattenberg · 23/11/2023 10:26

YANBU. English was my favourite subject at primary school and I loved writing stories. But I suspect that the focus on shoehorning fronted adverbials and other grammatical features into stories would have killed that enjoyment stone dead.

In late primary school (early 90s), we did learn about the main word classes especially nouns and verbs. I do wish we’d had an introduction to tenses, though. My first real encounter with them was in French lessons at secondary school!

SeedyM · 23/11/2023 10:25

I don’t think you do need to know all the grammar to have a good standard of written English. I was from the generation that got no English grammar tuition and still managed to get two English degrees and work in a job that required a lot of cogent writing. However, I have struggled to learn foreign languages without having the conscious grasp of linguistic structure and the names for elements of grammar. So I wish I had been taught and I think it does have a use.

Shinyandnew1 · 23/11/2023 10:09

tttigress · 23/11/2023 06:32

Speaking as someone that started to learn German at the age of 35 (currently living in a German speaking country), I would say it is important, in order to properly learn a foreign language.

If you don't understand the grammar structures of your own language, what hope have you got for a foreign language?

I think saying to kids hey you don't need to learn grammar, is the limit their opportunities on the world.

I think saying to kids hey you don't need to learn grammar is the limit their opportunities on the world

I don’t think there is a single person on this thread who is saying that. Read what people are actually saying about the primary curriculum.

DdraigGoch · 23/11/2023 09:55

Finteq · 22/11/2023 16:07

We never had to learn any of this.

But I've been told it might help if they have to learn a foreign language???

So they know what a pronoun is etc. when learning french or spanish.

A lot of it is just checking - does this sentence make sense.

We are working on a lot of this for 11 plus prep. But I think in Secondary school they don't care as much????

I can sort of see this. When I started learning a second language as an adult I had to be taught what the indefinite article was, even though I've been using it unconsciously for years.

Liveanlearn · 23/11/2023 09:49

Drives me mad. My Year 4 loves creative writing and (I think) writes really well and has some lovely ideas. Trouble is at school now she is constantly being told that what she writes is wrong, because it doesn't contain the right mix/formula of grammar. I encourage her to read widely and keep writing but it's so disheartening.

Sartre · 23/11/2023 09:29

English lit lecturer here and I totally agree. A lot of it was Gove. I have cousins who teach primary age and friends who teach secondary, they all hate it too. Fronted adverbials got me! We don’t ask for any of this shit when you do an actual English degree fwiw so it’s all useless information.

celticprincess · 23/11/2023 09:29

As others have said. Blame the politicians.

I suspect from another point of view that it’s to do with understanding how the English language is made up and why grammar changes and can be so complicated. Then it can be applied. But I agree personally it’s a waste of time. I’m a teacher and it’s the same with some maths. I had a child with additional needs who was able to do the old fashioned column addition and subtraction. Without fail for it right. But I wasn’t allowed to teach it in that year group and technically they shouldn’t have been taught it until later. Instead they have to do alsorts of complicated multistep chunking of bigger numbers so that they understand the values of the hundreds tens and units columns ans why we ‘borrow’ or ‘exchange’ digits etc. but I reality this child couldn’t get to grips with all the other methods and was perfectly secure in the old fashioned method (possibly taught at home as we hadn’t done it at school). At the end of the day people will revert to what they know and can apply.

we were always told you won’t have a calculator when you’re out shopping so mental maths is important. You won’t have a spell check or dictionary to help you out etc!! In reality we have all those things on our phones.

I do believe we need to teach good grammar, know the difference between their, there and they’re and my biggest bug bear - bought/brought which are two totally different root words which people often get wrong as they have totally different meanings. But finger adverbials and go as far as I’m concerned. It may all help with learning foreign languages but come GCSE they aren’t even compulsory these days.

FloweryPumpkin1 · 23/11/2023 09:24

I used to be a primary school teacher and bloody hated teaching all this. Agree with PPs that knowing BASIC grammar is important (noun, verb, adverb etc).

I used to have a colleague who had an encyclopaedic knowledge of grammar and was also an inspirational teacher. She found the most creative and engaging ways of teaching this stuff, and the kids in her class loved SPAG. The problem is that most teachers didn't cover all this at school (me included) and it's bloody difficult to understand, which leads to very dry teaching. Even then, I'm not sure what use it actually is apart from learning a second language.

I honestly think you'd get better results if you removed all but basic SPAG from the curriculum and replaced it with reading, listening to books read aloud, and listening to audiobooks. Lots of different texts written by authors with different writing styles, so a huge and varied exposure to different grammatically-correct ways of expressing ideas. I would bet my house this would result in better writing and a stronger grasp of grammar- with the added bonus of being enjoyable and exposing children to new ideas/times/places.

I've taught a lot of kids to write. In my experience, it's ALWAYS the children who are avid readers who turn into great writers (and spellers). Being read to/listening to audiobooks also works. In fact, I'd go as far as to say that it might be better to leave writing for a couple of years and focus most of the KS1 curriculum on reading and storytelling.

JassyRadlett · 23/11/2023 09:07

I think I have a slightly different perspective. I went through a school system in a different country where we did learn grammar in quite a bit of detail. And now I am in a field where excellent communication is important but many people aren't hired specifically for their writing skills.

My experience over many years is that the people who are naturally proficient and successful in fields where writing is important are fine. They're generally voracious readers and absorbed the rules more or less by osmosis because they had so much exposure to them.

I find that grammar is more useful with those who have less natural aptitude for it. It's helpful to be able to explain why that particular construction sounds jarring, or why that sentence structure isn't correct and many people will trip up reading it, or why you don't need seventeen commas in every sentence. Because when they know why it doesn't work, they can apply that in the future.

I've seen it with one of my own kids as well - his writing improved out of sight as he learned grammar and felt more confident that he knew what was "right" and was more willing to take risks. It was definitely a lesson for me as I was always an enthusiastic creative writer and unpicking why he found it challenging and overwhelming was fascinating and a real lesson for me. And now he's learning foreign languages properly he's definitely finding it useful.

Overall, with nearly 30 years in the field, I do think the overall standard of grammatical proficiency is declining, and I wonder if it's linked to the rise of social media and a reduction in people's exposure to many different styles of long form text. The latest innovation seems to be "when in doubt, shove in a comma". If a bit of grammar teaching can reverse that trend I'm very much in favour of it!

That said, I do find some of the attitudes on this thread a bit odd - that if everyone doesn't benefit in adulthood from being taught x, y, or z then it's pointless. I may not use physics or chemistry terribly much in my day to day life but I absolutely reap the benefits of the work of those who do!

Matronic6 · 23/11/2023 08:54

WallaceinAnderland · 22/11/2023 16:12

It's just general knowledge and has always been taught. People ought to know the difference between a noun and an adjective. It's pretty basic really.

If you are going to make a comment about it, at least have the foresight to go and look at the at the NC. Noun and adjective are common knowledge and should be taught. The present perfect, subjunctive form and passive voice are not common knowledge and there is no reason to teach them to 9/10 year olds.

DisquietintheRanks · 23/11/2023 08:50

bearfood · 22/11/2023 17:24

I am an English teacher and I couldn't agree more!

That's interesting. I used to think like the OP (still do to an extent) but there's no denying that my dc have found a lot of what they learnt useful when it's come to English Language and Literature gcses and, with A level drama, even more so.

Passepartoute · 23/11/2023 08:50

Poudretteite · 23/11/2023 06:59

Agree...if there is an academy near you, the curriculum is decided by parents and teachers instead.

I suspect that will come as a massive surprise to most parents of children in academies. the reality is that the curriculum is mostly decided by the academy trust's governing body with the headteachers and senior staff, and is mostly tailored to the requirements of national testing.

purplehair1 · 23/11/2023 08:50

I’m learning Spanish and I think if I had been able to remember ANY grammar (I can just about remember what a verb and a noun is)it would have been helpful.