Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find some Primary School teaching a bit pointless?

264 replies

Schooll · 22/11/2023 15:54

Every other day my child brings home homework asking her to identify a new type of pronoun, adjective etc.

My friend is over today too and we both work in fields that require a good standard of English. We cannot understand why we are still stressing children out with things like ‘identify the relative pronoun’, what use is this information?

Genuinely, when will my child ever need to know this and why is she spending so much time stressing over the different types when it’s unlikely to ever be needed again, unless she becomes a primary school teacher?

Am I missing something where this sort of information is actually really useful and we should still be using it to judge children’s intelligence in exams etc?

OP posts:
Deathwillbebutapause · 24/11/2023 07:29

Indeed.

It's disheartening how many teachers fervidly believe that teaching British children to write "Once upon a time COMMA" is both desperately difficult and useless.

I now spend far too many work hours trying to decipher gibberish from native English speakers who cannot write a single coherent paragraph. Punctuation may as well never have been invented. And it's not the subbies, it's the office managers with university degrees who are the least literate.

On the other hand, I read one works summary yesterday that was like a breath of fresh air. It was written by a recently-arrived Ukrainian contractor who had taken utmost pains to write as clearly as possible. Thanks, Myroslav.

larkstar · 24/11/2023 00:03

I'm guessing that you've never learned another language - it proved to be extremely useful to understand the building blocks of a language.

afuckinggoat · 23/11/2023 22:01

I was a primary school teacher for 10 years and have a special interest in grammar.

Without a solid understanding of the structure of our own language, accessing foreign languages becomes very difficult.

For children with a more mathematical brain, knowing and applying the rules of grammar and sentence composition can be a safe and reassuring route into writing.

For the majority of children, learning correct grammatical rules and technical terminology is not hard; from 4 year olds learning about digraphs in phonics, to 10 year olds learning about the subjunctive mood, most of them do get it.

Yes, for some children, learning about using a "subordinate clause" in Year 2 is going to be a challenge, but surely no one would advocate for an education system where the only content taught is pitched at the level of the least able learner? That is what differentiation is for.

MimsyBorogrove69 · 23/11/2023 17:46

I'm a TA. Last week I took out a group of three 8 year olds, who can barely read, to teach them about fronted adverbial phrases. A complete waste of my time and the poor children. The primary English curriculum is absolutely stultifying. It's shameful.

Pliudev · 23/11/2023 17:45

It's not about knowing the difference between a noun and an adjective. It's about archane grammatical definitions no adult will ever need to be aware of. Pre Gove the English language GCE syllabus was about competent use of language and understanding. He wrecked that and now primary school children are being taught this pointless information. I have a PhD and had to look some of this stuff up when I was tutoring. Thank goodness I don't have to teach it in school.

LadyMacbethssweetArabianhand · 23/11/2023 17:36

Shinyandnew I taught adverbs of time, manner and place. Never called them 'fronted' as that wasn't a term used in Scottish education as far as I'm aware. But adverbs were part of the primary curriculum. I see nothing wrong with primary schools teaching adverbs

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 23/11/2023 17:34

We cannot understand why we are still stressing children out with things like ‘identify the relative pronoun’, what use is this information?

Why on earth do people insist on regarding any grammatical terminology as 'stressful'? It's no more stressful than maths, science or geography terminology. Certainly, it's debatable how much of it they need to know in primary school, but there's nothing actually wrong with learning the names for different kinds of words.

Parents tend to be scared by it because they (unfortunately) didn't learn it at school. After 28 years of being an MFL teacher, it's frankly a relief to finally teach Year 7s who know a bit more than a vague idea of what a noun and an adjective are. Children in other countries learn about how their own language works - why shouldn't ours? I don't see why it's prefictably any less useful in life than lots of other things they learn!

Iamnotthe1 · 23/11/2023 17:27

Shinyandnew1 · 23/11/2023 13:29

The fronted adverbial is a cause célèbre based on a pretty clunky term for something fairly straightforward.

Indeed, which is what people on this thread are talking about. Nobody here has a problem with teaching a robust understanding of the parts of speech and uses of tenses and punctuation

Using clunky terms for straightforward terms confuses young children and becomes an abstract term that they can’t remember.

What was wrong with connectives, time words and magic e for 4-7 year olds?

The terms aren't seen as clunky when they are the first and only terms taught. They are just the correct term for the thing the child is being exposed to. Learning that it's a split digraph is no more difficult than learning it's a magic e special rule: both involve the memorisation of new vocabulary. However, one is the correct term and would never need to be unlearned. The other is a shortcut that becomes wrong in the future.

We don't say that children should avoid learning a second language because the vocabulary can be unusual and difficult: why do we underestimate the capabilities of children in other areas of the curriculum?

Iamnotthe1 · 23/11/2023 17:17

Shutthedoormargaret · 23/11/2023 16:25

Thanks for your reply @ColleenDonaghy 😊

Sorry - I replied earlier in the thread but just pressed reply rather than quote so it didn't tag you 😂. Just in case you thought I'd ignored your question.

Shivermetimbersmearty · 23/11/2023 17:15

As someone who has learned a couple of foreign languages to an advanced level, grammar is very useful for that.

but agree frontal adverbials and the like are a waste of time- my DC got all this too.

pointless- but will come in useful when correcting people’s grammar on mumsnet in the future! 🤦‍♀️

Shutthedoormargaret · 23/11/2023 16:25

ColleenDonaghy · 23/11/2023 07:14

Pretty much any decision around an unknown quantity is you doing algebra.

  • the recipe is for 4 eggs but I only have 3, how should I adjust the other quantities?
  • DC's present costs £100, how much do I need to save per week to be able to afford it?
  • I need to be at my appointment in two hours, the train takes half an hour and there's a walk, what time should I leave?
  • my favourite team or athlete is 10 points behind, what do they need to do to win?

Thanks for your reply @ColleenDonaghy 😊

Casperroonie · 23/11/2023 16:10

Welcome to the curriculum the Tories brought in.

I'm.pretty sure no great writer ever worried too much about learning different word types etc. Yes they are useful but not at such depth.

I'm a primary school teacher.

catmothertes1 · 23/11/2023 16:06

RaraRachael · 23/11/2023 13:47

I have an A in Higher English and was a primary school teacher in Scotland for 40 years. Thank goodness Gove's grammar obsession was never made compulsory here. If I'd taught in England I'd have had to learn all this stuff as I have no idea what most of it means.

In 40 years of teaching and 60 years of life, I've never needed it either so it's a pointless heap of shite.

Funny enough,I was a French teacher in Scotland. Pupils not understanding grammar made my life so much harder.

JassyRadlett · 23/11/2023 14:33

Shinyandnew1 · 23/11/2023 13:29

The fronted adverbial is a cause célèbre based on a pretty clunky term for something fairly straightforward.

Indeed, which is what people on this thread are talking about. Nobody here has a problem with teaching a robust understanding of the parts of speech and uses of tenses and punctuation

Using clunky terms for straightforward terms confuses young children and becomes an abstract term that they can’t remember.

What was wrong with connectives, time words and magic e for 4-7 year olds?

I mean OP was complaining about relative pronouns, which are a fairly standard and very useful part of speech.

Meanwhile, fronted adverbials aren't taught to 4-7 year olds, they're taught in Year 4 and if Year 4 kids can't figure out the combination of "front", "adverb" and (in the example upthread) "time" then I think we're probably in more trouble than we thought. I'm not fond of it as a mellifluous phrase - the "fronted" gives away where it sprang from really - but it's hardly inaccessible.

As I said, fronted adverbials have become everyone's favourite bogeyman when in reality, we probably don't need these kids to know the grammatical terms by the time they're at GCSE, we need them to have practised them enough earlier to have a degree of familiarity and facility with how they work. Even the kids who aren't the voracious readers. Just like you wouldn't expect kids in secondary to remember the phonics terms from reception and year 1, but they can still read using the skills they picked up back then.

Tumbleweed101 · 23/11/2023 14:00

Reading is the best teacher of writing.

Sherrystrull · 23/11/2023 13:52

To clarify, split vowel digraphs are taught in year 1 when children are 5/6. I've taught them many times and children generally have no problems understanding them.

RaraRachael · 23/11/2023 13:47

I have an A in Higher English and was a primary school teacher in Scotland for 40 years. Thank goodness Gove's grammar obsession was never made compulsory here. If I'd taught in England I'd have had to learn all this stuff as I have no idea what most of it means.

In 40 years of teaching and 60 years of life, I've never needed it either so it's a pointless heap of shite.

Shinyandnew1 · 23/11/2023 13:42

Can't believe so many people are arguing for keeping the old no grammar teaching of the 1980s.

I don’t think a single person on this thread is arguing for that.

You are correct though that some people really struggle with comprehension.

WillowCraft · 23/11/2023 13:37

The standard of written English is appalling in this country - as is comprehension - as is ability to speak foreign languages. So many people struggle through life because of this. What is school for if not to to equip people with life skills? Can't believe so many people are arguing for keeping the old no grammar teaching of the 1980s.

GinAndJuice99 · 23/11/2023 13:35

It's pointless because it's only taught in primary school and by the time they hit year 9 they've no more idea of what a fronted adverbial is than we have

WillowCraft · 23/11/2023 13:33

Nanny0gg · 22/11/2023 18:00

As a child I read everything I could get my hands on (old person here)
My spelling and punctuation is good, my vocabulary excellent and my grammar was better than many teachers I worked with. I do credit that to the authors I read. Never had a problem with writing stories or essays. However, I wouldn't know a fronted adverbial if it bit me on the arse. I probably used them happily in my writing as a kid without having the first idea of what they are.

I also got through life up till the age of 30-something without actually knowing what a digraph was and I still don't think that's a vital piece of knowledge for a primary school child.

There are a lot of people on this thread saying "I didn't learn it and I am doing fine" , and I'm sure they are right, I also write professionally and credit hours spent reading as a child for my ability.

But we only have to look on Facebook to see that the majority in this country cannot communicate correctly in their own language. So clearly they didn't pick up anything useful from reading. Perhaps the bottom two thirds benefit more from this explicit teacing than the top 10% that are probably most of the people responding to this thread.

Phonics is likely similar - people of above average ability learned to read fine using any old method, some books and a bit of encouragement and practice. However as anyone attending a mediocre state school can tell you, back in the 90s there was a high proportion of 12 year olds unable to read aloud fluently. In my mixed ability year 7 class there were only a handful who could read a sentence without stalling. I think the phonics methods used now hopefully mean that all children should be able to learn to read confidently, and not just the more able ones.

Shinyandnew1 · 23/11/2023 13:29

The fronted adverbial is a cause célèbre based on a pretty clunky term for something fairly straightforward.

Indeed, which is what people on this thread are talking about. Nobody here has a problem with teaching a robust understanding of the parts of speech and uses of tenses and punctuation

Using clunky terms for straightforward terms confuses young children and becomes an abstract term that they can’t remember.

What was wrong with connectives, time words and magic e for 4-7 year olds?

Moglet4 · 23/11/2023 13:25

Shinyandnew1 · 23/11/2023 11:44

Disclaimer-retired English teacher here.

Did you teach/use ‘fronted adverbials of time’?

Or my personal favourite: ‘split digraphs’ for four year olds! I am also an English teacher btw. This stuff is absolute nonsense

GreenMarigold · 23/11/2023 13:25

Personally I find the structure of language fascinating so I am quite pleased my children are being taught more about it than I was at school.

There are certain aspects of it, like being able to identify clauses within a sentence, that allow you to communicate more clearly and effectively.

I don’t think knowing the names of each structure is essential to effective communication but it is easier to teach something if it has an identity.