Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find some Primary School teaching a bit pointless?

264 replies

Schooll · 22/11/2023 15:54

Every other day my child brings home homework asking her to identify a new type of pronoun, adjective etc.

My friend is over today too and we both work in fields that require a good standard of English. We cannot understand why we are still stressing children out with things like ‘identify the relative pronoun’, what use is this information?

Genuinely, when will my child ever need to know this and why is she spending so much time stressing over the different types when it’s unlikely to ever be needed again, unless she becomes a primary school teacher?

Am I missing something where this sort of information is actually really useful and we should still be using it to judge children’s intelligence in exams etc?

OP posts:
Rockhopper81 · 25/11/2023 15:18

Sirzy · 25/11/2023 13:45

The problem with algebra and too much maths is real day to day application isn’t used enough when teaching it so people don’t actually realise how much they do use it. My dad was a nurse for 30 years but is still adamant he never used algebra even when it is explained about medication dosages etc.

I think if real world application was used more people would find it a lot less daunting.

This is spot on!! It's true of a lot of mathematics really, people think they don't use them because they don't see how they're applying them.

Nevermind31 · 25/11/2023 13:47

I found grammar to be really useful when I learnt other languages…

Sirzy · 25/11/2023 13:45

The problem with algebra and too much maths is real day to day application isn’t used enough when teaching it so people don’t actually realise how much they do use it. My dad was a nurse for 30 years but is still adamant he never used algebra even when it is explained about medication dosages etc.

I think if real world application was used more people would find it a lot less daunting.

HeeyMacarena · 25/11/2023 13:19

Glad to see someone sticking up for algebra!

I used simple algebra twice last week. Once to figure out is a piece of furniture I didn't have all the measurements for would fit in my daughter's room (song with a bit of Phythagous) and again at work to figure out how to budget the VAT costs. Algebra is a life skill, and not knowing it means you lack a very useful tool to solve all sorts of problems life will throw at you without having to resort to trial and error!

I'm an algebra fan.

I am not however a grammar fan, and I say that as someone who has learned several languages over my life!

Trishthedish · 25/11/2023 11:40

I worked in education and the amount of teaching staff who would weep when a new initiative was unveiled, was mega. I still have no clue as to what a fronted adverbial is and I’m 66.

zingally · 25/11/2023 11:05

As a primary school teacher, I completely agree!

Blame the government! It's all just total bollocks, and I certainly never learnt it at school! We did nouns, verbs and adjectives, that's it! But that being said, I feel like punctuation and spelling were more of a focus back then than they are now.

zdjptee · 25/11/2023 10:15

When it comes to learning foreign languages - other countries dont teach so much grammar because they love it but because it's necessary to speak correctly. Similarly as in English, it takes so long to read and write - it's much much easier to read German.

I teach in HE and no, our students' essays havent improved. In reality, they all just use chatgpt now which has kind of made this issue somewhat redundant.

waterdusky · 25/11/2023 09:57

The average reading comprehension age of UK adults is 9 years. I don't like Gove but the state schooling current adults were brought up in wasn't successful enough and we do need to raise standards. Grammar also opens doors to other skills too, such as foreign language learning. I see so many adults who claim they are not competent language learners, but the actual problem is they don't know what a modal verb is or a subordinating clause, meaning they can't access textbooks or grammar books, or choose the correct word from a bilingual dictionary or they have to work longer and harder to understand a concept because they can't recognise it in English.

Rosejasmine · 25/11/2023 09:21

It’s basic grammar and the fundamentals of the English language. It would be a shame if good grades at GCSE English Language could only be achieved by children attending elite private schools wouldn’t it?

privateano · 25/11/2023 08:46

gotomomo · 22/11/2023 16:19

I've got 2 degrees, a job that requires a high degree of literacy yet hadn't got a clue about these names of grammatical things, nor maths - I learnt things intuitively and never learned phonics either, wasn't the thing in the 70's. It's such a waste of time

I agree with most of what you say, though I do think that some need more than very basic maths. Also phonics does seem to work when they're learning to read - two of my children did phonics and two didn't, the latter took much longer to learn. Perhaps this doesn't work for all children, but my GS is almost reading now without any stress after starting school in September.
DD and I were talking about this the other day after yet another ridiculously long grammar homework session. It seems that in many people's opinion (including teachers) it is completely unnecessary. If they need more grammar later because they're studying Latin or whatever they can do it then.
I'm in my 70's and remember learning basic grammar, it's been enough for me and I'm educated to masters standard. There are so many more important things for them to be learning.

Shinyandnew1 · 25/11/2023 08:26

It’s been nearly ten years since Gove implemented this curriculum. If it’s been working so fabulously well, I presume there are now lots of secondary teachers and university lecturers who are being dazzled on a daily basis by the literacy skills of these children?!

Emeraldrings · 25/11/2023 08:03

I hope this changes before my DS has to learn this because I think I would struggle, never mind him.
My older teenagers never had to learn this stuff and seem to have turned out okay. Gove is a complete twat and I bet even teachers can't see the point of having to teach this.

EveSix · 25/11/2023 07:57

Celestia 😂 Seriously?
Just in case this is in earnest ‐life skills such as how to make toast are definitely ones to be taught at home. What is parenting if not this?

I teach sewing across the primary age range to whole classes. Believe me, what I accomplish with 30 9-year olds in 40 minutes you can do in 5 at home, and so much better. Ditto most practical things.

ColleenDonaghy · 25/11/2023 07:18

CelestiaNoctis · 25/11/2023 02:04

It's like my kid learning about vikings. Sure, it's interesting but what use is it. I'd rather she learned how to sew or use a toaster safely or cpr, anything useful in the real world. I dunno why it's all left up to the parents. Like I have to sit her down and teach her how to make a sandwich when she goes to school for 7 hours a day to learn already. Teach her life skills there?

Life skills are our job as parents.

Moraxella · 25/11/2023 06:46

@Catza
seconded. Lots of trig/algebra required in my part of medicine

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 25/11/2023 06:33

I'm perfectly willing to accept that, while I think a decent foundation of grammatical knowledge is good, the primary SPaG curriculum could do with tweaking. It seems odd that the only example of pointless primary school grammar that people can ever come up with is the fronted adverbial though. Although @Rockhopper81 you make a good point about the effect this kind of teaching can have on their writing, if it's not done well.

I do wonder if some of the SPaG hostility from some primary school teachers comes down to the fact that they simply don't have very good grammatical knowledge themselves (understandably, since they wouldn't have been taught it at school). My dc's primary school teachers regularly made SPaG mistakes and sometimes miscorrected children's 'mistakes'.

Echolocator · 25/11/2023 02:06

😂

CelestiaNoctis · 25/11/2023 02:04

It's like my kid learning about vikings. Sure, it's interesting but what use is it. I'd rather she learned how to sew or use a toaster safely or cpr, anything useful in the real world. I dunno why it's all left up to the parents. Like I have to sit her down and teach her how to make a sandwich when she goes to school for 7 hours a day to learn already. Teach her life skills there?

Rockhopper81 · 24/11/2023 23:46

I don't think anybody would argue that children shouldn't be taught what nouns/verbs/adjectives/adverbs are, or that they shouldn't know how to use a wide range of punctuation correctly.

However...

This 'fronted adverbial' malarkey is complete hogwash, as are most of the other SPaG components of KS1/KS2. They do absolutely nothing to foster a love of learning, reading, and writing because children eventually learn to shoehorn all of that crap into a piece of writing to tick boxes for them being there, when in the real world nobody writes like that!

I say this as a teacher with an English degree who still struggled with aspects of the SPaG curriculum.

Catza · 24/11/2023 23:41

Towwanthustice · 22/11/2023 16:09

I was an English teacher and ATM I home school. I honestly don't fill my child's head with that crap.
Why do we need to write persuasive speeches and learn anomalies or similies?
I teach her what's important for life, like writting letters and sending emails.
Just like what do we need to learn Algebra. When do we use it?

You certainly don’t persuade me with your speech. The whole point of broad education is that it opens opportunities for children after school. You may never need to use algebra, however a child who discovers passion for astrophysics is not going to thank you when they find out that being able to write an email to a university admissions office is not enough to secure them a place.

NewShoes · 24/11/2023 23:12

I am a secondary school English teacher and this drives me mad. Children come in at 11 with their heads full of ‘fronted adverbials’ (?) but can’t use basic punctuation like commas or full stops. The emphasis is all wrong.

Nanny0gg · 24/11/2023 23:08

Wouldyouguess · 24/11/2023 20:26

I used to teach in secondary schools and the level of knowledge about language and grammar was abysmal, so going against the grain here (funnily enough foreign kids who were educated abroad had a much better grasp of their home language grammar and hence the English grammar too), it's kind of good to know what different parts of speech are and it helps learning other languages too,.

Absolutely. I think grammar, spelling and a broad vocabulary is important

But is it necessary to know such detail? As in, the dreaded fronted adverbial?

Harls1969 · 24/11/2023 22:30

Yep totally agree. I taught in a SEND school and didn't understand why we were teaching spag rather than just encouraging children to just write. It's not just English, I have never (apart from when teaching) needed to know the properties of a shape. We should be teaching more functional skills.

ipop · 24/11/2023 22:06

Understanding grammar not only aids in comprehending complex texts but also lays a foundation for learning foreign languages by providing a framework for language structure and rules. It serves as a fundamental skill that transcends linguistic boundaries and contributes significantly to effective communication across various contexts and languages.

Shinyandnew1 · 24/11/2023 20:37

Sorry, but I disagree with most of you. I teach at a uni (elite, Russell Group) and am absolutely shocked at the appalling ignorance in basic grammar of my students when it comes to writing essays

Were those students at Primary under Gove’s curriculum?