Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To end friendship with person with Borderline Personality Disorder?

33 replies

TheKingnessofMadGeorge · 22/11/2023 15:29

We've been friends for years, both in our 50s, but I'm finding her more and more difficult to deal with.

She has a kind heart but everything has to be her way. For example, if I need to rearrange a meet up because I'm ill, I get given the silent treatment. I very rarely have to rearrange but each and every time has been met with drama and passive aggression.

The main reason I've stayed friends with her so long is because I fear she'll kill herself if I back off, and she's lost every other friend bar one. She's very emotionally volatile.

Would it be cruel to end the friendship, simply to make my life easier?

Does anyone have any experience of being friends with someone with BPD?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GrumpyOldCrone · 23/11/2023 01:05

I have friends with BPD. My experience is that it was hard to become close friends with them because I needed to be constantly aware of my boundaries. But at the same time, my friends with BPD are some of the sweetest, kindest people in the world.

It’s up to you, OP. But it sounds like the friendship isn’t working for you. Any friendship can change over time, and you don’t have to stay friends with someone you no longer feel a good connection with.

bottleofbeer · 23/11/2023 00:45

BPD/EUPD is EXTREMELY difficult to cope with when you're the friend or family member.

If it's not vaguely controlled then yes, it is often an abusive relationship.

Sorry, it just is. If it's too much, walk away.

BPDandme · 22/11/2023 20:59

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 22/11/2023 17:10

I'm curious, as there have been a few people with BPD on this thread, have you ever had a friend with BPD also? How do you deal with both of you reacting to rejection so strongly?

I haven't had 1 that I know of. But I only found out I have it recently enough in my early 30s.

My guess would be an intense co-dependant mess! Me in my 20s had serious lack of impulse control. I def met people like that too. But I honestly do not want to consider what may have happened me if 1 of me had met another 1 of me!! I am more relaxed now and can take a step back from myself so I'm not sure if it would be some sort of explosion now

XenoBitch · 22/11/2023 20:56

YANBU. You can break off a friendship for any reason you want. However, if you are only staying in her life because you are worried she might harm herself, then that is not a friendship. It is also not fair on either of you to carry on as you are.

I have BPD, and have several friends with BPD. I have had to break off some friendships because I was just getting used as a therapist (and that was also with other MH diagnosis.. the worst drain on my energy was someone with depression). When I have been unwell, I have had people leave me too.

I have had years of therapy and DBT, so I now feel more accountable for my behaviours, and can recognise things better so people do not feel they need to leave.

CaroleSinger · 22/11/2023 18:23

I've actually done it as I had no choice. Everyone around her was being sucked into all her endless drama. She's now on medication and is much easier to be around.

FMLife · 22/11/2023 18:18

You can end a friendship for any reason you want.

BeautyFromBad · 22/11/2023 17:51

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 22/11/2023 17:10

I'm curious, as there have been a few people with BPD on this thread, have you ever had a friend with BPD also? How do you deal with both of you reacting to rejection so strongly?

I can only speak for myself, but over two decades ago, I had a friend also diagnosed and we were intense and dramatic. It felt like a toxic romance tbh.

More recently, I have made a friend with BPD and as we are older and further on, it’s one of the most nourishing friendships I have. We are totally honest with each other if we’re having an episode. And support each other in that. We can tease each other even.

I guess the beauty is that we do recognise it in ourselves. (And are both fairly stable right now.) I wouldn’t have done at my worst.

NewspaperTaxis · 22/11/2023 17:23

I had a friend who was a bit like this many years ago, in that I feared if I broke it off they'd kill themselves, they were a paranoid schizophrenic acc to them though if this were the case it manifested itself in endless talking and stupid inane puns - they had a tendency to be charm on first meeting and could turn it on with strangers, once they were bedded in they could offload on you. They could in fairness also be good company and we could laugh at the same things. My point is, you do this stuff the once and once only. I ended the set-up with a bit of the 'it's not you it's me' line, sort of defeatedly I bowed out in that spirit rather than having it out with them big time. But if I met that type again, I'd pick up on it pretty damn quick and avoid.

I'd been vain and thought I'd be a good influence originally, that they'd pick up on the correct way of being through me, that they were down on their luck and just needed to be shown the way a bit. Actually, if you're getting involved with someone like that, you'll be no influence on them but trust me, they'll influence you.

I found the thing very intense so with stuff like that if feels like you're in or you're out. Looking back, and same with another past relationship, I wonder why it couldn't be more a gradual detachment, like, okay, meet up in a couple of months or more rather than break it off but with some types you just can't feel you can do that, it's full on or it's off.

Electrolens · 22/11/2023 17:20

I don’t think you’d be unreasonable to end the friendship - or at least cool it off as that sounds exhausting. If you don’t want to end it completely could you try cooling it off, or more impromptu meet ups so there less expectation?

However, I’m afraid I do think you’re unreasonable to have BPD in your thread title and attribute her behaviour solely to her diagnosis. I have BPD - I have lots of friends and I don’t behave like that. If anything I bend over backwards to not cause a fuss and please my friends. That’s not always perfect. But it’s a diagnosis with so much stigma and honestly threads like this don’t help.

It sounds as if your friend has complex mental health needs and you’ve been a good friend to her, but it can’t be at the cost of your own mental health and you also mustn’t feel you are responsible for her health and well-being.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 22/11/2023 17:10

I'm curious, as there have been a few people with BPD on this thread, have you ever had a friend with BPD also? How do you deal with both of you reacting to rejection so strongly?

WhereYouLeftIt · 22/11/2023 17:10

"We've been friends for years" - that makes her an old friend. This is not the same as a good friend. And many an old friend fades into an acquaintance, in a way that good friends never do.

I honestly cannot reconcile the idea of someone having "a kind heart" yet also being nasty to someone's because their illness inconvenienced them. That is not the action of a kind-hearted person. It's just not. So please, stop telling yourself she has a kind heart - she doesn't.

Also, I don't think she sees you as a friend. You are entourage, audience, emotional punchbag. You are not, in her eyes, 'friend'. So really, the 'friendship' is already ended, it's just that you now have to acknowledge that.

Shed the 'friend' and the accompanying guilt. This acquaintance is not your responsibility.

itsmyp4rty · 22/11/2023 17:01

I think the only way you can play it if you want to stay friends is to put in strong boundaries and accept that she will find them very difficult and may need time out to accept them. If you can reframe things in that way - so instead of her giving you the silent treatment, you see it as her needing time out with her emotions - then it might help you to maintain the friendship.

She can't cope with you disagreeing with her because her self esteem is so low it feels like an attack on her I guess. Can you preface your opinions with, 'I completely understand where you're coming from but I see it like this'. So you are validating her but still able to give your own opinion.

At the end of the day though if this is impacting you to the point where it is affecting your mental health then you need to tell her. Just do it as gently and compassionately as you can - and remember you cannot be responsible for her mental health or the choices she makes.

CheatingCheetos · 22/11/2023 16:58

Fearing what might happen if you don’t maintain a friendship isn’t a reason to maintain a friendship.

You’re not unreasonable to want to back away. You don’t have to be cruel about it or make a big deal of it, just let the friendship wither and quietly withdraw.

Birdcar · 22/11/2023 16:53

You are on the receiving end of an abusive relationship.

It's not deliberate and it's not her fault but the impact on you is the same either way.

There's no shame in stepping away to protect yourself.

StephanieLampshade · 22/11/2023 16:47

Would you consider a contract. Ie a warning to her of behaviour you won't tolerate.

And give her that info. It might relive your guilt if you do end the friendship.

She may be able to control her behaviour better if she has this clarity.

It's likely she grew up with parents with erratic behaviour and boundaries. BPD can genuinely not realise when they've beyond what is acceptable because they grew up with their own boundaries violated.

BeautyFromBad · 22/11/2023 16:42

As @Concannon88 says, it has felt like torture at times. I will always have strong feelings, but I can control my behaviours much better now. I’m lucky, but it has taken work and I’m grateful that work has helped.

BeautyFromBad · 22/11/2023 16:40

I am diagnosed with BPD and used to have to work very hard to keep my worst impulses under control. Now though, with practice, it’s become easy.

But people have had to distance themselves or cut themselves off from me in the past. It hurt and I railed for a while. But, looking back, I get it. I do. I can be a good friend now, but it’s taken a lot of effort to get here.

I can’t comment on your friend or your friendship. We are all different. But there is no shame in looking after yourself and it sounds like you need to. Good luck. Looking after yourself is sometimes vital.

Concannon88 · 22/11/2023 16:39

I have experience, but it's from the other point of view:( if you dont want to be friends with her, then end it. However if shes acting this was because of bpd, then its difficult for her, no one would blame someone for having a broken leg or being deaf. Bpd is not an excuse to treat peole like shit, but it is the reason they overreact and feel things so immensely. It actually feels like torture sometimes and is very real.

ManyATrueWord · 22/11/2023 16:34

@TheKingnessofMadGeorge Time to let go then. It sounds abusive and controlling now. Save yourself.

TheKingnessofMadGeorge · 22/11/2023 16:32

ManyATrueWord · 22/11/2023 16:19

I've been close friends with a person with BPD. It's hard going and I wouldn't do it again. I became a human sticking plaster. I was naive, I thought it someone was loved unconditionally they would heal. Not the case. Once you start having needs of your own it is difficult to maintain the level of care needed. Keeping healthy boundaries is exhausting.

This is exactly how I feel. I felt so sorry for her in the beginning because she really has had a hard life but I've come to realise that my friendship will not make everything better for her.

To answer the other posters, no, she isn't seeking treatment. I've been there for her through various therapists and psychiatrists (all of whom were considered amazing by her at first but inevitably become the spawn of the devil for various reasons). I've been with her at A&E and the crisis centre for suicide attempts.

She always ends up feeling like they are all against her and stops attending.

I know she's ill but I just can't cope with it any more. I daren't contradict her opinions because she gets hugely offended so I just agree with everything she says.

OP posts:
ManyATrueWord · 22/11/2023 16:19

I've been close friends with a person with BPD. It's hard going and I wouldn't do it again. I became a human sticking plaster. I was naive, I thought it someone was loved unconditionally they would heal. Not the case. Once you start having needs of your own it is difficult to maintain the level of care needed. Keeping healthy boundaries is exhausting.

NotLactoseFree · 22/11/2023 16:14

I don't know anything about this but a quick google agrees with PP that personal relationships can be hard. I think I'd take the same approach her as I would with any mental health condition - is she actively seeking help and support to manage this condition and is she aware of the way she acts? After an episode, does she, for example, acknowledge her behaviour?

Because that for me is the key.

I think that if you really do value her, I think a message highlighting where she's being unfair and why, and a suggestion that she discuss it with her therapist might be in order.

If, on the other hand, you're simply supposed to put up with shitty behaviour because she is ill, then no, you would not be unreasonable to decide this friendship has run its course.

BPDandme · 22/11/2023 16:14

I very probably have BPD but haven't been officially diagnosed because I don't want to be.

I take rejection extremely badly although I know that , that is my problem. Probably too much, to the point where I expect to be treated like a door mat but I digress.

If you are going to distance yourself from her, if it was me, I'd want to know. I have been ghosted by life long friends and that really really hurt.

You don't need to suffer her wrath though.

Seas164 · 22/11/2023 16:14

The main reason I've stayed friends with her so long is because I fear she'll kill herself if I back off

If this is the reason you're still maintaining contact, and there is nothing in it for you, then ending your relationship which sounds more like a hostage situation than a "friendship", would be a reasonable thing to do.

If guilt is keeping you stuck, then it's already over. Yes she's got a difficult situation to deal with in life, but it isn't your duty to be on call for her forever come what may, that's not what a friendship is.

ocarinaflow · 22/11/2023 16:09

SuperLoudPoppingAction · 22/11/2023 15:32

Yabu to give it this title.

It's more like are you unreasonable to end a friendship that isn't sustainable for you.
You're not.
It isnt about her illness though. Just you both don't sound compatible.

@SuperLoudPoppingAction, do you know what BPD is?

Swipe left for the next trending thread