Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think high marginal tax rates should of been the priority

41 replies

Pip47 · 22/11/2023 15:23

Does anyone else feel that it would have been much fairer and a better boost to productivity if the lower threshold had been increased, even slightly. In addition the astronomical marginal rates of tax those with children and or student loans end up paying when they go over 50k. Who can really get excited about a 2% NI cut but no doubt will cost the country billions

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DonnaBanana · 23/11/2023 00:30

I can't get too upset by people earning over £125k who don't get to see their tax allowance.

Maybe you can get more upset when people who are clearly skilled or in demand enough to earn such figures (e.g. surgeons or anaesthetists) reduce their hours to stay under the onerous tax brackets. It doesn’t matter if the earn more than you, there’s probably a reason for that and discouraging them from working reduces the value obtained in our society. If you really wanted to tax the rich there’d be a high tax band at say 500k plus where it’s almost entirely finance people.

Coolblur · 23/11/2023 00:22

I earn just shy of £100k. This tax year, I'll be just over having done a little overtime. Some will go into pension, and I won't do more OT because of the financial implications.

We have never received the financial benefit of child benefit because of my salary. We are one of those single income families that receive nothing, when two parents earning what I do together get the full child benefit amount.
DH isn't able to work due to ill health, so I'm often caring for him as well as DC, while working full time and paying for childcare. Because of this, we need all the money I earn, and things like tax free childcare help. Losing this and some tax free allowance is a big deal.
It's not all rosy for everyone in "the top 10%', though admittedly it would be tougher if I were on a lower salary.

ForestDad · 22/11/2023 23:22

Yup. I could earn over £100k. Choose not to due to tax rate. Instead I work PT and if I go over £100k anyway I'd put more into pension.
Did the same when I was at the £50k threshold.

Labraradabrador · 22/11/2023 22:51

having big cliff edges, regardless of where they occur, is a problem in that you are creating disincentives for work. No one is implying that people will turn down pay rises that take them over the threshold (£50k or £100k). What does happen though, is people reconsider the benefits of working full time or over time - when you can work 4 days instead of 5 and get virtually the same take home. However you feel about people on £100k+ salaries, it is a negative for the country when people are disincentivised from working, not just for the additional tax revenue, but more importantly for the resulting economic growth.

I am self employed, and actively push back on new work when I start to get close to £100k (plus pension), as it is extra work/stress/time away from family for significantly less money in my pocket incrementally. If there wasn’t a cliff edge I would be more tempted to take on the work, increasing my total tax bill and providing my subcontractors with more work opportunities

Plankingplanks · 22/11/2023 22:31

Plankingplanks · 22/11/2023 22:30

People forget that these are all relatively new things though, when I had my children I learnt £40k and wasn't entitled to a penny of help from the government. They have to cut off somewhere. Arguably it should be sooner than £100k!

*earned. Bloody autocorrect.

Also if you earn £100k plus then you will pay off your student loan pretty damn quickly.

Plankingplanks · 22/11/2023 22:30

People forget that these are all relatively new things though, when I had my children I learnt £40k and wasn't entitled to a penny of help from the government. They have to cut off somewhere. Arguably it should be sooner than £100k!

Eigen · 22/11/2023 22:17

edwinbear · 22/11/2023 20:05

@Plankingplanks once you earn over £125k, you don’t get any personal allowance at all. Everything you earn is taxed, it’s what causes the 60% marginal tax rate between £100k-£125k and why many doctors/dentists etc choose to work part time, to keep their earnings just below £100k. You get absolutely clobbered for tax between £100k-£125k.

Don’t forget if you’ve got a student loan you’re also losing another 10%.

People shit on bankers and their bonuses, but when they tell you your number you have to divide it by at least two. A huge chunk is going straight to the Exchequer.

Pip47 · 22/11/2023 22:02

Plankingplanks · 22/11/2023 21:30

Yes, it gets reduced but you don't pay 60% tax on the full £125k. And you can reduce your income by paying pension etc on this. You do you still get a personal tax allowance, it is just reduced if you earn between £100k-£125k. If you earn over that yoh are still entitled to a tax allowance if you reduce your income below that amount.

I can't get too upset by people earning over £125k who don't get to see their tax allowance.

The marginal loss can be even higher if losing the funded childcare hours too. I think the point is that is it fair to tax someone at that rate when the headline tax figure is significantly lower. Is that just, particularly given that it disproportionately affects only certain groups of people (ironically those with children and thus greater outgoings in the first place). Plus your overall rate or tax can end up higher than someone who is on 150k+
How fair and good for the economy is it also to be saying to people if you earn e.g between 50-70k or 100-125k we’re going to penalise you so much that it’s virtually not worth you working. I know doctors and nurses who would happily go and do some voluntary work but understandably don’t want to do paid work where virtually all the extra income (minus what they probably spend in commuting etc) gets clawed back in tax but would be quite happy if only being charged the headline 40-45%

OP posts:
Screwballs · 22/11/2023 21:30

babbygabby · 22/11/2023 16:10

Also, forgive me if I have no sympathy for those earning above £50k. I appreciate it isn't all that much in some areas but some people but that's almost as much as we earn between us so, ya know, I'm not fussed about "the rich" as I would label them.

Earning 50k doesn’t mean someone is rich 🙄

Hilarious thing to say, nothing like envy, like they'd turn the wage down if it was offered.

Plankingplanks · 22/11/2023 21:30

edwinbear · 22/11/2023 20:05

@Plankingplanks once you earn over £125k, you don’t get any personal allowance at all. Everything you earn is taxed, it’s what causes the 60% marginal tax rate between £100k-£125k and why many doctors/dentists etc choose to work part time, to keep their earnings just below £100k. You get absolutely clobbered for tax between £100k-£125k.

Yes, it gets reduced but you don't pay 60% tax on the full £125k. And you can reduce your income by paying pension etc on this. You do you still get a personal tax allowance, it is just reduced if you earn between £100k-£125k. If you earn over that yoh are still entitled to a tax allowance if you reduce your income below that amount.

I can't get too upset by people earning over £125k who don't get to see their tax allowance.

edwinbear · 22/11/2023 20:05

@Plankingplanks once you earn over £125k, you don’t get any personal allowance at all. Everything you earn is taxed, it’s what causes the 60% marginal tax rate between £100k-£125k and why many doctors/dentists etc choose to work part time, to keep their earnings just below £100k. You get absolutely clobbered for tax between £100k-£125k.

Pip47 · 22/11/2023 19:50

Lotyt · 22/11/2023 19:17

As the focus seems to be on getting people to work, they probably didn’t want to do anything that would aid those that don’t. Reducing NI benefits workers.

I think you’ve completely missed my point, I’m talking about marginal pinch points that penalise people heavily if they increase their earnings

OP posts:
Lotyt · 22/11/2023 19:17

As the focus seems to be on getting people to work, they probably didn’t want to do anything that would aid those that don’t. Reducing NI benefits workers.

superplumb · 22/11/2023 18:57

PositiveLife · 22/11/2023 15:45

Whilst someone on 50k might be earning a salary that you and your partner earn between you, they aren't taking home the same amount. You and your partner each get a personal tax allowance that a single parent only gets one of, you and your partner could both increase your earnings without losing child benefit but a single parent starts losing that as soon as they're over the 50k.

Exactly. It doesn't make sense to earn over 50 whereas 2 people could earn 25 each and still take home more and get child benefit.
I've never understood their point. 2 people earn 49k and claim cb but if one goes over 51k it tapers off..

OneForTheRoadThen · 22/11/2023 18:50

@Plankingplanks If you earn over £100,000, the personal allowance of £12,570 will be reduced by £1 for every £2 earned over the £100,000 limit. If you earn £125,000, you pay Income Tax on everything and there’s no tax-free allowance.

Plankingplanks · 22/11/2023 18:21

edwinbear · 22/11/2023 16:24

I don't get a personal allowance, both DC are in school now so the childcare element doesn't impact me and no student loans, so I'm quite happy with my 2% NI cut. Getting rid of removing the personal tax free allowance above £125k would have a huge impact on high earners, but would be very unpopular politically, so can't see it happening anytime soon. I do agree that thresholds around childcare and CB need looking at though, there are so many people trying to keep their income just below £100k through switching to PT and/or pension contributions.

Everyone gets a personal tax allowance!! It isn't cash in your hand, it is the amount you can earn before you pay income tax.

BarbaraofSeville · 22/11/2023 18:15

Tinkerbyebye · 22/11/2023 16:18

I dont earn enough to pay NI in my three part time jobs. So I don’t benefit at all

But you're already benefitting from a quirk in the system that means you don't pay NI so take home more money than you would if you had one full time job that paid the same as your three PT jobs.

Do you receive CB for DC under 12 or otherwise voluntarily pay NI credits so you don't miss out on your state pension?

Pip47 · 22/11/2023 17:51

FMLife · 22/11/2023 17:49

Should HAVE been, not should OF been.

Aww I’d edit it for your OCD but it won’t let me, sorry 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
Pip47 · 22/11/2023 17:49

YaWeeFurryBastard · 22/11/2023 16:29

We will be about £125 a month better off as both high earners. In all honesty I would prefer the £125 went to a lower earning family who needs it more than we do in this environment and I say that as someone who previously voted conservative.

I would rather they addressed the over £100k loss of personal allowance/benefits as currently I have no incentive to take a promotion as we’d actually be worse off. If they removed this then I’d pay more tax overall but still take home more!

Exactly, it’s that unfairness about it that frustrates me and no recognition for the impact it’s having on productivity. It is all very counterproductive

OP posts:
FMLife · 22/11/2023 17:49

Should HAVE been, not should OF been.

Pip47 · 22/11/2023 17:41

Savourycrepe · 22/11/2023 16:30

I agree OP. So many people think that people on £50k are ‘rich’ when the tax and benefits system mean that in fact there can be surprisingly little difference in their pay than someone on minimum wage if they have kids.

The current tinkering of thresholds has a situation where the incentives to work more are distorted by arbitrary thresholds. And then the government wonder why growth is low.

Absolutely, I’ve been on both sides and their really isn’t a huge amount of difference in disposable income between being entitled to top ups, 85% childcare costs and minimal tax/NI/SLC and being just over the threshold. At up to 80% marginal tax rates there is absolutely no incentive for any parent with several children and SLC payments to take any overtime or promotions etc to increase their income above the 50k mark and yet these is often the skilled work the country needs more of. Getting rid of these marginal pinch points would pay for itself. On the other hand if you’re earning 12k but the lower threshold would be increased to 15k then this is a huge benefit and incentive too to the lower paid.

OP posts:
Pip47 · 22/11/2023 17:24

Arightoldcarryabag · 22/11/2023 15:37

£100 a month between me and the wife. With a baby on the way in March this is huge for us.
That said, I'm furious about it, we are not in a position to be cutting revenue. This isn't about me and how it'll make my life easier, it is about the Country and it simply isn't for the best.

Also, forgive me if I have no sympathy for those earning above £50k. I appreciate it isn't all that much in some areas but some people but that's almost as much as we earn between us so, ya know, I'm not fussed about "the rich" as I would label them.

If you and your wife earn 50k between you, you’ll between you be paying much less tax (and student loan repayments)than a single parent on 50k who to boot loses her child benefit which you get to keep, in addition to having 2 of you to share the childcare between you both

OP posts:
TrashedSofa · 22/11/2023 16:55

Oh yeah, the Tories are fucked now whatever they do. Solving a problem they themselves created wrt child benefit isn't going to save them!

Eleganz · 22/11/2023 16:52

I think they are doomed regardless of whether they pull rabbits out of hats on marginal tax rates in Spring or not.

The higher income child benefit charge is simply manifestly unfair for a range of people who have more unequal income distribution between parents. You start paying the charge at £50k taxable income for the individual but that applies for each parent so you can each earn £49k and be exempt but if you are the sole earner on over £50k the government claws back the child benefit on a sliding scale up to £60k.