Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t want to pay less National Insurance, I’d like a better funded NHS

390 replies

CormorantStrikesBack · 22/11/2023 13:43

🤷‍♀️

obviously I appreciate I’m in a position to think that, but I’m not on a huge wage. I’m glad if it helps people who are struggling but I’m also worried about the nhs, school funding, etc.

They don’t seem to be managing now, I can only imagine it will get worse. There are councils going bankrupt and cutting services, respite care, libraries, etc.

id rather carry on paying what I’m paying than risk such services been funded even less.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
user1497207191 · 22/11/2023 14:49

Barnowlsandbluebells · 22/11/2023 14:48

Bad for landlords et al. who only pay income tax on their rent and the like.

Rent is their income - if they run a limited company, they can choose whether to take this as salary via PAYE or as dividends so ultimately, they choose how much national insurance they wish to pay, as do all company directors.

Edited

Yes, I know. My point is that workers have no choices like that - NIC is imposed on them as they can't "choose" to run a limited company and save NIC in that way.

Riverlee · 22/11/2023 14:49

Just saw that benefits are going up by 6.7%. How is that going to be funded? My wage hasn’t’t gone up, and the last pay increase I had was three years ago.

Justgotbackhome · 22/11/2023 14:48

They are very very strict in France. You have to show your passport. Nobody gets through the door except the patient and, if they cannot walk or talk, one named person. If they can walk and talk the named person cannot come in. The hospital will only communicate with that person. It is calm, not crowded and very efficient. You are expected to get an uber/taxi or lift from companion unless you really, really need an ambulance. But it is all very fast and efficient.

Barnowlsandbluebells · 22/11/2023 14:48

Bad for landlords et al. who only pay income tax on their rent and the like.

Rent is their income - if they run a limited company, they can choose whether to take this as salary via PAYE or as dividends so ultimately, they choose how much national insurance they wish to pay, as do all company directors.

infor · 22/11/2023 14:47

AgnesX · 22/11/2023 13:47

I'd like a specific tax for NHS funding. A pot that preferably couldn't be ransacked every time the government had a policy change

Edited

There is £20 billion+ ... taken from NI.

Choosychoice · 22/11/2023 14:46

I am so pleased as the higher rate threshold has been frozen for years here in Scotland, and income tax rates have gone up and up and up but a NICs cut is something the Scottish government has no control over.

Overthebow · 22/11/2023 14:44

user1497207191 · 22/11/2023 14:34

@Choosychoice

Cutting NICs rewards workers without rewarding wealthy pensioners.

Nail on the head. And rightly so. Workers have been disproportionately hit over the past 25 years and it's time they got a break. NIC has been an anomaly for decades and let's hope this is the first step towards it being scrapped entirely.

Lots of people, such as pensioners, buy to letters, investment portfolios, etc., have been largely insulated by "tax" rises over the past 25 years because they don't pay NIC. It would have been madness to give them a tax break at the moment as they pay less "tax" than workers anyway, due to NIC!

Yes, I completely agree with cutting NI rather than income tax as it affects workers. Pensioners have got the triple lock confirmed, they don’t need a tax cut too.

user1497207191 · 22/11/2023 14:43

sixteenfurryfeet · 22/11/2023 14:41

If people need to have made 30 qualifying year's-worth of NI contributions in order to qualify for a state pension and he is abolishing voluntary contributions for the self-employed, where does that leave them? How will they qualify for a state pension then? Or is this a way of making people go private?

Nope, answered upthread. Like low earning employees, the self employed get a "credit" towards state benefits if their earnings are over a lower earnings threshold for NIC, even though no NICs are actually payable at that level. It's been like that for employees for a few years now, and a couple of years ago, that system was extended to the self employed. It's the same kind of "credit" that people get when they are unemployed or a homemaker with young children or a carer etc. You no longer need to actually "pay" any NIC to get credits towards state benefits.

Papyrophile · 22/11/2023 14:41

The NHS could soak up all of GDP without improving. As @Justgotbackhome says, the European insurance based systems are much better run because the providers answer to their patients.

Chagallo · 22/11/2023 14:41

I'm glad they've cut NI contributions. I've already got over 40 years and I would have paid nearly 50 years by the time I get my state pension at 67. I'm self employed so this will make a big difference. The system is flawed - my friend who is the same age and hasn't worked for over 10 years will get the same state pension yet has made less than half the contributions I have. It isn't fair that I have to keep paying when I've paid the maximum I need to contribute already.

sixteenfurryfeet · 22/11/2023 14:41

If people need to have made 30 qualifying year's-worth of NI contributions in order to qualify for a state pension and he is abolishing voluntary contributions for the self-employed, where does that leave them? How will they qualify for a state pension then? Or is this a way of making people go private?

Justgotbackhome · 22/11/2023 14:38

My (adult) DC lives in France. They reckon they pay around 50% of their income on tax, health insurance (everyone does, this is the state system) and personal liability insurance (everyone has to have by law.
Child had an accident over the weekend. Went to A&E, seen straight away, triaged, saw doctor, given pain killers and sent to regional specialist centre by uber. Admitted straight away, triaged and in theatre for specialist surgery within 3 hours. On a Sunday. Discharged home. Back to see surgeon 2 days later, wound cleaned and redressed, painkillers and antibiotics. Physio arranged.
This is normal. Home help arranged for if assistance needed with washing, dressing, etc.
I fail to see how tax cuts for the rich are going to improve the NHS, transport, care of the elderly. I would rather pay more and have a decent service, but I am not convinced the people in charge are capable.

user1497207191 · 22/11/2023 14:34

@Choosychoice

Cutting NICs rewards workers without rewarding wealthy pensioners.

Nail on the head. And rightly so. Workers have been disproportionately hit over the past 25 years and it's time they got a break. NIC has been an anomaly for decades and let's hope this is the first step towards it being scrapped entirely.

Lots of people, such as pensioners, buy to letters, investment portfolios, etc., have been largely insulated by "tax" rises over the past 25 years because they don't pay NIC. It would have been madness to give them a tax break at the moment as they pay less "tax" than workers anyway, due to NIC!

Fionaville · 22/11/2023 14:31

I know exactly what you mean. It feels like that's the last thing that should be cut.
There are better ways that the government could help people, through policy and regulations (if they actually wanted to) Stop us being overcharged for necessities like water, energy and fuel for one!

user1497207191 · 22/11/2023 14:30

AutumnCrow · 22/11/2023 13:50

I don't understand how a whole class of National Insurance can be abolished and 'save' people money (Class 2s for self-employed). They can't just stop paying NI, can they, without fucking up their state pension entitlements?

So they will have to pay one of the other classes somehow (1,3,4) which will cost them a lot more? So how is it saving the self-employed money.

All this ^^ was why the idea got kicked into the long grass a few years ago.

Does anyone have any more info on this, in case the BBC is reporting it wrong?

It's the same system whereby workers earning under the threshold for paying NIC get a "credit" towards state pensions, also similar with unemployed, parents with young children, etc. As long as you earn over one threshold, you get "credits" for benefits such as state pension, whether you pay NIC or not.

CormorantStrikesBack · 22/11/2023 14:30

Sarahconnor1 · 22/11/2023 14:25

This is the march 2023 budget calculator.

I haven't seen one yet for the autumn statement but I'm sure one will be available soon.

Oh thanks, got all excited and didn’t clock the month.

OP posts:
Syndulla · 22/11/2023 14:30

They can afford this cut because so many people have been pulled into the higher rate tax band thanks to the ongoing freezes and high inflation. That measure is taking in the money so they can make it look like they are being generous and many, many people will fall for it.

mummymeister · 22/11/2023 14:29

edwinbear · 22/11/2023 14:01

Let's be honest, you could pour 100% of everyone's income into the NHS and it still wouldn't be enough.

100% agree with this statement. the NHS is an out of date system that limps along precisely because a disproportionate amount of money keeps being pumped into it and wasted. Basically because its become such a holy grail that no politician has had or will have the bottle to completely and totally reform it.

OP, its open to any of us to make a regular donation to a local cause like a food bank etc. in doing this you know that much more of your money will go directly to the people that need it rather than to the administrators. if you feel bad, do that. lots of us do this already and have done for years.

Sarahconnor1 · 22/11/2023 14:25

CormorantStrikesBack · 22/11/2023 14:14

I’ve just done the Sky calculator and it says I’ll be £50 worse off. Says my NI contributions will be the same which I don’t understand….is their calculations wrong? The being worse off bit seems to come from fuel so I’m guessing there’s been an increase in tax there?

https://news.sky.com/story/budget-2023-calculator-see-if-you-are-better-or-worse-off-after-chancellor-jeremy-hunts-statement-12834667

This is the march 2023 budget calculator.

I haven't seen one yet for the autumn statement but I'm sure one will be available soon.

Echobelly · 22/11/2023 14:25

YANBU. I could totally pay more tax. I wouldn't be thrilled but I would have no problem clothing, feeding and housing my family while paying more, and I'm not going to vote for anyone just because they cut my tax, as an above average earner. I don't even think about tax, we're not a highly taxed country.

briebella · 22/11/2023 14:22

We've had this debate on here so many times? And I always wonder if it's actually underfunded. People look at % of GDP and it's on par with other countries. But then it's lacking with per capita spending.

Also if we look at the last labour government. The NHS was apparently very good, but then it cost too much due to PFI and bankrupted NHS trusts.

edwinbear · 22/11/2023 14:22

I would like to see a system where everyone pays a bit more, according to their circumstances. For instance, wealthy people paying a certain percentage of their income, down to some people paying nothing if their income is low

This is the system we have already, I pay a marginal rate of c.60% on part of my income. Do you think I should pay a bit more? Is 60% not enough?

kdramaqueen · 22/11/2023 14:22

I voted YABU because the problem with the NHS is the shocking waste of money that goes on, which needs to be addressed before reviewing funding levels. Starting with a complete audit of frontline/admin staff ratios, supply contracts, lack of ability to pursue payment from those who are ineligible for treatment, what the NHS needs is a deep clean. And yes, as a public sector worker, you can tell me nothing about wasting taxpayers' money that I don't already know. 😡

CormorantStrikesBack · 22/11/2023 14:21

Aposterhasnoname · 22/11/2023 14:20

YABVVVVVVVU if you think chucking more money at the NHS is the answer.

Probably, but I’m not sure chucking less at it will help either. I agree it’s inefficient and needs sorting out but sadly that doesn’t seem to be on the cards regardless. Maybe they should give Cummings a job doing that.

OP posts:
Aposterhasnoname · 22/11/2023 14:20

YABVVVVVVVU if you think chucking more money at the NHS is the answer.