Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t want to pay less National Insurance, I’d like a better funded NHS

390 replies

CormorantStrikesBack · 22/11/2023 13:43

🤷‍♀️

obviously I appreciate I’m in a position to think that, but I’m not on a huge wage. I’m glad if it helps people who are struggling but I’m also worried about the nhs, school funding, etc.

They don’t seem to be managing now, I can only imagine it will get worse. There are councils going bankrupt and cutting services, respite care, libraries, etc.

id rather carry on paying what I’m paying than risk such services been funded even less.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Choosychoice · 22/11/2023 15:14

Study after study after study shows that the NHS has too few managers. It is badly run with poor workplace practices and high wastage because there are too few managers.

CormorantStrikesBack · 22/11/2023 15:13

Baffledandalarmed · 22/11/2023 15:05

Three dentists near me accepting NHS patients.

A&E all fine.

Two doctors surgeries you can get a same day appointment.

I need to move to near you. Not a single dentist in the whole city has taken nhs patients on for over five years. I can rarely get a GP appt, I ring at 8am on the dot and by the time I get through the appts have gone. I tend just to go to the urgent treatment centre instead. Dh has had a weird rash for six weeks and lost weight and hasn’t been able to see a doctor. A&e regularly reports 24 hour waits. 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
itsmyp4rty · 22/11/2023 15:11

Justgotbackhome · 22/11/2023 14:38

My (adult) DC lives in France. They reckon they pay around 50% of their income on tax, health insurance (everyone does, this is the state system) and personal liability insurance (everyone has to have by law.
Child had an accident over the weekend. Went to A&E, seen straight away, triaged, saw doctor, given pain killers and sent to regional specialist centre by uber. Admitted straight away, triaged and in theatre for specialist surgery within 3 hours. On a Sunday. Discharged home. Back to see surgeon 2 days later, wound cleaned and redressed, painkillers and antibiotics. Physio arranged.
This is normal. Home help arranged for if assistance needed with washing, dressing, etc.
I fail to see how tax cuts for the rich are going to improve the NHS, transport, care of the elderly. I would rather pay more and have a decent service, but I am not convinced the people in charge are capable.

Really? I don't see how unless they are extremely high earners?

What is the French income tax scale for 2023?
The country’s progressive tax scale bands for 2023 are now as follows:
Per household unit (for more on this, see our guide Understanding French Tax- What is a Fiscal Household in France?)

  • Up to €10,777: 0% tax rate
  • From €10,778 to €27,478: 11% tax rate
  • From €27,479 to €78,570: 30% tax rate
  • From €78,571 to €168,994: 41% tax rate
  • More than €168,994: 45% tax rate

Unfortunately though I think much of Europe has better health care than we do. The problem is OP it doesn't matter how much money we throw at the NHS nothing is going to solve the huge problems with it where there is so much wastage, so many poor decision makers, too many managers, no joined up thinking, too much out sourced and so done poorly (ie cleaning), such shortages of staff and those there are often not treated well, demotivated, just turning up for their pay check. It's poorly run and sadly I don't think it matters how much money you throw at it. I think it needs scrapping and starting over.

Caffeineislife · 22/11/2023 15:10

@Baffledandalarmed where do you live so we can all ring up the NHS dentists and get on their books please as many of us have no NHS dentist for miles and miles around, round us they don't even have spaces for children. Also would like to get a same day drs appointment and no massive wait for A+E if needed.

AboutYouTalk · 22/11/2023 15:10

YANBU. I thought the same, taking money from an already poorly funded NHS. This Tory govt are doing their best to finish off the NHS for their friends in the private sector. Absolute bunch of bastards.

Wherearemymarbles · 22/11/2023 15:10

Regarding the NHS I did a quick look.
In its 1st year it cost £373m. Adjusted for inflation thats around £16bn today against its current budget of £200bn
If we want a much better NHS ALL of us are going have to pay much, much more tax - and that just not going to happen.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 22/11/2023 15:09

i hear you op and agree. IF spent well, higher taxes are a good thing.

me and dh were out one day talking to a homeless man, afterwards dh said “I’m sure me and my friends would all put in say £10 a month to help someone like that get back on their feet”

my response

that’s literally taxes.

He is self employed, his friends are self employed trades people, they pay all their taxes , through the books etc, but dislike high taxes. After that and a few other conversations he gets it now and is pro higher taxes

Everanewbie · 22/11/2023 15:09

Think of it instead of a slight bit of relief from the fiscal drag of frozen thresholds which has a much greater affect than a slight NI reduction.

SaffronSpice · 22/11/2023 15:07

NHS is a money pit. It will take more than just money to improve it.

Baffledandalarmed · 22/11/2023 15:05

CormorantStrikesBack · 22/11/2023 13:48

I hope you find an nhs dentist to help with your dental pain.

Three dentists near me accepting NHS patients.

A&E all fine.

Two doctors surgeries you can get a same day appointment.

Barnowlsandbluebells · 22/11/2023 15:04

Tories are coming out on the side of "workers" who have been disproportionately hit by tax rises over the past 25 years. By reducing NIC rather than reducing income tax, it's a directed tax cut on workers only, i.e. not on pensioners, not on buy to letters, not on rich people living on investment portfolios, etc.

This is not quite correct - someone who runs a limited company will constantly be working out the most efficient way to take their income in terms of the mix of salary and dividends. A reduction in NI may swing the balance in favour of taking a greater portion of their income as salary versus dividends. It all depends on individual circumstances and their portfolio.....so this may well benefit some landlords.

CormorantStrikesBack · 22/11/2023 15:03

@user1497207191 thanks for that. Interesting post and that does make sense. Will certainly be interesting to see what Labour have to say.

OP posts:
hiddle · 22/11/2023 15:01

I agree. I don't see the value in reducing taxes when public services are in such a shit state and also when inflation is still high, the economy isn't fixed, my mortgage is still going to increase by hundreds a month but yay we'll have an extra £100 a month and continued shit services 🙄

AutumnCrow · 22/11/2023 15:01

Thanks for all the helpful answers to my query.

user1497207191 · 22/11/2023 15:00

CormorantStrikesBack · 22/11/2023 14:55

You’re probably right. It will certainly have been done in a desperate attempt to win votes. Whether it is such a small amount it makes a difference or not I don’t know,

It starts to put clear blue sky between the Tories and Labour.

Labour increased tax on workers, via NIC increases. Labour constantly talk about putting more money into public sector, i.e. care, NHS, education, etc. The clear intent is that "workers" pay for it.

Tories are coming out on the side of "workers" who have been disproportionately hit by tax rises over the past 25 years. By reducing NIC rather than reducing income tax, it's a directed tax cut on workers only, i.e. not on pensioners, not on buy to letters, not on rich people living on investment portfolios, etc.

So you can clearly see the battle lines being drawn. Tories are fighting for the votes of workers. It remains to be seen whether Labour will try to win the votes of workers in other ways, or whether they're going to try to rely on the votes of people who don't work!!

Barnowlsandbluebells · 22/11/2023 14:59

user1497207191 · 22/11/2023 14:49

Yes, I know. My point is that workers have no choices like that - NIC is imposed on them as they can't "choose" to run a limited company and save NIC in that way.

Income tax is not the same as dividend tax - see your comment above.

Choosychoice · 22/11/2023 14:59

Bromptotoo · 22/11/2023 14:50

Somebody has pointed out that by reducing NI while letting 'fiscal drag' increase the take from Income Tax Hunt has turned policy from Thatcher on upon its head.

The saving will go to working people and not pensioners, BTL landlords etc etc.

They could raise a LOT of tax just by simply rolling NIC into Income tax. It really should be done.

CormorantStrikesBack · 22/11/2023 14:59

EasternStandard · 22/11/2023 14:51

I don’t really mind either way but do think the point on who gets a cut is worth making

And workers not retired would be my priority too

I agree. But then in the next bit of the budget all pensioners are getting an 8.5% pension increase? So pensioners also getting prioritised.

Only a few months ago that the govt said public sector workers couldn’t get a 7% pay rise as no money for it. Only yesterday on here there was a thread by someone saying it’s common for TAs to be teaching classes now as the schools can’t afford qualified teachers for all classes. Hospitals have massive staff shortages because the wages for qualified staff aren’t enough for people to want to stay working there. Nursing degree applications were down 50% last year! People are seeing the headlines about the poor pay and conditions and not even signing up.

OP posts:
CormorantStrikesBack · 22/11/2023 14:55

Vinvertebrate · 22/11/2023 14:54

I think YABU - this is pre-election bread and circuses. The cuts to NI are worth bugger all, relative to freezing the HR band in an inflationary period. But here, have some peanuts and don't forget to vote Conservative. Grr.

You’re probably right. It will certainly have been done in a desperate attempt to win votes. Whether it is such a small amount it makes a difference or not I don’t know,

OP posts:
CormorantStrikesBack · 22/11/2023 14:54

Aposterhasnoname · 22/11/2023 14:50

Have they said they are cutting NHS funding?

Not that I’ve seen. But the NHS are always saying they don’t have enough. The govt says there’s no more to give them. So it doesn’t add up that the govt then willingly give away 2% of contributions which I’m sure the nhs would have appreciated.

Maybe it really will help “kickstart” the economy and people will spend more and it will help businesses and save jobs. Kickstarting the economy seems to be the politicians buzzword of the day. When in reality for a lot of people they will either save more as they’re already well off, or put it towards food or energy bills.

OP posts:
Vinvertebrate · 22/11/2023 14:54

I think YABU - this is pre-election bread and circuses. The cuts to NI are worth bugger all, relative to freezing the HR band in an inflationary period. But here, have some peanuts and don't forget to vote Conservative. Grr.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 22/11/2023 14:54

The state of our state systems - it is no time for tax cuts- the chancellor, like all the tories is trying anything to keep a vote because this time next year they are gone.
Will I financially benefit yes but to me it’s not worth it, what’s a few quid vs 20hrs in a&e, a crumbling school building and fuck all
police when needed.

EasternStandard · 22/11/2023 14:51

I don’t really mind either way but do think the point on who gets a cut is worth making

And workers not retired would be my priority too

Aposterhasnoname · 22/11/2023 14:50

CormorantStrikesBack · 22/11/2023 14:21

Probably, but I’m not sure chucking less at it will help either. I agree it’s inefficient and needs sorting out but sadly that doesn’t seem to be on the cards regardless. Maybe they should give Cummings a job doing that.

Edited

Have they said they are cutting NHS funding?

Bromptotoo · 22/11/2023 14:50

Somebody has pointed out that by reducing NI while letting 'fiscal drag' increase the take from Income Tax Hunt has turned policy from Thatcher on upon its head.

The saving will go to working people and not pensioners, BTL landlords etc etc.