Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s crazy you can parent whatever way you want?!

368 replies

ItsGivingJudgey · 22/11/2023 13:00

This OP will sound judgey has hell hence my username. I’ve NC but long time user.

I know it’s a free country (in the UK at least). I also really support human rights, however I still find it mad that you can have a child and raise them whatever way you want no matter how batshit so long as it doesn’t meet the very high legal requirements for removal.

Examples:

ONE:

My SIL does F all with her child and he’s now 2.5 years old. He literally does not leave the house other than for absolute essentials such as medical appointments. He doesn’t go to nursery despite it being free (she doesn’t work). He’s never been swimming, to feed the ducks, to the beach or the local park. He’s never met other children outside of his cousins. He’s only ever been to soft play twice when I have physically picked them up to take them with me and my dc.
He only ever leaves the house when my in-laws take him food shopping with them just to get him out. He can literally go 1-2 weeks without being outside his front door.
SIL on the other hand goes on holidays, days out with her boyfriend, cocktails with friends etc. She just has the in-laws babysit when she does. Her reasoning? ‘It’s a faff’ ‘the weather is bad’ or she ‘can’t be arsed today’. She was very lazy before becoming a parent but her laziness now has extended to her child who literally lives his entire life within the confines of the house. It’s nothing to do with mental health on her part, it’s pure laziness. She’ll only take him out if a member of the family with a car physically goes and picks them up and drops them back off home. The nursery is less than a 5 minute walk from her house. She was badgered by the health visitor to enroll him so she did it, took him for a week and then never bothered again as it was ‘too much faffing about for just a few hours’.

He lives off microwave meals and tinned food. Wakes up and spends the entire day in front of the tv or with his tablet. When my in-laws went away last year he didn’t leave the house for 3 weeks!!

It doesn’t meet the legal requirements or thresholds for social services. He is fed and clothed and has lots of toys. But it’s crazy that he is able to spend his entire life within the confines of a house and that’s that.

TWO:

My cousin. Very well educated, affluent and has always been a bit eccentric as is her DH. However over the years they have joined a kind of weird religion/cult like group and are massive conspiracy theorists. They homeschool their kids (fine), but have indoctrinated them with mad beliefs. The kids including the baby are vegan. Their unvaccinated. They can only bath in this specially filtered water. The kids are feral and not allowed to watch tv, listen to any type of mainstream music only this specifically selected whale like music. They avoid any type of radiation and limit sources of power so in the evenings the house is lit by candlelight and an open fire. The kids wear this robe like clothing that seems impractical. The kids no nothing outside of their parents beliefs. They have no awareness of the outside world. They only socialise with the other people in this conspiracy group that also homeschool.

My cousin and her husband are well meaning and obviously it’s their right to believe what they wish. But their kids won’t know how to use the internet, any real world references, learn about other religions or cultures. Surely this will do long term harm in some way?

The children couldn’t tell you what spaghetti bolognaise is or what a smartphone/tablet is or that there was ever a world war or even how what a kettle
is for. But they can tell you about crystal healing powers. What if when they get to 18 they want to live a ‘mainstream’ life and join society? How will they manage? Get a job? Make friends with peers?

It’s not that I believe there’s only one right way to parent or anything because I don’t. However I find it mad that you can have a baby and so long as you meet very basic standards, you can literally do as you want with actual human beings.

Please tell me if I’m being unreasonable to think it’s not right and if I am being unreasonable why so? I feel so sorry for these children.

OP posts:
OceanicBoundlessness · 22/11/2023 17:11

Hollyhead · 22/11/2023 14:50

@SouthLondonMum22 yes I would make the legal age for education 1, but it just wouldn’t be full time. The vast majority of children are in some form of setting by 1 anyway. The sad truth is that for many children by the time they start reception their educational chances are over as they’re years behind the children with good parents. 15 -20 hours a week from 1 would go some way to help.

1?
Many babies are still breastfeeding every few hours at 1.
I quit work because my 1 year old was so needy I couldn't imagine his needs being met in a room where there were carers being stretched looking after other babies and children too.
I can promise he's thriving as a 19 year old in college though so it hasn't held him back giving him an extra bit of nurturing as a baby.

gingercatnip · 22/11/2023 17:09

ItsGivingJudgey · 22/11/2023 14:53

I don’t think I’m a fascist, at least I really hope not.

I don’t think all kids should be parented one way and I believe in freedom to practice your religion of choice etc.

But when you inflict any type of extreme lifestyle on a child then I guess I do struggle.

My cousin for example and her husband won’t teach their kids the sciences because it conflicts with their beliefs. Actual proven facts conflicts with their beliefs.
They also won’t walk under street lights/antennas etc for fear of ‘waves’ they give off.
So in turn their kids are petrified of walking through cities and urban areas. They try and remain as ‘off grid’ as possible.

I think it’s perfectly fine for my cousin and her DH to believe this. They know what scientists and the ‘mainstream’ people believe and choose to believe otherwise. Fine. However their kids have no idea what others believe or what scientists think. Just this one way of thinking.

Most kids who are part of a religion of belief system such as Christian’s, Jews,
muslims etc are raised in their belief system but are also aware that there are other religions and belief systems too. So at some point they are able to make their own choices to continue with their familiar faith or look into the alternatives.

My cousins kids aren’t a part of wider society to have this awareness. They can raised to believe literally whatever my cousin wants. That is my cousins right. I guess I do struggle with it.

Religious Schools in the UK teach young children that a man died and then literally rose from the dead. We have far bigger issues in this country than one family passing on their equally odd beliefs onto their DC.

picturethispatsy · 22/11/2023 17:08

RagzRebooted · 22/11/2023 16:28

I live in England. But I think it's less about where I live and more about the people, I'm from quite a troubled and chaotic background with a huge extended family filled with people with a lot of issues (that can largely be blamed on poverty, mental health issues and drugs).

I also have a friend who HS and does it how you describe. Is part of a HS community, where they meet up and share tutors and activities and actually educate the kids. Obviously if you're part of that kind of community, you'd only meet others who do it like that. The friend and the people she HS with all seem quite middle class, so perhaps it is partly a class thing?
I suppose what my relatives are/were doing is more 'unschooling' as they aren't doing the educating part. But they also don't have the (material or intellectual) resources to do what you do.

I think then that that is quite a unique set of people/circumstance based on what you have said.
I don’t recognize it at all and I’ve been home educating for years and have met many. I’d be very surprised if there was a secret ‘hidden’ sect of people doing it in those circumstances.

Please don’t think it’s a class thing as a general rule despite the people you know who do it ‘right’. That makes me so disappointed to hear someone make that assumption. Nearly everyone HE family I know would be classed as working class as a rule. There are the odd ones who may at a push be called middle class.

JoanOfAllTrades · 22/11/2023 17:04

I think that not vaccinating children is wrong. There are many reasons for this such as measles. Not vaccinating a child against measles means that if the child contracts measles and then comes into contact with a baby, the baby could die. Pertussis can leave a baby with lifelong incontinence problems. Tetanus is also a killer. Diphtheria is actually on the increase in some countries. And that’s before we think about other viruses such as rubella, chickenpox which can lie dormant for years and then it’s hello 👋 shingles. So basically the child, other children/babies, and the immunocompromised will possibly pay the price because a parent didn’t want to vaccinate their child.

As far as laziness goes though, I don’t think there’s a solution other than the one which the in-laws in the first scenario are doing which is taking the child out and giving his days some sort of structure.

Cults or weird beliefs is again not something that there’s really an answer to. People believe what they want to believe.

picturethispatsy · 22/11/2023 17:00

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 22/11/2023 15:56

Come on though - you are a teacher.

You have a good understanding of pedagogy, the basic building blocks of learning, what your children will need to know to ultimately take exams that they will need to get the qualifications that will open up career paths for them that will be closed off completely if they fail to attain those qualifications.

You know how to identify and evaluate educational resources.

You are well-educated yourself to degree level.

Basically what your children get is access to what they would get in school but on a really personalised, 121/small group level.

Of COURSE that is going to be better for them, especially if enriched with contact with other home-ed children (you will know about, understand and know how to engage productively with those communities) and other life experiences (assuming you have a similarly professionally-employed spouse, you have the resources to enable this).

You are not 'the average parent' in this respect. The vast majority of parents would not be able to deliver at the level you can. Surely you see that.

It is very different someone qualified like you making an informed decision to home-ed their child so as to give them the best possible experience, and someone like the OP's cousin who is home-ed-ing apparently to avoid their children's ideological purity being compromised.

Ach I knew someone would say that.

Truly you do not need to be a teacher to home educate. Whilst there are a few of us, most of the other parents I know are most definitely not and they manage to access the same opportunities and resources I do. I do not have a special talent for accessing special resources despite my degree. All of the other home ed parents I know curate their child’s educations as well as I do.

But I take your point in that it may seem that way to a lay-person. Trust me, me being a teacher has been a hindrance if anything!

MrsHarrisAParis · 22/11/2023 16:59

It can't be both - your SIL can't stay in all the time and the toddler never gets out but somehow your SIL is also out for cocktails, away on holiday, and the toddler gets watched by GPs. Unless you're saying that the GPs also do nothing with the toddler and SIL's behaviour is learned behaviour from her parents?
Midwives and HVs and GPs don't just look at whether a baby is clean and has toys. They do monitor development and interaction, and send for more support if necessary. Likewise in schools. That kind of light touch is probably the best approach imo.
As for the cousins - you seem to know an awful lot about people who supposedly don't interact with anyone outside their belief group.
I'm always sceptical of people who want to 'police' parenting. Historically, their motivations are usually suspect and have little to do with protection of DCs and a lot to do with separating them from their parents and family units.

strawberriesarenot · 22/11/2023 16:56

What an unusual family you have.

Still, the kids can't be that isolated from the world of 'normal' people, since you have been allowed to observe their lives in such detail.

(Soft play is the pits. Never took mine either.)

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/11/2023 16:52

ItsGivingJudgey · 22/11/2023 16:44

@herewegoroundthebastardbush

I can feel your frustration about SIL and I agree entirely with you!

Our own circumstances do not enable us to be able to physically take him out regularly or trust me we would!!

When we are able to, we do!!

Other posters have asked about confronting the issues and what not.

Well a few twice PIL have tried to sit her down and say things need to change. Every time it ends in tears.
The last time she finally enrolled him in nursery using the 15 free hours. Great we all thought. This is fab. the nursery is a 9 minute walk away according to google maps too! Couldn’t be better!

She did it for a week. Less than a week actually, 4 sessions including the taster.

Her reasoning? ‘It’s all a big faff for just a few hours’.

The same with meals. Cooking is a ‘faff’ when he ‘probably won’t eat it anyway’.

Everything is a ‘faff’ as she puts it when it comes to taking him anywhere or doing anything.

Someone mentioned mental health. No she is not depressed, far from. This was her lifestyle BEFORE dc. Living in her pyjamas, watching boxsets, gaming and takeaways. She would only leave the house for drinks out and dating. But pretty much has always lived life like a teenager would during the holidays.

When she was pregnant her mum actually said ‘this will be the making of her’ as it was assumed she’d have to actually get out of the house and do things. But no, instead her toddler has just joined in the lifestyle.

What makes you say that it isn't poor mental health? If she had poor mental health before her son was born, then it is possible that she still has poor mental health.

It sounds like she could benefit from some low level intervention such as Early Help.

tattygrl · 22/11/2023 16:51

The way you describe SIL does sound like she's struggling with depression or maybe ADHD or other condition that causes executive dysfunction.

I know it can be frustrating to hear things like that when you're close to the person and have insight into who they are and how they've always been; but, the lifestyle you describe before having her son sounds dysfunctional and indicative of some kind of struggle. People often feel huge, huge shame around not being able to do what is expected of them, for example hold down a job, go out and about regularly, keep a tidy house, cook meals, plan activities, etc. This leads many people who struggle with this stuff to be blase about it and put on a front of "oh I just don't care", "oh I'm happy like this can't be arsed with anything else!". In reality it sounds like she struggles to manage "life" in general.

I'm not making excuses for her lack of engagement with her son and lack of enrichment and stimulation she provides him with. Not at all. No matter what her struggles, her child deserves his needs met. But I'd encourage you to try and look with fresh eyes, because she doesn't sound happy and fulfilled. She might just be putting on a front to deal with the shame. I believe she will be feeling shame.

Firebug007 · 22/11/2023 16:49

Who decides what the 'right' way to raise a child is, many on here seem completely unaware what dangerous talk this is.

SwordToFlamethrower · 22/11/2023 16:46

Fiesta example seems neglectful and lonely for the child.

The second example seems like a brilliant way to live. Society is totally batshit at the moment. No one needs TV or screen time, and certainly not children. Feral sounds like freedom to play, explore the world and use imagination. I bet the children in the second example are having a great time. More power to them.

Lavenderflower · 22/11/2023 16:46

The first example would probably warrant threshold of concern or even a different type of intervention. If she cannot bothered with taking him to nursery - how is she going to manage school.

ItsGivingJudgey · 22/11/2023 16:44

@herewegoroundthebastardbush

I can feel your frustration about SIL and I agree entirely with you!

Our own circumstances do not enable us to be able to physically take him out regularly or trust me we would!!

When we are able to, we do!!

Other posters have asked about confronting the issues and what not.

Well a few twice PIL have tried to sit her down and say things need to change. Every time it ends in tears.
The last time she finally enrolled him in nursery using the 15 free hours. Great we all thought. This is fab. the nursery is a 9 minute walk away according to google maps too! Couldn’t be better!

She did it for a week. Less than a week actually, 4 sessions including the taster.

Her reasoning? ‘It’s all a big faff for just a few hours’.

The same with meals. Cooking is a ‘faff’ when he ‘probably won’t eat it anyway’.

Everything is a ‘faff’ as she puts it when it comes to taking him anywhere or doing anything.

Someone mentioned mental health. No she is not depressed, far from. This was her lifestyle BEFORE dc. Living in her pyjamas, watching boxsets, gaming and takeaways. She would only leave the house for drinks out and dating. But pretty much has always lived life like a teenager would during the holidays.

When she was pregnant her mum actually said ‘this will be the making of her’ as it was assumed she’d have to actually get out of the house and do things. But no, instead her toddler has just joined in the lifestyle.

OP posts:
Lifestylechoices · 22/11/2023 16:40

picturethispatsy · 22/11/2023 15:23

I was just about to say the same.

There was plenty of weird stuff I was told at school (including if I didn’t turn to Christ if burn in hell).

School itself can be very damaging to children.

The one and only time I saw one of her dc upset over what they have been taught was when I looked after them and went into the garden to see her ds trying to knock down my wasp trap - he took one look at me and burst into tears saying ‘did you see ? Oh no did you see?’ Then sobbed and then told me how his mum had taught them that the kindest acts are the ones nobody ever knows about or witnesses as they are done genuinely and not to impress anyone and only the creator sees’ he had wanted to free the wasps that were suffering and was so so upset his kindness had been witnessed ‘by a mortal’

infor · 22/11/2023 16:40

ladyvimes · 22/11/2023 15:34

As a teacher we see the results of shit parenting all day every day. I bloody well do judge parents as so many children I work with would be completely different if their parents actually parented properly. How do we change it? We call it out and stop all this ‘don’t judge’ attitude. As a society we are failing so many children and it’s only going to get worse

I was talking to a volunteer sports coach who gives up their time for free to train ten year-olds and arrange matches for them. He is viewed as a free childminder and often has parents turning up half an hour late to collect cold, dirty and fed up children.
I asked if there are any that refuse to listen or follow instructions. His response was "What, other than the children of teachers?"

RafaFan · 22/11/2023 16:38

@Dotjones how would that work? Who would set the standard of what was acceptable?

WitchyWitcherson · 22/11/2023 16:32

First sounds pretty tragic, second sounds pretty batshit but perfectly fine in many ways, who needs internet and TV - my grandad learned to use the internet in his late 70's! Glad they're not out socialising outside of their batshit circle since they're unvaccinated.

startledbypostmodernity · 22/11/2023 16:28

The line between freedom and tolerance and also the children's rights is complicated. For example, there are children in the UK who are homeschooled/ attend unregistered schools where they don't even learn English. IMO, all children should have the chance to at least learn basic English and maths if the live in the UK. Otherwise, how can they ever make their own choices as adults?

Some people would say that the state would be massively overstepping to impose that kind of rule on all children.

RagzRebooted · 22/11/2023 16:28

picturethispatsy · 22/11/2023 15:37

Do you really have ‘several’ relatives that all home educate?! Where do you live?

I home educate my DC and know lots of other family that do too as we all socialise and learn together a lot and I can honestly say I’ve never met a single parent who doesn’t go to the ends of the earth to provide their children with the best possible education/life experience they can. Huge sacrifices are made financially and career-wise for their DC so this hugely surprises me.

I live in England. But I think it's less about where I live and more about the people, I'm from quite a troubled and chaotic background with a huge extended family filled with people with a lot of issues (that can largely be blamed on poverty, mental health issues and drugs).

I also have a friend who HS and does it how you describe. Is part of a HS community, where they meet up and share tutors and activities and actually educate the kids. Obviously if you're part of that kind of community, you'd only meet others who do it like that. The friend and the people she HS with all seem quite middle class, so perhaps it is partly a class thing?
I suppose what my relatives are/were doing is more 'unschooling' as they aren't doing the educating part. But they also don't have the (material or intellectual) resources to do what you do.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 22/11/2023 16:26

"I don’t have any issues with people living alternative lifestyle or whatever."

But you clearly do.

ItsGivingJudgey · 22/11/2023 16:21

To the home educators who’ve posted.

I have 0 issues with home education. I don’t have any issues with people living alternative lifestyle or whatever.

I’m talking about how it’s crazy you can literally take a tiny baby and do pretty much anything you want with them short of abuse. So you can literally take them off the radar, decline health visitors or any outside input and have them kept in a house 24/7 and tell them the sky is purple and the oceans are yellow and the earth is flat. You can say Hitler is a God and do as you like, providing you don’t cross the lines into abuse and even then it’s a high threshold.

This is what shocks me.

OP posts:
TrashedSofa · 22/11/2023 16:19

I tend to be quite sceptical of people who claim to want China style forced abortions. They're either bullshitters or so fringe as to be unimportant and uninteresting. The number of people who haven't the foggiest about foster care but don't let that stop them opening about it is probably more concerning.

OceanicBoundlessness · 22/11/2023 16:18

It's not one or two individual decisions alone that are worrying but everything together that forms a picture.

In the first example the child's need for fresh air and exercise doesn't sound like it's being met? Or interaction

In the second instance I'm curious about how they are the children's trajectory when they are teens. Will they be supported to go into further education? If so they'll very quickly catch up with their peers and the parents could be in for a big rebellion.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/11/2023 16:14

Dotjones · 22/11/2023 13:11

I agree, it's ridiculous you need a licence to drive a car (or even to operate a television) but literally anyone is allowed to become a parent. I'd like to see a system where parents and those who are expecting or trying to concieve have to attend classes and reach a certain standard, otherwise the kids are taken away/terminated and the parents sterilised.

Do you really want to live in a society where forced abortion and forced sterilisation is a thing?

What happens with existing kids who's parents fail? National Children's Homes housing thousands or kids under a certain age simply disposed of with a quite injection?

BananaSpanner · 22/11/2023 16:13

So why don’t you talk to SIL about it then, actually confront her about what she’s doing (or not doing). Doesn’t have to be hostile but when she’s declines to do something with him because it’s a faff, say “come one, that’s not good enough, he needs to go out”. Sit her down and explain things to her like you have here.

Also, you seem set on the fact that it doesn’t meet threshold for children’s services involvement. Have you actually referred? If you word your referral like you have here and explain the effect it is having on him, it would not surprise me if they do open some sort of contact with mum.

Swipe left for the next trending thread