Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s crazy you can parent whatever way you want?!

368 replies

ItsGivingJudgey · 22/11/2023 13:00

This OP will sound judgey has hell hence my username. I’ve NC but long time user.

I know it’s a free country (in the UK at least). I also really support human rights, however I still find it mad that you can have a child and raise them whatever way you want no matter how batshit so long as it doesn’t meet the very high legal requirements for removal.

Examples:

ONE:

My SIL does F all with her child and he’s now 2.5 years old. He literally does not leave the house other than for absolute essentials such as medical appointments. He doesn’t go to nursery despite it being free (she doesn’t work). He’s never been swimming, to feed the ducks, to the beach or the local park. He’s never met other children outside of his cousins. He’s only ever been to soft play twice when I have physically picked them up to take them with me and my dc.
He only ever leaves the house when my in-laws take him food shopping with them just to get him out. He can literally go 1-2 weeks without being outside his front door.
SIL on the other hand goes on holidays, days out with her boyfriend, cocktails with friends etc. She just has the in-laws babysit when she does. Her reasoning? ‘It’s a faff’ ‘the weather is bad’ or she ‘can’t be arsed today’. She was very lazy before becoming a parent but her laziness now has extended to her child who literally lives his entire life within the confines of the house. It’s nothing to do with mental health on her part, it’s pure laziness. She’ll only take him out if a member of the family with a car physically goes and picks them up and drops them back off home. The nursery is less than a 5 minute walk from her house. She was badgered by the health visitor to enroll him so she did it, took him for a week and then never bothered again as it was ‘too much faffing about for just a few hours’.

He lives off microwave meals and tinned food. Wakes up and spends the entire day in front of the tv or with his tablet. When my in-laws went away last year he didn’t leave the house for 3 weeks!!

It doesn’t meet the legal requirements or thresholds for social services. He is fed and clothed and has lots of toys. But it’s crazy that he is able to spend his entire life within the confines of a house and that’s that.

TWO:

My cousin. Very well educated, affluent and has always been a bit eccentric as is her DH. However over the years they have joined a kind of weird religion/cult like group and are massive conspiracy theorists. They homeschool their kids (fine), but have indoctrinated them with mad beliefs. The kids including the baby are vegan. Their unvaccinated. They can only bath in this specially filtered water. The kids are feral and not allowed to watch tv, listen to any type of mainstream music only this specifically selected whale like music. They avoid any type of radiation and limit sources of power so in the evenings the house is lit by candlelight and an open fire. The kids wear this robe like clothing that seems impractical. The kids no nothing outside of their parents beliefs. They have no awareness of the outside world. They only socialise with the other people in this conspiracy group that also homeschool.

My cousin and her husband are well meaning and obviously it’s their right to believe what they wish. But their kids won’t know how to use the internet, any real world references, learn about other religions or cultures. Surely this will do long term harm in some way?

The children couldn’t tell you what spaghetti bolognaise is or what a smartphone/tablet is or that there was ever a world war or even how what a kettle
is for. But they can tell you about crystal healing powers. What if when they get to 18 they want to live a ‘mainstream’ life and join society? How will they manage? Get a job? Make friends with peers?

It’s not that I believe there’s only one right way to parent or anything because I don’t. However I find it mad that you can have a baby and so long as you meet very basic standards, you can literally do as you want with actual human beings.

Please tell me if I’m being unreasonable to think it’s not right and if I am being unreasonable why so? I feel so sorry for these children.

OP posts:
Fwiw2 · 23/11/2023 18:51

If you are concerned, make a referral to the local authority. Certainly a child never being taken out of the house would concern me enough to raise. There are a number of steps LAs can take that are short of removal; early help, child in need plans and support (inc parenting classes)

More generally. Hedley J in Re L (a family law case which is often quoted) said;

“…society must be willing to tolerate very diverse standards of parenting, including the eccentric, the barely adequate and the inconsistent. It follows too that children will inevitably have both very different experiences of parenting and very unequal consequences flowing from it. It means that some children will experience disadvantage and harm, while others will flourish in atmospheres of loving security and emotional stability. These are the consequences of our fallible humanity and it is not the provenance of the state to spare children all the consequences of defective parenting. In any event, it simply could not be done.”

Mamato29192 · 23/11/2023 18:38

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/11/2023 17:20

OP is talking about the 15 hours for 2 year olds that only parents on universal credit, benefits etc get. Not universal childcare.

Both parents don't have to be on UC to get it. Just one parent

Horrace · 23/11/2023 18:28

Dotjones · 22/11/2023 13:11

I agree, it's ridiculous you need a licence to drive a car (or even to operate a television) but literally anyone is allowed to become a parent. I'd like to see a system where parents and those who are expecting or trying to concieve have to attend classes and reach a certain standard, otherwise the kids are taken away/terminated and the parents sterilised.

Take the kids away and terminate them?
Fuck me. That's extreme

OhcantthInkofaname · 23/11/2023 18:21

Isn't there basic curriculum or testing for homeschooled children in the UK?
As for situation 1 when is this child expected to start schooling? That will solve some of the issue.

Ace56 · 23/11/2023 16:23

jolaylasofia · 22/11/2023 20:37

I think you are all nuts. Why does a 2 year old HAVE to go to nursery?? Research shows that children benefit more from being with their main care giver until they are at least 3.
All my kids have been with me or grandparents u til they start school nursery.

A 2 year old absolutely does not have to go out every day. Playing with mom, discovering foods, role playing, being in garden etc is just as beneficial.

Did you actually read the thread? OP isn’t just concerned because the child isn’t going to nursery, but because he doesn’t go out for WEEKS on end or see many other people. And it’s not like the mum is providing a rich learning environment at home either ‘role playing’ or ‘discovering foods’. Come on.

TrashedSofa · 23/11/2023 16:06

AgnesX · 23/11/2023 15:13

I concede my post wasn't well written but a) I did say that the original suggestion was extreme b) that I didn't know the answer and what I didn't say as it should be obvious, that since there appear to be a good few feckless adults out there who think it's their right to reproduce, something should change.

So your answer then @TrashedSofa ?

I'm still not sure exactly what your first post meant then? You said you don't think people will want to pay more, what does that have to do with the post about mass sterilisation that you mentioned? I'm not aware of a lower budget option personally, but maybe I will be after you've explained.

AgnesX · 23/11/2023 15:13

TrashedSofa · 23/11/2023 14:46

Asking you why you wrote something isn't having a go. You can ask me questions when you've answered mine. What's the relevance of the comment about people not wanting to pay extra when discussing forced sterilisation and abortion?

I concede my post wasn't well written but a) I did say that the original suggestion was extreme b) that I didn't know the answer and what I didn't say as it should be obvious, that since there appear to be a good few feckless adults out there who think it's their right to reproduce, something should change.

So your answer then @TrashedSofa ?

WinterDeWinter · 23/11/2023 14:57

picturethispatsy · 23/11/2023 13:25

As an ex primary teacher and now home educator I find your comments laughable and so naive. The irony too…

You really need to educate yourself on what home education is! The irony of your post is that all the home educated children and young people I know are MORE educated on the things you’ve outlined than most school children. What do you think they actually teach in schools?! They barely scrape the surface of your examples.

Oh and the irony of your comment about ‘what is freedom’ ! Home educated children have the ultimate lived example of freedom just by not being in an institution.

Great, your kids will be fine then and society will benefit from their expanded world view. There are others - like those mentioned in the Op - who are not as lucky, and for whose parents home Ed is an opportunity to indoctrinate. Others whose parents ‘home Ed’ because they can’t / won’t get them to school (ie neglect).

and ofc plenty of state educated children who are also indoctrinated at home - removed from PSHE etc, or exposed to racist or homophobic or misogynistic views.

Everyone would benefit.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 23/11/2023 14:49

So, I was abused by my parents but from a naice family where things like that didn't happen and therefore when I tried to report it, I wasn't believed (1990s/early 2000s). I myself am infertile and ineligible to adopt a child because I have comorbid mental health conditions, most likely resulting from my own abuse in childhood.

I absolutely one hundred per cent get, emotionally, where OP is coming from. I've spent years trying to come to terms with the fact that my parents could keep having kids, treat them literally however they liked, and there'd be no consequences for them. None. The consequences fall on the children - as an adult, I've spent thousands on therapy so that I wouldn't pass on the cycle if I became a parent myself. I've spent thousands on therapy so that I could function in society and be completely independent of the people who treated me like that.

Only to get there and find that society deems me the one who shouldn't have a child. Me the one that's unsuited to parenthood, because I have some issues resulting from my own abuse.

And I'm not saying that it's wrong that I can't adopt. I'm genuinely not. I might well be a dreadful parent and a kid that's been through trauma already deserves better.

What I'm saying is that there's literally nothing stopping people like my parents from continuing to have kids and mistreat them, even though they too are seriously mentally ill and addicted to alcohol.

There's no answer to it because the state cannot be allowed to control fertility and family planning, but by God it is enraging to see people who wouldn't be trusted with a plant continue to produce human beings and ruin them, over and over and over again.

TrashedSofa · 23/11/2023 14:46

AgnesX · 23/11/2023 14:43

@TrashedSofa Given the circumstances I mentioned what IS the answer?

Instead of having a go at me what are your suggestions?

Edited

Asking you why you wrote something isn't having a go. You can ask me questions when you've answered mine. What's the relevance of the comment about people not wanting to pay extra when discussing forced sterilisation and abortion?

AgnesX · 23/11/2023 14:43

@TrashedSofa Given the circumstances I mentioned what IS the answer?

Instead of having a go at me what are your suggestions?

TrashedSofa · 23/11/2023 14:40

AgnesX · 23/11/2023 14:38

Read the comment. I said I didn't know the answer.

Then what was the relevance of your remarks about finances?

AgnesX · 23/11/2023 14:38

TrashedSofa · 23/11/2023 14:28

Just to clarify, do you think a mass programme of compelled abortion and sterilisation would be something we could do on the cheap?

Read the comment. I said I didn't know the answer.

TrashedSofa · 23/11/2023 14:28

AgnesX · 23/11/2023 14:05

What are British values then. Ones where toddlers and babies are beaten, battered, left neglected to live in shit by useless adults?

@Dotjones is extreme but what's the answer? SS resources are stretched, finances are tight and people don't want to pay extra.

Just to clarify, do you think a mass programme of compelled abortion and sterilisation would be something we could do on the cheap?

autumnnightsaredrawingin · 23/11/2023 14:13

I have been thinking about this more and more, I took my toddler to the park this morning, he went on the swings and the slide, went to see the ducks, have a snack on the park bench and then we got some food shopping. I am NOT a perfect parent. But it makes me really sad that some kids will just never do these kind of basic experiences, be talked to and engaged with, see and talk about the different things outside (eg I talked about the different coloured leaves, pointed out aeroplanes in the sky etc). It IS pretty bad parenting if your child doesn’t have this surely.

AgnesX · 23/11/2023 14:05

MidnightOnceMore · 22/11/2023 13:39

People who think like this are a danger to society.

This is fascism. This is not in line with British values.

What are British values then. Ones where toddlers and babies are beaten, battered, left neglected to live in shit by useless adults?

@Dotjones is extreme but what's the answer? SS resources are stretched, finances are tight and people don't want to pay extra.

MarkWithaC · 23/11/2023 13:54

picturethispatsy · 23/11/2023 13:25

As an ex primary teacher and now home educator I find your comments laughable and so naive. The irony too…

You really need to educate yourself on what home education is! The irony of your post is that all the home educated children and young people I know are MORE educated on the things you’ve outlined than most school children. What do you think they actually teach in schools?! They barely scrape the surface of your examples.

Oh and the irony of your comment about ‘what is freedom’ ! Home educated children have the ultimate lived example of freedom just by not being in an institution.

TBF Winter is talking about what's currently not taught in schools, not just what (they think; rightly or wrongly, I don't know) isn't taught at home.

I may be wrong, but my feeling is that people who home-ed are more likely to teach the sort of thing and hold the sort of principles Winter is talking about; I'd imagine that as a group they are generally speaking more highly educated and more interested in things Winter advocates teaching on.

Your position on freedom is debatable. I take the point about institutions, but freedom is not simply about freedom from mainstream setups. You could argue that experiencing time away from the family home and learn/socialise with peers in a school setup is freedom too.

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 23/11/2023 13:32

EggEggEgg · 23/11/2023 03:04

I somewhat agree with this. When I was growing up - very rurally - my father was often away for 6 weeks at a time and my mother didn't drive. We didn't have the all the activities that it seems children have now - we just had the library and a park near by. None of us went to pre-school. We didn't have a huge amount of toys, either, as we weren't well-off, and our we lived far away from any family, too.

But in MN terms, we were severely neglected?

No one is saying that amounts to neglect, I somehow doubt your mother let you sit in your PJs all day and kept you indoors while she was gaming. The nursery argument is only relevant because the mother isn't interacting with the child at all and therefore neglecting the child. I don't think anyone is suggesting children at home with loving families at 2 are being neglected.

picturethispatsy · 23/11/2023 13:25

WinterDeWinter · 22/11/2023 18:28

Agree with most pps that there's no way of addressing these things that don't verge towards oppressive BUT

I think that all children should have to be educated about ethics and society, and politics and democracy - so that they have an understanding of what makes a decent society, what is freedom and where are its limits, why we have taxation and benefits, our responsibilities to our fellow citizens, 'prosocial' behaviour, what is a 'good life' etc are discussed and debated, plus issues like consent - and I definitely think that parents including home edders should not be able to remove their children from that. I'd go further and say that home educated children should receive that aspect of education from adults other than their parents.

Edited to add - maybe parenting should also be a module. What does a child need and deserve? kind of thing. Part of my reasoning for the whole idea is that they will themselves be less likely to be the kind of parents that their own parents were.

Edited

As an ex primary teacher and now home educator I find your comments laughable and so naive. The irony too…

You really need to educate yourself on what home education is! The irony of your post is that all the home educated children and young people I know are MORE educated on the things you’ve outlined than most school children. What do you think they actually teach in schools?! They barely scrape the surface of your examples.

Oh and the irony of your comment about ‘what is freedom’ ! Home educated children have the ultimate lived example of freedom just by not being in an institution.

MrsAvocet · 23/11/2023 12:13

EggEggEgg · 23/11/2023 03:04

I somewhat agree with this. When I was growing up - very rurally - my father was often away for 6 weeks at a time and my mother didn't drive. We didn't have the all the activities that it seems children have now - we just had the library and a park near by. None of us went to pre-school. We didn't have a huge amount of toys, either, as we weren't well-off, and our we lived far away from any family, too.

But in MN terms, we were severely neglected?

I don't think anyone is saying that. For a start, most posters who have said they think the OP's nephew is neglected have acknowledged that it isn't severe when you consider the forms that neglect and abuse can take. And the child does have a huge amount of toys apparently - it's not material things that are the issue, but the lack of interaction and the fact that the mother seemingly can't be bothered to do things with him. (I agree with those who have suggested that she may in fact have some mental health problems and be in need of support and education rather than punishment however.)
It is in fact the lack of the basic stuff like going to the park and library etc that is the worry. To my mind, the fact that the child apparently does not go outdoors for weeks at a time is a concern. Unless they live somewhere like Hampton Court Palace and he has the Long Gallery to run around in, how does a child who rarely leaves the house get enough physical exercise and develop motor skills? You need space that a typical house just doesn't provide. And what about Vitamin D? We know a significant proportion of the population, especially in the more northerly parts of the country where there is less sunlight become Vit D deficient in the winter months even if they do spend time outdoors and rickets, though still rare, is making a comeback. So a child who does not go out and has a suboptimal diet must surely be at greater risk than average ?
I grew up in a small industrial Northern town in the late 60s/70s and we didn't have much either. I spent most of my time within my immediate family or with the neighbours. There weren't many organised activities for kids and what there were we couldn't afford. But I was never stuck in the house all day or short of physical activity, even if it was just the daily walk to the shops sometimes. I bet you weren't either.
The world has changed. You can't make direct comparisons with the past.

MarkWithaC · 23/11/2023 11:10

WinterDeWinter · 22/11/2023 18:28

Agree with most pps that there's no way of addressing these things that don't verge towards oppressive BUT

I think that all children should have to be educated about ethics and society, and politics and democracy - so that they have an understanding of what makes a decent society, what is freedom and where are its limits, why we have taxation and benefits, our responsibilities to our fellow citizens, 'prosocial' behaviour, what is a 'good life' etc are discussed and debated, plus issues like consent - and I definitely think that parents including home edders should not be able to remove their children from that. I'd go further and say that home educated children should receive that aspect of education from adults other than their parents.

Edited to add - maybe parenting should also be a module. What does a child need and deserve? kind of thing. Part of my reasoning for the whole idea is that they will themselves be less likely to be the kind of parents that their own parents were.

Edited

I think this sounds sensible, particularly about society, freedom and consent. The rule of law applies to us all, regardless of social/religious/cultural differences, and I think everyone should be exposed from a young age to the concept of it. If someone wants to teach their child at home that (for example) in their religion being gay is a sin, then I personally think that's execrable, but they have freedom of belief. BUT everyone should also be aware of what the actual laws are on issues like this.

MarkWithaC · 23/11/2023 11:03

EggEggEgg · 23/11/2023 03:04

I somewhat agree with this. When I was growing up - very rurally - my father was often away for 6 weeks at a time and my mother didn't drive. We didn't have the all the activities that it seems children have now - we just had the library and a park near by. None of us went to pre-school. We didn't have a huge amount of toys, either, as we weren't well-off, and our we lived far away from any family, too.

But in MN terms, we were severely neglected?

That sounds like my early childhood; I spent a lot of time at home doing simple things like finger paints and reading/being read to, and a lot of time walking round our village, with just my mum. No money for structured activities and I'm not even sure there were any. Not many toys either. We watched kids' telly (such as it was in the late 70s) but I had hardly any screen time compared to what's available today.

And no, I wouldn't say either of us were neglected. But going to the park and library with a parent like (I assume) you did, or walking round the village, looking at and talking about plants, horses, birds etc, and doing simple craft things, like me, isn't the same as hardly leaving the house and mainly having a tablet for stimulation.

WandaWonder · 23/11/2023 05:23

There is being concerned for a child/ren and there is being a overinvested busy body

MixedCouple · 23/11/2023 05:11

Example 1 is border line neglect especially if she goes out. BUT he will go to school soon so will have social life and will make friends.

I grew up with no social life outside of school apart from Family and lots of cousins as I was too abnormal for the kids at school. Fine they played with me at school but being a different ethnicity and religion meant I was excluded from everything. My parents were relaxed but no one wanted to befriend me as I was different. I grew up fine I have strong family bonds.
But my parents were fantastic and did loads with us, trips, outings, swiming, roller blasing, biking etc etc. They were very hands on.

2nd one isn't as bad as the first. I agree with them on a few things. Yes the government and water companies acknowledge water contamination but cant be arsed to fix it as it wip coat £30billion to tax payers. There are peer reviewed studies on the contaminations. Power to them if they can afford filtered safe water. Us peseants just suffer.

We will be homeschooling our kids and we do not vaccinate (I have a million vaccinations as I worked in the NHS). Have done my own peer reviewed research. We also don't do TV
But allow monitored screen time on my Mobile / Laptop. Our child is bright and super social.
We actually go to loads of groups but again being and looking different no one includes us any groups outside of the playgroup. they do lots but never tell us.
We try to integrate but the door has been shut closed on us.

So yes your judgment is fair in some parts but the reat is opinion. But the first one is concerning. Instead of judging I would just be more hands on aunty and get the kids out more often or have sleep overa so they have a good 2 days for freedom. Staying indoors for weeks is not healthy for anyone.

sashh · 23/11/2023 04:51

Summermeadowflowers · 22/11/2023 13:37

Isn’t that (sort of) what happened in Canada, though? My memory is vague but I think First Nations children were removed from their parents. It didn’t go well and my understanding is that Canada is still recovering from that now so to speak.

And in Australia. Aborigine children taken away from their parents because white people thought they didn't parent well. Aborigine parents did things like teach their child to hunt, allowed them to not wear clothes, sleep on the floor on a hunting trip.

It's so difficult to tell what is a cult and what damage does it do? Or does it not do.

Some ultra orthodox jews live their lives within their own communities.

Amish are similar.

They believe they are doing the best for their children and community. Who is to say whether they are or are not?