Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s crazy you can parent whatever way you want?!

368 replies

ItsGivingJudgey · 22/11/2023 13:00

This OP will sound judgey has hell hence my username. I’ve NC but long time user.

I know it’s a free country (in the UK at least). I also really support human rights, however I still find it mad that you can have a child and raise them whatever way you want no matter how batshit so long as it doesn’t meet the very high legal requirements for removal.

Examples:

ONE:

My SIL does F all with her child and he’s now 2.5 years old. He literally does not leave the house other than for absolute essentials such as medical appointments. He doesn’t go to nursery despite it being free (she doesn’t work). He’s never been swimming, to feed the ducks, to the beach or the local park. He’s never met other children outside of his cousins. He’s only ever been to soft play twice when I have physically picked them up to take them with me and my dc.
He only ever leaves the house when my in-laws take him food shopping with them just to get him out. He can literally go 1-2 weeks without being outside his front door.
SIL on the other hand goes on holidays, days out with her boyfriend, cocktails with friends etc. She just has the in-laws babysit when she does. Her reasoning? ‘It’s a faff’ ‘the weather is bad’ or she ‘can’t be arsed today’. She was very lazy before becoming a parent but her laziness now has extended to her child who literally lives his entire life within the confines of the house. It’s nothing to do with mental health on her part, it’s pure laziness. She’ll only take him out if a member of the family with a car physically goes and picks them up and drops them back off home. The nursery is less than a 5 minute walk from her house. She was badgered by the health visitor to enroll him so she did it, took him for a week and then never bothered again as it was ‘too much faffing about for just a few hours’.

He lives off microwave meals and tinned food. Wakes up and spends the entire day in front of the tv or with his tablet. When my in-laws went away last year he didn’t leave the house for 3 weeks!!

It doesn’t meet the legal requirements or thresholds for social services. He is fed and clothed and has lots of toys. But it’s crazy that he is able to spend his entire life within the confines of a house and that’s that.

TWO:

My cousin. Very well educated, affluent and has always been a bit eccentric as is her DH. However over the years they have joined a kind of weird religion/cult like group and are massive conspiracy theorists. They homeschool their kids (fine), but have indoctrinated them with mad beliefs. The kids including the baby are vegan. Their unvaccinated. They can only bath in this specially filtered water. The kids are feral and not allowed to watch tv, listen to any type of mainstream music only this specifically selected whale like music. They avoid any type of radiation and limit sources of power so in the evenings the house is lit by candlelight and an open fire. The kids wear this robe like clothing that seems impractical. The kids no nothing outside of their parents beliefs. They have no awareness of the outside world. They only socialise with the other people in this conspiracy group that also homeschool.

My cousin and her husband are well meaning and obviously it’s their right to believe what they wish. But their kids won’t know how to use the internet, any real world references, learn about other religions or cultures. Surely this will do long term harm in some way?

The children couldn’t tell you what spaghetti bolognaise is or what a smartphone/tablet is or that there was ever a world war or even how what a kettle
is for. But they can tell you about crystal healing powers. What if when they get to 18 they want to live a ‘mainstream’ life and join society? How will they manage? Get a job? Make friends with peers?

It’s not that I believe there’s only one right way to parent or anything because I don’t. However I find it mad that you can have a baby and so long as you meet very basic standards, you can literally do as you want with actual human beings.

Please tell me if I’m being unreasonable to think it’s not right and if I am being unreasonable why so? I feel so sorry for these children.

OP posts:
Simonjt · 24/11/2023 06:45

Portakalkedi · 23/11/2023 23:34

I've often thought this OP, that there should be some sort of 'licence' you have to have to be allowed to procreate. Far far too many terrible, lazy or downright abusive people having kids without the slightest forethought. At least something like what is required for adoption. You can't say this IRL though.

So you would either happily have the rights to your own body removed, or you would be happy for women to be imprisoned and they be forced into abortions they don’t want, or would you go for the method of drowning new born babies of parents who don’t pass your assessments?

picturethispatsy · 24/11/2023 04:47

Fionaville · 23/11/2023 22:28

This 👏👏 So many misconceptions about home ed on this thread.
We do it because it's wonderful, our children are having the best childhood and quite frankly they know more about the world than most of their schooled friends. They aren't indoctrinated, they are out in the world. They have lots of friends from their various clubs, both home ed and school kids. They are happy, healthy, confident and well balanced young people. As are their home ed friends. Home ed kids are a joy to be around, they play for much longer than school kids because they dont feel any pressure to grow up too soon. They converse well with adults and when they are interested in a topic, they deep dive into it and love to talk about it. Most of them are still interested in the latest trends, they aren't all totally sheltered and wearing gowns. They are just normal children from normal families, who have made a big investment in their children's education and happiness.

This is my experience too.

The funniest thing people say about home Ed kids is ‘how will they be prepared for the real world?’ totally missing the entire point of home ed which is that they are IN the real world everyday 😂 not sat in an institution for most of their childhood being told what and how to learn to pass tests (with other kids the exact same ages as them only) or which will never happen again in their lives (obviously other than further education in some cases). They are in museums, on trains, in parks, at exhibitions, traveling, in shops, in cafes, in sports centres, in forests at forest school, with friends, parents, grandparents, at workshops etc etc everyday.

SurvivorsInc · 24/11/2023 02:40

Summermeadowflowers · 22/11/2023 13:41

Could go into more detail? I’d find it interesting if you have time Smile

I recommend you read Oranges and Sunshine by Margaret Humphreys. Very interesting but profoundly sad and shocking book.

Lucytheloose · 24/11/2023 02:33

Lifestylechoices · 22/11/2023 14:12

I know of a large family where the dc are homeschooled and the mother has seemingly made up her own religion and teaches the dc her beliefs - she argues that nobody can provide proof of any other religion so why is she wrong to teach hers

To be fair, she has a point.

Blueink · 24/11/2023 01:51

WhenSheWasBadshewasawesome · 24/11/2023 00:11

A few points

Whilst I believe the first would probably count as neglect, it's interesting that those of us that had babies in 2020 were legally not allowed to take our children anywhere. For nearly two years our children were not allowed consistently on day trips, socialisation and softplay. When I raised this at the time with a health visitor she said all baby needs is mum. Except the studies coming out of COVID have identified that as bullshit. It actually took me a while to do proper outings and things because I had it drummed into me that going out was bad and staying home was enough. You just kind of get used to staying home all day and playing with the same toys and reading the same books.
I just think it's interesting three years down the line what we were forced to do is largely being agreed as neglect on here. I seem to recall at the time the consensus was if you took your kid to the park you were an evil granny killer.

Point two the NHS says a well planned vegan or vegetarian diet is suitable for all stages of life. So you are very much wrong about that. I find it interesting that you dislike cults but there is no bigger cult and lies than the meat industry. I'm all for live and let live (or die in the case of meat eaters) but really most meat eaters peddle such absolute rubbish about the welfare origins and health benefits of their food whilst chugging down proven cancer causing animal products. Every bit as cult like as anything in your op if you ask me.

Homeschooling is a valid choice but like school it needs to be well planned and carried out for good results. It's rapidly becoming the only choice for Sen families.

Anti vac is a bit of a broad brush. Huge difference between those parents who won't allow any vaccinations and those who are hesitant for their children to become COVID vaccination Guinea pigs.

If you work within neurodiversity and mental health you'll know how common it is for women to have nd conditions or mental health problems ignores by professionals. Don't become one of them.

Report neglect. Step up to support your own family.

There has undoubtedly been a huge impact on DC (and their parents), but being in a pandemic situation is obviously a very different context.

This government were an absolute shambles and exploited the situation for their own gains. They dithered at the start and mismanaged things, like Sunak’s eat out policy, which led to harsh rebound restrictions.

Even with the most restricted measures though, PP describing going out looking at leaves, splashing in puddles etc could all still happen during pandemic times. If SIL was interacting with him in this way even now I don’t think a concern would be there.

timesaretight · 24/11/2023 00:54

Parents cannot parent however they want.

Christmaste · 24/11/2023 00:30

I’m not sure I believe this. You seem to know an awful lot about the exact ins and outs of the lives of these kids.

If he never went out he’d probably have a vitamin D deficiency. I don’t think any of this is true.

garlictwist · 24/11/2023 00:21

Dotjones · 22/11/2023 13:11

I agree, it's ridiculous you need a licence to drive a car (or even to operate a television) but literally anyone is allowed to become a parent. I'd like to see a system where parents and those who are expecting or trying to concieve have to attend classes and reach a certain standard, otherwise the kids are taken away/terminated and the parents sterilised.

WTF 😲

WhenSheWasBadshewasawesome · 24/11/2023 00:11

A few points

Whilst I believe the first would probably count as neglect, it's interesting that those of us that had babies in 2020 were legally not allowed to take our children anywhere. For nearly two years our children were not allowed consistently on day trips, socialisation and softplay. When I raised this at the time with a health visitor she said all baby needs is mum. Except the studies coming out of COVID have identified that as bullshit. It actually took me a while to do proper outings and things because I had it drummed into me that going out was bad and staying home was enough. You just kind of get used to staying home all day and playing with the same toys and reading the same books.
I just think it's interesting three years down the line what we were forced to do is largely being agreed as neglect on here. I seem to recall at the time the consensus was if you took your kid to the park you were an evil granny killer.

Point two the NHS says a well planned vegan or vegetarian diet is suitable for all stages of life. So you are very much wrong about that. I find it interesting that you dislike cults but there is no bigger cult and lies than the meat industry. I'm all for live and let live (or die in the case of meat eaters) but really most meat eaters peddle such absolute rubbish about the welfare origins and health benefits of their food whilst chugging down proven cancer causing animal products. Every bit as cult like as anything in your op if you ask me.

Homeschooling is a valid choice but like school it needs to be well planned and carried out for good results. It's rapidly becoming the only choice for Sen families.

Anti vac is a bit of a broad brush. Huge difference between those parents who won't allow any vaccinations and those who are hesitant for their children to become COVID vaccination Guinea pigs.

If you work within neurodiversity and mental health you'll know how common it is for women to have nd conditions or mental health problems ignores by professionals. Don't become one of them.

Report neglect. Step up to support your own family.

Portakalkedi · 23/11/2023 23:34

I've often thought this OP, that there should be some sort of 'licence' you have to have to be allowed to procreate. Far far too many terrible, lazy or downright abusive people having kids without the slightest forethought. At least something like what is required for adoption. You can't say this IRL though.

Fionaville · 23/11/2023 22:28

picturethispatsy · 23/11/2023 19:58

No, there isn’t, because the local authority know that we don’t need one. They know that we’re giving our children a personalised 1-2-1 education and that statistically home educated children/teens have equal or better outcomes in life than schooled kids 😊

This 👏👏 So many misconceptions about home ed on this thread.
We do it because it's wonderful, our children are having the best childhood and quite frankly they know more about the world than most of their schooled friends. They aren't indoctrinated, they are out in the world. They have lots of friends from their various clubs, both home ed and school kids. They are happy, healthy, confident and well balanced young people. As are their home ed friends. Home ed kids are a joy to be around, they play for much longer than school kids because they dont feel any pressure to grow up too soon. They converse well with adults and when they are interested in a topic, they deep dive into it and love to talk about it. Most of them are still interested in the latest trends, they aren't all totally sheltered and wearing gowns. They are just normal children from normal families, who have made a big investment in their children's education and happiness.

Blueink · 23/11/2023 21:50

OP when you say SIL situation doesn’t meet the threshold, has all this been reported? I agree with PP he wouldn’t be removed for this, but that doesn’t mean he wouldn’t be eligible for support as a child in need.

How is he behaving around family taking him out is very telling, especially trying to get out and crying when brought back.

Jack80 · 23/11/2023 21:28

I've always gone on the theory most people can create a baby but not all are capable of looking after them unfortunately. We have a horrid neighbour, I'm sure she has additional needs she shouts constantly at her two children. The eldest tried to stab her and lives elsewhere, the middle boy goes a special school and the youngest who is a girl always looks like her clothes are bobbly and well worn. She always get takeaways and has amazon deliveries and doesn't work. She had an altercation with a neighbour in another close near by blamed her sons needs and not getting help and people don't know what she puts up with. She always has a skip every few months god know where she gets the c*rap she puts in it or the money.

She can't be reported to social services I imagine because she will say the children are looked after and we'll fed as are her 3 dogs and cat.

Leah5678 · 23/11/2023 21:15

Twinsmamma · 23/11/2023 20:15

In additional to my previous message, can I ask why have you or his grandparents not taken him to a park? I do understand he’s not your responsibility but he’s family and surely family have to look out for each other. She may be a lost cause but it sounds like you and his grandparents have a chance to help this poor boy MASSIVELY, and maybe aren’t? You sound as though you live close by with children a similar age, can you not just take it upon yourself to do more? I’d not sit by while my nieces and nephews were treated like this I’d not sleep at night!

Exactly this.
Going by what I've read on this thread op drives and has kids a similar age. It is surely as easy as just picking the kid up and taking him on family days out (dosent have to be big and expensive could just be a picknick in the park or just spending time together)
Ops kids would probably love being with their cousin and the boy will be getting out and experiencing the world. It's a win for everyone

Blueink · 23/11/2023 21:04

SIL I would consider to be neglectful - it isn’t just about having enough food, she isn’t meeting his other needs such as socialisation.

She seems very self centred and can obviously be bothered to go out when it’s a jolly for her.

MichB86 · 23/11/2023 20:50

ItsGivingJudgey · 22/11/2023 13:46

I agree with every response so far.

How do you judge it? And by whose standards?

I guess this is where my unreasonableness comes in.

I don’t think I’m a perfect parent at all. There are a hundred things people could judge me on I’m sure. But then I think there’s an unwritten line. When things aren’t quite abuse but also aren’t right by the majorities standards?

So SIL in example 1. Okay, he is warm, clothed and fed. Not abused. But then he lives his life in pyjamas. You’ll see him in a Christmas onesie at 2pm in August. It’ll be a lovely day of sunshine and he hasn’t left his house in 10 days and won’t for another week or so. He won’t see a soul or experience the sun or going on a swing or slide. Another day being sat in front on the tv with his tablet and bag of crisps on his own whilst SIL games. This will be repeated every single day through summer until grandparents are able to come and physically get him to take him out.

Most people would say that’s out of order and borderline neglect. However legally no laws have been broken and he doesn’t meet any thresholds for abuse so it is what it is. He can be damned to that life forevermore and there’s nothing we can do about it.
That’s what i find mind blowing.

This is just so incredibly sad.

Twinsmamma · 23/11/2023 20:15

In additional to my previous message, can I ask why have you or his grandparents not taken him to a park? I do understand he’s not your responsibility but he’s family and surely family have to look out for each other. She may be a lost cause but it sounds like you and his grandparents have a chance to help this poor boy MASSIVELY, and maybe aren’t? You sound as though you live close by with children a similar age, can you not just take it upon yourself to do more? I’d not sit by while my nieces and nephews were treated like this I’d not sleep at night!

picturethispatsy · 23/11/2023 19:58

OhcantthInkofaname · 23/11/2023 18:21

Isn't there basic curriculum or testing for homeschooled children in the UK?
As for situation 1 when is this child expected to start schooling? That will solve some of the issue.

No, there isn’t, because the local authority know that we don’t need one. They know that we’re giving our children a personalised 1-2-1 education and that statistically home educated children/teens have equal or better outcomes in life than schooled kids 😊

DetectiveDouche · 23/11/2023 19:24

I’ve scanned through the thread and apologise if I’ve missed it but has no one mentioned Early Help? OP, you can Google and find out the Early Help contact number for your region and speak to someone about your concerns. You don’t have to give your name.

Early Help can then be instigated and the family offered assistance although your family member (sorry was it cousin? Re Scenario 1) .. will need to agree to see an Early Help Worker who may or may not take this as far as an assessment but you cousin can choose not to comply at any time and withdraw consent. However, the fact that she may be offered assistance, in various forms, ranging from help with basic parenting through to the EHW spending time with the child and making referrals to other agencies for further input, may appeal to your cousin? Maybe not but perhaps the “free stuff” might appeal?

Also, although EH requires parental consent to proceed, if the worker is able to at least start to work with/assess the family, they may observe enough to escalate it to some form of intervention that does require consent. Not necessarily heavy handed intervention but mandatory input nonetheless, that has to be complied with and may instigate positive changes for the child.

Mostly EH exists to support parents and children but it is a form of low level social services and the EH workers do work alongside social workers.

WhatNoUsername · 23/11/2023 19:23

Dotjones · 22/11/2023 13:11

I agree, it's ridiculous you need a licence to drive a car (or even to operate a television) but literally anyone is allowed to become a parent. I'd like to see a system where parents and those who are expecting or trying to concieve have to attend classes and reach a certain standard, otherwise the kids are taken away/terminated and the parents sterilised.

Well you've just described some horrifying dystopia....fuck me.

Twinsmamma · 23/11/2023 19:20

Lisa46 · 23/11/2023 19:09

I really feel for this little child - I want to come and take him out myself, but I can't. I guess the one ray of hope is that he will have to go to school - it'll be too much of a faff for her to home school him.

Same, breaks your heart to think how bored and lonely he is!

BubbleBubbleBubbleBubblePop · 23/11/2023 19:15

@ItsGivingJudgey just out of curiosity, your SIL's child, is he behind with milestones? How is he with speech, understanding, following instructions, his gross motor skills etc? Has his development been hampered because of this lifestyle? Poor kid.

Twinsmamma · 23/11/2023 19:14

Your SIL scenario has actually upset me quite a bit, my twins are the exact same age and I genuinely feel like a bad parent if mine don’t leave the house for 1 day!!! And they have each other to play with all day. I know you’ve tried intervention but please try again if you can, has it been outlined to her this is actually very cruel and will most likely cause life long damage to him and his development? This is very neglectful and so unfair on him. What does your DH say assuming it’s his sister?

TrashedSofa · 23/11/2023 19:10

Fwiw2 · 23/11/2023 18:51

If you are concerned, make a referral to the local authority. Certainly a child never being taken out of the house would concern me enough to raise. There are a number of steps LAs can take that are short of removal; early help, child in need plans and support (inc parenting classes)

More generally. Hedley J in Re L (a family law case which is often quoted) said;

“…society must be willing to tolerate very diverse standards of parenting, including the eccentric, the barely adequate and the inconsistent. It follows too that children will inevitably have both very different experiences of parenting and very unequal consequences flowing from it. It means that some children will experience disadvantage and harm, while others will flourish in atmospheres of loving security and emotional stability. These are the consequences of our fallible humanity and it is not the provenance of the state to spare children all the consequences of defective parenting. In any event, it simply could not be done.”

The last sentence is the most important one there.

Lisa46 · 23/11/2023 19:09

I really feel for this little child - I want to come and take him out myself, but I can't. I guess the one ray of hope is that he will have to go to school - it'll be too much of a faff for her to home school him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread