Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s crazy you can parent whatever way you want?!

368 replies

ItsGivingJudgey · 22/11/2023 13:00

This OP will sound judgey has hell hence my username. I’ve NC but long time user.

I know it’s a free country (in the UK at least). I also really support human rights, however I still find it mad that you can have a child and raise them whatever way you want no matter how batshit so long as it doesn’t meet the very high legal requirements for removal.

Examples:

ONE:

My SIL does F all with her child and he’s now 2.5 years old. He literally does not leave the house other than for absolute essentials such as medical appointments. He doesn’t go to nursery despite it being free (she doesn’t work). He’s never been swimming, to feed the ducks, to the beach or the local park. He’s never met other children outside of his cousins. He’s only ever been to soft play twice when I have physically picked them up to take them with me and my dc.
He only ever leaves the house when my in-laws take him food shopping with them just to get him out. He can literally go 1-2 weeks without being outside his front door.
SIL on the other hand goes on holidays, days out with her boyfriend, cocktails with friends etc. She just has the in-laws babysit when she does. Her reasoning? ‘It’s a faff’ ‘the weather is bad’ or she ‘can’t be arsed today’. She was very lazy before becoming a parent but her laziness now has extended to her child who literally lives his entire life within the confines of the house. It’s nothing to do with mental health on her part, it’s pure laziness. She’ll only take him out if a member of the family with a car physically goes and picks them up and drops them back off home. The nursery is less than a 5 minute walk from her house. She was badgered by the health visitor to enroll him so she did it, took him for a week and then never bothered again as it was ‘too much faffing about for just a few hours’.

He lives off microwave meals and tinned food. Wakes up and spends the entire day in front of the tv or with his tablet. When my in-laws went away last year he didn’t leave the house for 3 weeks!!

It doesn’t meet the legal requirements or thresholds for social services. He is fed and clothed and has lots of toys. But it’s crazy that he is able to spend his entire life within the confines of a house and that’s that.

TWO:

My cousin. Very well educated, affluent and has always been a bit eccentric as is her DH. However over the years they have joined a kind of weird religion/cult like group and are massive conspiracy theorists. They homeschool their kids (fine), but have indoctrinated them with mad beliefs. The kids including the baby are vegan. Their unvaccinated. They can only bath in this specially filtered water. The kids are feral and not allowed to watch tv, listen to any type of mainstream music only this specifically selected whale like music. They avoid any type of radiation and limit sources of power so in the evenings the house is lit by candlelight and an open fire. The kids wear this robe like clothing that seems impractical. The kids no nothing outside of their parents beliefs. They have no awareness of the outside world. They only socialise with the other people in this conspiracy group that also homeschool.

My cousin and her husband are well meaning and obviously it’s their right to believe what they wish. But their kids won’t know how to use the internet, any real world references, learn about other religions or cultures. Surely this will do long term harm in some way?

The children couldn’t tell you what spaghetti bolognaise is or what a smartphone/tablet is or that there was ever a world war or even how what a kettle
is for. But they can tell you about crystal healing powers. What if when they get to 18 they want to live a ‘mainstream’ life and join society? How will they manage? Get a job? Make friends with peers?

It’s not that I believe there’s only one right way to parent or anything because I don’t. However I find it mad that you can have a baby and so long as you meet very basic standards, you can literally do as you want with actual human beings.

Please tell me if I’m being unreasonable to think it’s not right and if I am being unreasonable why so? I feel so sorry for these children.

OP posts:
Blueink · 24/11/2023 20:48

TrashedSofa · 24/11/2023 08:31

It is pretty interesting to view this discussion in the context of recent pandemic response policy.

One point that's not come up yet, I don't think, is that for varying reasons a lot of parents are angry about the way the state has treated the welfare of their children since covid kicked in, and so there's a lot of mistrust. This isn't limited to one particular view on lockdown either. There are people who feel their children have been thrown under the bus because of schools closing, not closing soon enough, air quality in classrooms, isolation bubble rules, kids being allowed in when covid positive now... those arguments exist right across the spectrum. It's not a pro or anti lockdown thing, it applies to both.

So the idea of the state being either practically or morally qualified to set out and enforce much more intrusive standards on things like fresh air, tablet time and socialisation is, well, not exactly universally accepted. Not when so many people feel their DCs welfare has been treated as collateral.

I agree totally that children and their parents were adversely affected as I said and per my post also very critical of how this was (mis) managed by our gov, so very much share your anger.

I don’t see it as being “forced to neglect our children” but being in a pandemic situation with a shambolic gov - lazy and uncaring as evidenced by their shenanigans some of which now exposed through media and enquiry. They are the neglectful ones, but have a poor track record in non pandemic times too when it comes to supporting children, so what did we expect.

There are green spaces in our cities and unless the lifts are out of order it is perfectly possible to get outside. I have lived in a high rise in the city with no car. OP’s SIL is not in any case living in a high rise flat.

I don’t want to comment on Spain or Malaysia, partly because I don’t have a lived experience of bringing up DC or being in pandemic times in those countries and partly because it is even more removed from the situation described by OP of her SIL I mentioned “looking at leaves” etc because as I said it was something mentioned by PP and was still possible to go outside to do with DC in UK pandemic times.

Rhaenys · 24/11/2023 19:35

Realistically, in scenario 1 things will chance drastically once the child starts school.

Naptrappedmummy · 24/11/2023 15:19

I actually don’t detect judgement outside what mainstream parents would think. I don’t think she’s judging these things individually but they’re all part of a wider picture where the children have every aspect of life drilled into them as something dangerous or nefarious. If all they were doing was using distilled water for baths I doubt she would have bothered to write about them. She isn’t extremely judgemental to think depriving a child of learning virtually anything about the society they live in is disadvantageous. I won’t paste verbatim because i would have to open a new window and I’m not that fussed about making my point! But I think she acknowledges the home schoolers aren’t abusive as such just unconventional to the point they’re going to leave their children with an unhealthy fear of the world around them. I saw a thread the other day where a poster complained about her mother in law cleaning the baby high chair with mr muscle and she was told to relax because her ocd would give the baby a complex. So it all ties in with the fact posters have responded not according to the subject matter but the fact it’s op judging someone else and regardless of the facts she must therefore be put in her place

WhenSheWasBadshewasawesome · 24/11/2023 14:49

"They homeschool their kids (fine), but have indoctrinated them with mad beliefs.*

What are mad beliefs? Op doesn't say but then goes on to describe veganism as a mad belief. A very acceptable way of living approved by the NHS and rather mainstream these days considering the state meat makes of the planet.

They can only bath in this specially filtered water.
Plastic waste yes, but otherwise hurts no one. Pointless judging.

The kids are feral and not allowed to watch tv,
What does feral mean in this context? So far it sounds like they might go outdoors and climb trees, use tools as they are not using television. Shocking.

listen to any type of mainstream music only this specifically selected whale like music.
So different music then. Bet the op doesn't let her child listen to every genre of music. Again. Who is it harming if kids don't hear pop music, which is mostly disgustingly misogynistic anyway at this point?

They avoid any type of radiation and limit sources of power so in the evenings the house is lit by candlelight and an open fire.
Sounds like they are harming no one. Cosy.

The kids wear this robe like clothing that seems impractical.
Again, how is a robe a worse choice than putting a baby girl in a bow and dress. Pretty mainstream but impractical. And most girls under ten have those awful impractical dolly shows then get clunky heels. Op probably fine with that. Parent choices. Why is one terrible and one not worth commenting on?

Also, I'm not sure I believe that bit. She's jumped the shark there .

The kids no nothing outside of their parents beliefs. They have no awareness of the outside world. They only socialise with the other people in this conspiracy group that also homeschool.

People can see the judgement here because this is largely how homeschool works. Only exposed to people in your social circle. It's also how schools work, which is why you look round schools and find out their ethos before you send your children there. But one is seen as conspiracy and one just normal. If you go to Catholic school same result for example.

But their kids won’t know how to use the internet, any real world references, learn about other religions or cultures. Surely this will do long term harm in some way?

They might use it to learn about the Amish or Mormons.
But probably they'd just access porn.

*The children couldn’t tell you what spaghetti bolognaise is or what a smartphone/tablet is or that there was ever a world war or even how what a kettle
is for. *

Implied judgement. People must eat my foods and use technology I deem important. My kids don't have spaghetti Bolognese very often as it's rank. I'm sure we eat lots of things op has never heard of. Call social services.

In terms of wars I doubt any children below ks2 know about a world war. I myself don't like the glorification of war and think the national curriculum changes to put it in older year groups is a good one. Maybe they are following that logic. Maybe they are just nuts. Who knows. Op is unreliable source.

As for the kettle. I assume she means an electric one..plenty of us grew up using a stove kettle and then got our electric kettles just fine when we went to university. Or is she saying they use a cauldron? Either way I'm sure they have the means to boil water

But they can tell you about crystal healing powers. What if when they get to 18 they want to live a ‘mainstream’ life and join society? How will they manage? Get a job? Make friends with peers?

They'll go 'oh that's interesting tell me more.' Yes I always wanted to work part time in a slaughter house and the other part heating spaghetti Bolognese in my office job.

It's not that I believe there’s only one right way to parent or anything because I don’t.

If you can't detect the judgement that contradicts this statement I can't help you. It's right on there you just need critical thinking skills.

Naptrappedmummy · 24/11/2023 14:15

Can you quote what she has said to make you believe she thinks all home educating parents are negligent and that anything outside of her own narrow perspective is abuse? I re read all her posts and saw nothing?

WhenSheWasBadshewasawesome · 24/11/2023 13:59

You miss my point, I agree that specific example is neglectful. But it's the way that the op has conflated two completely different circumstances that makes it judgemental.

Her argument is essentially, people who neglect their children by never taking them out, are vegan, homeschool, don't like technology are all neglectful.

She's seen something she should be concerned about that would constitute neglect, which is why I pointed out that it was in fact wrong of the government to gaslight us into collectively neglecting our children, and then applied the same logic to every tiny difference in parenting choices.

Naptrappedmummy · 24/11/2023 13:55

@WhenSheWasBadshewasawesome i disagree. I think if this was a reverse and poster was complaining about being judged for keeping her kid cooped up for weeks on end, everyone would tell her she was neglectful and that it’s no life for a small child. Because it’s not that way round and op is instead doing the judging, the responses are totally different. Because ‘judging’ itself transcends whatever it is they’re judging. And people feel that they have to argue against her opinion because they simply don’t like how she is making it. Thats my view anyway

elliejjtiny · 24/11/2023 13:47

Thing is, if the SIL in the first example was referred to early help or social services the first thing that would happen is that they would be asking what her family was doing to help and trying to get them to help more. In my experience that is always the first option before social services provide their own support. Same with elderly people asking for carers or children being removed from their birth parents. They always ask relatives to step in first because it's cheaper and less paperwork. I completely get that the OP and grandparents can't do any more but that's what social services will be asking/persuading them to do, probably with a tonne of pressure to step up thrown in for good measure.

WhenSheWasBadshewasawesome · 24/11/2023 11:37

@Naptrappedmummy I can't speak for anyone else, but I would say the op has earned ire because she's equated perfectly fine parenting choices like homeschooling, veganism and non electronic toys with neglect. She's basically saying that the only way to parent is her way and that anything outside her narrow experience is neglect. She doesn't say what the so called conspiracy theories are and tbh, I'd have less worry about someone who thinks 9 11 was planned or we didn't go to the moon than some of the misogynistic Scientology like crap. The fact op doesn't provide examples of the conspiracies and lumps them in with the above perfectly acceptable choices tells me she's controlling and judgemental. That coupled with her assertion that she's absolutely sure there are no nd or mental health issues makes me seriously question her judgement.

It's quite simple former. If I think someone needs help I give it. If I think neglect I report it. Other than that mind my own business. Op just wanted a pile on.

Naptrappedmummy · 24/11/2023 10:45

I honestly don’t understand why somebody is being criticised for not stepping up and supporting the child when his own mother isn’t? And is beyond reproach? Maybe op has mental health or physical health issues or is just flat out busy like most of us and doesn’t have the time to take on somebody else’s child. Why are our expectations of parents on here so low yet our expectations of their wider family members so high.

CasaAmarela · 24/11/2023 10:30

WhenSheWasBadshewasawesome · 24/11/2023 00:11

A few points

Whilst I believe the first would probably count as neglect, it's interesting that those of us that had babies in 2020 were legally not allowed to take our children anywhere. For nearly two years our children were not allowed consistently on day trips, socialisation and softplay. When I raised this at the time with a health visitor she said all baby needs is mum. Except the studies coming out of COVID have identified that as bullshit. It actually took me a while to do proper outings and things because I had it drummed into me that going out was bad and staying home was enough. You just kind of get used to staying home all day and playing with the same toys and reading the same books.
I just think it's interesting three years down the line what we were forced to do is largely being agreed as neglect on here. I seem to recall at the time the consensus was if you took your kid to the park you were an evil granny killer.

Point two the NHS says a well planned vegan or vegetarian diet is suitable for all stages of life. So you are very much wrong about that. I find it interesting that you dislike cults but there is no bigger cult and lies than the meat industry. I'm all for live and let live (or die in the case of meat eaters) but really most meat eaters peddle such absolute rubbish about the welfare origins and health benefits of their food whilst chugging down proven cancer causing animal products. Every bit as cult like as anything in your op if you ask me.

Homeschooling is a valid choice but like school it needs to be well planned and carried out for good results. It's rapidly becoming the only choice for Sen families.

Anti vac is a bit of a broad brush. Huge difference between those parents who won't allow any vaccinations and those who are hesitant for their children to become COVID vaccination Guinea pigs.

If you work within neurodiversity and mental health you'll know how common it is for women to have nd conditions or mental health problems ignores by professionals. Don't become one of them.

Report neglect. Step up to support your own family.

Completely agree with everything you've said.

OceanicBoundlessness · 24/11/2023 10:30

Thelnebriati · 24/11/2023 10:06

We aren't born knowing how to parent, we learn how to parent. And thats the point of parenting classes - to give children the info they don't get from their role models.

What should parenting classes teach and at what age?

If you teach them to children, will there be a counselling service for those children who are not being raised according to these classes? There may be a whole loads of pennies dropping and there needs to be an adequate plan for supporting these children.

Thelnebriati · 24/11/2023 10:06

We aren't born knowing how to parent, we learn how to parent. And thats the point of parenting classes - to give children the info they don't get from their role models.

Honeychickpea · 24/11/2023 09:38

ClairDeLaLune · 24/11/2023 09:30

Totally agree with you OP. DBIL and DSIL adopted and they had to go through months of intensive scrutiny, whereas any old shit parent can pop a baby out and treat it however they want. Seems very unfair.

Take it up with God/Mother Nature or whomever your belief system holds responsible for biology.

ClairDeLaLune · 24/11/2023 09:30

Totally agree with you OP. DBIL and DSIL adopted and they had to go through months of intensive scrutiny, whereas any old shit parent can pop a baby out and treat it however they want. Seems very unfair.

Leah5678 · 24/11/2023 09:26

Portakalkedi · 23/11/2023 23:34

I've often thought this OP, that there should be some sort of 'licence' you have to have to be allowed to procreate. Far far too many terrible, lazy or downright abusive people having kids without the slightest forethought. At least something like what is required for adoption. You can't say this IRL though.

Yeah and how much money and taxes would be spent implementing this only for the abusers to still slip under the radar because they know how to put on an act?

curaçao · 24/11/2023 09:08

I dobt really believe in these 'examples' you have painted.

TrashedSofa · 24/11/2023 08:31

WhenSheWasBadshewasawesome · 24/11/2023 08:15

@Blueink as I said it was more of an observation than anything.
Many countries like those in Spain and Malaysia could not " going out looking at leaves, splashing in puddles etc could all still happen during pandemic times.". Children stuck in high rise flats without going outside for months at a time.

And don't forget in England you were not allowed to drive anywhere for your 'daily walk'. Fine for those in the country, but those in the city were rather limited.

But I just think it's interesting I was one of the very few who said it was having too much of a terrible impact on children to be justified. Just interesting how when I wanted to provide my child with an all round human experience sitting iny house for two years with the occasional walk and family visit when the restrictions lifted was deemed ok, but people are unanimous it's abuse in another context.

Regardless of 'reasons', it's the same impact on the child. We were forced to neglect our children.

It is pretty interesting to view this discussion in the context of recent pandemic response policy.

One point that's not come up yet, I don't think, is that for varying reasons a lot of parents are angry about the way the state has treated the welfare of their children since covid kicked in, and so there's a lot of mistrust. This isn't limited to one particular view on lockdown either. There are people who feel their children have been thrown under the bus because of schools closing, not closing soon enough, air quality in classrooms, isolation bubble rules, kids being allowed in when covid positive now... those arguments exist right across the spectrum. It's not a pro or anti lockdown thing, it applies to both.

So the idea of the state being either practically or morally qualified to set out and enforce much more intrusive standards on things like fresh air, tablet time and socialisation is, well, not exactly universally accepted. Not when so many people feel their DCs welfare has been treated as collateral.

WhenSheWasBadshewasawesome · 24/11/2023 08:15

@Blueink as I said it was more of an observation than anything.
Many countries like those in Spain and Malaysia could not " going out looking at leaves, splashing in puddles etc could all still happen during pandemic times.". Children stuck in high rise flats without going outside for months at a time.

And don't forget in England you were not allowed to drive anywhere for your 'daily walk'. Fine for those in the country, but those in the city were rather limited.

But I just think it's interesting I was one of the very few who said it was having too much of a terrible impact on children to be justified. Just interesting how when I wanted to provide my child with an all round human experience sitting iny house for two years with the occasional walk and family visit when the restrictions lifted was deemed ok, but people are unanimous it's abuse in another context.

Regardless of 'reasons', it's the same impact on the child. We were forced to neglect our children.

FreddieMercurysCat · 24/11/2023 08:06

@Dotjones
Bloody hell! Bit much… Don’t think that’s really very appropriate.

TrashedSofa · 24/11/2023 07:28

Portakalkedi · 23/11/2023 23:34

I've often thought this OP, that there should be some sort of 'licence' you have to have to be allowed to procreate. Far far too many terrible, lazy or downright abusive people having kids without the slightest forethought. At least something like what is required for adoption. You can't say this IRL though.

Because people point out what an exceptionally stupid idea it is.

BuddyBuddyBumBum · 24/11/2023 07:28

Dotjones · 22/11/2023 13:11

I agree, it's ridiculous you need a licence to drive a car (or even to operate a television) but literally anyone is allowed to become a parent. I'd like to see a system where parents and those who are expecting or trying to concieve have to attend classes and reach a certain standard, otherwise the kids are taken away/terminated and the parents sterilised.

20 years ago this idea would’ve HORRIFIED me. Then I became a teacher.

Some people should not be allowed to have children.

Wordsmithery · 24/11/2023 07:23

He's not getting some of his basic needs met (being ignored all day, potentially poorly nourished, socially isolated). I'd argue this is neglect and you should report to social services. They are not all about removing kids. They also work with and educate families. They may be able to help her, or she may be beyond help if she has failed to bond with her child. Either way, you need to do something.

Wordsmithery · 24/11/2023 07:17

Exactly. SIL does sound like a terrible parent but OP does have some power to improve things.

Wordsmithery · 24/11/2023 07:15

Now I feel like I'm reading some bad dystopian fiction

Swipe left for the next trending thread