Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s crazy you can parent whatever way you want?!

368 replies

ItsGivingJudgey · 22/11/2023 13:00

This OP will sound judgey has hell hence my username. I’ve NC but long time user.

I know it’s a free country (in the UK at least). I also really support human rights, however I still find it mad that you can have a child and raise them whatever way you want no matter how batshit so long as it doesn’t meet the very high legal requirements for removal.

Examples:

ONE:

My SIL does F all with her child and he’s now 2.5 years old. He literally does not leave the house other than for absolute essentials such as medical appointments. He doesn’t go to nursery despite it being free (she doesn’t work). He’s never been swimming, to feed the ducks, to the beach or the local park. He’s never met other children outside of his cousins. He’s only ever been to soft play twice when I have physically picked them up to take them with me and my dc.
He only ever leaves the house when my in-laws take him food shopping with them just to get him out. He can literally go 1-2 weeks without being outside his front door.
SIL on the other hand goes on holidays, days out with her boyfriend, cocktails with friends etc. She just has the in-laws babysit when she does. Her reasoning? ‘It’s a faff’ ‘the weather is bad’ or she ‘can’t be arsed today’. She was very lazy before becoming a parent but her laziness now has extended to her child who literally lives his entire life within the confines of the house. It’s nothing to do with mental health on her part, it’s pure laziness. She’ll only take him out if a member of the family with a car physically goes and picks them up and drops them back off home. The nursery is less than a 5 minute walk from her house. She was badgered by the health visitor to enroll him so she did it, took him for a week and then never bothered again as it was ‘too much faffing about for just a few hours’.

He lives off microwave meals and tinned food. Wakes up and spends the entire day in front of the tv or with his tablet. When my in-laws went away last year he didn’t leave the house for 3 weeks!!

It doesn’t meet the legal requirements or thresholds for social services. He is fed and clothed and has lots of toys. But it’s crazy that he is able to spend his entire life within the confines of a house and that’s that.

TWO:

My cousin. Very well educated, affluent and has always been a bit eccentric as is her DH. However over the years they have joined a kind of weird religion/cult like group and are massive conspiracy theorists. They homeschool their kids (fine), but have indoctrinated them with mad beliefs. The kids including the baby are vegan. Their unvaccinated. They can only bath in this specially filtered water. The kids are feral and not allowed to watch tv, listen to any type of mainstream music only this specifically selected whale like music. They avoid any type of radiation and limit sources of power so in the evenings the house is lit by candlelight and an open fire. The kids wear this robe like clothing that seems impractical. The kids no nothing outside of their parents beliefs. They have no awareness of the outside world. They only socialise with the other people in this conspiracy group that also homeschool.

My cousin and her husband are well meaning and obviously it’s their right to believe what they wish. But their kids won’t know how to use the internet, any real world references, learn about other religions or cultures. Surely this will do long term harm in some way?

The children couldn’t tell you what spaghetti bolognaise is or what a smartphone/tablet is or that there was ever a world war or even how what a kettle
is for. But they can tell you about crystal healing powers. What if when they get to 18 they want to live a ‘mainstream’ life and join society? How will they manage? Get a job? Make friends with peers?

It’s not that I believe there’s only one right way to parent or anything because I don’t. However I find it mad that you can have a baby and so long as you meet very basic standards, you can literally do as you want with actual human beings.

Please tell me if I’m being unreasonable to think it’s not right and if I am being unreasonable why so? I feel so sorry for these children.

OP posts:
Chipsahoyagain · 22/11/2023 15:34

I find HS the most unbelievable though. In my home country you can HS but you have to have the kids assessed by a government official as well. There are regular checks and it's illegal to decide to HS and disappear of the radar. I don't think just because you are a parent you should HS without very, very good reason and this should be monitored very strictly.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 22/11/2023 15:32

Dotjones · 22/11/2023 13:11

I agree, it's ridiculous you need a licence to drive a car (or even to operate a television) but literally anyone is allowed to become a parent. I'd like to see a system where parents and those who are expecting or trying to concieve have to attend classes and reach a certain standard, otherwise the kids are taken away/terminated and the parents sterilised.

Are you for real?

RagzRebooted · 22/11/2023 15:30

elliejjtiny · 22/11/2023 13:29

Not anything hugely intrusive or like social services, but health visitors monitor pre school children and the school will monitor children at school. So something similar should be in place for homeschooled children.

Agree with this. I have several relatives who are homeschooling their children, for various reasons. Except they aren't, they just aren't sending them to school. There's a big difference but no one really checks.

Fionaville · 22/11/2023 15:29

SIL is lazy. She's not parenting well. There's nothing you can do, other than give her DC a good time when you see him.

The home ed family. You are judging them by your standard of normal. So they arent exposed to the latest music or other media. That also means they aren't being exposed to the filth/bullying/societal expectations of consumerism/porn and quite frankly ridiculous and dangerous trends on Tiktok etc. You don't know what they are learning about really. It's just different to the 'norm' and you don't like it. Who's to say who's right or wrong in this situation?
I think it's crazy that parents let their children have unrestricted access to the Internet/phone using at a young age. Then wonder why kids are sexualised from primary school. But they can do them.

OutsideLookingOut · 22/11/2023 15:24

It is biology. You don't have to be smart, kind, diligent etc to have a child, just fit enough to carry or father one. However the way society works perhaps we should be happy this is the case, we need enough people at the bottom of society for it to function. People starting at the back foot, who are unlikely to take the top jobs. And if they ever recognise this we can point out the exceptions who made it!

picturethispatsy · 22/11/2023 15:23

MidnightOnceMore · 22/11/2023 14:15

Is what she is teaching objectively damaging?

I was told at school if I did certain things I would burn in hell. Is that better?

I was just about to say the same.

There was plenty of weird stuff I was told at school (including if I didn’t turn to Christ if burn in hell).

School itself can be very damaging to children.

jolaylasofia · 22/11/2023 15:20

is the child fed, clothed, washed? does the parent show their child affection? is the child safe?
If he's to all then stay in your lane and mind your business.

Notcontent · 22/11/2023 15:19

Ace56 · 22/11/2023 13:36

The first example is a type of neglect. Not bad enough to be recognised by SS, but neglect none the less. She is not fulfilling her child’s physical (movement) needs (do they have a garden he can run around in/kick a ball?), intellectual needs or social needs (he’s not seeing other adults or children enough). In an ideal world someone should be intervening here, but in reality SS don’t have capacity to address cases like this, as you say as long as the child is clothed and fed they don’t consider it.

The second example may seem batshit but it just means the children will grow up to be a bit different - and we need different types of people in society! Agree with pp that they will likely branch out as teens or young adults.

I agree with the above. The first example is concerning and sadly there are lots of parents like that - but not much you can do about that, although I there is an argument that there should be parenting classes offered to everyone and perhaps there could be some incentives to make people attend them (e.g. vouchers).

the second example is not that worrying, provided the kids are being educated and their diet is not too restrictive. There are lots of people who have gone on to achieve great things after having very “different” childhoods and different can be quite positive.

TrashedSofa · 22/11/2023 15:18

tattygrl · 22/11/2023 15:16

Astounding the glibness with which some people will suggest "removing the child" as some sort of panacea for a troubled family.

Removing a child, even from a family that is indeed neglectful or abusive, causes damage and trauma in itself, significantly. This is why there is a balance in what social and child services (and the law!) can do in terms of intervention. Taking a child away from an abusive or neglectful family is not the fairy godmother-esque act of mercy that it may seem. When a child needs to be taken away, it is of course good when they are removed; however, it's like losing a limb. Sometimes necessary, but with inherent trauma, damage and risk for future effects. Only to be done when no other option is available.

I saw a comment upthread suggesting a penalty for a child not being kept up to certain hygiene standards could be "temporary removal" of the child. I wish people would educate themselves on things like this before spouting off "shoulds". There are people who are experts in these areas for a reason. It's incredibly complex.

These posters have also failed to engage with the non-trivial possibility that all these enhanced opportunities to interfere in family life will attract the percentage of humans who we know are abusers and nonce.

Middleagedmeangirls · 22/11/2023 15:17

YABU. It's virtually impossible to judge who is a good parent and who isn't.

To the outside world we were a reasonable middle class family. Not much money but adequately fed and clothed. My mum was active in the PTA and local Guide group. We did our homework on time and were taken to the dentist every 6 months. We went to art galleries and museums and even the occasional stately home.

Behind closed doors we were miserable because we weren't loved. Verbal abuse, emotional neglect and excessive physical discipline were our norms.

tattygrl · 22/11/2023 15:16

Astounding the glibness with which some people will suggest "removing the child" as some sort of panacea for a troubled family.

Removing a child, even from a family that is indeed neglectful or abusive, causes damage and trauma in itself, significantly. This is why there is a balance in what social and child services (and the law!) can do in terms of intervention. Taking a child away from an abusive or neglectful family is not the fairy godmother-esque act of mercy that it may seem. When a child needs to be taken away, it is of course good when they are removed; however, it's like losing a limb. Sometimes necessary, but with inherent trauma, damage and risk for future effects. Only to be done when no other option is available.

I saw a comment upthread suggesting a penalty for a child not being kept up to certain hygiene standards could be "temporary removal" of the child. I wish people would educate themselves on things like this before spouting off "shoulds". There are people who are experts in these areas for a reason. It's incredibly complex.

temperedolive · 22/11/2023 15:13

Where do these taken away children go?

Social services are stretched to the limit as it is. Presumably, under this system, you'd predict a fair amount of failures just from people not in step with current ideological practices or people of lower material means. Say 25%. The number of children in care would dramatically increase. What happens to them then? "Taken away" children don't disappear into a void. Are families who have passed the training course going to be forced to parent a set number of children not their own? Do we start having them sleep in school gymnasiums? Who pays for this? And how does society absorb wave after wave of care leavers who were raised with the right amount of soft play and screen time but are launched into the world without support once they age out of the system?

Or by terminate, do you mean living children whose parents don't meet the standards?

SleepingStandingUp · 22/11/2023 15:06

enchantedsquirrelwood · 22/11/2023 13:27

however I still find it mad that you can have a child and raise them whatever way you want no matter how batshit so long as it doesn’t meet the very high legal requirements for removal

Well how would you decide that your standards for "parenting" are the right ones?

Take breast versus bottle
Nursery versus childminder versus SAHM
Screen time
Allowing your child to eat at McDonalds
Supervising homework to the nth degree versus letting the child face the consequences of not doing it.

I've news for you. Parents are not perfect, not even MNers, and they don't "parent" perfectly. Most bring their kids up as best they can. Their kids turn out reasonably well despite their "parenting". Not because of it. Parent is a thing you are, not what you do.

There are abusive parents and that's where social services step in.

But not because they'd do it another way.

I think ops point tho is the grey area. Most of us are doing reasonable attempts. Some are clearly abusive. But ops SIL isn't trying her best if we assume it is laziness not MH and the cousins idea of clearly trying very hard to do the best is going to impact those kids negatively for a long time.
So whilst there's little by way of solutions and no it's claiming they could write a definitive book on it, clearly some children are getting a problematic childhood.

Orangeandgold · 22/11/2023 15:05

I agree - I think it is insane. I constantly ask myself “how am I qualified to be a mother!” But I had my DD young and spent my whole 20s being her mum or working. I couldn’t tell you what’s “cool” and I often have no idea what a normal “20s” of travelling and clubs and freedom looks like but I’ve loved being a mother and know that I’m not perfect. But my DD comes first.

I know for some people their children are either an extension of them, a nuisance, just kids so it doesn’t matter - as opposed to them being seen as people who will grow up, who have feelings, who need to go out and socialise etc etc.

To police parenting you would need to police sex - let’s face it - that will never happen unless you want a Handsmaid tale scenario.

I think there needs to be more support for parents. More free opportunities for parents to exchange information and knowledge. More integration with parents and teachers and it should be government supported - they are the people of tomorrow after all.

MsCactus · 22/11/2023 15:05

I mean there's lots of abusive families where kids are berated/manipulated etc - yet if no physical violence they stay with parents - which is far worse than your example 1. Those kids would probably love to stay in and watch TV in a relaxed home and see grandparents occasionally.

Also worth saying that sometimes kids from horrible homes actually turn out better as adults than those who are overindulged in everything. It's bizarre but studies have shown that being overprotective/spoiling kids with the 'perfect' life actually causes lots of mental health issues in adults. The other side of this is that neglect and abuse causes mental health issues - neither are good.

Kids from lazy parents usually think/know they're not special and don't get a shock as adults when the world is unkind.

For the cult example, they won't be able to brainwash their kids forever - they'll probs rebel as teens.

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/11/2023 15:01

TrashedSofa · 22/11/2023 14:56

Whichever government was in charge, I suppose. Boris Johnson's ideas on parenting, anyone?!

Which is exactly what makes it such a terrifying thought and is something that should never happen.

nosleepforme · 22/11/2023 15:00

There are things that are fine that you mention, but if accurate the overall pic is crazy.
eg my kids are home with me till age 2 and I work from home. There’s no reason why kids NEED to go to nursery, provided that they are getting the right care at home. If anything, mums will generally give more love and care to an infant.
also, my kids don’t watch tv whatsoever (they are still young). I don’t think less screen time or no screen time is insane. Not usual in today’s day and age, but kids can only gain.
id also avoid radiation where possible so I don’t have a microwave (I cook a fresh hot meal for supper every day and dc has hot lunch in school as well). Nothing wrong with that! But I do have a smartphone, so not as strict as them on the radiation.

point being, not everything these people are doing is worthy of having children taken away whatsoever. All together though, the picture you paint is extreme and concerning. Not leaving the house for weeks is absolutely neglectful. Children should get out every day!

TheRealLilyMunster · 22/11/2023 14:59

Dotjones · 22/11/2023 13:11

I agree, it's ridiculous you need a licence to drive a car (or even to operate a television) but literally anyone is allowed to become a parent. I'd like to see a system where parents and those who are expecting or trying to concieve have to attend classes and reach a certain standard, otherwise the kids are taken away/terminated and the parents sterilised.

I'd like to see a system where parents and those who are expecting or trying to concieve have to attend classes and reach a certain standard, otherwise the kids are taken away/terminated and the parents sterilised.

Are you actually serious?

I think we are straying into Hitler territory here. I have no words.

orchardsquare · 22/11/2023 14:58

I'm pleased you're getting some sensible replies. In the first scenario (if this thread is true) the situation obviously isn't ideal but what would the alternative be, remove the child? He at least has a caring wider family, who can take him out, and will soon be in school or nursery where he will be able to socialise all day. The mum might be depressed but she has his whole childhood to turn things around.

MidnightOnceMore · 22/11/2023 14:57

ItsGivingJudgey · 22/11/2023 14:53

I don’t think I’m a fascist, at least I really hope not.

I don’t think all kids should be parented one way and I believe in freedom to practice your religion of choice etc.

But when you inflict any type of extreme lifestyle on a child then I guess I do struggle.

My cousin for example and her husband won’t teach their kids the sciences because it conflicts with their beliefs. Actual proven facts conflicts with their beliefs.
They also won’t walk under street lights/antennas etc for fear of ‘waves’ they give off.
So in turn their kids are petrified of walking through cities and urban areas. They try and remain as ‘off grid’ as possible.

I think it’s perfectly fine for my cousin and her DH to believe this. They know what scientists and the ‘mainstream’ people believe and choose to believe otherwise. Fine. However their kids have no idea what others believe or what scientists think. Just this one way of thinking.

Most kids who are part of a religion of belief system such as Christian’s, Jews,
muslims etc are raised in their belief system but are also aware that there are other religions and belief systems too. So at some point they are able to make their own choices to continue with their familiar faith or look into the alternatives.

My cousins kids aren’t a part of wider society to have this awareness. They can raised to believe literally whatever my cousin wants. That is my cousins right. I guess I do struggle with it.

Then report them.

Stop pretending that child abuse is allowed. It is isn't.

If you have concerns, do your duty and report.

The laws are there. We don't need fascist oversight of families - as you've proven, because you know what is happening.

It's your failure to do anything you should be reflecting on.

MerryMidwinter · 22/11/2023 14:57

I dont know the answer to this but so much of the thread seems to be about the rights of the adults - what about the child's right to a decent life?

I know what's 'decent' is subjective but it's so sad when kids lose out because the adults in their lives can't or won't do more than the bare minimum and quite often the result is a cycle where each generation just repeats the pattern of the previous one.

TootiiFrootii · 22/11/2023 14:56

I don't know about the kids in the near cult, but I'd plan treats and trips out to see the ducks and play in the park with your little nephew. Give him your time and show him some love and fresh food. It wouldn't take much to help him along in his development.

TrashedSofa · 22/11/2023 14:56

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/11/2023 14:55

Some on here would suggest that even part time, nursery isn't ideal for a 1 year old. There was a thread recently where some people said that nursery shouldn't even be available for babies and children should be at home with mum until 3.

Who is right? Who would get to decide?

Whichever government was in charge, I suppose. Boris Johnson's ideas on parenting, anyone?!

JustSettleOnAUsername · 22/11/2023 14:56

For so many reasons, many already posted, Children’s Services thresholds can't be lowered. They're set to balance the significant harm of not intervening with the significant harm of intervening (particularly with removal of children which causes so much damage).

In these cases, I'm not even sure the thresholds would need to be lowered?

I know Child In Need is voluntary process but if parents don't engage it can be stepped up to Child Protection:
Under Section 17 Children Act 1989, a child will be considered in need if:

  • they are unlikely to achieve or maintain or to have the opportunity to achieve or maintain a reasonable standard of health or development without provision of services from the Local Authority;
  • their health or development is likely to be significantly impaired, or further impaired, without the provision of services from the Local Authority;

Both scenarios the children are being neglected. In the second scenario they are also Children Missing Education (CME) because that is not a suitable education. Arguably some of their human rights are being contravened too...

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/11/2023 14:55

Hollyhead · 22/11/2023 14:50

@SouthLondonMum22 yes I would make the legal age for education 1, but it just wouldn’t be full time. The vast majority of children are in some form of setting by 1 anyway. The sad truth is that for many children by the time they start reception their educational chances are over as they’re years behind the children with good parents. 15 -20 hours a week from 1 would go some way to help.

Some on here would suggest that even part time, nursery isn't ideal for a 1 year old. There was a thread recently where some people said that nursery shouldn't even be available for babies and children should be at home with mum until 3.

Who is right? Who would get to decide?

Swipe left for the next trending thread