Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby/Toddler groups

32 replies

NiceParkingSpotRitaThanksJanet · 22/11/2023 09:46

I have a recently turned 2 year old who admittedly is very "on the go" and loves to be outdoors. I work 3 days a week (30 hours) his dad does full time in 4 days and we have family childcare the other 2 days.

We have been to a few baby/toddler groups and each time I find that the more structured ones leave me feeling like a shit mum with a feral child. Yesterday we went to a music class. My son was wandering a bit as he does, and at one point put on one of the adults wellies (which was hilarious) before I noticed. They got this parachute thing out where everyone holds it in a circle and moves it up and down. He was absolutely delighted by this and wanted to jump on it, I obviously moved him immediately but he kept going to do the same thing and I could see the leader getting annoyed.

Throughout the group she made several references to him not sitting on my knee and saying things like "we aren't running round, sit on my knee or mummys" - to be fair to him he wasn't running, more wandering with the train I can't get him to put down, and sporadically coming over to me for a quick cuddle or to join in. He then found some bubbles which we have a lot of at home and excitedly brought them over to me, I of course returned them however was told to put them out of his reach (which I was going to anyway!) He's very gentle, wasn't hurting anyone and sometimes just wanted to look or play with his train (or crawl under the chairs at the back of the hall!) Most of the other kids were sat obediently on their parents knees and I'm not sure if I'm paranoid but I did feel like my child was "that child" and that I've done something wrong.

He's always been active, inquisitive and doesn't like to sit still but he's not aggressive and he just loves being with other children, which is why I like to take him to groups if I can.

Am I that parent with the feral child? Or do other people find these groups difficult too?!

OP posts:
saamantha19881 · 22/11/2023 10:14

Yeah, I am the same. My toddler used to go to a rhyme time every week... Until it wasn't stimulating enough anymore and he would be pulling books of the shelf (it was at a library) and trying to walk away. I saw this as our cue to change groups and went to a stay and play at the local church hall instead. He loves it and is really well behaved there... Just more active. It isn't a reflection on your child, they are just more suited to different types of groups xx

DuploTrain · 22/11/2023 10:14

ShazzaF · 22/11/2023 10:09

No idea about OP's situation, but my eldest has also just turned two like OP's and RE your last point - this is what I'm having trouble with. I can tell him to sit on my knee until the cows come home, but if he's in a big hall with loads of space to run around then that is exactly what he will do. I could physically stop him and put him on my knee, but he would just scream and wriggle, and presumably ruin the activity for everyone even more so than him just running about in the background.

Is it abnormal for a just turned 2yo to just ignore instructions like this? Confused

No I don’t think it’s abnormal for a 2 year old not to be able to sit still (some can, some can’t).

But some parents will kind of encourage their child to be disruptive in groups.. e.g. their child will be running round screaming, standing on chairs or doing something they shouldn’t and the parent will be like haha he’s so cute. Instead of trying to distract/ redirect into something that’s less disruptive for the rest of the group.

(I’m absolutely not saying that’s what you or the OP are doing … it’s just an example).

ShazzaF · 22/11/2023 10:09

DuploTrain · 22/11/2023 10:03

I think it’s good for children to get some practice of more structured activities. If he’s not ready for it, then don’t force it, but at some point he’ll have to learn that different environments have different expectations (e.g. when everyone is sitting in a circle, he sits down too).

It sounded from your post (and I may have got this wrong) that you were just letting him wander around rather than asking him to come and sit on your knee? The group leader’s instructions were probably for your benefit rather than his!

No idea about OP's situation, but my eldest has also just turned two like OP's and RE your last point - this is what I'm having trouble with. I can tell him to sit on my knee until the cows come home, but if he's in a big hall with loads of space to run around then that is exactly what he will do. I could physically stop him and put him on my knee, but he would just scream and wriggle, and presumably ruin the activity for everyone even more so than him just running about in the background.

Is it abnormal for a just turned 2yo to just ignore instructions like this? Confused

ShazzaF · 22/11/2023 10:05

Omg I could have written this myself. I have sworn off toddler groups for a little while because I just get so upset afterwards, I feel like everyone is judging me.

If it makes you feel better, my mom says that I was equally feral when she used to go to stay and play groups with me. She absolutely hated them so never took me after going to a few and realising I couldn't be tamed. She was a SAHM and I didn't go to anything formal until reception. I'm a relatively normal adult and I did well in school, so there's hope for our little feral toddlers yet!

DuploTrain · 22/11/2023 10:03

I think it’s good for children to get some practice of more structured activities. If he’s not ready for it, then don’t force it, but at some point he’ll have to learn that different environments have different expectations (e.g. when everyone is sitting in a circle, he sits down too).

It sounded from your post (and I may have got this wrong) that you were just letting him wander around rather than asking him to come and sit on your knee? The group leader’s instructions were probably for your benefit rather than his!

LuvSmallDogs · 22/11/2023 09:57

I'd just take him to a non-structured group from now on - you know, mums sitting with tea, a big pile of toys and kids running round. That's the only group I ever took mine to.

"Feral" for wanting to move around and getting bored - he's two! He's fine, you're fine, the music lessons don't suit him.

ShirleyPhallus · 22/11/2023 09:48

Not all groups are for all children as children are so different. One of mine sat still beautifully, but she was so shy she rarely joined in. Whereas the other would wander all over the place, couldn’t sit still but loved the activities.

It doesnt mean there is anything wrong with you or your child or your group, but some children are suited to different groups more.