Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ban this girl from my house and my daughter from calling her?

37 replies

emmainadilemma34 · 21/11/2023 19:46

My daughter is 10 and in primary 6. She has had her usual friendship dramas but nothing crazy. She has had same little friend group since starting primary. However, recently she has started hanging about with a different girl in her class.

I am pretty laidback and happy for my daughter to hang about with whomever makes her happy. When I first met this girl I thought she was nice and polite.

As time has went on, my daughter has put he on a pedestal. She can do no wrong. A couple of things have happened recently which I am just so unhappy about and don't really know how to deal with it without losing my cool to be honest.

  • I first noticed it when I took my daughter and her friend (who she chose) to a caravan for 2 nights for my daughters birthday. This friend was moody and constantly critical of my daughter. I remember thinking 'do you even like her?' She seemed to enjoy more spending time with adults. She was also quite cheeky to me at times. However, at end of the trip she wanted to come back to our house rather than go home so I thought she couldn't have had that bad a time.
  • my daughter will text her asking do you want to go to the park, she will simply reply 'no' and if my daughter asks why she says 'because I said so'.
  • she has slapped my daughter across the face twice at school. Today she hit my daughter with a stick on the hand, my daughter said it really hurt and she started to cry where this girl then said to others that my daughter is getting on her nerves.
  • my daughter and her were on the phone playing Roblox one night and the friend said, 'why did I even call you? You're so annoying'.
  • she invited my daughter to a sleepover at her house with two other girls at the weekend and told my daughter her breath stinks. She then said it again today at school (daughters breath does not stink).

I have noticed my daughter is becoming quiet and withdrawn. When I try and speak to my daughter regarding this she tells me it's fine and that she is a good friend and is just joking. She tells me not to contact the girls mum (who is lovely by the way) and really kicks off and defends the girl.

Today she called after school and asked if this girl could come over to the house I just replied no she can't. And I honestly don't want her in my house anymore, don't want my daughter going there and don't want her calling this girl to be berated. Daughter is kicking off at this, storming around telling me I can't do this.

I just don't know how else to deal with this. What do I do? The friend is quite popular and I really worry she is saying these nasty comments about my daughter to others. My daughter calls her her best friend and the girl does not feel the same.

It's so hard as the friend does sometimes phone my daughter and asks to come play etc but it's always on her terms and my daughter never knows what mood she is getting. I have told my daughter to smack her back at this point but she won't. There is no getting through to her and I'm so upset by it all.

What should I do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HappsClaps · 22/11/2023 08:33

Hankunamatata · 21/11/2023 21:48

I'd work on building her self confidence. There's some great resources around building self worth and self esteem. Also what makes a good friend and how good friends should make you feel and treat you

This sounds good, can you or anyone recommend resources to build up self esteem?

Somewhereovertherainbowweighapie · 22/11/2023 02:18

It’s tricky. You can’t force DD to end the friendship, but I wouldn’t have the girl over or let DD go to her place. I wouldn’t bother talking to the mum, just go to the school.

VintageBlossomHill · 22/11/2023 02:12

Gingerkittykat · 21/11/2023 20:33

Can you talk to the girl's mum? If she is truly lovely then she will be horrified her child is behaving like this.

I was in a very similar situation last year. 9 year old daughter friends with another from before they even started primary. Other girl is mature for age and super confident. I considered her mum a good friend also. There were lots of incidents of meanness, bullying and belittling. I am pretty sure the mum knew what was going on and chose to ignore it. I raised it as sensitively as possible with the mum as it was impossible to ignore and I couldn’t hang out with the mum or allow my daughter to go to their house etc It did not go well both friendships over as long as repercussions on my circle of friends. Upset about it but my daughter is much happier.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 22/11/2023 01:04

I think you need to tread carefully and keep speaking to the Mum in reserve as once you've done that the cat is out of the bag so to speak.
It is better to be a bit cautious because if you go to the Mum and she takes it the wrong way, she will start having chats with her DD and the DD resenting that your daughter has spilled the beans on her... this could cause the girl to retaliate and for there to be real emnity. So hold that talk in reserve perhaps for when other steps have failed? Only you can judge this tho.

A quiet word with the class teacher about the slapping would be a better first step, and make sure they are aware, so that its not you or your DD who has complained and "Caused trouble" for the other girl but the teacher picking up on her behaviour.

And then also to quietly take a step back, arrange things with other friends etc... so that its less dramatic and less cause for the other girl to start kicking off. So that the intense "friendship" peters out more naturally and quietly.. without kids getting involved. I think that might be easier on your daughter.

Also if you have a word with secondary school before they start and let them know that you'd like them to be in different classes. Normally they try to put kids in the same class if they went to same primary, but if you ask, they will tend to put them on different timetables, but do it before they start arranging everything. Its a much bigger place and everyone will be new. Your DD will be able to form new friendships. Dont forget they will also have the summer holidays which is a long gap and you can steer your DD to other less stressful friendships

Angrywife · 21/11/2023 23:16

I had a friendship like this as a teenager, it was very confusing. The other party would say we were best friends, and make demands of me as "her best friend" but she would put me down and bully me in much the same way you have described.
She would also nag to come to my house, to have sleep overs, for me to go out with her etc. My mum was ultra strict and the answer was usually no, my "friend" would then bully me for that too.

Eventually I managed to move away from her but it was tough for a while and I was very unhappy, though like your daughter, I would defend the friendship to my mum. I was scared of my "friend".

PestilencialCrisis · 21/11/2023 23:10

If she has slapped your daughter twice, of course you should be speaking to her mum about it. Wouldn't you want to know if your daughter was behaving that way?

I think you are totally right to be stopping the playdates at your house. My eldest has a friend i think is no good for him (caused damage in my house last time he came over, is very rude to his mum, to me and to my son, and my son then copies some of the rude behaviours). I don't think that child is good for my child and I prefer not to have him in my house. I think you are doing the right thing.

Colette88 · 21/11/2023 23:04

@emmainadilemma34 They say Hurt people, hurt people.

Has this girl got other things going on? A shitty stepdad? Mum seems nice but could be not nice behind doors maybe? This could explain her exerting force on your daughter

Devonshiregal · 21/11/2023 22:56

MuddleClassMom · 21/11/2023 20:07

Your daughter is being bullied.

The definition our school use for bullying is STOP - 'Several Times On Purpose' that you hurt or upset someone else and this girl is deliberately hurting and upsetting your daughter repeatedly.

I would raise this with the teacher and I would expect the school to intervene with respect to the incidents at school, talk to your daughter about bullying and respectful friendships and stop accepting this girl into your space until she is acting in a kinder way.

I hope she can either escape this toxic friendship or that her 'friend' can learn to be kind. I'm sorry you're both having to go through this.

This pp is correct.

What’s the age rating for mean girls…?

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 21/11/2023 22:48

MuddleClassMom · 21/11/2023 20:07

Your daughter is being bullied.

The definition our school use for bullying is STOP - 'Several Times On Purpose' that you hurt or upset someone else and this girl is deliberately hurting and upsetting your daughter repeatedly.

I would raise this with the teacher and I would expect the school to intervene with respect to the incidents at school, talk to your daughter about bullying and respectful friendships and stop accepting this girl into your space until she is acting in a kinder way.

I hope she can either escape this toxic friendship or that her 'friend' can learn to be kind. I'm sorry you're both having to go through this.

Echoing this - but also just to say that STOP acronym is such a good one.

withoutjeans · 21/11/2023 22:39

As others have said I think you're right to put boundaries around this.

Encourage your daughter to invite different friends round or perhaps could you put on a bit of a treat for her and another friend eg cinema night or something (but on condition it's a different friend).

I had a horrible 'friend' at secondary school who was cruel and manipulative, and would bully me and basically have me hang around to do her bidding. Much later I found out my parents didn't like her but to this day I have no idea why they didn't once try to intervene or help or even have a conversation with me.

So TL:dr stick to your guns . I totally support children having agency and the right to chose, but they also need support and protection and adults to sometimes make those decisions for them.

CoffeeBeansGalore · 21/11/2023 22:39

Would your dd be interested in karate? It teaches self discipline & gives a quiet confidence to kids who are keen. This in turn makes them less of a target for bullies. The added advantage of self defence would be a life skill.

A new club would also give your dd a chance for a different circle of friends

billybear · 21/11/2023 22:35

similar girl on my small housing estate she really is evil,she changes friendship groups till the last lot cant stand her any more, i never thought a girl so young aged 9 called be called evil, but she really is, told 3 little ones aged about 4 that santa was not real, gives little digs at people,when i moved in about 2 years ago a neighbour tried to tell me how bad she was, it took me a while then i thought my god he is right,very hard to say that someone so young is that bad but she really is TRUST HOW YOU FEEL

MrsOvertonsWindow · 21/11/2023 22:29

Itha · 21/11/2023 22:21

Absolutely, cut as much contact as you can. This girl is an abusive bully who’s got your daughter under control. Tell the teacher, particularly about the physical incidents.

Talk to your daughter about what abusive relationships are like.

This. Your daughter needs adults to intervene and to be helped to understand that she doesn't have to put up with this.

Have a quiet talk to the class teacher or senior member of staff. I'll bet they're seeing similar - but maybe not appreciating what they're looking at iyswim?
They can help with a bit of careful separation for groups etc.

RandomMess · 21/11/2023 22:26

You go to the school because going direct to the parent never goes well!

Itha · 21/11/2023 22:21

Absolutely, cut as much contact as you can. This girl is an abusive bully who’s got your daughter under control. Tell the teacher, particularly about the physical incidents.

Talk to your daughter about what abusive relationships are like.

emmainadilemma34 · 21/11/2023 22:20

Hi everyone, thank you so much for taking the time to give your advice. I really appreciate it. I thought about contacting the girls mum about this before the school but I wonder if it's best to go straight to the school? I just don't want the mum to ask why I didn't bring it up to her. It's so difficult. I have discussed with my daughter until I'm blue in the face about healthy friendships, self respect etc. She just always has excuses for the girl. Luckily my daughter does have other friends and hobbies so I am going to encourage those relationships more with inviting the girls over/days out.

Good idea re books about this stuff, great idea and I am going to look at some and order a few.

Unfortunately the girl is going to the same secondary school.

I think I really need to discuss this with the school, I just worry if my daughter gets wind and then it causes her more bother and/or she doesn't tell me anything anymore as she doesn't trust me.

I don't like this girls behaviour, however, I also have wondered if something more is going on in her life to cause her to act this way. If so, of course I have empathy for her and hope it gets sorted but I need to protect my girl first and foremost. Her mum is really nice, however, she works a-lot and the girl is in the house alone a-lot. But the mum is a single mum and I think she struggles with the balance. I have heard the mum say to the girl 'stop being so bossy to your friends' and she's also told me before to give her into trouble if she is rude so think the mum has an idea.

It's hard all round.

OP posts:
OrderOfTheKookaburra · 21/11/2023 22:12

Yes, stop all socialisation that you can, arrange activities with other friends (invite that parent as well and use this as the excuse why your DD doesn't get to choose the friend.)

If they are going to the same secondary school (they often do a form to list several children to share classes with) put in the comments to NOT have this girl in the same class due to previous bullying incidents. (I did this and am glad I did as I'm sure the other child listed my DS but being in other classes they formed different friendship groups. And he was as much a toe rag in secondary school....)

mrlistersgelfbride · 21/11/2023 22:09

I think you've done the right thing trying to distance your daughter.
I had a best friend like this when I was young, we are still friends to this day but she has always been so critical of me. It's genuinely shaped me as a person and in my teens and 20s contributed to me having no confidence.
I echo a pp saying try to help your daughter with her confidence and self esteem. This is bullying (low level or not) and you don't have to put up with it or have her in your house.
Forgive me if I've missed this, are they going to the same secondary school?

anon2134 · 21/11/2023 22:03

She's not popular, she's tolerated because it's easier to be quiet than to be on the receiving end of her shitty behaviour.

Text the mum and tell her to pull her daughter into line.

Slapping is not ok, tell your dd to slap her right back.

LittleMousewithcloggson · 21/11/2023 21:53

We had this when my DD was 9/10
Was reluctant to stop the friendship completely as thought it would make it worse as my DD would want to be with her even more
I spoke to school about the behaviour and the teacher had observed it. Without making a big deal she made sure they weren’t together in lesson times - didn’t partner them up, mixed up the seating plan etc
This gave DD the opportunity to make new friends and took some control away from the other girl
We also told DD she could still have her friend around but in between every visit she had to invite a different friend around as we wanted her to have a lot of friends
Within 6 months the girl no longer had the same sort of hold on her
A year later they weren’t really friends at all and DD even said to me she has no idea why she ever liked her in the first place!

Hankunamatata · 21/11/2023 21:48

I'd work on building her self confidence. There's some great resources around building self worth and self esteem. Also what makes a good friend and how good friends should make you feel and treat you

LynetteScavo · 21/11/2023 21:43

I would think there is something not very happy going on in this girls life. My DD certainly wouldn't be going to her house. If she came to my house I would stay within earshot. I would also limit the amount of time my DD had contact with this girl.

I would be chatting to my DD about why she still wanted to be friends with someone who had slapped her - to me that would be the end of a friendship. I would want my DC have enough self respect not to put up with someone being violent towards them. What did school say about it?

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 21/11/2023 21:39

If she slapped her in the face twice at school, you should let the class teacher know about it and the other unkind behaviour.

Its very tricky because whilst the Mum is lovely, its hard to know how she will react.

I would try to encourage a distance between your daughter and this girl to break the cycle. They've got into confirmed roles and you have to untangle that

and encourage DD to expand her circle of friends, invite more new people over.. reduce the out of school contact with the girl in a gradual way and as pp said, find a class/hobby/sport/interest for your daughter which is not full of school class mates so she can see that there are friendships outside of school and outside of class. Some schools have lunchtime classes which you could sign her up for, which would break up the pattern.
Has she got any cousins of similar age - that's always good for the odd weekend of fun activities,

Haveyouanyjam · 21/11/2023 21:33

I absolutely agree that you are right to set boundaries on this ‘friendship’ to protect your daughter. When she is a teenager it will be largely out of your control so better she understands now to stand her ground with your support.

Whilst I appreciate she is responsible for her behaviour, I would definitely be asking questions why the girl is behaving this way, if outwardly her mum seems lovely etc. then I would assume there’s something else going on, or her mum would want to be aware at the very least. I do appreciate that you don’t want to make it worse for your daughter, but I would continue to set the boundary and if it comes up why you won’t let her round, just be honest.

diddl · 21/11/2023 21:16

She has slapped your daughter & your daughter still wants contact with her?

Is that because she thinks that things would be even worse?