Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the gym staff should sort it?

119 replies

80skid · 21/11/2023 18:44

I've been going to my gym for years. It's not the cheapest, but there are plenty more expensive.

There's a good mix of age groups and it's generally a friendly and relaxed place to go. I've noticed recently that there's a big trend for dropping weights after the end of a set. It's always young men who do this, often when training together but sometimes alone. It's deliberate and exhibitionist. On one occasion, the vibrations from the weight dropping was so great that the weights on my machine were rattling. On another, the crash was so loud and sudden that I genuinely believed there to be a medical emergency. The noise is deafening, repetitive and needless.

This morning, I came to the conclusion that the noise level was such that in an industrial setting, ear defenders would be mandatory. There's usually staff about but they're often personal training or doing inductions, so not approachable.

AIBU to think the gym should make a greater effort to manage this? I know an autistic gym member who finds it really distressing and I can't say I'm that keen either. Don't start me on the people who think training barefoot on mats and then putting their sweaty feet on the wall while doing sit-ups is ok. It's basic manners isn't it?

OP posts:
firef1y · 22/11/2023 12:06

FarEast · 22/11/2023 11:54

I’m a female grunter. Mostly in the metcon section of my workout rather than the lifting /strength section. If you’re doing 20 Cala on the SkiErg and trying to hit 900 to a 1000 on your speed, then you’re gasping for air sometimes which is very like grunting.

It’s about the breath working for you.

Hilariously I have exactly the same grunt that I use to lift a heavy weight when I throw a hard punch in kickboxing.

You're right, it's all about using your breathing to get that little but extra oomph

firef1y · 22/11/2023 12:04

Elastica23 · 22/11/2023 11:54

Thank fuck, no I haven't ever felt the need to do anything so ridiculous just to keep myself fit.

If "heavy lifters" need to make such noise then perhaps they should have a separate room, preferably sound-proof, the anti-social twats.

If I can hear you over the music in my headphones, you are definitely too loud, shut the fuck up.

As long as we have the platforms, squat racks, benches, power racks, bars, plates, dumbells etc and enough space to not be under each others feet I'm all for that. Means I won't have to work out best time to be in gym to miss out on the cheesy music playing in a few of the classes

BusySittingDown · 22/11/2023 11:59

I think some people need some noise cancelling headphones for Christmas.

FarEast · 22/11/2023 11:54

I’m a female grunter. Mostly in the metcon section of my workout rather than the lifting /strength section. If you’re doing 20 Cala on the SkiErg and trying to hit 900 to a 1000 on your speed, then you’re gasping for air sometimes which is very like grunting.

It’s about the breath working for you.

BusySittingDown · 22/11/2023 11:54

KimberleyClark · 22/11/2023 11:50

Only if they are wearing outdoor shoes in the gym. My gym shoes are plimsoll types and I only wear them in the gym. At my gym yoga and Pilates classes happen in the studio rooms and people generally bring their own mat. No one does yoga or Pilates in the main gym hall.

Yeah but you can't know for sure who wears outdoor shoes in the gym or not! Confused Just because you're considerate and wear shoes purely for the gym, someone else might wear their outdoor running trainers on the treadmill.

Elastica23 · 22/11/2023 11:54

firef1y · 22/11/2023 11:49

Well done on being in the 2plate club. Took me almost 4 years to get there, was stuck at 99kg for the longest time.

Thank fuck, no I haven't ever felt the need to do anything so ridiculous just to keep myself fit.

If "heavy lifters" need to make such noise then perhaps they should have a separate room, preferably sound-proof, the anti-social twats.

If I can hear you over the music in my headphones, you are definitely too loud, shut the fuck up.

Elastica23 · 22/11/2023 11:51

I rather like the "no grunts" sign at my gym, and fortunately there is very little of it. Making noise louder than the sound of your breathing is just a waste of energy and and also anti-social.

KimberleyClark · 22/11/2023 11:50

firef1y · 22/11/2023 11:46

Have you tried doing yoga or pilates in socks?? Would be seriously dangerous, you risk slipping about and a stretch going painfully wrong. As long as they wipe the mat after themselves what's the problem??? As for the floor, there's probably far worse on the bottom of people's shoes than there is on bare feet

Only if they are wearing outdoor shoes in the gym. My gym shoes are plimsoll types and I only wear them in the gym. At my gym yoga and Pilates classes happen in the studio rooms and people generally bring their own mat. No one does yoga or Pilates in the main gym hall.

firef1y · 22/11/2023 11:49

FarEast · 22/11/2023 11:33

Have you ever done a heavy deadlift? Like say twice your bodyweight?

Indeed! The only time I tend to drop weights coming out of a deadlift is when it’s over 90kg. My 1RM is 100k - not quite twice my bodyweight but effing heavy.

Lowering slow is a really good thing to do to develop strength but not at near to 1RM.

I think the OP. Is probably not a lifter.

Well done on being in the 2plate club. Took me almost 4 years to get there, was stuck at 99kg for the longest time.

Elastica23 · 22/11/2023 11:48

I brought my own mat when I went to yoga at the gym, but yeah, you don't do it in trainers or socks and other people just used the mats the gym provided.

But yeah, dropping weights is shit. I'd contact the gym about it.

firef1y · 22/11/2023 11:46

KimberleyClark · 22/11/2023 11:39

On the hygiene thing, well gyms are stinky, sweaty places 🤷‍♀️. Having bare feet out isn't much different to a sweaty person lying on a bench. Or someone dripping sweat all over the treadmill. I assume they're wearing socks?

People are expected to wear flip flops in the gym changing rooms for hygiene reasons, so why should it be acceptable to be barefoot in the gym itself?

Have you tried doing yoga or pilates in socks?? Would be seriously dangerous, you risk slipping about and a stretch going painfully wrong. As long as they wipe the mat after themselves what's the problem??? As for the floor, there's probably far worse on the bottom of people's shoes than there is on bare feet

firef1y · 22/11/2023 11:43

Everanewbie · 22/11/2023 11:16

@firef1y I don't doubt what you're saying, but this isn't something you're doing at the local leisure centre or sports direct gym, I guess?

OP, I think it depends on the gym. If you turn up to a powerlifting/Crossfit specialist gym, you are being completely unreasonable, as above posters have said, dropping weights and having a good shout and grunting is par for the course. They probably don't like beginners and causals getting in their way.

If you're talking general fitness centres where the vibe is inclusive wellness, good ones are concerned for the comfort of all and in my experience, take a dim view for dropping heavy weights, excessive grunting etc. Some expressly ban it and enforce it. Not that there is anything wrong with proper powerlifters, but they need to go elsewhere if that's what they want to do.

It might be worth having a chat with the staff about your concerns to help you establish whether this is the gym for you.

I live in a very small town. There's the 2 gyms, one calls itself a boutique fitness centre and I'm in no doubt that I would not be very welcome in there. I like to lift up heavy things, which means I make noise, I grunt (Yes I'm a female who grunts) when I'm having to force myself to push out one more rep. I have to bail out sometimes, which means dumbells and barbells sometimes hit the ground. I do complexes that mean that I need to drop the bar at the end of a set. I challenge anyone to very gently return the bar to the floor at the end of DT. I also do a lot of crossfire style workouts, which means I'm slamming balls, jumping on boxes and even doing the dreaded burpees while leaving a pool of sweat on the floor (which I do clean up afterwards). So I know the boutique gym isn't for me (in fact I know the owner and know he is very in to the being quiet and not making a lot of noise, would probably be the ideal gym for those of you that don't like to hear weights banging)

The other gym, which I do belong to, markets itself as a family gym and really does have allsorts. From the 80 year old doing very sedate chair based classes and I kid you not an 86yo aerobics instructor (whose routine hasn't changed in the 7 years I've been going to the gym), to the cardio bunnies on the stairs master, to people that just want to get fit, to power lifters, bodybuilders and Olympic lifters and those that work out in the style I do. When I first started there I was literally the only female in the free weight section and learnt lifts from old school bodybuilders, including the need to drop weights at times.

BusySittingDown · 22/11/2023 11:40

KimberleyClark · 22/11/2023 11:39

On the hygiene thing, well gyms are stinky, sweaty places 🤷‍♀️. Having bare feet out isn't much different to a sweaty person lying on a bench. Or someone dripping sweat all over the treadmill. I assume they're wearing socks?

People are expected to wear flip flops in the gym changing rooms for hygiene reasons, so why should it be acceptable to be barefoot in the gym itself?

Like I said: I assume they're wearing socks? I train without shoes on but I always wear socks.

KimberleyClark · 22/11/2023 11:39

On the hygiene thing, well gyms are stinky, sweaty places 🤷‍♀️. Having bare feet out isn't much different to a sweaty person lying on a bench. Or someone dripping sweat all over the treadmill. I assume they're wearing socks?

People are expected to wear flip flops in the gym changing rooms for hygiene reasons, so why should it be acceptable to be barefoot in the gym itself?

KimberleyClark · 22/11/2023 11:36

The ladies showers at my gym seem to be just under the weightlifting bit of the gym hall. The noise is quite something.

FarEast · 22/11/2023 11:33

Have you ever done a heavy deadlift? Like say twice your bodyweight?

Indeed! The only time I tend to drop weights coming out of a deadlift is when it’s over 90kg. My 1RM is 100k - not quite twice my bodyweight but effing heavy.

Lowering slow is a really good thing to do to develop strength but not at near to 1RM.

I think the OP. Is probably not a lifter.

BusySittingDown · 22/11/2023 11:30

Wow, there are some absolute machines on this thread! 👏👏 Amazing! 140kg deadlifts and 200kg hip thrusts, brilliant work! 🫡

I don't actually go to the gym anymore as I'm fortunate enough to have one at home. Sometimes I miss it though, just for the change of scenery.

Even with a "no drop rule" weights are gonna be dropped. Sometimes people can't help it.

I must admit though, at my old gym, there was a powerlifter bloke (not a powerlifter gym, just a basic cheap one) who used to yell during his lifts and drop his weights down with an almighty crash! Even though I was expecting it each time it made me jump 😂.

On the hygiene thing, well gyms are stinky, sweaty places 🤷‍♀️. Having bare feet out isn't much different to a sweaty person lying on a bench. Or someone dripping sweat all over the treadmill. I assume they're wearing socks?

I always train bare foot, but like I said, I train at home. Not sure I would in the gym.

firef1y · 22/11/2023 11:29

Sallythecamelhad · 22/11/2023 00:08

My gym has signs saying not to drop weights. Its a big no-no in every gym I've been in.
Those saying it's safer to drop that to lower down - bullshit. If you can lift but can't lower you're vanity lifting (and it's not impressing anyone). Stick to the weights you can manage if you don't want to hurt yourself. Controlled lowering requires strength which you clearly don't have if you have to drop your weight

I can chest press the 25kg dumbells, because I'm using those nice big muscles across my chest. I can even carry those dumbells over to the bench and set myself up. What I can't do is put them down on the floor afterwards, when I'm fatigued and needing to use my much smaller shoulder muscles to put them down in a range of motion not usually used in lifting which would involve my arm hanging almost behind my body.
I can safely put down the 12.5kg dumbells while laying on the bench, but they're not heavy enough for me to get a good workout

Cookiedough123 · 22/11/2023 11:18

I’ve been to a few different gyms and most frowned upon dropping weights.
Then I started a CrossFit gym and it seems to be normal to drop the weights here! Usually as they are encouraging you to hit your max !

Everanewbie · 22/11/2023 11:16

@firef1y I don't doubt what you're saying, but this isn't something you're doing at the local leisure centre or sports direct gym, I guess?

OP, I think it depends on the gym. If you turn up to a powerlifting/Crossfit specialist gym, you are being completely unreasonable, as above posters have said, dropping weights and having a good shout and grunting is par for the course. They probably don't like beginners and causals getting in their way.

If you're talking general fitness centres where the vibe is inclusive wellness, good ones are concerned for the comfort of all and in my experience, take a dim view for dropping heavy weights, excessive grunting etc. Some expressly ban it and enforce it. Not that there is anything wrong with proper powerlifters, but they need to go elsewhere if that's what they want to do.

It might be worth having a chat with the staff about your concerns to help you establish whether this is the gym for you.

firef1y · 22/11/2023 11:07

Doubleespresso33 · 22/11/2023 10:09

There’s a lot of exercises where it’s better to do it with no shoes on such as squats. There is method to the madness, it’s not just people wanting to be gross (gyms are sweaty and unhygienic anyway).

dropping weights although discouraged at a lot of gyms, if really normal especially if people are doing a 1 rep max or crazy set, it’s not a big deal

I usually keep my socks on when I squat, mostly because of the gross people that don't take their shoes off (which tbh isn't very many) and could have stepped in anything before they got on the rack.

Squatting without shoes is really very much the norm. It's better for stability and better for mechanics.

firef1y · 22/11/2023 11:04

CaramacFiend · 22/11/2023 10:06

Have you ever done a heavy deadlift? Like say twice your bodyweight?

Some movements cannot be reversed slowly, especially explosive movements. Imagine trying to slowly reverse the action of throwing a cricket ball or slowly reversing a long jump.

It does seem that most of the people saying dropping a weight is a big no no have neither lifted heavy or done an explosive Olympic style lift.
I actually can't imagine how much I'd injure my shoulders if I did a nice slow release from a heavy snatch instead of dropping it.

Some people need to watch some actual olympians doing snatches, they always drop the weights

Maybe some of you should ask the gym to either install a deadlifting platform or if they already have point people in that direction. There'll still be some noise. But it does deaden it a bit

firef1y · 22/11/2023 10:57

ShirleyPhallus · 21/11/2023 19:08

If you have to drop the weight then it’s too heavy for you and you likely have poor form

Putting the weight back properly is about half the lift. You’re cheating yourself to drop it and annoying everyone in the process

Nope. My form is good, the weight isn't too heavy, lighter weights I will put down on the floor, but if I'm close to my max then I will drop it. Its a deadlift not a dead put down and if its close to my max then all my energy has gone in to lifting it off the ground and locking out.

Luckily my gym actually realises this, we have deadlifting platforms where we can deadlift and do Olympic lifts and so drop the bars.

Throwing weights, now that's another matter, no need to throw them. But dropping yes, including when you've tried to push one more rep and need to bail

firef1y · 22/11/2023 10:51

Sorry but you're being unreasonable both about the noise of weights being dropped and bare feet.

I lift heavy (for me) and if I'm going for a deadlift pr then it is going to make a noise when the bar goes down. Same if I'm doing a lifting complex for time. If I've just done a set of deadlifts, hang cleans and push presses l, believe me I am going to drop the bar at the end of the set. Its what deadlifting platforms are for.

As for the bare feet, I stretch barefoot, I use a mat, I wipe the mat afterwards, what's the problem with that.

CaramacFiend · 22/11/2023 10:27

I find the shouty fitness/spin classes with amplified instructor annoying tbh. Even in the side studio they're incredibly loud.

Swipe left for the next trending thread