Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the gym staff should sort it?

119 replies

80skid · 21/11/2023 18:44

I've been going to my gym for years. It's not the cheapest, but there are plenty more expensive.

There's a good mix of age groups and it's generally a friendly and relaxed place to go. I've noticed recently that there's a big trend for dropping weights after the end of a set. It's always young men who do this, often when training together but sometimes alone. It's deliberate and exhibitionist. On one occasion, the vibrations from the weight dropping was so great that the weights on my machine were rattling. On another, the crash was so loud and sudden that I genuinely believed there to be a medical emergency. The noise is deafening, repetitive and needless.

This morning, I came to the conclusion that the noise level was such that in an industrial setting, ear defenders would be mandatory. There's usually staff about but they're often personal training or doing inductions, so not approachable.

AIBU to think the gym should make a greater effort to manage this? I know an autistic gym member who finds it really distressing and I can't say I'm that keen either. Don't start me on the people who think training barefoot on mats and then putting their sweaty feet on the wall while doing sit-ups is ok. It's basic manners isn't it?

OP posts:
Spongekirst · 22/11/2023 13:34

YANBU - Chucking weights on the floor is SO annoying! They only do it so everyone glances over to see how heavy they were lifting. Anyone who disagrees is dellusional!

There's not much the gym can do really other than put up a sign (like my one has) but maybe you can suggest they run a quieter session a couple of times a week for those who might find it genuinely hard to listen to beyond general annoyance.

gingercatnip · 22/11/2023 13:30

If they have to drop the weights they can’t cope with the weight …. I’d be ashamed to drop them but you are correct that it’s new behaviour. At our gym it’s usually young men dripping in fake tan and teeth whitener dropping the weights loudly.

CaramacFiend · 22/11/2023 13:30

firef1y · 22/11/2023 13:18

Yeah we are far more likely to become obsessed, not only with the exercise itself but our numbers and for those of you that seem to think if our weights bang our form is bad, we also tend to obsess over form. I regularly video myself and compare to online videos and am my own worse critic.

I video myself too. 😂

sparklefresh · 22/11/2023 13:21

And don't get me started on the 'urgh, the new year crowd' snobbery.

sparklefresh · 22/11/2023 13:20

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 22/11/2023 13:00

Oh Christ. I am 39 this year and I know I really need to start building in resistance training to get out in front of the menopause, but God this thread gives me, well, pause. Because OH MY GOD people are fucking tedious and pedantic about 'lifting heavy'. I guess it's addictive like a lot of sport (runners and cyclists seem to get particularly monomaniacal on their sport of choice), and at least it's good for people and keeps them out of the public houses as my Granny used to say, but jeepers all the naff terminology-touting, the patronising 'don't you know that...' drivelling on... I just want to do exercise that will keep me fit and slow osteoporosis, I hope it's possible to find a gym where I can do that without becoming or being surrounded by total obsessive bores. No fucker goes on and on and on in this tedious self-aggrandizing fashion about zumba, or swimming.

Couldn't agree more with this. My god, the state of some of these replies. People who define themselves by how much they can 'clean' need to get out more. And before anyone moans - I do a fair bit of strength training, and have for years. I know what I'm doing. I just haven't lost the ability to exercise (no pun intended) basic courtesy.

firef1y · 22/11/2023 13:18

RayKray · 22/11/2023 13:15

@herewegoroundthebastardbush lifting sports appeal to a lot of neurodiverse people for a whole host of reasons, so they may be more likely to know a lot and communicate in ways you don't seem to like. You can strength train without taking part in lifting as a sport, so you're perfectly safe.

Yeah we are far more likely to become obsessed, not only with the exercise itself but our numbers and for those of you that seem to think if our weights bang our form is bad, we also tend to obsess over form. I regularly video myself and compare to online videos and am my own worse critic.

firef1y · 22/11/2023 13:15

CaramacFiend · 22/11/2023 13:08

Says 'CaramacFiend'. 😳😂

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Hey I've been guilty of being bulky thanks to what I eat.
The great thing is I weigh the same as I did 4years ago, back then I was an 18 now I'm a 10-12. The shock of people's faces when they discover I weigh 80kg at 5'1 is always amusing. Not so amusing that I'm considered obese at 25% bodyfat, but hey ho

RayKray · 22/11/2023 13:15

@herewegoroundthebastardbush lifting sports appeal to a lot of neurodiverse people for a whole host of reasons, so they may be more likely to know a lot and communicate in ways you don't seem to like. You can strength train without taking part in lifting as a sport, so you're perfectly safe.

CaramacFiend · 22/11/2023 13:08

Says 'CaramacFiend'. 😳😂

CaramacFiend · 22/11/2023 13:07

firef1y · 22/11/2023 13:00

The gym I go to has seen a huge culture change in the last 3 or so years. I've gone from being the only female in the free weight area to one of many. Don't get me wrong, I love it, but you still get a lot of prejudice, from both men and women who can't understand why a woman would enjoy heavy lifting and want to build muscle. And the judgment from those that don't understand the sheet joy of mastering a new lift or getting a pr and just complain that we're being noisy.

I think a lot of people think that weights make women bulky. It's actually sitting on your arse and eating chocolate that does that. 😂

MagpiePi · 22/11/2023 13:06

Can’t see why people get worked up about other people in socks or bare feet, other than abhorrence of bare feet is a peculiarly British thing.
The trainers that you traveled to the gym in are probably more gross in terms of what they leave on the floor.

firef1y · 22/11/2023 13:00

CaramacFiend · 22/11/2023 12:46

100%

I do wonder if part of the issue is that commercial gyms have seemingly embraced deadlifting/squatting etc over the past decade or so. Gone are the days of women lifting pink fluffy dumbells.

The gym I go to has seen a huge culture change in the last 3 or so years. I've gone from being the only female in the free weight area to one of many. Don't get me wrong, I love it, but you still get a lot of prejudice, from both men and women who can't understand why a woman would enjoy heavy lifting and want to build muscle. And the judgment from those that don't understand the sheet joy of mastering a new lift or getting a pr and just complain that we're being noisy.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 22/11/2023 13:00

Oh Christ. I am 39 this year and I know I really need to start building in resistance training to get out in front of the menopause, but God this thread gives me, well, pause. Because OH MY GOD people are fucking tedious and pedantic about 'lifting heavy'. I guess it's addictive like a lot of sport (runners and cyclists seem to get particularly monomaniacal on their sport of choice), and at least it's good for people and keeps them out of the public houses as my Granny used to say, but jeepers all the naff terminology-touting, the patronising 'don't you know that...' drivelling on... I just want to do exercise that will keep me fit and slow osteoporosis, I hope it's possible to find a gym where I can do that without becoming or being surrounded by total obsessive bores. No fucker goes on and on and on in this tedious self-aggrandizing fashion about zumba, or swimming.

CaramacFiend · 22/11/2023 12:58

BusySittingDown · 22/11/2023 12:46

Seriously though! How the hell would you have a "No Grunting" rule?!? Some people grunt just getting up from sitting 😂.

😂

CaramacFiend · 22/11/2023 12:56

Elastica23 · 22/11/2023 12:35

Basically I fucking hate the afterwork crowd and I'm bracing myself because the New Year New Me crowd are coming soon.

Ah, yes. The latter aren't too bad though apart from just filling the place up more than usual. DH will be one as I've bought him some PT sessions to get started. 😅

My bugbear is mostly young men (to be fair, the biggest users of my gym are young men) taking bloody ages on one piece of equipment, and often just sitting there on their phones on the leg raise as if it's an arm chair. With one lad I wasn't that bothered about the leg raise, or I'd have said something, and could fit it in later, but I did three different types of weights, 2 x 15 or 20 reps, and went on the cross trainer for ten minutes and he got off while I was doing tricep extensions after, so he must have been nearly 25 minutes on one pieceof equipment, mostly just sitting there. I know people might do more sets/take longer in between and that's fine but for some there does seem to be a lot of sitting around and not much doing. I'd be there all day if I was that slow!

Edited

I rest for five mins between sets of DLs and squats so can easily be 30 mins once you factor in the warmup sets. But most people that use the power cage understand. Common courtesy is to let somebody work in if they ask but most can't be arsed to keep changing the weights, taking plates on and off.

But if it's just a young bloke on a machine messing around on his phone I'll usually ask how many sets he's got left which let's him know I'm waiting. There's nothing rude about doing so because if they've only just started it gives you the chance to do something else first.

firef1y · 22/11/2023 12:53

TravelInHope · 22/11/2023 12:22

If you can’t set the weights down gently then they are too heavy for you, and of course you risk injuring yourself.

Seriously this is not true.
Let's take the snatch, it's an explosive lift, you're exploding through your whole body to get the bar over your head, your arms are (almost) straight through the whole movement. If you tried to slowly and gently reverse the movement you would dislocate your shoulders. There's no way to actually reverse that movement, the movement itself involves you coming up on your toes, it involves a squat (and the heavier the weight the deeper the squat), it involves pulling the bar from shin height to overhead. It sometimes even involves a small jump.
Now tell me how I gently reverse that movement?
If the weights not too heavy I can do the reverse of a clean, but I can snatch heavier than I can clean, plus hand position on the bar is completely different to a clean, your hands are much wider, the risk of injuring my shoulder if I try is very very real.
What I can do is bring the bar down to shoulder height and then drop it, which is the safe way of dealing with the bar.

You might not realise it, but deadlifts (even the slow, heavy ones) are also explosive and involve a complex chain of muscles and movements that are almost impossible to replicate in reverse. Sure during warm up sets it's easy enough to return the bar to the ground gently, but if your lifting more than 70% of your max then gentle ain't gonna happen. Its the reason platforms are a thing

BusySittingDown · 22/11/2023 12:46

Seriously though! How the hell would you have a "No Grunting" rule?!? Some people grunt just getting up from sitting 😂.

CaramacFiend · 22/11/2023 12:46

firef1y · 22/11/2023 11:04

It does seem that most of the people saying dropping a weight is a big no no have neither lifted heavy or done an explosive Olympic style lift.
I actually can't imagine how much I'd injure my shoulders if I did a nice slow release from a heavy snatch instead of dropping it.

Some people need to watch some actual olympians doing snatches, they always drop the weights

Maybe some of you should ask the gym to either install a deadlifting platform or if they already have point people in that direction. There'll still be some noise. But it does deaden it a bit

100%

I do wonder if part of the issue is that commercial gyms have seemingly embraced deadlifting/squatting etc over the past decade or so. Gone are the days of women lifting pink fluffy dumbells.

Bendysnap · 22/11/2023 12:42

YANBU . I can tolerate a little bit of weight dropping in my DL gym as it’s a big space, padded floor etc etc. but I totally see where you’re coming from. Do complain.

what I CANNOT abide is people dropping their weights from waist height in a pump class. SMASH onto the newly refurbished sprung wood floor paid for with our membership fees. Luckily most instructors pick up on it straight away but there are an awful lot of dickheads ready to drop their 20kg weights in the next class…

Elastica23 · 22/11/2023 12:35

Basically I fucking hate the afterwork crowd and I'm bracing myself because the New Year New Me crowd are coming soon.

Ah, yes. The latter aren't too bad though apart from just filling the place up more than usual. DH will be one as I've bought him some PT sessions to get started. 😅

My bugbear is mostly young men (to be fair, the biggest users of my gym are young men) taking bloody ages on one piece of equipment, and often just sitting there on their phones on the leg raise as if it's an arm chair. With one lad I wasn't that bothered about the leg raise, or I'd have said something, and could fit it in later, but I did three different types of weights, 2 x 15 or 20 reps, and went on the cross trainer for ten minutes and he got off while I was doing tricep extensions after, so he must have been nearly 25 minutes on one pieceof equipment, mostly just sitting there. I know people might do more sets/take longer in between and that's fine but for some there does seem to be a lot of sitting around and not much doing. I'd be there all day if I was that slow!

CoffeeWithCheese · 22/11/2023 12:26

BusySittingDown · 22/11/2023 11:59

I think some people need some noise cancelling headphones for Christmas.

I refuse to go to the gym without mine (I'm autistic and it's hellishly loud otherwise).

Things that piss me off:
You're asked to spray the sanitiser onto the blue roll and then wipe - not make a huge thing over using half a bottle to cover the treadmill you've been on and then only half wipe it off so the next person to get on gets to find all these moist bits that you're not sure if they're sweat, other bodily fluids or cleaning spray.
Groups of blokes egging each other on on one of the resistance machines (fine) but manspreading so they're leaning all over the neighbouring machine I'm trying to use and just generally being in my space.
There's one bloke who brings his kid just to sit the kid on another machine so he can lay claim to both of them - fine, but not in the peak after work busy slot.
Another couple who bring their kids who just fuck about and don't do anything but block machines for anyone who wants to use them.
Blokes who sweat ridiculous amounts and try to shake it around like a fucking dog shaking water off them - and wear the exact same t-shirt every single night covered in the performative sweat.
There's one personal trainer who's been in a couple of times training someone and he counts reps at the same volume that the exercise studio next door is using for a full class, with a microphone, to be heard over the music - there's no need for me to be able to hear in the cardio room 2 rooms away that Dave is onto crunch number FIFTEEN - it's just being a loud twat for the sake of being a loud twat.
Judgemental glares because I'm fat and in the gym - find it particularly hilarious when blokes try to match what I'm doing to prove they're better than me and then can't do it.
Oh and carrying your entire gym bag around with you like it's fucking Tinkywinky's handbag - the rule is none of them on the gym floor - put it on the shelving like every bugger else does.

Basically I fucking hate the afterwork crowd and I'm bracing myself because the New Year New Me crowd are coming soon.

GoudaThunkIt · 22/11/2023 12:25

I’ve swapped gyms recently because of this phenomenon. I think it’s people that are learning to lift on the internet, which has its place, but if you want to drop stupidly heavy weights like the competition guys do go to CrossFit not the council gym.

TravelInHope · 22/11/2023 12:23

CaramacFiend · 21/11/2023 19:42

How do you propose I lower this slowly?

In the reverse manner to picking it up.

TravelInHope · 22/11/2023 12:22

CeeChynaa · 21/11/2023 18:58

The gym is not a library. It’s not meant to be a quiet place where no one makes a peep.

If you’re doing deadlifts/RDL’s and lifting pretty heavy, the safest way to place the bar down without injuring your back is to drop the bar. I lift heavy and won’t place the bar down quietly and risk injuring my lower back for someone who wants a quiet environment.

You should speak with the management team and they’d probably say the same

If you can’t set the weights down gently then they are too heavy for you, and of course you risk injuring yourself.

firef1y · 22/11/2023 12:13

BusySittingDown · 22/11/2023 11:59

I think some people need some noise cancelling headphones for Christmas.

I have a brilliant pair from Samsung, fully cuts out the gym music (which is very often not to my taste) and only let's through the very loudest of bar drops. Which if I bother to look, I'm usually quite impressed with what they've lifted to make that noise. Seriously there was a guy lifting 5plates (for those of you that don't lift that comes in at 220kg) no way that was going back down quietly even on the platform.
Gyms are noisy places, if you don't like.noise invest in some decent, noise cancelling headphones (which are always great when you don't want to talk to people either, there's an unwritten rule among serious gym goers/lifters that if the headphones/earphones are on then that person doesn't want to interact)