Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not expect the school to educate my dc?

155 replies

Christmascarolle · 21/11/2023 11:55

Met a teacher friend for coffee, her child is 11 like mine & are in the same class both would be high achieving.
I mentioned to my friend that I do extra at home with my dd, she has extra maths, literacy, geography & history which she really enjoys doing & reads lots in her spare time.
My teacher friend said she shouldn't be doing this extra work that it's up to the teacher & school to educate the children in their care.
I disagree as there is 30 in a class & all different levels. My dd enjoys going beyond the basics & is thriving in school.
Aibu or is the teacher friend? (according to my child the teachers daughter does lots of extension work with her mum. She never mentioned this to me just criticised me for going the extra mile with my child!)

OP posts:
Christmascarolle · 21/11/2023 13:38

@twistyizzy thanks! Great reply & so true 😁 No cajoling to do the extra work, she's very bookish & really enjoys schoolwork as mad as it seems. There seems to be a culture in her school to get all kids to "average" & nothing beyond that. Abseentism of her teachers this year & in the past has been a big problem so I took it upon myself to fill gaps so to speak.
But the difference in the education, expectations & ambitions of the dc we know who go to private & grammar are a world apart from what my child is getting.

OP posts:
LessonsInPhysics · 21/11/2023 13:35

Sounds to me like she is just doing a bit of extra work herself because she likes it?
This is fabulous and should be encouraged. Lots of kids will be working at greater depth, carrying out extension work and reading around topics. Just because the teacher's child isn't, doesn't mean others won't be.

edwinbear · 21/11/2023 13:34

I have 2 DC in private, who have been there since Reception, now Y7 and Y10. Y10 had a lot to do over the 2 week October half term, understandably, now he's in a GCSE year. In relation to the Y7, school sent a message to all the parents saying they had worked hard settling in and the school also values rest, so nothing was set for them so they could recharge over the break. Saturday mornings are for sport not school work at DC's school. I wouldn't believe everything your friends say about their DC's private/grammars.

twistyizzy · 21/11/2023 13:31

It's funny, on the anti-private school posts the comments are always in the ilk of "state + supplementing with tutoring + extra curricular work" is more acceptable than sending a kid to private school. OP is doing that but then getting some criticism for doing so 😁.
@Christmascarolle imo you are correct. DD is in Yr 7 private. School day is 8.30-5pm + 2 x 20 min homework subjects per night. With a class of 30+ there is no way a teacher can meet the needs of all DC in that class and it is usually the top ones who get overlooked as quite rightly the lower ability kids need additional time.
All I would say is that if you are trying to match a private/grammar curriculum then you need to do more sports/arts/drama than you currently are.
At the end of the day it is your child and if she is happy and completing the extra work without cajoling or bribery then it's all good.

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 21/11/2023 13:28

Different families approach education differently.
Personally I’d be stretching the extra-curricular aspect and mastery of one outside interest vs classroom material.

Octavia64 · 21/11/2023 13:27

Neither of you are unreasonable.

School should educate your child.

A standard state school will not educate your child to the point they can compete with grammar/private school kids so if you want them to be at that level you need to supplement.

Singleandproud · 21/11/2023 13:24

Yes and no, the problem with teaching your child things on the curriculum is that you could be teaching them how to use different methods which can cause confusion later. Your teacher friend will be more aware of current teaching strategies.

But teaching things that aren't on the curriculum or giving context without overlapping directly - visiting museums on a topic watching related documentaries is great

Maybetoofarsouth · 21/11/2023 13:18

Christmascarolle · 21/11/2023 13:14

We have friends with kids at top grammers & private schools. They have longer school days, lots of homework & projects, Saturday school & set work over the holidays. Dds education is very basic in comparison & I'd like her to be on an even keel to children her own age however much of a wanker I sound!

I can completely see where you're coming from when you put it in context. DD1 is in a grammar and gets lots more homework than her friends from primary school.

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 21/11/2023 13:17

Christmascarolle · 21/11/2023 13:07

It's an interesting one especially coming from a teacher. The way I see it is my child will hopefully be competing for jobs with kids from grammar & private schools who would be going the extra mile in & outside school.
Our state school is anti homework & it's literally 10 mins a day & half the time isn't even collected.

Where is this school. I wish my kids school was anti homework. Instead we get bland, unchallenging twinkle print outs, “spellings” that they already know and reading books that they have read or don’t enjoy as much as their own books.

Id much rather not have that homework and have more time to do engaging educational activities at home.

RockStarship · 21/11/2023 13:15

Neither of you are right or wrong. If your dc likes doing extra at home and you have time to facilitate that then that's fine. If other parents/kids don't want to do that and just leave it to the teacher then that's also fine.

Christmascarolle · 21/11/2023 13:14

We have friends with kids at top grammers & private schools. They have longer school days, lots of homework & projects, Saturday school & set work over the holidays. Dds education is very basic in comparison & I'd like her to be on an even keel to children her own age however much of a wanker I sound!

OP posts:
shepherdsangeldelight · 21/11/2023 13:11

I agree with others - I'd want to be spending the time on "enriching" activities rather than more book learning. Fair enough if your child is behind to try to plug the gap, but otherwise why not leave it to school?

I'm not sure hours and hours of homework is that beneficial at 11 tbh.

user1496146479 · 21/11/2023 13:10

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/11/2023 13:00

Well it would be reasonable to expect the school to give her an education. But it’s not unreasonable to do extra if you want to/ think it’s needed.

It seems an odd argument tbh

Agree with this

Christmascarolle · 21/11/2023 13:07

It's an interesting one especially coming from a teacher. The way I see it is my child will hopefully be competing for jobs with kids from grammar & private schools who would be going the extra mile in & outside school.
Our state school is anti homework & it's literally 10 mins a day & half the time isn't even collected.

OP posts:
sollenwir · 21/11/2023 13:06

I wholeheartedly agree with others that if your child is bright and reaching/exceeding targets in school, then home 'education' should be on other things which the school might not have the time/money to do - obviously it needs to be age appropriate but taking them to museums, libraries, out on long walks/hikes, cooking and baking, swimming, volunteering, encouraging them to be creative (art, poetry, crafts), basic budgeting (can be introduced early on), and so many other things. An over-achiever in primary school doesn't always become a 'high achiever' (and that's a horrible term anyway, because we all have different skills and talents, and academic achievement is not the only sort of achievement).

I also feel like this is a humble brag, even if you don't think it is.

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 21/11/2023 13:06

Neither are being unreasonable. Each child, situation is different and you have a difference of opinion about how much educating should be done at home.

I will say though that many people ‘educate’ their children at home without doing “top up” maths type activities. Teaching life skills, a culture of reading books, cooking etc are all educational in a less formal format.

personally I don’t do too much “work” at home with the children, however we do encourage their interests (eg get books linked to the animal they like, talk a lot when they have questions etc) and do broadly educational things together.

ActDottie · 21/11/2023 13:03

I agree with you. The school provides the basics for learning but I personally believe to do well academically parents need to also do extra with their children. My parents did and it has set me up for life in terms of I’m in a really good professional job and lead a pretty comfy life. But this is just my view from my personal experience.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/11/2023 13:01

Cliva · 21/11/2023 12:57

I only realised this when my oldest dc ended up being significantly behind in maths. School really can’t teach everything, sometimes even at a basic level. There are plenty of kids who leave primary without basic numeracy and literacy. Sad but that’s reality.

I think kids who are struggling in school probably benefit enormously from extra parental support and/or 1:1 tutoring to help them catch up, and this kind of academic intervention makes sense to me.

But for a bright child who is already doing well at school? I would choose to stretch them in other ways.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/11/2023 13:00

Well it would be reasonable to expect the school to give her an education. But it’s not unreasonable to do extra if you want to/ think it’s needed.

It seems an odd argument tbh

Sceptre86 · 21/11/2023 13:00

I think it's a weird competitve thing. Dh mentioned once to my sil that I do extra work with my dd1 and ds and she have me a whole lecture about how kids learn enough at school. When we next saw them bil mentioned it again until I reminded him that sil did the same when her son was my kid's age and has only stopped because she struggles to make the time now she has 2 kids so feels guilty. Well I have 3 and I prioritise it but that doesn't mean I look down on those that can't (for whatever reason). For the record dd1 does 10minutes of comprehension, 10 minutes of handwriting practice and 10 minutes if times table practice a week. Ds does 10 minutes of spellings, 10 minutes of handwriting and 10 minutes of times tables. I make the time to do it. This isn't always sat at a table but more often on the go. Dd1 has issues with fine motor skills so needs support with her handwriting as does ds with his spellings. For us it's a case of supporting the work they do at school.

So in my view yanbu. With 30 kids in a class, some who will have sen and no extra help I do not believe any teacher can give each child the same level of attention. If your child is already very bright I'd work on breadth of knowledge which it sounds like you already are. If it gives her increased confidence, she is happy and you can make the time then why not?

Cliva · 21/11/2023 12:57

I only realised this when my oldest dc ended up being significantly behind in maths. School really can’t teach everything, sometimes even at a basic level. There are plenty of kids who leave primary without basic numeracy and literacy. Sad but that’s reality.

mumonthehill · 21/11/2023 12:52

I agree with @MrsBennetsPoorNerves . Ds was very bright so did not need extra maths or English. What we could give him was access to books, museums, the news, travel that gave depth to the stuff he was learning. He was lucky we could and he can now debate me under the table! He has a wide and varied knowledge and more importantly he is inquisitive.

VickyEadieofThigh · 21/11/2023 12:52

My mother taught me to read and write before I was 4 (I didn't start school until April in the year I had my (June) birthday.

It was by far the greatest gift she could've given me. Parental input doesn't need to be extra lessons - read early, read regularly with your child and help her/him to love reading and writing. Practise their tables with them regularly until they know them.

Cultivate their interests and talk to them about these. Ask them when they come home from school to tell you about the most interesting things they learnt.

But hothousing and piling on extra work - this can be counterproductive.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/11/2023 12:49

I absolutely believe that education needs to happen in the home as well as at school, and I don't think your friend should be telling you how to parent your child.

Personally, though, I wouldn't go for the academic hothousing approach for a bright child. The kind of education that I would focus on at home would be the stuff that they don't do in school - stuff that provides breadth, variety and enrichment as well as opportunities to develop skills beyond the academic stuff that they do in school.

I can't see the point of doing lots of extra maths and literacy if the child is already ahead in school...you just end up pushing them even further ahead and making school really boring for them. There are so many other things that kids can learn!

Birdcar · 21/11/2023 12:48

There's no right or wrong answer. Situations vary.
YABU just for asking the question.