Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if this is just what secondary school is like?

132 replies

Notmyusual80 · 20/11/2023 22:59

DD is 14, in year 9. She loved primary - always wanted to go in, got excited about the simplest activities/events and got involved with everything.

Now I know secondary is very, very different - more pressure (especially as she goes to a grammar), more independence expected of them etc. But I just feel like her school is slowly grinding her down.

The emphasis is on tests and perfect uniform. If someone misbehaves, they all get shouted at, all the time. In fact it feels like their approach is to assume they’re all badly behaved (even though she’s clearly not) and are hard on them all just in case, iyswim. She hasn’t bonded with any of her teachers and some of them just seem really harsh disciplinarians. She also finds a lot of the lessons uninspiring.

She’s successfully put herself forward for several roles (think school council etc) and then….nothing…there have been no activities associated with the roles she’s supposed to be doing. They’re just titles.

And so far, she’s been on two trips since year 7. That’s it. I know they need to focus on work/study but would a little fun here and there hurt? My secondary years were great fun and I still managed to do well.

She’s just not enjoying school now and doesn’t look forward to going in.

I feel like she started off an eager, proactive, enthusiastic student and they’ve totally knocked this out of her.

Is this just what secondary is like now? And if not, what can I do? There are no opportunities to give this kind of feedback and even if I did, how can I get this across without it sounding like “DD is not enjoying school and finds it boring” which is how it’s going to sound isn’t it?

OP posts:
BCBird · 22/11/2023 05:42

Teacher here in her 50s. I think trips are more infrequent than they used to be, for various reasons. Maybe that school is not for her? Ask her. Look around for a state school with a less ' traditional attitude. Speak to other parents about their child's experience. See if u can chat to someone at other places and bisit too. If she is bright she will thrive someone else. Grammar school would not have suited me.

Zanatdy · 22/11/2023 05:35

I think grammars are very pressured but the naughty kid situation will be far worse in a normal secondary. My DD is never naughty, but her class are forever getting told off, even in yr 11 some kids think they are class clowns and don’t care if they are disrupting education for others. Maybe look for a new school for A levels but stay for now if she won’t leave right now

electriclight · 22/11/2023 05:26

I don't think you can be surprised by firm discipline, strict uniform codes and lots of tests - it's what anyone would expect of a grammar school and why some parents choose them.

A whole-school telling off at the end of assembly is also quite usual - if you don't know who the culprits are, if a large % of the cohort are involved. I assume this is along the lines of 'lots of you are forgetting your pe kits' or 'there are bins on the playground for a reason'?

Not gelling with any teacher or enjoying any lesson is unusual. It can't be like primary school when some teachers only see you for an hour a week but I think most students enjoy some lessons. I wonder if other pupils feel like this? Would be interesting to know whether every teacher really is awful or whether dd would feel like this even if she moved schools.

I think I'd be asking about trips though.

Nonplusultra · 22/11/2023 05:12

We had the opposite where I didn’t grasp how bad the primary was until they got to secondary.

It has taken three years for ds to unknot himself but now he’s thriving in a lovely, nurturing school community where he’s appreciated and encouraged.

Dd has only started in a completely different big, bustling school and has come back to life again.

I think you should definitely consider moving her. I wish I’d recognised the problems earlier.

ChekhovsMum · 22/11/2023 05:04

Some grammars really are like this. A lot of ‘aspirational’ parents don’t seem to care how miserable their kids are as long as they get a string of Grade 8 and 9 GCSEs. Save your daughter from it if you can - either by getting her out or by providing the best counter-narrative you know how to at home.

Oblomov23 · 22/11/2023 04:59

Hmm. Ds2 has only been on a weekend away so far, and that was not last year, but the year before!

I'd ask HoY re the position with no responsibilities, and the punishing all by shouting at all, not ok.

But he does live doing cross country, and weekly playing football for the school that he adores. Is she sporty?

sheflieswithherownwings · 22/11/2023 03:22

My year 7 DS is not at a grammar but having very similar feelings to your DD about school. It makes me v sad as he loved primary. It just feels relentless and he too finds the lessons mostly boring . And says the teachers shout a lot. For those saying move schools, are other schools really that different? In what way? From speaking to friends with similar aged kids they all sound about the same… a lot of focus on discipline and little interest in getting to know the kids or making lessons engaging. Tbh I was assuming it would be better at a grammar!

penjil · 22/11/2023 02:45

Ger your daughter out while you can.

That school sounds like a gulag.

Try the local comprehensive, she may flourish there, as it won't be an exam factory, and may enjoy more holistic lessons like food tech or art. She'll be able to "breathe" better.

PinkArt · 22/11/2023 00:43

I went to a grammar and some of this sounds hideously familiar. They absolutely don't relax because they have the smart kids - their job is to take the smart kids and get amazing exam results from them, before they all go to the right uni and become lawyers or doctors. That creates a very hot house environment and in the case of my school, one that activity made the kids feel less smart than they were. We'd get marked a B- for essays that were an easy A or A* when marked by exam boards. It's hard not to have your self esteem knocked when you think you are delivering great work - because you are - and are always told it's more like not bad work.
In the case of girls' grammars, that competitive hot house can become an easy breeding ground for all sorts of mental health issues, most notably eating disorders. Thankfully there is much more of a conversation around that these days but back in the 90s I think we were all a bit of a mess but no-one ever talked about it.
What doesn't sound familiar though it the lack of trips and extra curriculars. Mine very much encouraged girls to do hockey, tennis etc clubs and we had theatre trips, history trips and so on. It sounds like your daughter's has an odd mix of pushing for success but not adding in some of the extras that are a huge part of that.
I'd look at the alternatives with her. It might be moving her away from friends and a familiar environment really isn't for the best, but making it the most informed decision possible probably is.

Z0rr0 · 22/11/2023 00:35

@Notmyusual80 It makes me so sad that she's just not enjoying it and actively dreads it at the end of holidays / Sunday night.
And she's a pretty good student, she just shouldn't have to put up, with all the other crap that's going on.
My first daughter who has just started uni had the same experience but she is more self confident so was better able to shrug off the crap, but my Y10 DD has quite low self esteem and has to really work hard to understand the tougher subjects and that's made umpteen times more difficult with all the disruption and the often rubbish teaching.
We're not at a grammar, it's a regular church comp in Surrey, but not a posh part of Surrey.
I'm really sorry your DD is feeling similarly. It's so disheartening. I think the education system is just another thing that's broken in this country tbh.

SwedishSchnauzer · 22/11/2023 00:28

I don’t know many of my children’s friends who truly enjoyed secondary school. Non of my kids did and non of their secondary schools were truly nurturing or child centred in any meaningful way. All mine relived to find training/work/college a suitable mature environment which played to their skills and interests

Notmyusual80 · 22/11/2023 00:16

@Z0rr0 sounds so similar to DD’s experience. The obsession with the bloody uniform gets on my nerves for one thing! And I can absolutely sympathise with you feeling like you’re “counselling her through it.”

@Spinderellaseverywhere that’s the thing, she’s really starting to become unhappy 😞

OP posts:
Z0rr0 · 21/11/2023 23:53

I can't wait for my DD Y10 to finish her GCSEs and put secondary school behind us. I used to think we chose a good school but it feels like it's gradually declining and I hate having to constantly counsel my girls through it.
The endless poor behaviour and low level disruption, lack of discipline, or too much discipline which makes the (good) kids afraid. Teachers failing to adequately teach the curriculum, constant policing of girls uniforms (but not boys), shortened break times, unreasonable rules around use of toilets, lack of teaching staff, dull lessons, lack of attention to boys harassing of girls, lack of spaces for children to eat or relax together...
It's ruined education for my daughter who really enjoyed school before. I don't even think it's particularly the fault of teachers who now have to spend half their time being social workers.
I've been helping out with exam invigilating and honestly you couldn't pay me enough to be a teacher for what they have to cope with every day, but I wish they would pay them well and get actually decent teachers who last more than a year or two.
It's grim honestly and disappointing because although I know secondary school is a bit shit for most kids, I have generally good memories of it, and I loved learning. I'm sad she's lost her feel for it because of how miserable an experience it is most weeks.

Spinderellaseverywhere · 21/11/2023 23:44

Well I went to a comp and there was a lot of mass discipline / keeping the whole class back during break time for a few badly behaved kids so it’s not necessarily a grammar thing. I hated it! It did improve when we were put in sets / subject choices for GCSE (most of the really naughty kids left then).

My DCs school does hardly any trips which I do find a bit sad too. I loved trips.

If she’s doing well and not really unhappy I’d probably persevere until 6th form.

Notmyusual80 · 21/11/2023 23:37

@DisquietintheRanks when we were choosing schools, it was in the thick of the pandemic so all we had as a guide were videos that each of the schools had made. Found it an impossible task. ☹️

OP posts:
Notmyusual80 · 21/11/2023 23:34

Thank you all. And the PP who said I shouldn’t fanny around with GCSEs approaching - I know, and this stresses me out! I’ve mentioned to her about changing schools and she's not overly keen - worried that it might be a case of out of the frying pan into the fire…going to try to get her to at least look at a school, though, if I can.

I just feel so gutted and deflated for her - all that enthusiasm she has just gone down the pan.

OP posts:
DisquietintheRanks · 21/11/2023 22:48

My kids school is not like this. It's a comp that gets good results and is slightly old fashioned and strict, but not nearly as dull and depressing as your dd's school seems to be. Plenty of lunchtime clubs, plenty of school trips.

I'm wondering why you picked that particular school for your dd?

mrsnoodle55 · 21/11/2023 22:47

My oldest son went to our local grammar. Thrived, no issues. Plenty of trips and sports etc. But hardly any arts (which he has no interest in). Now at uni and no negative memories. In fact he really liked school. Got on sports teams, sports trips etc.

My daughter has started at the rural comp this year; small, arty focused school with lots of trips/ clubs/ shows etc. So far so good. Early days of course. She would have been lost at the grammar. It’s v v strict, (a bit OTT I think), but the teams, clubs, performing arts and trips out etc stuff makes up for it. She’s had 3 trips (local, day trips) so far and she’s in yr 7. She would have hated the grammar. Maybe it’s worth exploring the other school.

VickyEadieofThigh · 21/11/2023 22:44

CoffeeCantata · 21/11/2023 13:42

Give it time, OP. I bet they'll be laying down the law and 'not smiling till Christmas' so that the new intake understand they need to step up.

I'm sure things will improve as teachers relax with the new students. But grammar school is pressured - my son went to one and loved it. If your child likes a challenge and 'grown up' expectations she will settle in and begin to enjoy things soon.

She's in Y9 - has already done more than two years!

Motherhubbardscupboard · 21/11/2023 22:41

If she's not desperately unhappy I don't think I would move her at this stage. If the move doesn't work she'll be in Year 10 and stuck. In 2.5 years she can leave and go elsewhere for sixth form, which is basically what I did. Does she do much outside of school? When I look back I have very neutral feelings about school, I didn't enjoy it but also wasn't unhappy. But I had a really good hobby outside school which I have my happiest memories from. And I really enjoyed my sixth form years at a college.

Octavia64 · 21/11/2023 22:35

Sounds like an exam factory.

Some schools are some schools aren't.

Maybe ask around locally or try to find out the reputations of the schools.

IDoughnutKnow · 21/11/2023 22:32

OP, that sounds rubbish, and it does not correspond to the experience my DC had at their secondary schools.

Just a school that makes an effort to build the kids up and give them some sort of sense that they care about them is all I really want

I think that's a very good aspiration. Pupils should feel on the whole that they matter and are valued for who they are. If a school isn't doing this, it is doing something wrong.

XelaM · 21/11/2023 22:28

Not all secondary schools are joyless. Definitely look around. If you’re anywhere near Latymer I’ve heard it’s quite relaxed and loads of extra curricular activities. Their drama performances are West End quality. (That’s if you want to try another grammar school).

cansu · 21/11/2023 22:06

It is hard to tell from your OP.

  1. It could be that the grammar is not suitable for her. They can be very traditional in style.
  2. No secondary is going to be like a lovely primary school. Secondaries are huge schools where the emphasis is on grades and exams. This can mean they are a bit stern and less fun. They also need to be strict with rules as teens can quickly become poorly behaved.
  3. The comp might be more relaxed but not necessarily. It could be similarly strict or it could have lots of low level disruption which is annoying and difficult if your child wants to get on and learn.

I think I would be very careful about moving. I would look around the comp and if possible ask if she could do a couple of trial days. This would allow her to see the school in reality and decide if it would suit her.

O0oO0o · 21/11/2023 21:53

This was my DD's experience of secondary school too. Not a grammar, but a girls church school.

She left in June and was absolutely adamant she wasn't going to a school sixth form for year 12. She's at the local college and is much happier.

Swipe left for the next trending thread