Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if this is just what secondary school is like?

132 replies

Notmyusual80 · 20/11/2023 22:59

DD is 14, in year 9. She loved primary - always wanted to go in, got excited about the simplest activities/events and got involved with everything.

Now I know secondary is very, very different - more pressure (especially as she goes to a grammar), more independence expected of them etc. But I just feel like her school is slowly grinding her down.

The emphasis is on tests and perfect uniform. If someone misbehaves, they all get shouted at, all the time. In fact it feels like their approach is to assume they’re all badly behaved (even though she’s clearly not) and are hard on them all just in case, iyswim. She hasn’t bonded with any of her teachers and some of them just seem really harsh disciplinarians. She also finds a lot of the lessons uninspiring.

She’s successfully put herself forward for several roles (think school council etc) and then….nothing…there have been no activities associated with the roles she’s supposed to be doing. They’re just titles.

And so far, she’s been on two trips since year 7. That’s it. I know they need to focus on work/study but would a little fun here and there hurt? My secondary years were great fun and I still managed to do well.

She’s just not enjoying school now and doesn’t look forward to going in.

I feel like she started off an eager, proactive, enthusiastic student and they’ve totally knocked this out of her.

Is this just what secondary is like now? And if not, what can I do? There are no opportunities to give this kind of feedback and even if I did, how can I get this across without it sounding like “DD is not enjoying school and finds it boring” which is how it’s going to sound isn’t it?

OP posts:
adomizo · 22/11/2023 22:39

This doesn't sound great at all. I have 2 kids at grammar and their experience isn't like this. I would write an email to the head and outline what you have said here in a nice way. They have a duty of pastoral care to some degree and if they don't respond then its a clear message to do something..

stayathomer · 22/11/2023 22:33

Comedycook
Hopefully something turns with them both

ProfSleepzz · 22/11/2023 21:45

I’ve NTRTF but this sounds like a crap school. I teach in a grammar (having taught in comps for 15 years) and my school doesn’t treat kids like this. We have high expectations but we’re kind too. If you have a title, it’s meaningful. I have two school council reps - they go to weekly meetings and the meeting minutes are fed back at SLT and SLT respond to every point each week. (Sometimes saying yes we’ll change it. Sometimes saying no we won’t but thank you for telling us.) We do plays and musicals and trips - abroad and in the uk. The thing is I’ve worked in brilliant schools (comps and selective) and awful schools (in my experience comp only - but obviously selective schools can also be rubbish). The Ofsted rating is irrelevant. My last school was ‘good’. It wasn’t. It was sodding awful. I would challenge the school about the things that aren’t working for your daughter calmly and rationally, with suggestions for how they could help her. If they do, great. If they don’t, it’s not going to change and you’ll have a decision to make. My kids’ (primary) school isn’t great. I regularly (& politely) suggest what they could do. They then do it. So while it’s not a great school, I can cope because they’ll take feedback. If they refused to take feedback I’d be considering a different school.

Comedycook · 22/11/2023 20:45

stayathomer · 22/11/2023 20:25

Comedycook
ah bless him, you’re probably the same as me so, I hugely love the school holidays to give him a break

Yes its horrible when they're not happy. His mood during the school holidays is so much better than during the school week

stayathomer · 22/11/2023 20:25

Comedycook
ah bless him, you’re probably the same as me so, I hugely love the school holidays to give him a break

Justenjoyinglife · 22/11/2023 18:53

Only just starting out on the secondary school route but yours does sound problematic & very demoralising for your daughter. DS has just started secondary at a school that gets amazing results and has very high expectations but so far it seems they have a very good way of encouraging students and rewarding engagement and good behaviour. One term in and he’s been on a school trip already, had 6 sports events.
They actively seek our feedback and have a very open door policy about talking to form tutors/head of year. Maybe look around other local schools to see if they would be a better fit and hopefully bring back your DD’s enthusiasm for school.

SiennaMillar · 22/11/2023 18:46

I would tell them what you’ve told us: that they’re grinding her spirit down with their too harsh discipline, and strict attitude, no trips, no meetings for school council, and no bonds with teachers. Remind them that they’re dealing with children.

topnoddy · 22/11/2023 18:44

Sounds like all the school is interested in is ticking boxes and getting exam results that make them look like a good school

Comedycook · 22/11/2023 18:40

stayathomer · 22/11/2023 13:32

Op I feel your pain, my ds was top of his class in primary, hardworking, had a few really nice friends, took part in school. Secondary went well in 1st year, he just worked on made friends etc, this year he’s doing the ‘I can’t believe it’s Monday tomorrow’ thing, quiet going in on a Monday, quiet during the week, a lot of sighing, in working in office until late then comes out saying’guess I’m going to bed now,’ and he’s now said once or twice he can’t believe he has 3 or 4 years of this. We’ve had chats and told him to take his foot off the pedal, tried to get him to play board games or even to go gaming instead of doing every bit of homework but it’s like he’s a bit broken. He said his friends don’t do the same amount of work. Worst thing is the teachers are saying well done etc

My ds loved primary school. He started year 7 full of enthusiasm and excited. Teachers were incredibly strict from the very start. I know why they do it...they have hundreds of kids and some will behave appallingly but I believe it turned my enthusiastic, eager child into a miserable one. He is 15 now and hates school. He behaves himself because he just wants to get through the day. He had a little meltdown at the end of the school holidays recently, said he hated just having to sit still and keep quiet for hours. It's probably a really unnatural way for teens to be.

Julimia · 22/11/2023 18:33

Especially as she goes to a grammar? ?

Wonder where the pressure is coming from?

Wisenotboring · 22/11/2023 18:23

This sounds very familiar. I think behaviour and parental support have become so poor over the past decade or so that schools simply have to go in so hard and in a very joyless manner to get behaviour and standards under control. Effectively it's catering for the worst which leaves nice kids who don't need to be scared to death in a horrible position. My eldest was just broken when he went. He is improved now a few years later, but there is so much wrong with the system. Massive schools, no money and poor resources have really spoilt so much education. I'm a teacher so have seen it from.both sides. I just don't know what we are doing to our children.

KillswitchEngage · 22/11/2023 14:45

For what it’s work our local high school is like this. My daughter is ur 9 also and always enjoyed school and done well. Now it’s onstant tests and assessments, some teachers are great and super involved (my daughter chose her subjects based on a combination of teaching style and subject matter) bit for the most part they don’t want to be there and are teaching to pass the next assessment. She’s always been a very hardworking kid and one day she lost her book (it had slid down the back of her desk drawer) and she had a full blown panic attack because she knew she’d be torn off a strip in front of the class for it. On another occasion she was yelled at by a teacher for not doing her home work (which she had set on a day my daughter was absent and had been given a weeks notice to give her the work in advance). I emailed about that incident as it was not my daughters fault but got no apology. I understand teaching is a hard profession right now and the government want constant tangible results which is why they are tested to kingdom come but there’s no joy in going to school for her anymore. No trips at ours either unless you’re one of the fortunate lot who get one of the 40 spots on the annnual ski trip which costs an arm and a leg. It’s so sad for them.

ReadyForPumpkins · 22/11/2023 14:11

DC is in year 8 at a state comprehensive and it's not like this at all. They have been on many school trips. There is a big one at the end of Year 7 and they went to Windsor Legoland. I remember there was a field trip for Geography. They went to the panto in a large local theatre last year. There were discos, concerts, musicals. There is a lot of work but DC likes most of her teachers.

My only problem is that there are a lot of substitute teachers. There is a staffing issue but I believe it's a nationwide problem. (Blaming the government, not the school).

stayathomer · 22/11/2023 13:32

Op I feel your pain, my ds was top of his class in primary, hardworking, had a few really nice friends, took part in school. Secondary went well in 1st year, he just worked on made friends etc, this year he’s doing the ‘I can’t believe it’s Monday tomorrow’ thing, quiet going in on a Monday, quiet during the week, a lot of sighing, in working in office until late then comes out saying’guess I’m going to bed now,’ and he’s now said once or twice he can’t believe he has 3 or 4 years of this. We’ve had chats and told him to take his foot off the pedal, tried to get him to play board games or even to go gaming instead of doing every bit of homework but it’s like he’s a bit broken. He said his friends don’t do the same amount of work. Worst thing is the teachers are saying well done etc

waterrat · 22/11/2023 13:24

This is our experience too. My son started year 7 full of enthusiasm and the boring sedentary day and strict teachers have just crushed the life out of him.

Our Education system is ruining childhood in so many ways

Chattygirl123 · 22/11/2023 13:22

Re uninterested staff and high turn over. No-one who hasn't worked in a school in England can understand the pressure teachers and staff are under. From poor behaviour and exam results and ofsted. Plus poor pay for a profession. I'm out 14 years and so glad!!! I do think education shouldn't be like this but I mostly blame the government. I hope you find the right school environment for your child.

Phineyj · 22/11/2023 13:11

Hi OP, sorry, didn't mean to stress you out!

Go and look at the other school. Tell DD it's not committing to anything to go and look (it isn't).

Foxesandsquirrels · 22/11/2023 13:05

XelaM · 22/11/2023 11:53

Latymer is very relaxed for example

Exactly the school I was thinking of.

Foxesandsquirrels · 22/11/2023 13:05

StrawberriesSW1 · 22/11/2023 11:40

Where in London do you have grammars?

Can't speak fof the whole of London but in my area kids go to Latymer, QE Boys, Henrietta Barnet or the semi selectives like DAO.

Fionaville · 22/11/2023 13:00

Your DD sounds like me. First two years happy to go and eager to learn. Then they just crush your love of learning. That's the saddest part about high school for me and the reason why people leave education and are happy to not learn anything new for a very long time. Learning should be a joy. It should inspire creative thinking and prepare young people for the evolving world. The current system doesn't do that for most. It's become a system focused on attendance and exam results, which mainly benefit the school itself so that the cycle can continue.

Underappreciated786 · 22/11/2023 12:14

I meant sporty… typo…

Underappreciated786 · 22/11/2023 12:14

Agreed 100%… same with my daughter who has always been eager and enthusiastic learner… they just honestly knock the stuffing out of them… also I find they don’t really reach the individual child to their strengths unless of course you’re musical or apart in which they love you because you “market” the school..,

XelaM · 22/11/2023 11:53

StrawberriesSW1 · 22/11/2023 11:40

Where in London do you have grammars?

Latymer is very relaxed for example

BurbageBrook · 22/11/2023 11:46

Lots of schools at secondary level are going in this direction. There are some better ones out there though, so I'd consider moving her.

NotLactoseFree · 22/11/2023 11:45

@StrawberriesSW1 in greater London there are lots I think. We live on the London/Surrey border and there are plenty around here. Tiffin in Surbiton. Nonsuch in Cheam. Wilsons (Worcester Park? Not sure). Wallington in Croydon. Then all the grammars in Sutton.