Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner not wanting to split household bills

383 replies

mum1010219 · 20/11/2023 20:29

Me and my and are moving in together, but I have a son from previous relationship but the issue isn't he doesn't want to pay 50/50 on the bills as he will in hindsight be paying for my child, I only work one day a week just now due to childcare and son only being 3 ( he starts funded place in the new year) so he makes nearly 4 times a month what I do, I was saying it will be joint household bills if we all live together?
Made me feel awful as we are trying for a baby of our own and felt like he will never seen my son as his step child, he treats him like one but saying that hurt...

OP posts:
Pumpkinpie1 · 22/11/2023 17:49

Having a child together is a terrible idea

ThisMama1 · 22/11/2023 17:33

your child is going to end up feeling singled & rejected when your ‘new child’ is being bought things by your partner & he refuses to pay for thing for your first child. Either you’re a package or you’re not. If you weren’t planning a baby it wouldn’t be too bad but when there’s two kids & one is treated differently it’s going to cause issues for that child. Believe me, along with my brother I was that child.

My sister treated so differently than us by her dad, we were ‘her kids’, my sister was my mums & his kid. The fact he didn’t fully accept us meant that his family didn’t fully accept us so we were left out of everything. It caused so much trauma. We’re now in our 40s & still don’t have the best sibling relationship

When me & my now husband moved in together he accepted my son & me came as a package. When we had our son together our boys were treated the same, there was so he’s yours & he’s mine, they both were ours & even though there’s 11 years between them they have an amazing relationship. My husband has an amazing relationship with my first born who is now 22. Whereas i have no relationship whatsoever with my ‘step dad’. Funnily enough, my mum managed to stand 15 years of him treating us so differently before she decided enough was enough & she couldn’t tolerate how divided our household was. She had to work nights to pay for us whilst he worked days & had extra money because she had to contribute more to the household. It tore the whole family apart & was so damaging to everyone involved. Even he said in hindsight he should have never had a child with her if he couldn’t be a proper step dad to us. Too little too late

Justanothermum42 · 22/11/2023 15:45

Do not move in with him. Ever.

6Claire · 22/11/2023 13:58

Wow! Red flags, he needs to go I’m afraid! Get rid, my partner took me on with a ds and we now have 2 kids also but he never questioned once about paying, he pays more bills than I do due to earning more and also pays towards bdays/ Christmas for all 3 kids etc as we share money so if he needs it I give it and vice versa! That’s how a relationship works, not this nonsense about not paying because you have a son!

DoughBallss · 22/11/2023 12:22

Your household bills would still be same with or without your 3 year old there, food bill slightly more if anything.

He’s being a tight arse and not accepting you and your child as a package.

Muchof · 22/11/2023 06:55

The whole thing is ridiculous. Why on earth are you trying for a baby with somebody without having these very basic discussions first.

Beezknees · 22/11/2023 06:30

You'd be a massive fool if you moved in with him and you wouldn't be putting your child first quite honestly. Do the right thing.

Beezknees · 22/11/2023 06:29

MMCQ · 22/11/2023 01:25

Why should any step parent expect to pay for you to be off work 4 days of the week exactly? Each parent should pay their share. If you have a child you get money for them from that child’s other parent. You are 2 people and your current partner is 1. When you have a child together the ratio changes. You should contribute 2.5 to his 1.5 and so on. Your child may be small now but when he’s a teenager every costs huge amounts and why should the step parent find their holidays, clothes, books, trips, lunches, uniform, school clubs and sports etc.

Er, not everyone gets money from their child's other parent. What planet do you live on??

NewStart2131 · 22/11/2023 06:28

If he earns 4 times more than you then bills should be split according to that, so he should be paying more than 50% anyway.

Once you move in with him your benefits will dramatically reduce or worst case stop all together if you earn over the threshold as a couple. If your benefits stop there’s a risk that you wouldn’t be able to afford 50% of the bills or be left with absolutely nothing once you do

I think his attitude is disgusting, your child is a 3 year old little person, he’s not going to be increasing the bills by that much at all. I can understand him not wanting to pay towards the childcare fees or something but do not agree to pay more than 50% of the bills because he is completely taking advantage with that.

You are trying for a baby with this man, I think you need to have some hard conversations before you continue with that, for example is he going to support you while you’re on a reduced maternity leave wage? If not you’re going to be left skint, in debt and unable to afford the basics.

S251 · 22/11/2023 05:10

kushty · Today 01:48

It's pretty clear she has no intention of dumping him. He'll move in. They'll have a kid. It'll be the golden child to him. He'll want her kid out the house ASAP and treat him as lesser. Probably any teenage angst and He'll want to sling him out. Your son will likely resent his sibling through no fault of their own and likely go low or no contact with you for allowing it to happen. What a lovely future... harsh? yes. Fair? Yes. You need to give yourself a bloody good shake for the potential future you're creating for your son for the sake of some dick.

This happened to me as a child, my mum was married to the man and they eventually divorced but not until years of bullying and making my life a living misery. Its lead to many issues with my mum and mental health struggles.

S251 · 22/11/2023 05:04

Massive red flag. Do not move in with man, he will not treat your child nicely. Also if do have children together the way he treats your child will become even worse. Also why are you trying for a baby with a man you don’t live with? Would it not have been sensible to live together first to make sure this works first. (He has shown you it clearly it won’t)

kushty · 22/11/2023 01:48

It's pretty clear she has no intention of dumping him. He'll move in. They'll have a kid. It'll be the golden child to him. He'll want her kid out the house ASAP and treat him as lesser. Probably any teenage angst and He'll want to sling him out. Your son will likely resent his sibling through no fault of their own and likely go low or no contact with you for allowing it to happen. What a lovely future... harsh? yes. Fair? Yes. You need to give yourself a bloody good shake for the potential future you're creating for your son for the sake of some dick.

Londonscallingme · 22/11/2023 01:28

Don’t move in with him.

MMCQ · 22/11/2023 01:25

Why should any step parent expect to pay for you to be off work 4 days of the week exactly? Each parent should pay their share. If you have a child you get money for them from that child’s other parent. You are 2 people and your current partner is 1. When you have a child together the ratio changes. You should contribute 2.5 to his 1.5 and so on. Your child may be small now but when he’s a teenager every costs huge amounts and why should the step parent find their holidays, clothes, books, trips, lunches, uniform, school clubs and sports etc.

Tryingmybestadhd · 22/11/2023 00:21

He should be paying 75% and you paying 25% according to those wages . Please do not move in together , he is not a nice partner . I earn more than hubby and pay more than him as I would hate him having no money left the same way I have . He is not ready to be a partner , in a household all should be fair

Over40Overdating · 21/11/2023 22:41

@Sto123 He sounds like a very decent guy and that’s how it should be with kids.

Katej82 · 21/11/2023 22:39

Sto123 · 21/11/2023 22:33

Don't even go there honestly! My man moved in with me when I had 2 kids! Took over the rent and bills took them on as his own while they were little. He didn't want kids of his own. We did end up having one eventually but even now he treats them all equally, and we've now split up but he takes them all on holiday/ days out together spends the same amount etc etc

Wow what a guy! Good on him and you co parenting so well.

Sto123 · 21/11/2023 22:33

Don't even go there honestly! My man moved in with me when I had 2 kids! Took over the rent and bills took them on as his own while they were little. He didn't want kids of his own. We did end up having one eventually but even now he treats them all equally, and we've now split up but he takes them all on holiday/ days out together spends the same amount etc etc

Katej82 · 21/11/2023 21:39

Over40Overdating · 21/11/2023 18:26

Why on Earth are you even posting this - as soon as your boyfriend (he is not your partner by any measure) made it clear your son will be a second class citizen for the entirety of his life whilst he is around, you should have ended things, not posted looking for confirmation that this is something you should accept.

I really hope for the sake of your son you see this man for what he is - a mean, nasty, cocklodging little scrote who is happy to use a 3 year old as a way to save himself as much of his living expenses as he can get away with.

Why is this the best you can do for a stepfather for your son or potential father for any new kids?

This 💯👍

Haydenn · 21/11/2023 21:23

Coconutts · 21/11/2023 20:25

@mum1010219 I've just moved in with my partner and my two DC. We have a joint account that we both pay into for bills, split according to income. We have a separate account for our own fun money (equal amounts each) and any other money goes into joint savings. We are partnership and it's 'our' money.

This guy is not for you honey. Throw this one back. You will regret it in the long run

Can I ask for a ballpark on your incomes though. OP here is earning significantly less here with greater liabilities. If her chap moved in he would start picking up 80% of her her living expenses overnight- which is a major change.

most people try out living together before making a life commitment. They aren’t married, based on her child’s age haven’t been together very long at all. By your logic any new partner picking up 80% of expenses is a big reach as a first step

Bluewater1 · 21/11/2023 20:31

Run. Run as fast as you can

Coconutts · 21/11/2023 20:25

@mum1010219 I've just moved in with my partner and my two DC. We have a joint account that we both pay into for bills, split according to income. We have a separate account for our own fun money (equal amounts each) and any other money goes into joint savings. We are partnership and it's 'our' money.

This guy is not for you honey. Throw this one back. You will regret it in the long run

RantyAnty · 21/11/2023 20:14

Of course don't move this cocklodger in.

With a 3 year old, you can't have known him very long.

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 21/11/2023 19:59

I wouldn't be moving in with him.

ALJT · 21/11/2023 19:56

He clearly does not see your child as part of his family now or in the future. I wouldn’t stay with him never mind move in with him